| Literature DB >> 32188074 |
Hélène Amieva1, Camille Ouvrard1.
Abstract
Hearing loss is the third most prevalent health condition in older age. In recent years, research has consistently reported an association between hearing loss and mental health outcomes, including poorer cognitive performances. Whether treating hearing loss in elders improves cognition has been directly or indirectly addressed by several studies. This review aims at providing a synthesis of those results. Regarding the literature on hearing aids' use and cognition, although the lack of interventional studies has to be underlined, observational data suggest that hearing aids positively impact long-term cognition, even though more research is necessary to ascertain this statement and provide information on the length or frequency of use required in order to observe benefits. Regarding cochlear implants in elders experiencing more severe auditory deprivation, the literature is scarcer. The available studies have many limitations and do not allow the drawing of clear conclusions. Taken together, the results are encouraging. Nevertheless, because hearing loss is suspected to account for 9% of dementia cases, and also because hearing loss is one of the few potentially modifiable factors from a dementia prevention perspective, the need to stimulate research to have clearer knowledge of the benefits of treating hearing loss on cognitive outcomes is urgent.Entities:
Keywords: cochlear implant; cognitive decline; dementia; hearing aid; hearing loss
Year: 2020 PMID: 32188074 PMCID: PMC7141203 DOI: 10.3390/jcm9030805
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Clin Med ISSN: 2077-0383 Impact factor: 4.241
Main studies assessing the association between hearing aid use in older adults and cognitive outcomes.
| Study | Cross-Sectional or Prospective Design (and Length Follow-Up) | Sample Size | Cognitive Tools | Main Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ray et al. 2018 [ | Cross-sectional | 7385 | 10-word list immediate and delayed recall test, verbal fluency task | Higher cognitive scores in HA users |
| Lin et al. 2013 [ | Prospective: 6-year follow-up | 1984 | 3MS | No significant difference |
| Deal et al. 2015 [ | Prospective: 20-year follow-up | 253 | Delayed word recall test, verbal fluency task, | Lower decline in HA users in a global composite score |
| Acar et al. 2011 [ | Prospective: 3-month follow-up | 34 | MMSE | Lower decline in HA users |
| Amieva et al. 2015 [ | Prospective: 25-year follow-up | 3670 | MMSE | Lower decline in HA users |
| Dawes et al. 2015 [ | Prospective: 11-year follow-up | 666 | MMSE, TMT, auditory verbal learning, DSST, verbal fluency task | No significant difference |
HA, Hearing aids; 3MS, Modified Mini Mental State Examination; DSST, Digit symbol substitution test; MMSE, Mini Mental State Examination; TMT, Trail Making Test.
Main studies assessing the association between cochlear implantation in older adults and cognitive outcomes.
| Study | Length Follow-Up after Cochlear Implantation | Sample Size | Cognitive Tools | Main Result |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Crary et al. 1982 [ | 1 year | 46 | WAIS, Graham–Kendall Memory for Designs, TMT, Bender Visual Motor Gestalt | Improved performance in a subsample of participants by descriptive data only |
| Castiglione et al. 2015 [ | 1 year | 15 | MOCA | Improved performance |
| Mosnier et al. 2015 [ | 1 year | 94 | MMSE, Five-Word Test, Clock drawing test, d2 test of attention, TMT | Improved performance |
| Cosetti et al. 2016 [ | 3.7 years in average | 7 | WAIS, TMT, controlled oral word association test, Boston naming test, RBANS | Improved performance reported in some participants by descriptive data only |
| Ambert-Dahan et al. 2017 [ | 1 year | 18 | CODEX, MOCA | Improved performance reported in some participants by descriptive data only |
| Jayakody et al. 2017 [ | 1 year | 39 | CANTAB | Improved performance |
| Sonnet et al. 2017 [ | 1 year | 16 | MMSE, Rey complex figure test, TMT, Five-Word Test, oral naming test DO80 | No difference |
| Sarant et al. 2019 [ | 1.5 year | 59 | Groton Maze Learning Test from CogState battery | Improved performance in a subsample of participants |
WAIS, Wechsler abbreviated scale of intelligence; TMT, trail making test; MOCA, montreal cognitive assessment; MMSE, mini mental state examination; RBANS, repeatable battery for the assessment of neuropsychological status; CODEX, cognitive disorders examination; CANTAB, Cambridge neuropsychological test automated battery.