| Literature DB >> 31263971 |
Jennifer M Hensel1, Katherine Ellard2, Mark Koltek2, Gabrielle Wilson2, Jitender Sareen2.
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: This review summarizes digital health solutions being used for Indigenous mental well-being, with emphasis on available evidence and examples reported in the literature. We also describe our own local experience with a rural telemental health service for Indigenous youth and discuss the unique opportunities and challenges. RECENTEntities:
Keywords: Digital health; Indigenous; Mental health; Social media; Telemental health
Year: 2019 PMID: 31263971 PMCID: PMC6602981 DOI: 10.1007/s11920-019-1056-6
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Curr Psychiatry Rep ISSN: 1523-3812 Impact factor: 5.285
Indigenous search term developed in consultation with a librarian with expertise in Indigenous literature
| Indigenous search term | |
|---|---|
| Indigenous OR Aboriginal OR “First Nations” OR Metis OR Inuit* OR Ojib* OR Anishinaabe OR Anishinabe OR Anishnabe OR Cree OR Dene OR “Alaska* native” OR “native Alaska” OR “native American” OR Mohawk OR Maori OR Nunavut OR Nunavik OR “Torres Strait Island*” OR Koori OR Goori OR Murri OR Nyoongah OR Koorie OR Yolngu OR Anangu OR Palawa OR Nunga OR Ngarrindjeri OR “Murray Island” OR “Mer Island” |
Summary of the available digital health solutions for Indigenous mental well-being with examples, strengths, and limitations
| Digital solution | State of the evidence | Examples | Benefits | Limitations |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||
| Telemental health | Moderate to Strong • Quantitative studies demonstrating feasibility and cost effectiveness • Qualitative studies demonstrating acceptability | • Psychiatric assessment and management • Psychotherapy | • Reduces need for travel and has associated cost saving benefits • Keeps individuals in their home community • Facilitates involvement of family and other supports | • Some prefer face-to-face interactions, and may feel it depersonalizes the ‘human connection’ • May detract from local recruitment and capacity building efforts |
| Electronic consult | Fair • Pilot study in Indigenous Inuit community found cost-savings and provider satisfaction | • ChamplainBASE Nunavut project | • Keeps individuals in their home community • Enhances continuity of care • Enhances primary care provider satisfaction • Reduces need for travel and has associated cost saving benefits | • Relies on primary care assessment; specialist provides advice only • Requires access to a secure platform for information exchange |
|
| ||||
| Electronic learning | Poor • No specific studies in Indigenous contexts | • Health care provider courses • Mental Health First Aid Training | • Standardizes material for large groups • Allows for distribution of information over large geographical distances • Enhances attendance rates | • Lack of face-to-face interaction, which is preferred by some • Lack of supervision may lead to underdeveloped skills • Difficulties assessing whether acquired skills are being utilized in practice |
| Electronic screening and decision support tools | Fair • Positive results in subset analyses and pilot studies | • YouthCHAT • Anchorage Depression Management DSTs • Intimate Partner Violence DSTs | • May help reduce racialized discrimination • Assists in identifying risky behaviors and health concerns • Facilitates patient-centred discussion surrounding treatment options | • Requires the health care provider knows how to work with the decision output |
| Virtual communities of practice | Poor • No specific studies in Indigenous contexts | • ECHO Ontario First Nations, Inuit, Metis Program | • Promotes collaborative learning among health professionals • Allows for team members to remain in their home community • Increased participant self-efficacy and satisfaction with reduced isolation | • Attendance may be limited by competing demands • Learning models utilized may not be accepted by all participants • Requires access to a multi-user digital platform |
|
| ||||
| Web-based applications | Fair to Moderate • Small number of RCTs demonstrating evidence for specific apps • Studies limited to Australian contexts | • Mindspot • ibobbly • AIMhi Stay Strong | • Tailored to the specific needs of a targeted group • Increases accessibility in a cost-effective, portable manner • Potential for co-design and adaptation of existing applications to be culturally relevant | • Variable accessibility dependent on the user, the environment, and the app design itself • Variable uptake by health care workers, due to their level of tech support, workload levels, office policies, and perceptions among staff members |
| Digital storytelling | Fair • Some preliminary evidence of benefit in Indigenous Alaskan youth | • Digital storytelling as a component of suicide prevention kits in Indigenous Alaskan Youth | • Enhances the sharing of personal experiences and learning from peers • May promote stronger intergenerational bonds • Allows a medium for users to reflect back on their own experiences and identify one’s own coping strategies | • Issues surrounding confidentiality • May perpetuate stereotypes • Can trigger past traumas among some members |
| Social media | Poor • No specific studies in Indigenous mental health • Some positive evidence of behavior change in other domains | • Indigenous run Twitter and Facebook accounts (Ex. @IndigenousX) • Social marketing campaigns for lifestyle changes | • Provides a platform for users to showcase their own unique identity • Allows for the sharing of information and ideas among millions of users • May enhance community connections • Ability to be tailored to user’s culture • Allows users to gain a sense of power/control | • May or may not be moderated leading to potential negative and/or harmful content • Accessibility and uptake will vary by user, and availability of technology |
Fig. 1Digital health solutions for Indigenous mental well-being depicted around the Indigenous Medicine Wheel with the individual located at the center