| Literature DB >> 32971611 |
Prerna Ahuja1, Zelda Dadachanji1, Rohit Shetty1, Sowmya Arudi Nagarajan2, Pooja Khamar1, Swaminathan Sethu3, Sharon D'Souza1.
Abstract
Keratoconus (KC) is an ectatic disease of the cornea characterized by localized thinning and protrusion causing irregular astigmatism, which can lead to significant visual impairment. KC has often been associated with allergy and/or atopy, which are immune-mediated inflammatory reactions primarily driven by IgE. A higher proportion of KC patients were reported to have history or suffer from systemic and/or ocular allergy with elevated allergen-specific IgE and/or total serum IgE. Eye rubbing, one of the risk factors for worsening of the disease and developing related complications in KC, is associated with IgE driven conditions. The current review enumerates and contextualizes the evidence related to IgE in mediating KC pathogenesis, including aberrant extra-cellular matrix remodeling. This review also discusses clinical strategies directed at modulating IgE-mediated responses in the management of KC, and the emerging academic and plausible clinical relevance of assessing serum and tear IgE (allergen-specific and total) status in improving the understanding of disease pathobiology, treatment planning, and prognosis.Entities:
Keywords: Allergy; IgE; atopy; eye rubbing; keratoconus
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2020 PMID: 32971611 PMCID: PMC7727983 DOI: 10.4103/ijo.IJO_1191_19
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Indian J Ophthalmol ISSN: 0301-4738 Impact factor: 1.848
The status of Atopy/Allergy in Keratoconus
| Key findings | Species | Ref |
|---|---|---|
| Case reports describing the presentation of KC and various atopic conditions | Human | [ |
| Increased frequency of asthma was observed in KC patients compared to controls | Human | [ |
| Four cases of cataract with keratoconus were reported in patients suffering from dermatitis including its atopic form. | Human | [ |
| Atopy was found in 35% of KC subjects and 12% in the matched control group. | Human | [ |
| Increased prevalence of asthma was observed in KC patients compared to controls | Human | [ |
| 23% of controls and 40% of KC subjects had a history of present or past atopic disease. | Human | [ |
| History of systemic atopic disease did not influence the rate of progression of KC to penetrating keratoplasty (PK). However, the progression to PK in one eye resulted in increasing the risk of progression in the contralateral eye. | Human | [ |
| KC patients without atopic dermatitis was observed to have better graft prognosis compared to those patients with severe form of atopic dermatitis | Human | [ |
| An association was observed between KC and atopy (OR 3.6, 95% CI 0.8-15.8) | Human | [ |
| Reducing in anterior keratocyte density was observed to be significantly associated with history of atopy in KC patients | Human | [ |
| 4 out of 7 KC patients who underwent deep lamellar keratoplasty were atopic | Human | [ |
| Corneal topographic and pachymetric features were observed to be significantly worse and distinct in KC subjects with atopy compared to KC subjects without atopy. | Human | [ |
| Atopic conditions such as asthma, eczema and hay fever was observed in 23%, 14% and 30% of KC patients, respectively | Human | [ |
| KC patients with atopy showed a trend that the rate of graft rejection was twice that of non-atopic KC patients. However, this observation was not statistically significant. | Human | [ |
| VKC was significant risk factor for KC. Atopy was observed to be a significant risk factor for developing corneal hydrops in KC patients. | Human | [ |
| Graft survival chances in KC patients were not observed to significantly different between KC subjects with and without history of atopy. | Human | [ |
| KC associated with atopy (OR 3.0, 95% CI 1.2-7.6) | Human | [ |
| History of skin allergy (26.6%), symptomatic ocular allergy (24.45%) and asthma (11.31%) were observed in KC patients | Human | [ |
| More severe form of KC was observed in those patients with vernal keratoconjunctivitis (VKC) compared to KC patients without VKC or with allergic conjunctivitis | [ | |
| KC comprised 6% of the VKC-associated complication | Human | [ |
| Of the patients who underwent intrastromal corneal ring segment (ICRS) treatment, complication such as corneal melt or ICRS extrusion was observed in 1.24% of them. All of these 1.24% of patients had history of atopic dermatitis and had episodes of atopic dermatitis exacerbation with itching and burring in the eyes prior to corneal melt/ICRS extrusion | Human | [ |
| Atopic keratoconjunctivitis patients exhibited higher rate of corneal thinning and KC | Human | [ |
| The odds ratio of asthma, allergic rhinitis, and the combination of allergic conjunctivitis, chronic blepharitis and vernal keratoconjunctivitis with reference to KC was 2.0 (95% CI: 1.6-2.5), 1.6 (95% CI: 1.3-2.0) and 6.0 (95% CI: 4.0-9.2), respectively. | Human | [ |
| KC patients exhibited history of allergic disorders (29.7%) | Human | [ |
| KC patients with atopy showed corneal densitometry changes compared to KC subjects without atopic disease. | Human | [ |
| Case report: History of allergic conjunctivitis and eye rubbing was associated with progression of keratoconus after collagen cross-linking | Human | [ |
| The hazard ratio for keratoconus in subjects with severe atopic dermatitis was 10.01 (95% CI, 5.02-19.96) | Human | [ |
| In 885 KC subjects, 50.7% had a history of allergic diseases. KC patients with VKC or AC exhibited a more severe form of disease than those without a history of allergic disease | Human | [ |
| Significant progression of KC in patients with allergies | Human | [ |
| Compared to subjects without allergic conjunctivitis (AC), those with AC exhibited a 37% increase in odds to be diagnosed with KC. However, the opposite relationship was observed between allergic rhinitis and KC. | Human | [ |
| The odds ratio of asthma, allergic rhinitis, and atopic dermatitis with reference to KC was 2.21 (95% CI: 1.91-2.55), 3.44 (95% CI: 2.75-4.30) and 7.97 (95% CI: 6.21-10.21), respectively. | Human | [ |
| The proportion KC patients with progression of ectasia, 2 years after collage cross-linking was not significantly different between those with (18.5%) and without VKC (16.7%) | Human | [ |
| The odds ratio of allergy, asthma, and eczema with reference to KC was 1.42 (95% CI: 1.06-1.79), 1.94 (95% CI: 1.30-2.58) and 2.95 (95% CI: 1.30-4.59), respectively. | Human | [ |
The status of IgE in Keratoconus
| Key findings | Species/Sample | Ref |
|---|---|---|
| IgE was raised in 17% of the KC studied. | Human/Serum | [ |
| IgE levels >200 IU/ml was observed in 47% of the KC subjects and 6% in controls. 60% of the KC subjects with higher IgE were atopic and 40% of the KC subjects with higher IgE were non-atopic. IgE in KC patients ranged between 10-4000 IU/ml and in controls ranged between 10-272 IU/ml. | Human/Serum | [ |
| Levels of IgE on the ocular surface of KC and controls were not significantly different | Human/Tear fluid | [ |
| 30% of the KC subjects and 20% of controls showed higher IgE (>120 UI/ml) levels. | Human/Serum | [ |
| High IgE levels (>120 IU/ml) was observed in 52% of the KC subjects and 7% in controls. IgE in KC patients ranged between 6.5->1000 IU/ml and in controls ranged between 5-185 IU/ml. Significantly higher levels of specific IgE was observed in 59% of the KC subjects and 13% of the controls. | Human/Serum | [ |
| Prospective survey of a family with KC members: 2/12 members presented with KC and they also exhibited elevated total and allergen specific IgE. 2 of 3 other members (with no KC at initiation of the study) with higher levels of IgE developed KC over the course of the study period | Human/Serum | [ |
| Clinical atopy was observed in 44% of the KC patients in the study. Relatively higher frequency of atopic KC patients underwent keratoplasty. 4/5 atopic patients with graft rejection had IgE levels >1000 U/ml | Human/Serum | [ |
| Case report: KC with hyperimmunolgoublin E syndrome. IgE=28900 IU/ml | Human/Serum | [ |
| Case report: IgE=38000 IU/ml | Monkey/Serum | [ |
| Case report: IgE levels in KC subjects ( | Human/Serum | [ |
| Significantly higher levels of serum and tear IgE was observed in KC subjects compared to controls. | Human/Serum/Tear fluid | [ |
Figure 1Proposed role of IgE in keratoconus pathogenesis. Schematic hypothesizes that raised IgE will bind to its receptor (FcεR) on the ocular surface immune cells including mast cells. Binding of IgE to FcεR results in the degranulation of FcεR expressing cells, releasing itch factors. These factors -enzymes and cytokines can trigger eye rubbing and degranulated factors along with mechanical force of eye rubbing can have an effect on epithelium, keratocytes and fibroblasts of cornea resulting in an inflammatory molecular milieu contributing to dysregulated focal ECM remodeling resulting in keratoconus pathogenesis
Figure 2Algorithm for clinical management of Keratoconus, raised IgE and Allergy. The relationship between allergy and KC is important in KC management. Treatment planning involves triaging KC patients based on allergy signs, history and eye rubbing. A multidisciplinary team with an immunologist is useful in patients with recurrent, severe allergy or history of atopy. Identification of allergen (skin prick or patch test; allergen specific IgE) and control (sublingual immunotherapy; avoidance of exposure) is possible. Total IgE status aids as well. Reducing ocular surface inflammation, IgE and induced effectors prior to treatment would improve outcome. Ag – Antigen/Allergen