| Literature DB >> 31709355 |
Alexander Upfill-Brown1, Nicholas Satariano2, Brian Feeley2,3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The number of anatomic total shoulder (TSA), hemiarthroplasty (HA), and reverse total shoulder arthroplasties (RTSA) is rapidly increasing in the United States. Stemless shoulder arthroplasty has numerous theoretical advantages, including preserved bone stock, decreased operating time, reduced rate of intraoperative humerus fracture, and flexibility of anatomic reconstruction. Only recently studies with more than 5 years of mean follow-up have become available.Entities:
Keywords: Shoulder arthroplasty; canal-sparing; press-fit; reverse shoulder arthroplasty; stemless
Year: 2019 PMID: 31709355 PMCID: PMC6835021 DOI: 10.1016/j.jses.2019.07.008
Source DB: PubMed Journal: JSES Open Access ISSN: 2468-6026
Summary of stemless anatomical TSA and HA studies identified, grouped by average length of follow-up
| Study | Device | Type | Patients | Reported indications | Mean FU (mo) | Reported outcomes | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| TSA | HA | ||||||
| Medium term | |||||||
| Habermeyer et al 2015 | Arthrex/Eclipse | Case series | 29 | 39 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA, postinfectious OA, instability, CTA, GD | 72 | CMS, ER, Flex, Abd |
| Hawi et al 2017 | Arthrex/Eclipse | Case series | 17 | 32 | Post-trauma OA, primary OA, instability, CTA, postinfectious OA | 108 | CMS, ER, Flex, Abd |
| Uschok et al 2017 | Arthrex/Eclipse | Randomized | 14 | Primary OA | 68 | CMS, ER, Flex, Abd | |
| Beck et al 2018 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 31 | Primary OA, RA, post-traumatic and HH necrosis | 95 | CMS, QuickDASH, VAS, Abd, Flex | |
| Short term | |||||||
| Huguet et al 2010 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 19 | 44 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA, osteonecrosis | 45 | CMS, ER, Flex |
| Brunner et al 2012 | Arthrex/Eclipse | Case series | 119 | 114 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA, postinfectious OA, AVN, RA, instability, CTA | 23 | CMS, ER, Flex, Abd |
| Berth and Pap 2012 | Biomet/TESS | Randomized | 41 | Primary OA | 31 | CMS, DASH, ER, Abd, Flex | |
| Razmjou et al 2013 | Biomet/TESS | Comparative | 17 | Primary OA | >24 | RCMS, ASES, QuickDASH, WOOS | |
| Bell and Coghlan 2014 | Mathys/Affinis | Case series | 12 | Primary OA | >24 | CMS, ASES, DASH, SPADI, Abd | |
| Mariotti et al 2014 | Wright Med/Simpliciti | Comparative | 9 | Primary OA | 24 | CMS, SST, ER, IR, Abd, Flex | |
| Ballas et al 2016 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 27 | Malunion | 44 | CMS | |
| Churchill et al 2016 | Wright Med/Simpliciti | Case series | 149 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA | >24 | CMS, ASES, SST, VAS, ER, Abd, IR | |
| Spranz et al 2017 | Biomet/TESS | Comparative | 12 | Primary OA | 52 | CMS, ER, Flex, Ext, Abd | |
| Krukenberg et al 2018 | Zimmer/Sidus | Case series | 73 | 32 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA, AVN, instability, RA | >24 | CMS, ASES, SSV, ER, Flex |
| Heuberer et al 2018 | Arthrex/Eclipse | Case series | 33 | 40 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA | 58 | CMS |
| Very short term | |||||||
| Sayed-Noor et al 2018 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 63 | Primary OA | 12 | QuickDASH, ER, Abd | |
| Maier 2015 | Biomet/TESS | Comparative | 12 | Primary OA | 6 | CMS, ER, IR, Abd, Flex | |
| Schoch et al 2011 | Arthrex/Eclipse | Case series | 115 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA | 12 | CMS, ER, Abd, Flex | |
| Kadum et al 2011 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 22 | Primary OA, post-trauma OA, RA | 14 | QuickDASH, EQ-5D, VAS | |
TSA, total shoulder arthroplasty; HA, hemiarthroplasty; FU, follow-up; OA, osteoarthritis; CTA, cuff tear arthropathy; GD, glenoid dysplasia; CMS, Constant-Murley score; ER, external rotation; Flex, flexion; Abd, Abduction; TESS, Total Evolutive Shoulder System; RA, rheumatoid arthritis; HH, humeral head; DASH, Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score; VAS, visual analog scale for pain; AVN, avascular necrosis; RCMS, relative Constant-Murley score; ASES, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score; WOOS, Western Ontario Osteoarthritis Shoulder score; SPADI, Shoulder Pain and Disability Index; SST, Simple Shoulder Test; IR, internal rotation; SSV, Subjective Shoulder Value.
Summary of stemless RTSA studies identified
| Study | Device | Type | Patients | Reported indications | Mean FU (mo) | Reported outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ballas and Béguin 2013 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 56 | RCT, CTA, primary OA | 59 | CMS, OSS, ER, Abd |
| Kadum et al 2014 | Biomet/TESS | Comparative | 16 | CTA, primary OA with RCD, post-trauma sequelae, RA | 39 | QuickDASH, EQ-5D, VAS, IR, Abd, Flex |
| Teissier et al 2015 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 87 | RCT, CTA | 41 | CMS, QuickDASH, ASES, ER, Abd, Flex |
| von Engelhardt et al 2015 | Biomet/TESS | Case series | 65 | CTA, revision arthroplasty | 18 | RCMS, DASH |
| Levy et al 2016 | IDO/Verso | Case series | 98 | CTA, post-trauma sequelae, RA, RCT, RCD | 50 | CMS, SSV, ER, IR, Abd |
| Moroder et al 2016 | Biomet/TESS | Comparative | 24 | CTA | 34 | CMS, ASES, SSV, VAS |
RTSA, reverse total shoulder arthroplasty; FU, follow-up; TESS, Total Evolutive Shoulder System; RCT, rotator cuff tear; CTA, cuff tear arthropathy; OA, osteoarthritis; CMS, Constant-Murley score; OSS, Oxford Shoulder Score; ER, external rotation; Abd, abduction; RCD, rotator cuff deficiency; RA, rheumatoid arthritis; DASH, Disabilities of the Arm, Shoulder, and Hand score; VAS, visual analog scale; IR, internal rotation; Flex, flexion; ASES, American Shoulder and Elbow Surgeons score; RCMS, relative Constant-Murley score; SSV, Subjective Shoulder Value.
Only postoperative values reported for these scores.
Figure 1Humeral components from 2 stemless total shoulder arthroplasty systems most commonly found in literature. (A) Picture of the Eclipse (Arthrex, Naples, FL, USA) from Habermeyer et al, with (B) the representative AP radiograph from Brunner et al. (C) Picture of Simpliciti (Wright Medical, Memphis, TN, USA) and (D) the representative anteroposterior radiography both from Churchill et al.
Figure 2Reported outcomes before and after anatomical stemless total shoulder arthroplasty and hemiarthroplasty for Constant-Murray score (A) and external rotation (B). Colors represent each study, with warm colors corresponding to medium-term follow-up studies and cool colors corresponding to short-term follow-up studies. Very short–term studies (average follow-up <18 months) were excluded.
Figure 3Reported outcomes before and after stemless reverse total shoulder arthroplasty for Constant-Murray score (A), external rotation (B), and abduction (C). Colors represent each study. The size of the point represents the number of patients in each study.
Summary of humeral component complications in stemless anatomical TSA and HA
| Study | Patients | Complications | Radiologic changes | Related revisions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medium term | ||||
| Habermeyer et al 2015 | 78 | 1 incomplete RLL, 3 partial osteolysis under HH, 34% with decreased BD of GT | None | |
| Hawi et al 2017 | 43 | 1 asymptomatic radiological loosening | 1 incomplete RLL on HH, 29% decrease BD over GT | None |
| Uschok et al 2017 | 14 | Reduced BD in GT in 29% | None | |
| Beck et al 2018 | 31 | None | None | |
| Short term | ||||
| Huguet et al 2010 | 63 | 5 intraoperative fracture of metaphysis | None | |
| Brunner et al 2012 | 233 | 1 asymptomatic radiological loosening | 9 incomplete RLL <2 mm, 5 incomplete RLL >2 mm, 2 RLL >2 mm | None |
| Berth and Pap 2012 | 41 | None | None | |
| Razmjou et al 2013 | 17 | 1 RLL | ||
| Bell and Coghlan 2014 | 12 | None | None | |
| Mariotti et al 2014 | 9 | None | ||
| Ballas et al 2016 | 27 | 1 osteolysis under HH | None | |
| Churchill et al 2016 | 149 | None | None | |
| Spranz et al 2017 | 12 | |||
| Krukenberg et al 2018 | 105 | 1 intraoperative fracture greater tuberosity | 1 incomplete RLL HH | None |
| Heuberer et al 2018 | 73 | 8 with signs osteolysis, decreased BD over GT in 43% | None | |
| Very short term | ||||
| Sayed-Noor et al 2018 | 63 | None | ||
| Maier 2015 | 12 | None | ||
| Schoch et al 2011 | 115 | |||
| Kadum et al 2011 | 22 | |||
TSA, total shoulder arthroplasty; HA, hemiarthroplasty; RLL, radiolucent lines; HH, humeral head; BD, bone density; GT, greater tuberosity.
Summary of humeral component complications in stemless RTSA
| Study | Patients | Complications | Radiologic changes | Related revisions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ballas and Béguin 2013 | 56 | 1 intraoperative fracture of metaphysis, 1 loosening (3 d) | None | 1 |
| Kadum et al 2014 | 16 | None | None | None |
| Teissier et al 2015 | 87 | None | None | None |
| von Engelhardt et al 2015 | 67 | 1 loosening (in revision), 1 malposition | NR | 2 |
| Levy et al 2016 | 98 | 2 intraoperative fracture of metaphysis | None | None |
| Moroder et al 2016 | 24 | None | 3 incomplete RLL | None |
RTSA, reverse total shoulder arthroplasty; NR, not reported; RLL, radiolucent lines.
Summary of glenoid component complications in stemless anatomical TSA and HA
| Study | Patients | Complications | Radiologic changes | Related revisions |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Medium term | ||||
| Habermeyer et al 2015 | 78 | 2 loosening | Incomplete RLL in 8.3% of MBC and 53% of cemented | 2 |
| Hawi et al 2017 | 43 | 5 with RLL, 27% with incomplete RLL | None | |
| Uschok et al 2017 | 14 | 2 loosening | 2 incomplete RLL | 0 |
| Beck et al 2018 | 31 | 1 loosening, 1 failure MBC | 20 of 22 with RL | 1 |
| Short term | ||||
| Huguet et al 2010 | 63 | None | ||
| Brunner et al 2012 | 233 | 1 loosening | None | 1 |
| Berth and Pap 2012 | 41 | 1 intraoperative fracture | 9 with RL | None |
| Razmjou et al 2013 | 17 | 6 intraoperative perforation | 1 subsidence | |
| Bell and Coghlan 2014 | 12 | 8 incomplete RLL | None | |
| Mariotti et al 2014 | 9 | None | ||
| Ballas et al 2016 | 27 | None | None | |
| Churchill et al 2016 | 149 | 1 loosening | None | 1 |
| Spranz et al 2017 | 12 | NR | ||
| Krukenberg et al 2018 | 105 | 6 complete RLL, 10 incomplete RLL | None | |
| Heuberer et al 2018 | 73 | None | None | |
| Very short term | ||||
| Sayed-Noor et al 2018 | 63 | NR | None | |
| Maier 2015 | 12 | NR | None | |
| Schoch et al 2011 | 115 | 2 loosening | NR | |
| Kadum et al 2011 | 22 | NR | ||
TSA, total shoulder arthroplasty; HA, hemiarthroplasty; RLL, radiolucent lines; MBC, metal-backed component; RL, radiolucent; NR, not reported.
Summary of glenoid component complications in stemless RTSA
| Study | Patients | Complications | Radiologic changes | Scapular notching (%) | Related revisions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Ballas and Béguin 2013 | 56 | 3 disassociation | None | 5 (9) | 3 |
| Kadum et al 2014 | 16 | 2 loosening | None | 4 (25) | 2 |
| Teissier et al 2015 | 87 | None | None | 17 (19) | None |
| von Engelhardt et al 2015 | 67 | 3 loosening, 2 malpositioning | NR | 9 (13) | 4 |
| Levy et al 2016 | 98 | 1 loosening | None | 21 (22) | 1 |
| Moroder et al 2016 | 24 | None | NR | 2 (8) | None |
RTSA, reverse total shoulder arthroplasty; NR, not reported.