| Literature DB >> 31455315 |
Tomoyuki Hayashi1,2, Yvan J-F Hutin3, Marc Bulterys3, Arshad Altaf4, Benedetta Allegranzi5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Reuse of injection devices to give healthcare injections decreased from 39.8 to 5.5% between 2000 and 2010, but trends since 2011 have not been described. We reviewed results of Demographic and Health Surveys (DHS) to describe injection practices worldwide from 2011 to 2015.Entities:
Keywords: DHS; Demographic and health surveys; Healthcare injection; Injection device; Injection practice; Needle; Syringe; Unsafe injection
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 31455315 PMCID: PMC6712605 DOI: 10.1186/s12913-019-4366-9
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMC Health Serv Res ISSN: 1472-6963 Impact factor: 2.655
40 countries with injection practices data -in DHS surveys conducted between 2011 and 2015 and 16 countries with corresponding prior data (2004–2010). As of December 2017, we identified 92 countries with DHS data available between 2004 and 2015. Among these countries, 43% (40/92 countries) included injection safety data for 2011–2015. Among these, 40 countries, 40% (16/40 countries) also had the data in 2004–2010 available for comparison over time
| Region | Country | Year with data available | Year with data available |
|---|---|---|---|
| (2011–2015) | (2004–2010) | ||
| African | Benin | 2011 | 2006c |
| African | Cameroon | 2011 | No data |
| African | Congo | 2011 | No data |
| African | Cote d’Ivoire | 2011 | No data |
| African | Equatorial Guinea | 2011 | No data |
| African | Ethiopia | 2011 | 2005 |
| African | Mozambique | 2011 | No data |
| African | Uganda | 2011 | 2006 |
| African | Comoros | 2012 | No data |
| African | Gabon | 2012 | No data |
| African | Mali | 2012 | 2006c |
| African | Niger | 2012 | No data |
| African | Gambia | 2013 | No data |
| African | Liberia | 2013 | 2007 |
| African | Namibia | 2013 | 2006 |
| African | Nigeria | 2013 | 2008 |
| African | Sierra Leone | 2013 | 2008 |
| African | Togo | 2013 | No data |
| African | Zambia | 2013 | 2007 |
| African | Chad | 2014 | No data |
| African | Ghana | 2014 | 2008 |
| African | Kenya | 2014 | No data |
| African | Lesotho | 2014 | No data |
| African | Rwanda | 2014 | 2005, 2010 |
| African | Tanzania | 2015 | 2004, 2010c |
| African | Zimbabwe | 2015 | 2005, 2010 |
| Americas | Hondurasa | 2011 | No data |
| Americas | Haiti | 2012 | 2005 |
| Americas | Dominican Republic | 2013 | No data |
| Eastern Mediterranean | Pakistan | 2012 | 2006c |
| Eastern Mediterranean | Yemen | 2013c | No data |
| Eastern Mediterranean | Afghanistan | 2015 | No data |
| European | Kyrgyz Republic | 2012 | No data |
| European | Tajikistan | 2012c | No data |
| European | Armenia | 2015 | 2010 |
| South-East Asia | Nepal | 2011 | No data |
| South-East Asia | Indonesia | 2012 | No data |
| South-East Asia | Indiab | 2015 | No data |
| South-East Asia | Myanmar | 2015 | No data |
| Western Pacific | Cambodia | 2014 | No data |
a Only frequency data available (no safety data)
b Average value of the five areas surveyed
c Only female data available (Only female data used in the comparisons)
Injection practices in WHO regions according to DHS surveys conducted in 2011–2015. The Eastern Mediterranean Region had the highest number of unsafe injections (0.376 per person per year). The Eastern Mediterranean Region also had the highest average number of health care injections per person in the last 12 months and the lowest proportion of injections with devices from a new package. The Eastern Mediterranean Region was followed by the South-East Asia Region (0.178 per person per year), the European Region (0.085 per person per year), the African Region (0.039 per person per year), the region of the Americas (0.020 per person per year), and the Western Pacific Region (0.019 per person per year)
| Frequency | Safety | Number of unsafe injections per person per year a | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Country | Health care injections per person per year | Sample size | Use of an unopened syringe or needle | Sample size | |
| African | 1.18 | 466,836 | 96.7% | 144,115 | 0.039 |
| Americas | 1.28 | 73,335 | 98.4% | 12,951 | 0.020 |
| Eastern Mediterranean | 3.84 | 82,347 | 90.2% | 32,467 | 0.376 |
| European | 2.92 | 29,148 | 97.1% | 6,881 | 0.085 |
| South-East Asia | 2.66 | 166,277 | 93.3% | 75,233 | 0.178 |
| Western Pacific | 1.60 | 22,768 | 98.8% | 7,973 | 0.019 |
| Total | 1.64 | 840,711 | 96.1% | 279,620 | 0.064 |
a Number of injections multiplied by the proportion unsafe
Fig. 1Annual number of safe and unsafe injections, by WHO region, DHS surveys conducted in 2011–2015. The Eastern Mediterranean Region had the highest number of unsafe injections (0.376 per person per year). The Eastern Mediterranean Region also had the highest average number of health care injections per person in the last 12 months and the lowest proportion of injections with devices from a new package. The Eastern Mediterranean Region was followed by the South-East Asia Region (0.178 per person per year), the European Region (0.085 per person per year), the African Region (0.039 per person per year), the region of the Americas (0.020 per person per year), and the Western Pacific Region (0.019 per person per year)
Injection practices in counties according to DHS surveys conducted in 2011–2015. Detailed injection practices in counties according to DHS surveys conducted in 2011–2015. The data was divided by country from Table 2
| Frequency | Safety | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Region | Country | Health care injections per person per year | Sample size | Use of an unopened syringe or needle | Sample size |
| African | Benin | 0.60 | 21,739 | 94.7% | 3,419 |
| African | Cameroon | 1.80 | 14,648 | 97.6% | 5,883 |
| African | Congo | 1.80 | 15,964 | 98.3% | 4,042 |
| African | Cote d’Ivoire | 1.20 | 15,195 | 96.8% | 5,767 |
| African | Equatorial Guinea | 2.60 | 5,400 | 96.1% | 2,063 |
| African | Ethiopia | 1.35 | 30,625 | 97.6% | 10,053 |
| African | Mozambique | 0.50 | 17,780 | 94.6% | 3,196 |
| African | Uganda | 1.65 | 10,969 | 95.6% | 4,328 |
| African | Comoros | 0.60 | 7,496 | 91.7% | 1,486 |
| African | Gabon | 1.20 | 14,076 | 97.6% | 4,626 |
| African | Mali | 0.70 | 14,823 | 98.0% | 3,231 |
| African | Niger | 0.80 | 15,088 | 96.8% | 5,539 |
| African | Gambia | 0.90 | 14,054 | 97.5% | 4,438 |
| African | Liberia | 1.65 | 13,357 | 98.1% | 5,372 |
| African | Namibia | 0.85 | 13,197 | 97.2% | 4,028 |
| African | Nigeria | 1.10 | 56,307 | 97.3% | 14,097 |
| African | Sierra Leone | 1.95 | 23,920 | 97.4% | 9,581 |
| African | Togo | 1.15 | 13,956 | 94.5% | 4,207 |
| African | Zambia | 0.75 | 31,184 | 97.0% | 6,956 |
| African | Chad | 2.05 | 11,433 | 94.1% | 4,124 |
| African | Ghana | 0.70 | 13,784 | 98.0% | 4,030 |
| African | Kenya | 1.45 | 27,444 | 98.5% | 10,877 |
| African | Lesotho | 0.75 | 9,552 | 95.2% | 2,764 |
| African | Rwanda | 1.30 | 19,714 | 99.2% | 10,977 |
| African | Tanzania | 0.90 | 16,780 | 97.6% | 4,786 |
| African | Zimbabwe | 0.50 | 18,351 | 97.6% | 4,245 |
| Americas | Hondurasa | 1.60 | 29,877 | No data | No data |
| Americas | Haiti | 0.60 | 23,780 | 98.4% | 5,720 |
| Americas | Dominican Republic | 1.65 | 19,678 | 98.5% | 7,231 |
| Eastern Mediterranean | Pakistan | 5.15 | 16,692 | 87.7% | 9,875 |
| Eastern Mediterranean | Yemenb | 3.30 | 25,434 | 91.8% | 8,989 |
| Eastern Mediterranean | Afghanistan | 2.80 | 40,221 | 91.8% | 13,603 |
| European | Kyrgyz Republic | 2.55 | 10,621 | 96.5% | 2,720 |
| European | Tajikistanb | 7.10 | 9,656 | 98.7% | 2,963 |
| European | Armenia | 1.20 | 8,871 | 97.1% | 1,198 |
| South-East Asia | Nepal | 1.20 | 16,795 | 98.3% | 5,430 |
| South-East Asia | Indonesia | 1.35 | 54,913 | 90.0% | 23,557 |
| South-East Asia | Indiac | 5.82 | 76,947 | 86.5% | 36,902 |
| South-East Asia | Myanmar | 2.25 | 17,622 | 98.7% | 9,344 |
| Western Pacific | Cambodia | 1.60 | 22,768 | 98.8% | 7,973 |
a Only frequency data available
b Only female data available
c Average value of the five areas surveyed
Comparison of injections practices up to 2010 and since 2011 in the 16 countries where DHS data were available for comparison. Among the 16 countries with 2004–2010 and 2011–2015 data, the average annual number of injections decreased from 1.44 (sample size: 252,513) to 1.25 (sample size: 317,886). Similarly, the average proportion of safe injection increased from 95.9% (sample size: 70,953) to 97.0% (sample size: 98,103)
| Frequency | Safety | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Health care injections per person per year | Sample size | Use an unopened syringe or needle | Sample size | |
| Up to 2010a | 1.44 | 252,513 | 95.9% | 70,953 |
| Since 2011 | 1.25 | 317,866 | 97.0% | 98,103 |
a Use only more recent data if there are multiple data