| Literature DB >> 31297255 |
Asha George1, Amnesty Elizabeth LeFevre2, Tanya Jacobs1, Mary Kinney1, Kent Buse3, Mickey Chopra4, Bernadette Daelmans5, Annie Haakenstad6, Luis Huicho7, Rajat Khosla8, Kumanan Rasanathan9, David Sanders1, Neha S Singh10, Nicki Tiffin11,12, Rajani Ved13, Shehla Abbas Zaidi14, Helen Schneider1.
Abstract
Health systems are critical for health outcomes as they underpin intervention coverage and quality, promote users' rights and intervene on the social determinants of health. Governance is essential for health system endeavours as it mobilises and coordinates a multiplicity of actors and interests to realise common goals. The inherently social, political and contextualised nature of governance, and health systems more broadly, has implications for measurement, including how the health of women, children and adolescents health is viewed and assessed, and for whom. Three common lenses, each with their own views of power dynamics in policy and programme implementation, include a service delivery lens aimed at scaling effective interventions, a societal lens oriented to empowering people with rights to effect change and a systems lens concerned with creating enabling environments for adaptive learning. We illustrate the implications of each lens for the why, what and how of measuring health system drivers across micro, meso and macro health systems levels, through three examples (digital health, maternal and perinatal death surveillance and review, and multisectoral action for adolescent health). Appreciating these underpinnings of measuring health systems and governance drivers of the health of women, children and adolescents is essential for a holistic learning and action agenda that engages a wider range of stakeholders, which includes, but also goes beyond, indicator-based measurement. Without a broadening of approaches to measurement and the types of research partnerships involved, continued investments in the health of women, children and adolescents will fall short.Entities:
Keywords: epistemology; governance; health systems; measurement; power; rights
Year: 2019 PMID: 31297255 PMCID: PMC6590975 DOI: 10.1136/bmjgh-2018-001316
Source DB: PubMed Journal: BMJ Glob Health ISSN: 2059-7908
Figure 1Elements of governance.
Why, what and how we measure health systems drivers of women’s, children’s and adolescents’ health with a governance focus
| Why we measure | What we measure | How we measure | ||
| Framing | Health systems drivers relevant to governance | Measurement variables | Research epistemologies, methodologies and methods | Research continuum |
| |
Policy mandate Coordination for continuity across levels and sectors Service delivery readiness User characteristics |
Technical content of policies Management mechanisms: committees, review meetings, etc Inputs/resources (human resources for health, supplies, finances) User profile (literacy, gender, class, ethnicity, age) | Measuring adherence to recommended protocols (users and providers) Applying implementation checklists Analysing household, facility surveys or routine HMIS and system-generated data Ecological analysis of large datasets |
|
| Unidirectional/power over/zero-sum Co-produced/relational | Macro: Political prioritisation |
Stakeholder positions and interests Participation/mobilisation Organisational cultures Transparency Credibility/trust Social capital and networks Social/informal norms Framing | Legal analysis Health policy and systems research Stakeholder analysis, political mapping Social network analysis Case study research | |
| Creative: disruptive/productive |
Dis/equilibria Feedback loops Eventuality of change Emergence Path dependence |
Diversity of actors, varying power, alignment and interests Contextual permeability Adaptive or learning capacities Tipping points and motivation for emergence and change | Ethnography Participatory action research Systems modelling Hidden transcripts Causal loop diagrams | |
HMIS, health management and information systems.
Lenses and levels for examining drivers of digital health
| Health systems drivers with a governance focus | Health system levels | ||
| Macro | Meso | Micro | |
| Service delivery lens | |||
|
Policy mandate Coordination mechanisms Service delivery readiness User capacity |
Policies on privacy of personal data, interoperability, procurement, etc Network coverage: cell phone towers |
Composition and organisational location of task force Technology design choices Network coverage: mobile network operator verification systems Health worker workload Financial resources to support the programme |
User mobile literacy, access and ownership Network coverage: SIM turnover, handset type and functionality |
| Society lens | |||
|
Political prioritisation Accountability dynamics Interpersonal dynamics |
Trust in government or private companies maintaining information responsibly |
Incentives and positionality of implementing partners (Ministry of Health, technology partners, mobile network operators, academic/research partners) Stakeholder relationships: NGOs with prior positive relationships with government more able to present data with negative findings to government Health worker responses and prioritisation |
Women with culture of concealing pregnancy, not being aware that they would be receiving SMS, can distrust or be jeopardised by text messages from unknown numbers DRC: more men than women accessing digital app on family planning originally targeted for women; is male power reinforced vs transformed? |
| Systems lens | |||
|
Dis/equilibria Feedback loops Eventuality of change Emergence Path dependence |
Tanzania: trained enumerators using smartphone apps in people’s homes was a trigger for conversations and relationship building… community validation meetings where people discussed results offline and local health workers present who saw it as an opportunity to channel demands upwards to district authorities for resource allocation decisions South Africa: health workers adapting registration processes from individual to batch registration; increases numbers of people registered, decreases waiting time for services, but uncertain consent procedures Nigeria: women promised recharge cards to elicit participation, but then not all tech partners agreed, backfired against women who responded but belonged to these excluded tech partner networks… women then deleted messages and refused to participate | ||
DRC, Democratic Republic of Congo; NGO, non-governmental organisation.
Lenses and levels for examining drivers of maternal and perinatal death surveillance and response (MPDSR)
| Health systems drivers with a governance focus | Health system levels | ||
| Macro | Meso | Micro | |
| Service delivery lens | |||
|
Policy mandate Coordination mechanisms Service delivery readiness User capacity |
National MPDSR policy and guidelines Death notification requirements (legal framework for notifying deaths) Legal mandate to involve communities and other sectors Human resources shortages across the system but particularly for maternal and child health specialists |
Committees formed Committee composition: profession, gender, seniority Meeting frequency Publication of proceedings Strategy for staff orientation to MPDSR Availability of MPDSR tools Health worker workload Functionality of information systems |
Competencies of managers, supervisors, providers to analysis and interpret data and information |
| Society lens | |||
|
Political prioritisation Accountability dynamics Interpersonal dynamics |
National prioritisation of preventing maternal and perinatal deaths Perceived preventability of deaths Social implications of political party affiliation, gender, class, among committee members, etc Community engagement |
Leadership: individuals (champions) and of system (space for teamwork) Moving away from blame to learning environment/ trust Credibility of HMIS system Visibility of effect/impact Health worker responses and prioritisation |
Confidence of and capability of health workers to complete and analyse deaths Relationship between committee members Mentorship, clinical outreach and supervisory activities through district engagement |
| Systems lens | |||
|
Dis/equilibria Feedback loops Eventuality of change Emergence |
Kenya: MPDSR process/outcomes fail to deliver on actions due to health system barriers which perpetuates a demoralising work environment and undermines commitment to attending meetings Nigeria: improved MPDSR led to increased reporting of deaths and therefore an increase in mortality further documenting poor performance. However, responses to insufficient blood supply led to community mobilisation for blood donor club formation. Inclusion of findings in State Medium Term Strategy led to the provision and maintenance of blood banks in state hospitals | ||
HMIS, health management and information systems.
Lenses and levels for examining drivers of multisectoral action for adolescent health
| Health systems drivers with a governance focus | Health system levels | ||
| Macro | Meso | Micro | |
| Service delivery lens | |||
|
Policy mandate Coordination mechanisms Service delivery readiness User capacity |
Policies across different sectors recognising adolescent health (Adolescent Health in All Policies approach) Policies across different sectors recognising multisectoral action for adolescent health |
Existence of adolescent health committee/unit Constitution and functioning of committee/unit Location and linkages of the committee/unit within sectoral hierarchies Availability and authority to deploy resources |
Profile of policy champions: profession, seniority, age, gender Competency of all stakeholders in adolescent health and multisectoral actions Capacity to generate and use evidence on mutlisectoral action |
| Society lens | |||
|
Political prioritisation Accountability dynamics Interpersonal dynamics |
Adolescent leadership and participation and mobilisation overall Social determinants of health including, gender, diversity and socioeconomic and political context Framing and alignments of sector goals |
Incentives and constraints of stakeholders, including adolescents Leadership and organisational cultures supporting multisectoral action |
Social networks and histories between policy advocates Trust, communication and credibility between policy advocates |
| Systems lens | |||
|
Dis/equilibria Feedback loops Eventuality of change Emergence |
Policies that prohibit adolescent girls from being pregnant while being in school, inhibits early care seeking for pregnancy care by these adolescents and has a negative impact on their future education and health Not including adolescents in leadership and participation during the design, implementation, monitoring and evaluation of adolescent health programme will contribute to a negative feedback loop in terms of nature, quality and impact of the programme Initial gains on collaborating on health education or HPV at schools, builds trust and relationships between sectors, that enables further work on more complex mutual aims such as mental health or comprehensive sexual and reproductive health programmes or violence prevention | ||
HPV, human papilloma virus.