| Literature DB >> 31535461 |
Yannick D Muller1,2,3, Julien Vionnet2,4, Franziska Beyeler5, Philippe Eigenmann6, Jean-Christoph Caubet6, Jean Villard7, Thierry Berney8, Kathrin Scherer9, Francois Spertini10, Michael P Fricker11, Claudia Lang12, Peter Schmid-Grendelmeier12, Christian Benden13, Pascale Roux Lombard1, Vincent Aubert10, Franz Immer5, Manuel Pascual2, Thomas Harr1.
Abstract
Allergy transfer upon solid organ transplantation has been reported in the literature, although only few data are available as to the frequency, significance, and management of these cases. Based on a review of 577 consecutive deceased donors from the Swisstransplant Donor-Registry, 3 cases (0.5%) of fatal anaphylaxis were identified, 2 because of peanut and 1 of wasp allergy. The sera of all 3 donors and their 10 paired recipients, prospectively collected before and after transplantation for the Swiss Transplant Cohort Study, were retrospectively processed using a commercial protein microarray fluorescent test. As early as 5 days posttransplantation, newly acquired peanut-specific IgE were transiently detected from 1 donor to 3 recipients, of whom 1 liver and lung recipients developed grade III anaphylaxis. Yet, to define how allergy testing should be performed in transplant recipients and to better understand the impact of immunosuppressive therapy on IgE sensitization, we prospectively studied 5 atopic living-donor kidney recipients. All pollen-specific IgE and >90% of skin prick tests remained positive 7 days and 3 months after transplantation, indicating that early diagnosis of donor-derived IgE sensitization is possible. Importantly, we propose recommendations with respect to safety for recipients undergoing solid-organ transplantation from donors with a history of fatal anaphylaxis.Entities:
Keywords: IgE; allergy; allergy transfer; anaphylaxis; business/management; clinical decision-making; clinical research/practice; diagnostic techniques and imaging; guidelines; immunoglobulin E; immunosuppression; immunosuppression/immune modulation; management; organ transplantation in general; patient safety; solid organ transplantation
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31535461 PMCID: PMC7065229 DOI: 10.1111/ajt.15601
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Am J Transplant ISSN: 1600-6135 Impact factor: 8.086
Systematic review of the literature for allergy transfer
| Series 1 | Series 2 | Series 3 | Series 4 | Series 5 | Series 6 | Series 7 | Series 8 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Organ(s) with allergy transfer | Liver | Liver | Liver | Liver, lung | Liver‐kidney | Pancreas‐kidney, liver (no information provided) | Lung | Lung |
| Organ(s) without allergy transfer | Kidney, kidney‐pancreas | — | Kidneys, heart | Kidney, pancreas | Pancreas‐kidney | Kidney | — | Kidney, kidney‐pancreas |
| Cause of donor death | Anaphylaxis | Anaphylaxis | Anaphylaxis | Car accident | Anaphylaxis | Anaphylaxis | Obstructed ventriculoperitoneal shunt | Anaphylaxis |
| Supposed responsible allergen for death | Peanut, cashew nut, sesame seed | Unknown | Peanut | — | Peanut | Peanut | — | Peanut |
| Donor history of allergy | Atopic dermatitis, asthma | Allergy to nuts, kiwi, seafood, and wheat | Asthma | Asthma, peanut allergy | — | Peanut allergy | Peanut allergy | Peanut allergy |
| Anaphylaxis events (Muller classification) in the recipient | POD 25 (grade 2), POW 32 (unclear) | POD 8 (grade 3) | POD 10 and 28 (grade 1) | Liver: POM 2 (grade 4), lung: POM 3 (grade 3) | POM 3 (grade 3) | — | POW < 4 (4 episodes, up to grade 4) | POD 4 (asthmatic crisis), POW 5‐16 (asthmatic crisis), POM 7 (grade 3) |
| Time to allergy test | POW 9‐10 | POW 4 | POD > 28 | Liver: POD 1, lung: POM 4 | POW > 12 | POW 4 | POW 8 | POW > 28 |
| Duration of allergy (supposed) | >48 wk | >3 wk | >4 wk | Liver: <8 mo, lung: >18 mo | >12 wk | <24 wk | <1.5 y | >7 y |
| Skin Test | Positive for peanut, cashew, sesame (POW 6) | Negative | Positive for peanut (POD28) | Liver: negative (POM 8), lung: positive for peanut (POM 4‐18) | — | Positive for peanut (POM 1), negative (POM 6) | Positive for peanut (POM 2), negative (1 y after Tx) | Positive for peanut (POM > 7), negative (5 y after Tx) |
| IgE serology | Negative | Negative | Negative | Liver: positive for rAra h3 (POD 1), negative (POM 5), lung: positive for rAra h1‐2‐3 (POM 4‐8‐18) | Positive for peanut (POM 3) | Positive for rAra h1‐2 (POM 1), negative (POM 6) | Negative | Negative (5 y after Tx) |
| Oral challenge | — | Positive for walnuts (grade 3, POW 4‐5) | — | Liver: negative (POM 8) | — | Negative (POM 6) | Negative (1.5 y after Tx) | Positive (asthmatic crisis) 7 y after Tx |
| Immunosuppression | Tacrolimus, Azathioprine, Glucocorticoids | Tacrolimus, MMF, Glucocorticoids | Cyclosporine, Glucocorticoids | Liver: Cyclosporine, MMF, Glucocorticoids, lung: Tacrolimus, MMF Glucocorticoids | Cyclosporine, Azathioprine, Glucocorticoids | — | Azathioprine, Cyclosporine | Cyclosporine, Azathioprine, Glucocorticoids |
| Atopic status of the recipient | — | — | — | Liver: ‐, lung: negative | — | — | Positive | — |
| Age/Sex of the recipient | 60/m | 54/m | 28/f | Liver: 62/f, lung: 54/f | 35/m | 32/f | 47/f | 42/f |
| Reference (PMID) | 12546616 | 19424047 | 11753913 | Liver: 21668638, lung: 22172896 | 9297112 | 24919754 | 21766079 | 18926410 |
| Reference | Phan et al (ref | Vagefi et al (ref | Trotter et al (ref | Dewachter et al (ref | Legendre et al (ref | Berry et al (ref | Bhinder et al (ref | Khalid et al (ref |
MMF, mycophenolate mofetil; PMID, Pubmed ID; POD, postoperative day; POM, postoperative month; POW, postoperative week; Tx, transplantation.
Baseline clinical data of the recipients. Atopic status was assessed by the presence of specific IgE against, pollen, animal dander, or house dusts mites using commercial protein microarray bearing recombinant allergenic molecules (ISAC)
| Recipients organ | Donor | Baseline disease | Atopic status | Age at Tx (y) | Induction immunosuppression | Maintenance immunosuppression (6 mo) | Maintenance immunosuppression (12 mo) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Heart | 1 (peanut) | Dilated cardiomyopathy (anthracycline‐ induced sarcoma) | Negative | 11 | ATG, Glucocorticoids, TAC, MMF | TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids |
| Lung | 1 (peanut) | Cystic fibrosis | Positive | 25 | Basiliximab, CsA, MMF, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MPA, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MPA, Glucocorticoids |
| Liver left | 1 (peanut) | Biliary atresia | Positive | 1 | Basiliximab, Glucocorticoids, TAC | Glucocorticoids, TAC | TAC |
| Liver right | 1 (peanut) | Primary biliary cholangitis | Positive | 17 | Basiliximab, TAC, MMF | TAC, MMF | TAC, MMF |
| Kidney left | 1 (peanut) | Hypertension/renovascular glomerulosclerosis | Negative | 76 | Thymoglobulin, TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids |
| Lung | 2 (wasp) | Cystic fibrosis | Positive | 20 | Basiliximab, TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids |
| Kidney left | 2 (wasp) | Glomerulonephritis/vasculitis | Negative | 58 | Basiliximab, TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids | Basiliximab, TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids | Basiliximab, TAC, MMF, Glucocorticoids |
| Heart and kidney | 3 (peanut) | Ischemic heart disease, Hypertension/renovascular glomerulosclerosis | Negative | 49 | ATG, Glucocorticoids, CsA, MMF | Glucocorticoids, CsA, MMF | Glucocorticoids, CsA, MMF |
| Liver (left) | 3 (peanut) | Sclerosing cholangitis | Negative | 5 | Basiliximab, TAC, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MMF | TAC, MMF |
| Kidney pancreas | 3 (peanut) | Diabetic nephropathy (type 1 DM) | Negative | 49 | Thymoglobulin, TAC, MPA, Glucocorticoids | TAC, MPA | TAC, MPA |
CsA, cyclosporine; DM, diabetes mellitus; MMF, mycophenolate mofetil; MPA, mycophenolic acid; TAC, tacrolimus; TX, transplantation.
Figure 1Allergy transfer analysis in donor and recipients. A, Overview of 3 series of donors who died because of fatal anaphylaxis. Green charts show patients with IgE transfer and red charts patients without detectable IgE transfer. Dashed lines highlight recipients with positive oral challenge. § shows atopic recipients. Atopic status was assessed by the presence of specific IgE against, pollen, animal dander, or house dust mites using commercial protein microarray bearing recombinant allergenic molecules (ISAC). B, Donors sera analysis with ISAC. Green recombinant IgE highlights those who were transferred into recipients (left Y axis). Yellow bars (right Y axis) represent the tryptase (ng/mL) measured in donors during their hospitalization. C, IgE follow‐up over time in recipients (liver recipient 1 [LiverR1], liver recipient 2 [LiverSplitR2], lung recipient [LungR3]) of series 1 compared to donor. D, Percentage of atopic recipients with or without IgE transfer. E, Absolute number of sensitizations before and 6 months after transplantation in all atopic recipients (series 1‐3) [Color figure can be viewed at http://www.wileyonlinelibrary.com]
Figure 2Allergy persistence in 5 symptomatic atopic patients. A, Immunosuppression protocol of the 5 recipients over time. B, Representative skin prick test results 7 days after transplantation in 1 of the recipients. C, Areas in mm2 of the positive skin prick tests the day before transplantation 7 and 90 days after transplantation. D, Level of total IgE over time (day before transplantation, 7 and 90 days after transplantation). E, Level of recombinant IgE over time (day before transplantation, 7 and 90 days after transplantation). F, Rhinoconjunctivitis symptoms score before and 90 days after transplantation [Color figure can be viewed at http://www.wileyonlinelibrary.com]
Figure 3Mechanisms for allergy transfer. IgE, immunoglobulin E; MC, mastocyte; IgE‐Bcs, IgE‐producing B cells; Th, T helper cells; IgG1‐MBcs, IgG1 memory B cells
Figure 4Recommendation for patient management in case of solid organ transplantation from donors who died because of fatal anaphylaxis. IgE, immunoglobulin E