| Literature DB >> 32907845 |
Ruud Gerard Nijman1,2, Johanna Krone3, Santiago Mintegi4, Christoph Bidlingmaier5, Ian K Maconochie2, Mark D Lyttle6,7, Ulrich von Both3,8.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Refugee children and young people have complex healthcare needs. However, issues related to acute healthcare provision for refugee children across Europe remain unexplored. This study aimed to describe the urgent and emergency healthcare needs of refugee children in Europe, and to identify obstacles to providing this care.Entities:
Keywords: emergency department; global health; infectious diseases; mental health; paediatrics
Year: 2020 PMID: 32907845 PMCID: PMC7788210 DOI: 10.1136/emermed-2019-208699
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Emerg Med J ISSN: 1472-0205 Impact factor: 2.740
Figure 1Overview of respondents in Europe.
Overview of respondents and their institutions (total n=148)
| Grade of person completing survey | |
| Consultant paediatric emergency care | 55 (37%) |
| Consultant paediatrics | 27 (18%) |
| Consultant in paediatric infectious diseases | 30 (20%) |
| Consultant, other | 5 (3%) |
| junior doctor or trainee (junior level, up to 3 years of experience in specialty) | 5 (3%) |
| junior doctor or trainee (senior level, 4 or more years of experience in specialty) | 18 (12%) |
| Nurse | 2 (1%) |
| Paramedic | 2 (1%) |
| Other healthcare professional | 4 (3%) |
| Country of response in EU | 136 (92%) |
| Hospital setting (for 141 hospital-based respondents) | |
| Teaching or academic hospital | 118 (84%) |
| General district hospital | 23 (16%) |
| Which major transport links do you have in your geographical area?* | |
| Airport, international | 91 (73%) |
| Airport, national | 49 (40%) |
| Harbour, international | 36 (29%) |
| Harbour, national | 25 (20%) |
| Trains, international | 62 (50%) |
| Trains, main train station | 80 (65%) |
| Trains, local only | 64 (52%) |
| Motorway | 89 (72%) |
| Is your hospital located in the vicinity of a refugee camp?† | |
| Yes | 30 (26%) |
| In your hospital, where do you see children for non-planned emergency care* (tick all that apply) | |
| Paediatric emergency department | 89 (76%) |
| Mixed adult and paediatric emergency department | 16 (14%) |
| Outpatient clinics | 20 (17%) |
| Paediatric ward | 30 (26%) |
| Other | 7 (6%) |
| In your hospital, who provides the emergency care for children?† (tick all that apply) | |
| Paediatric trainees (junior level, up to 3 years of experience in specialty) | 85 (73%) |
| Paediatric trainees (senior level, 4 or more years of experience in specialty) | 78 (67%) |
| Emergency care trainees (junior level, up to 3 years of experience in specialty) | 58 (50%) |
| Emergency care trainees (senior level, 4 or more years of experience in specialty) | 55 (47%) |
| Paediatric consultants | 83 (71%) |
| Paediatric emergency care consultants | 68 (58%) |
| Emergency care consultants | 35 (30%) |
| Nurse specialist practitioners in paediatric emergency care | 53 (45%) |
| Nurse specialist practitioners in emergency care | 29 (25%) |
| Other | 5 (4%) |
| How many children (<18 years) visit your hospital for emergency care annually?† (available for 92/117) | |
| <5000 | 10 (11%) |
| 5000–10 000 | 11 (12%) |
| 10 000–25 000 | 25 (27%) |
| 25 000–50 000 | 28 (30%) |
| >50 000 | 18 (20%) |
*One response per setting including responses from non-hospital-based respondents (n=124).
†If >1 respondent from 1 setting, then used only 1 response per setting, from most senior respondent (n=117 unique hospital settings).
EU, European Union.
Overview of current healthcare delivery systems of respondents
| How many refugee children visited in the last 12 months for emergency care?* (available for 92/117) | |
| Nil | 9 (10%) |
| <25 | 21 (23%) |
| 25–100 | 23 (25%) |
| 100–500 | 10 (11%) |
| >500 | 7 (8%) |
| Unknown | 22 (24%) |
| How do refugee children present to your emergency care facilities?* (tick all that apply) (available for 92/117) | |
| Self-referred | 58 (63%) |
| GP referred | 32 (35%) |
| Private paediatrician | 6 (7%) |
| Ambulance | 34 (37%) |
| Specific services for refugees | 35 (38%) |
| Referred by public health authorities | 29 (32%) |
| Other | 9 (10%) |
| Unknown | 9 (10%) |
| Which services are responsible for conducting routine, standardised point of entry screening and medical assessments of refugee children (non-acute care)?† (tick all that apply) (available for 95/124) | |
| This does not happen in an organised manner in our area | 25 (27%) |
| Paediatric outpatient clinics (hospital) | 15 (16%) |
| Primary care paediatricians (community) | 21 (23%) |
| GPs | 13 (14%) |
| Public health services | 28 (29%) |
| Emergency care departments or other acute care facilities | 7 (8%) |
| Third party organisations (Red Cross, Medicines Sans Frontiers) | 12 (13%) |
| Other | 5 (5%) |
| Unknown | 18 (19%) |
| Does your hospital routinely provide follow-up appointments in your hospital for refugee children after a first visit to the emergency department?* (available for 97/117) | |
| Yes, always | 6 (6%) |
| Not routinely, based on clinical indication | 68 (70%) |
| Never | 11 (11%) |
| Unknown | 12 (12%) |
| Does your hospital provide teaching sessions for physicians on how to manage refugee children in emergency care?* (available for 97/117) | |
| Yes | 13 (13%) |
| No | 80 (83%) |
| Unknown | 4 (4%) |
| Does your hospital have regular discussions with Public Health or other organisations concerning healthcare of refugee children?* (available for 97/117) | |
| Yes | 17 (18%) |
| No | 56 (58%) |
| Unknown | 24 (25%) |
| Are there any organisations active in your region providing support and healthcare for refugee children?† (available for 103/124) | |
| Yes | 57 (55%) |
| No | 16 (16%) |
| Unknown | 30 (29%) |
| Availability of guidelines(available for 125/148) | |
| Immunisations and catch-up immunisation schedule | 37 (30%) |
| Infection screening | 40 (32%) |
| Safeguarding concerns and social care referral | 38 (31%) |
| Mental health issues and symptoms of post-traumatic stress disorder | 17 (14%) |
| Managing refugee children in emergency care | 22 (18%) |
*If >1 respondent from 1 setting, then used only 1 response per setting, from most senior respondent (n=117 unique hospital settings).
†One response per setting including responses from non hospital-based respondents (n=124).
GP, general practitioner.
Figure 2Statements on needs for providing urgent and emergency care to refugee children and young people in hospitals. Statements on needs for providing urgent and emergency care to refugee children and young people in hospitals. Respondents were asked to indicate (on a 5-point Likert scale) to which degree they agreed with the posed statements.
Overview of (national) guidelines in Europe6–10
| Country | National Society of Paediatrics | Website | Title |
| Denmark | Dansk Paediatrisk Selskab |
| Sundhedsstyrelsen: Migranters sundhed. |
| Germany | Deutsche Gesellschaft fur Kinder- und Jugendmedizin |
| Empfehlungen zur infektiologischen Versorgung von Influenzächtlingen im Kindes- und Jugendalter in Deutschland. |
| The Netherlands | Nederlandse Vereniging voor Kindergeneeskunde |
| Dossier Kinderen van Vluchtelingen. |
| Spain | Asociación Española de Pediatría |
| Comité Asesor de Vacunas de la Asociacion Espanola de Pediatria. Seccion III. Inmunización en circunstancias especiales: 12. VACUNACIÓN DE NIÑOS INMIGRANTES, REFUGIADOS Y ADOPTADOS. Manual de vacunas en línea de la AEP (internet). Madrid. |
| United Kingdom | Royal College of Paediatrics and Child Health |
| Refugee and unaccompanied asylum seeking children and young people. |
| Pan-European | European Academy of Paediatrics |
| Medical care for migrant children in Europe: a practical recommendation for first and follow-up appointments. |
Figure 3Perceived obstacles to providing urgent and emergency care to refugee children and young people in hospitals. Perceived obstacles to providing urgent and emergency care to refugee children and young children in hospitals. Respondents were asked to indicate if specified items were perceived as obstacles for providing urgent and emergency care to refugee children (on a 5-point Likert scale). ED, emergency department.
Figure 4Presenting signs and symptoms of refugee children and young people to emergency care facilities. Respondents were asked if signs and symptoms were seen more or less commonly in refugee children and young people in comparison with the local population (on a 5-point Likert scale). Metabolic disorders: such as exacerbated type I Diabetes Mellitus, including ketoacidosis; musculoskeletal problems: non-traumatic, for example, limp, joint swelling, back pain; referral for routine screening: referral by other healthcare professional.