Linna Duan1, Eric Milan Mukherjee2, Daniel Glenn Federman1,3. 1. Department of Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, CT, USA. 2. Department of Medicine, Yale University Waterbury Hospital Health Center, Waterbury, CT, USA. 3. Department of Medicine, VA Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven, CT, USA.
Abstract
Background: Little is known about patient preference regarding the physical exam in non-urgent primary care settings.Objective: To determine the differences between a patient's expectations of the physical exam and the actual components of the physical examination performed during a non-urgent visit.Design: A total of 452 surveys administered in the waiting room of a VA primary care clinic in West Haven, CT.Key results: The response rate was 91.6% (n = 414). For 15 of 16 maneuvers on the survey, more respondents believed a reasonable provider should conduct it than received it at their annual physical exam; for 7 of them (breast, axillary, rectal, pelvic, total body skin exam, electrocardiogram, and stress test), over twice as many respondents believed they should be done than received them. There was an association between a patient's perception of their primary care provider and the number of maneuvers recalled at their annual exam (P < 0.001), and a gap in the number of maneuvers expected from a reasonable provider by nonwhite and white patients (P < 0.001).Limitations: Convenience sample, response bias (healthy patients are more likely to respond) and recall bias. Conclusion: Patient perception of their primary care provider is strongly associated with the number of maneuvers recalled during an annual physical. Furthermore, the number of maneuvers expected by a patient is influenced by race, with nonwhite patients desiring more. This suggests the need for further research on the role of race in the expectations of healthcare providers.
Background: Little is known about patient preference regarding the physical exam in non-urgent primary care settings.Objective: To determine the differences between a patient's expectations of the physical exam and the actual components of the physical examination performed during a non-urgent visit.Design: A total of 452 surveys administered in the waiting room of a VA primary care clinic in West Haven, CT.Key results: The response rate was 91.6% (n = 414). For 15 of 16 maneuvers on the survey, more respondents believed a reasonable provider should conduct it than received it at their annual physical exam; for 7 of them (breast, axillary, rectal, pelvic, total body skin exam, electrocardiogram, and stress test), over twice as many respondents believed they should be done than received them. There was an association between a patient's perception of their primary care provider and the number of maneuvers recalled at their annual exam (P < 0.001), and a gap in the number of maneuvers expected from a reasonable provider by nonwhite and white patients (P < 0.001).Limitations: Convenience sample, response bias (healthy patients are more likely to respond) and recall bias. Conclusion:Patient perception of their primary care provider is strongly associated with the number of maneuvers recalled during an annual physical. Furthermore, the number of maneuvers expected by a patient is influenced by race, with nonwhite patients desiring more. This suggests the need for further research on the role of race in the expectations of healthcare providers.
Authors: Sylvia K Oboler; Allan V Prochazka; Ralph Gonzales; Stanley Xu; Robert J Anderson Journal: Ann Intern Med Date: 2002-05-07 Impact factor: 25.391
Authors: Susan L Zickmund; Kelly H Burkitt; Shasha Gao; Roslyn A Stone; Audrey L Jones; Leslie R M Hausmann; Galen E Switzer; Sonya Borrero; Keri L Rodriguez; Michael J Fine Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2018-01-08 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Abraham Verghese; Blake Charlton; Jerome P Kassirer; Meghan Ramsey; John P A Ioannidis Journal: Am J Med Date: 2015-07-02 Impact factor: 4.965