Literature DB >> 33170341

A tale of too many tasks: task fragmentation in motor learning and a call for model task paradigms.

Rajiv Ranganathan1, Aimee D Tomlinson2, Rakshith Lokesh2, Tzu-Hsiang Lin2, Priya Patel2.   

Abstract

Motor learning encompasses a broad set of phenomena that requires a diverse set of experimental paradigms. However, excessive variation in tasks across studies creates fragmentation that can adversely affect the collective advancement of knowledge. Here, we show that motor learning studies tend toward extreme fragmentation in the choice of tasks, with almost no overlap between task paradigms across studies. We argue that this extreme level of task fragmentation poses serious theoretical and methodological barriers to advancing the field. To address these barriers, we propose the need for developing common 'model' task paradigms which could be widely used across labs. Combined with the open sharing of methods and data, we suggest that these model task paradigms could be an important step in increasing the robustness of the motor learning literature and facilitate the cumulative process of science.

Keywords:  Design; Power; Replication; Sample size; Science; Standardization

Year:  2020        PMID: 33170341     DOI: 10.1007/s00221-020-05908-6

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Exp Brain Res        ISSN: 0014-4819            Impact factor:   1.972


  98 in total

1.  Learning curves; facts or artifacts?

Authors:  H P BAHRICK; P M FITTS; G E BRIGGS
Journal:  Psychol Bull       Date:  1957-05       Impact factor: 17.737

2.  A closed-loop theory of motor learning.

Authors:  J A Adams
Journal:  J Mot Behav       Date:  1971-06       Impact factor: 1.328

3.  Flexible explicit but rigid implicit learning in a visuomotor adaptation task.

Authors:  Krista M Bond; Jordan A Taylor
Journal:  J Neurophysiol       Date:  2015-04-08       Impact factor: 2.714

4.  Evaluating the replicability of social science experiments in Nature and Science between 2010 and 2015.

Authors:  Colin F Camerer; Anna Dreber; Felix Holzmeister; Teck-Hua Ho; Jürgen Huber; Magnus Johannesson; Michael Kirchler; Gideon Nave; Brian A Nosek; Thomas Pfeiffer; Adam Altmejd; Nick Buttrick; Taizan Chan; Yiling Chen; Eskil Forsell; Anup Gampa; Emma Heikensten; Lily Hummer; Taisuke Imai; Siri Isaksson; Dylan Manfredi; Julia Rose; Eric-Jan Wagenmakers; Hang Wu
Journal:  Nat Hum Behav       Date:  2018-08-27

5.  Investigating three types of continuous auditory feedback in visuo-manual tracking.

Authors:  Éric O Boyer; Frédéric Bevilacqua; Patrick Susini; Sylvain Hanneton
Journal:  Exp Brain Res       Date:  2016-11-17       Impact factor: 1.972

6.  Information about relative phase in bimanual coordination is modality specific (not amodal), but kinesthesis and vision can teach one another.

Authors:  Geoffrey P Bingham; Winona Snapp-Childs; Qin Zhu
Journal:  Hum Mov Sci       Date:  2018-05-28       Impact factor: 2.161

Review 7.  Power failure: why small sample size undermines the reliability of neuroscience.

Authors:  Katherine S Button; John P A Ioannidis; Claire Mokrysz; Brian A Nosek; Jonathan Flint; Emma S J Robinson; Marcus R Munafò
Journal:  Nat Rev Neurosci       Date:  2013-04-10       Impact factor: 34.870

8.  The effects of a two-step transfer on a visuomotor adaptation task.

Authors:  Christopher A Aiken; Zhujun Pan; Arend W A Van Gemmert
Journal:  Exp Brain Res       Date:  2017-08-24       Impact factor: 1.972

9.  Variance in exposed perturbations impairs retention of visuomotor adaptation.

Authors:  Cesar Augusto Canaveral; Frédéric Danion; Félix Berrigan; Pierre-Michel Bernier
Journal:  J Neurophysiol       Date:  2017-08-16       Impact factor: 2.714

10.  Toward open behavioral science.

Authors:  Karen E Adolph; Rick O Gilmore; Clinton Freeman; Penelope Sanderson; David Millman
Journal:  Psychol Inq       Date:  2012-09-10
View more
  2 in total

1.  Ten guidelines for designing motor learning studies.

Authors:  Rajiv Ranganathan; Mei-Hua Lee; Chandramouli Krishnan
Journal:  Braz J Mot Behav       Date:  2022-06

Review 2.  Always Pay Attention to Which Model of Motor Learning You Are Using.

Authors:  Wolfgang I Schöllhorn; Nikolas Rizzi; Agnė Slapšinskaitė-Dackevičienė; Nuno Leite
Journal:  Int J Environ Res Public Health       Date:  2022-01-09       Impact factor: 3.390

  2 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.