| Literature DB >> 32338425 |
Samantha Pollard1, Steve Kalloger2,3, Deirdre Weymann1, Sophie Sun4,5,6, Jennifer Nuk4,7, Kasmintan A Schrader4,7,8, Dean A Regier1,2.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Multi-gene panel testing is replacing single-gene testing for patients with suspected hereditary cancer syndromes. The detection of a hereditary cancer syndrome allows tested individuals to initiate enhanced primary and secondary prevention efforts-where available-with a view to reduce disease burden. Current policy prevents testing programmes from communicating genetic test results with potentially affected family members, yet it is well documented that tested individuals face multiple challenges in initiating such discussions with relatives.Entities:
Keywords: family communication; genetic counselling; genetic testing; hereditary cancer syndromes; medical decision making; risk communication
Year: 2020 PMID: 32338425 PMCID: PMC7495068 DOI: 10.1111/hex.13062
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Health Expect ISSN: 1369-6513 Impact factor: 3.377
Interview topic guide
| Topic | Selected semi‐structured interview question | Prompt (optional) |
|---|---|---|
| Decision‐making process | What kind of information do you think is important to have before deciding whether or not to have a genetic test? | Is there anything that you know now that you wish you had known before you made the decision? Which of these issues is the MOST important to you? |
| How do you think that information should be presented? | In person by a genetic counselor? Online? | |
| Experience with the return of results | Can you tell me about what it was like to receive the results of your genetic test? | Is there anything that could have been done to make the results easier to understand? |
| Experience communicating with family | How prepared did you feel, to receive the results of your genetic testing? | Did you have enough information? Would you have preferred to have additional information prior to receiving those results? |
| Did you choose to share the results of your genetic test? Why or why not? | With which family members did you share the results? Is there anything that could have made it easier to share that information with (family member)? |
Participant demographics (N=25)
| Participant characteristic |
|
|
| Female | 16 | 64 |
| Mean age (range) | 53 (32‐78) | |
| Marital status | ||
| Married/ civil partnership | 18 | 72 |
| Single | 3 | 12 |
| Divorced/ separated | 3 | 12 |
| Widowed | 1 | 4 |
| Education | ||
| ≤ High school | 7 | 28 |
| Non‐university certificate | 9 | 36 |
| University degree | 9 | 36 |
| Employment | ||
| Paid | 12 | 48 |
| Retired | 7 | 28 |
| Long‐term disability | 6 | 24 |
| Cancer Site | ||
| Breast | 9 | 36 |
| Colon | 5 | 20 |
| Melanoma | 2 | 8 |
| Testicular | 1 | 4 |
| Renal | 2 | 8 |
| Lung | 2 | 8 |
| Endometrial | 1 | 4 |
| Ovarian | 1 | 4 |
| Participant reported test result | ||
| Index negative or carrier uninformative | 15 | 60 |
| Index or carrier pathogenic | 10 | 40 |
| Variant of unknown significance/inconclusive finding | 10 | 60 |
Categories are not mutually exclusive.
Barriers to communicating genetic risk with family members
| Major analytic theme | Quote # | Supporting quote |
|---|---|---|
| Family culture | 1 | “Like, the first thing I was kind of annoyed at my extended family for not telling us anything. But we lived in a kind of family who has a culture that you don't tell stuff that's personal. And so, man oh man, it would have been really good to know about that, but that's nothing to do with institutions. That's a family culture problem, the hush‐hush.” (004) |
| 2 | “I don’t communicate with my family”. (024) | |
| 3 | “…it's hard because my mom is not living with me, she is back home…So, it's hard to tell them what's really going on. Our culture is different from here…They hear you have cancer…I know I'm going to die, but it's hard for them and it's hard for me”. (001) | |
|
| “We're very open to talking to one another about everything in our lives, and so when we share something like heredity and DNA, then it just sort of confirms that we are definitely part of a family”. (003) | |
| Communicating with young relatives | 5 | “I have two sons, grown‐up sons with children of their own. And I told them. It was hard to tell them…I remember myself at their age. Things like that meant nothing to me…” (014) |
| 6 |
“I don't know how seriously they take it. You know, even with the melanoma…I'm always going on about sunscreen, and being careful and wearing hats, and… I don't think they pay that much attention or take it that seriously… I find that, you know, that's the thing about young people thinking they're infallible perhaps’. (018) | |
| 7 | “The conversation with my brother was… awkward a little bit…I don’t really think he fully understands what it might mean for him down the road if he decides to have children”. (009) | |
| Resistant family members | 8 | “So I just tried to explain to her that it's good to know, and now you will be able to keep on top of it with screening and so on. So it's good information to have. And the other daughter, of course, feels the opposite. She feels not knowing would be better than having the stress of knowing”. (012) |
| 9 | “She's one of these people that isn't wanting to know too many medical details”. (021) | |
| 10 | “I think it scared them when I got cancer because they saw what happened to my mom. So when it came down to the genetics, they didn’t want to think about it. Especially my oldest and she’ll probably never, ever”. (023) | |
| 11 | And my brother reacts strongly to all this. When I had the…cancer and I told him, he said, “Oh, they always make mistake. You have nothing”. (014) | |
| 12 | “I worry more about my nieces and my nephews. And I don't know what to do. If I should tell them or not…It's like putting a bowling ball in their lives. I don't know how to do it”. (014) | |
| 13 | “So my brother's wife was a little resistant. She was like, "If you have it I'm not telling my daughters…I don't want to start freaking them out for the future." But to me that was a poor decision, but I guess that leads to some other moral issues. Do you go behind their backs and tell their daughter…?’ (006) | |
| Familiarity with discussing cancer | 14 | “She's always known, all along, you know, that this may be passed on, and that we will end up having this discussion”. (017) |
| 15 | “I was in touch with the other [siblings] as I was having the testing done, and I said, "This could ‐‐ you know, you could possibly ‐‐ if this test comes back positive, there is an option that you guys could be tested and see if it stops here." And they were all onboard with that. None of them didn't want to know. They all wanted to know so that they could take possible actions to stop it. And two of my siblings have female offspring, and they're worried about them having the breast cancer factors. And so they're going through the testing right now. And I was informed that if it's negative for them, then it doesn't go past that generation”. (002) | |
| 16 | “That's maybe one of the sad parts, when there's enough people in the family that have had cancer that ‐‐ I guess they sort of accept it as a reality that, you know, the likelihood of people getting cancer is quite high. So they're sort of familiar with the process”. (015) | |
| 17 | It was a little challenging initially just telling my parents, because both of them didn’t want it to be from them. So, there was a bit of tension. And a little bit of guilt from both of them, and that was really tough. 009 |
Participant recommendations
| Recommendation | Quote # | Supportive quote |
|---|---|---|
| Lay summary provided by testing facility | 18 | “…And explain that the rates are low even among those under 50 or 60. But still to go through that information, and then have it so that they can sort of read it. So something that has like a basic definition of Lynch syndrome, a description of sort of the incidence rate of it, what it would mean in terms of passing that on to your children, and what it would mean for siblings, other family members. Because I know that while I was going through the testing my sister was, you know, stressed out wondering if she should be getting checked out too. And it turned out all to be negative in my case, but it would just be good to have that information up front for people…” (005) |
| 19 | “Something to send to the family members…what the results were, what this means for them, and, you know, what the next step is for them…” (017) | |
| 20 | “For family members who you may not even be that close to get the message, sometimes having a form is more helpful, having to call everyone or email…” (018) | |
| Advice for communicating with family | 21 |
“Other people's stories. That maybe, to know what they experience. I think I looked at something like that on the internet, but I would like to have something that is brought by the system, by the medical system where people say this is what happened when I told my children or, you know, my siblings and their reaction. And I think something like that would have helped. To be prepared of what the possibilities are” (014) |
| 22 |
“…you have to have the conversation with them. You can't just send them an e‐mail…So, something maybe around coaching people on how to tell family might be a little bit more useful”. (009) | |
| 23 |
“I think it would have been good to sort of address that piece, like how to approach your children about ‐‐ regardless if they’re positive or negative…a pamphlet on how to talk to children?”(020) |