Literature DB >> 32056020

Natural history collections and the future legacy of ecological research.

Rodrigo B Salvador1, Carlo M Cunha2.   

Abstract

Natural history collections are now being championed as key to broad ecological studies, especially those involving human impacts in the Anthropocene. However, collections are going through a crisis that threatens their present and future value, going beyond underfunding/understaffing to a more damaging practice: current researchers are no longer depositing material. This seems to be especially true for ecological studies that now benefit from historical collections, as those researchers are not trained to think about voucher specimens. We investigated indexed journals in Ecology and Zoology to assess if they have guidelines concerning voucher specimens. Only 4% of ecological journals presently encourage (but mostly do not require) voucher deposition, while 15% of zoological journals encourage it. In the first place, this goes contrary to scientific standards of reproducibility, since specimens are primary data. Secondly, this erodes the legacy we will leave for future researchers, because if this trend goes on unchecked, it will leave a massive gap in collections' coverage, undermining the quality that is presently acclaimed. The scientific community needs a wakeup call to avoid impoverishing the future value of natural history collections. Training and changing researchers' mindsets is essential, but that takes time. For the moment, we propose a stopgap measure: at the minimum, academic journals should encourage authors to deposit specimens in open collections, such as museums and universities.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Museums; Primary data; Reproducibility; Voucher specimens; Vouchering

Mesh:

Year:  2020        PMID: 32056020     DOI: 10.1007/s00442-020-04620-0

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Oecologia        ISSN: 0029-8549            Impact factor:   3.225


  8 in total

1.  The importance of being earnest: what, if anything, constitutes a "specimen examined?".

Authors:  L A Ruedas; J Salazar-Bravo; J W Dragoo; T L Yates
Journal:  Mol Phylogenet Evol       Date:  2000-10       Impact factor: 4.286

2.  Berkeley accused of biotech bias as ecologist is denied tenure.

Authors:  Rex Dalton
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2003-12-11       Impact factor: 49.962

3.  Error cascades in the biological sciences: the unwanted consequences of using bad taxonomy in ecology.

Authors:  Alejandro Bortolus
Journal:  Ambio       Date:  2008-03       Impact factor: 5.129

4.  Phylogenies without roots? A plea for the use of vouchers in molecular phylogenetic studies.

Authors:  F Pleijel; U Jondelius; E Norlinder; A Nygren; B Oxelman; C Schander; P Sundberg; M Thollesson
Journal:  Mol Phylogenet Evol       Date:  2008-03-21       Impact factor: 4.286

5.  Specimens as primary data: museums and 'open science'.

Authors:  Menno Schilthuizen; Charles S Vairappan; Eleanor M Slade; Darren J Mann; Jeremy A Miller
Journal:  Trends Ecol Evol       Date:  2015-03-23       Impact factor: 17.712

6.  Mass extinction in poorly known taxa.

Authors:  Claire Régnier; Guillaume Achaz; Amaury Lambert; Robert H Cowie; Philippe Bouchet; Benoît Fontaine
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2015-06-08       Impact factor: 11.205

7.  Specimen collection: an essential tool.

Authors:  L A Rocha; A Aleixo; G Allen; F Almeda; C C Baldwin; M V L Barclay; J M Bates; A M Bauer; F Benzoni; C M Berns; M L Berumen; D C Blackburn; S Blum; F Bolaños; R C K Bowie; R Britz; R M Brown; C D Cadena; K Carpenter; L M Ceríaco; P Chakrabarty; G Chaves; J H Choat; K D Clements; B B Collette; A Collins; J Coyne; J Cracraft; T Daniel; M R de Carvalho; K de Queiroz; F Di Dario; R Drewes; J P Dumbacher; A Engilis; M V Erdmann; W Eschmeyer; C R Feldman; B L Fisher; J Fjeldså; P W Fritsch; J Fuchs; A Getahun; A Gill; M Gomon; T Gosliner; G R Graves; C E Griswold; R Guralnick; K Hartel; K M Helgen; H Ho; D T Iskandar; T Iwamoto; Z Jaafar; H F James; D Johnson; D Kavanaugh; N Knowlton; E Lacey; H K Larson; P Last; J M Leis; H Lessios; J Liebherr; M Lowman; D L Mahler; V Mamonekene; K Matsuura; G C Mayer; H Mays; J McCosker; R W McDiarmid; J McGuire; M J Miller; R Mooi; R D Mooi; C Moritz; P Myers; M W Nachman; R A Nussbaum; D Ó Foighil; L R Parenti; J F Parham; E Paul; G Paulay; J Pérez-Emán; A Pérez-Matus; S Poe; J Pogonoski; D L Rabosky; J E Randall; J D Reimer; D R Robertson; M-O Rödel; M T Rodrigues; P Roopnarine; L Rüber; M J Ryan; F Sheldon; G Shinohara; A Short; W B Simison; W F Smith-Vaniz; V G Springer; M Stiassny; J G Tello; C W Thompson; T Trnski; P Tucker; T Valqui; M Vecchione; E Verheyen; P C Wainwright; T A Wheeler; W T White; K Will; J T Williams; G Williams; E O Wilson; K Winker; R Winterbottom; C C Witt
Journal:  Science       Date:  2014-05-23       Impact factor: 47.728

8.  Non-repeatable science: assessing the frequency of voucher specimen deposition reveals that most arthropod research cannot be verified.

Authors:  Shaun Turney; Elyssa R Cameron; Christopher A Cloutier; Christopher M Buddle
Journal:  PeerJ       Date:  2015-08-06       Impact factor: 2.984

  8 in total
  5 in total

1.  Migratory connectivity then and now: a northward shift in breeding origins of a long-distance migratory bird wintering in the tropics.

Authors:  Camila Gómez; Keith A Hobson; Nicholas J Bayly; Kenneth V Rosenberg; Andrea Morales-Rozo; Paula Cardozo; Carlos Daniel Cadena
Journal:  Proc Biol Sci       Date:  2021-04-14       Impact factor: 5.349

2.  Relative Contribution of Citizen Science, Museum Data and Publications in Delineating the Distribution of the Stag Beetle in Spain.

Authors:  Marcos Méndez; Fernando Cortés-Fossati
Journal:  Insects       Date:  2021-02-27       Impact factor: 2.769

3.  Extreme bill dimorphism leads to different but overlapping isotopic niches and similar trophic positions in sexes of the charismatic extinct huia.

Authors:  Barbara M Tomotani; Rodrigo B Salvador; Amandine J M Sabadel; Colin M Miskelly; Julie C S Brown; Josette Delgado; Patrick Boussès; Yves Cherel; Susan M Waugh; Sarah J Bury
Journal:  Oecologia       Date:  2021-11-29       Impact factor: 3.225

4.  Global insect decline is the result of wilful political failure: A battle plan for entomology.

Authors:  Philip Donkersley; Louise Ashton; Greg P A Lamarre; Simon Segar
Journal:  Ecol Evol       Date:  2022-10-12       Impact factor: 3.167

5.  Citizen science and online data: Opportunities and challenges for snake ecology and action against snakebite.

Authors:  Andrew M Durso; Rafael Ruiz de Castañeda; Camille Montalcini; M Rosa Mondardini; Jose L Fernandez-Marques; François Grey; Martin M Müller; Peter Uetz; Benjamin M Marshall; Russell J Gray; Christopher E Smith; Donald Becker; Michael Pingleton; Jose Louies; Arthur D Abegg; Jeannot Akuboy; Gabriel Alcoba; Jennifer C Daltry; Omar M Entiauspe-Neto; Paul Freed; Marco Antonio de Freitas; Xavier Glaudas; Song Huang; Tianqi Huang; Yatin Kalki; Yosuke Kojima; Anne Laudisoit; Kul Prasad Limbu; José G Martínez-Fonseca; Konrad Mebert; Mark-Oliver Rödel; Sara Ruane; Manuel Ruedi; Andreas Schmitz; Sarah A Tatum; Frank Tillack; Avinash Visvanathan; Wolfgang Wüster; Isabelle Bolon
Journal:  Toxicon X       Date:  2021-06-22
  5 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.