An RNA Ring was Not the Progenitor of the tRNA Molecule.

I analyzed the model that suggests that an RNA ring might have been the progenitor of the tRNA molecule (Demongeot and Moreira in J Theor Biol 249:314-324, 2007; Demongeot and Seligmann in J Mol Evol 1-23, 2019a; Demongeot and Norris in Life 9(2):51, 2019). In particular, I analyze three ways in which this precursor, especially in its RNA hairpin form, could have evolved into the complete tRNA molecule. These three modalities are based on multiple duplication events, and therefore, appear to be less parsimonious than that which assumes that this molecule originated through one duplication of a single hairpin structure. The conclusion is, therefore, that the latter model appears to be preferable with respect to that of the RNA ring, also because there are many independent observations and some of a historical nature that would corroborate it in an extraordinary way.