| Literature DB >> 32642685 |
Roei D Mazor1, Ran Weissman1,2,3, Judith Luckman4, Liran Domachevsky4,5, Eli L Diamond6, Omar Abdel-Wahab7, Shirley Shapira8,9, Oshrat Hershkovitz-Rokah1,2,3, David Groshar4,5, Ofer Shpilberg1,3,10.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Erdheim-Chester disease (ECD), a rare inflammatory myeloid neoplasm, is known to be fundamentally reliant on the constitutive activation of the MAPK signaling pathway in the majority of patients. Consequently, inhibition of the V600E-mutant BRAF kinase has proven to be a safe and efficacious long-term therapeutic strategy for BRAF-mutant ECD patients. Nevertheless, in a subset of patients with CNS disease, the efficacy of long-term treatment may diminish, facilitating suboptimal responses or disease progression.Entities:
Keywords: BRAF; Cobimetinib; Erdheim–Chester disease; Vemurafenib; histiocytosis
Year: 2020 PMID: 32642685 PMCID: PMC7212923 DOI: 10.1093/noajnl/vdaa024
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Neurooncol Adv ISSN: 2632-2498
The clinical and radiological chronicles of three ECD patients
| Patient 1 | Patient 2 | Patient 3 | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sex, age (years) | Female, 51 | Male, 64 | Male, 43 |
| Intracranial ECD involvement sites, per MRI | (1)nSOL—pons, lt. middle cerebellar peduncle, lt. cerebellar peri-dentate region (2)Pituitary (DI) | SOL—involving the midbrain, lt. superior and middle cerebellar peduncles | (1)nSOL—lt. cerebellar peri-dentate region, cerebellar atrophy (2)Pituitary (DI) |
| Extracranial ECD involvement sites, per multiple modalitiesa | Bone marrow, peri-renal infiltration, peri-orbital xanthelasma, lungs, retro-orbital masses involving orbital muscles, retinal infiltration | Bone marrow, aortic coating, peri-renal infiltration | None |
| Previous treatments | Steroids, IFNa, IFNa+vinblastin, anakinra, cladribine | None | Steroids, cyclophosphamide, rituximab, plasmapheresis, cladribine |
| Time points for the emergence of first documented ECD symptoms and diagnosis | Symptoms: 2005 Diagnosis: 2007 | Symptoms: 2007 Diagnosis: 2015 | Symptoms: 2005 Diagnosis: 2014 |
| Neurological baseline prior to targeted therapy | Rapid deterioration, severe cerebellar syndrome—dysarthria, ataxia, patient bedridden ECOG: 4 | Rapid deterioration, severe cerebellar syndrome, dysarthria, loss of gag reflex necessitating PEG insertion, loss of functional motor capacity of the left arm, patient confined to a wheelchair ECOG: 4 | Indolent disease. Severe cerebellar atrophy, dysarthria, dysmetria, patient confined to a wheelchair ECOG: 4 |
| Monotherapy type, duration (months), and dosage | Vemurafenib 52 months (April 2013– July 2017) 960 mg/day | Vemurafenib 14 months (December 2015– February 2017) 1920 mg/day | Vemurafenib monotherapy 6 months (March 2016–August 2016) 960 mg/day Cobimetinib monotherapy 2 months (March 2017–May 2017) 60 mg/day |
| Monotherapy clinical gain | Rapid neurological deterioration halted, marked neurological improvement: improved dysarthria with partial regaining of speech fluency, regaining of locomotion up to distances of 500 m ECOG: 2 | Rapid neurological deterioration halted, mild improvement in cerebellar function ECOG: 3 | For both monotherapies independently: Incremental clinical improvement in alertness, upper body strength, in the capacity to lift the arms above the shoulders and maintain an erect posture ECOG: 4 |
| Time to initial response | 3 weeks | 1 month | Vemurafenib monotherapy: 1 month Cobimetinib monotherapy: 2 months |
| Time to maximal response | 3 months | 4 months | Vemurafenib monotherapy: 1 month Cobimetinib monotherapy: 2 months |
| Monotherapy imaging effect, per MRI | Normalization of the pontocerebellar abnormalities | Decrease in the sizes of the SOLs, decrease in the compression of the fourth ventricle | No significant change in MRI studies |
| Monotherapy- associated adverse events | Emergence of multiple keratoacanthomas (excised) | None | Vemurafenib monotherapy Grade 3 skin toxicity: deterioration of existing pressure ulcers → cessation of therapy Cobimetinib monotherapy Grade 3 skin toxicity: macular-pustular rash necessitating hospitalization → therapy restarted at a decreased dosage following complete resolution of the skin-related adverse event |
| Basis for conversion to Vemurafenib/ Cobimetinib dual therapy | Slow neurological deterioration including slowing of speech, compromised fine motor skills, gait disturbances necessitating the usage of ambulatory aids, re-emergence of pontocerebellar abnormalities on MRI | Worsening of dysarthria, horizontal nystagmus, marked gait disturbances, recurrent hospitalizations due to gag reflex insufficiency associated aspiration pneumonia | Worsening dysarthria, loss of the ability to balance the head, intolerable skin toxicity at effective doses |
| Vemurafenib/ Cobimetinib dual therapy duration (months) and dosage | 19 months (July 2017– February 2019) 960 mg/day (VEM), 60 mg/day (COBI) | 23 months (March 2017– February 2019) 1440 mg/day (VEM), 40–60 mg/day (COBI) | 21 months (May 2017–February 2019) 480 mg/day (VEM), 20–60 mg/day (COBI)b |
| Time to initial response | 1 month | 1 week | 1 month |
| Time to maximal response | 3 months | Maximal response not yet achieved | 6 months |
| Dual therapy clinical gain | Improvement in speech fluency and fine motor skills, stabilization of gait disturbances ECOG: 2 | Marked neurological improvement: regaining of the ability to ambulate with aids for short distances, improvement in speech fluency, gradual improvement in swallowing, reconstitution of the strength of the left arm ECOG: 3 | Further improvement in the ability to maintain an erect posture, executes functional motions with both arms, moves lower limbs, a further increase in appetite and body weight ECOG: 4 |
| Dual therapy imaging effect, per MRI | Normalization of pontocerebellar abnormalities on MRI | Complete regression of the SOLs on MRI | No significant change in MRI studies |
| Dual therapy- associated adverse events | None | Grade 1 diarrhea, grade 1 maculopapular rash | Grade 1 macular rash |
| Overall multifocal PET/CT response to treatmentc | Complete metabolic response | Complete metabolic response | Disease not PET avid |
COBI, cobimetinib; ECOG, eastern cooperative oncology group performance score; DI, diabetes insipidus; IFNa, interferon alpha; lt., left; PEG, Percutaneous endoscopic gastrostomy; SOL, space-occupying lesions; nSOL, non-space-occupying lesions; VEM, vemurafenib.
aBone scintigraphy, CT, PET/CT, MRI, confocal scanning laser ophthalmoscopy, and dermoscopy.
bDue to former cutaneous adverse events, the dosage was moderately escalated from 20 to 60 mg/day over a period of 2 months.
cPET/CT performed prior to monotherapy and following dual therapy.
Figure 1.Cerebellar MRI findings of patient 1. Axial T2-weighted MR images of patient 1 at the level of the cerebellum, middle cerebellar peduncles, and pons. (A) Baseline MR study prior to biological therapy exhibits a diffuse, heterogeneous hyperintense signal involving mainly the pons and left middle cerebellar peduncle. (B) Fourteen months following initiation of Vemurafenib monotherapy, these loci of abnormal signal attenuate. The state of near normalization persists for 2 years before new minute hyperintensities involving the left region of the pons emerge (C). These loci intensify over the course of 11 months and 2 consecutive scans. (D) Normalization of the hyperintense signals occurs 9 months following initiation of Vemurafenib/Cobimetinib dual therapy. Nevertheless, over the course of her disease, the patient exhibits loss of cerebellar mass regardless of any therapeutic interventions.
Figure 2.Cerebellar MRI findings of patient 2. Contrast-enhanced axial T1-weighted MR images of patient 2 at the levels of the superior cerebellar peduncles (A–C) and middle cerebellar peduncles (D–F). (A) Baseline MR study prior to biological therapy reveals a contrast-enhancing space-occupying lesion involving the left superior cerebellar peduncle, compressing the fourth ventricle. Following 4 months of Vemurafenib monotherapy, partial regression of the lesion is noted. (B) The lesion then stabilizes and maintains its dimensions, evident 10 months following Vemurafenib monotherapy. (C) Fifteen months pursuant initiation of Vemurafenib/Cobimetinib dual therapy, marked regression of the lesion is noted. (D–F) Similar dynamics appear in respect to the lesions involving the middle cerebellar peduncles. (D) Multiple contrast-enhancing lesions appear at a baseline involving mainly the left middle cerebellar peduncle as well as in proximity to the fourth ventricle. (E) Marked regression of these lesions occurs in response to Vemurafenib. (F) Complete regression appears following Vemurafenib/Cobimetinib dual therapy. Note that despite treatment, a marked loss of cerebellar mass occurs over the natural history of the disease. (G) Quantification of lesions’ dimensions between June 2015 to January 2018.
Figure 3.PET/CT findings of patients 1 and 2. (A and B) Axial PET/CT fusion images at the level of the kidneys of patient 1 prior to initiation of monotherapy (A) and following dual therapy (B). Note the complete regression of the PET-avid space-occupying lesion compressing the right kidney (white arrow). (C) Graphic representation of the SUVmax values measured in different lesions from patient 1. (D–F) Sagittal PET/CT fusion images at the level of the brainstem of patient 2 prior to initiation of monotherapy (D) and following dual therapy (E). A significant decrease in FDG uptake is noted in the brainstem lesion (white arrow). (F) Graphic representation of the SUVmax values measured in different lesions from patient 2.