BACKGROUND: Ketamine has rapid antidepressant effects and shows great promise as a novel treatment for depression, but its limitations including its abuse potential are poorly understood. Given that the prevalence of depression is twice as high in women as in men and that depression and substance use disorders are highly comorbid, we hypothesized that a sex-specific responsivity to behavioral assays that characterize addiction-like behavior may arise in rats with prior exposure to chronic stress and therapeutically relevant ketamine. METHODS: Male and female rats that underwent chronic mild stress were treated with four 1.47 mg/kg intravenous ketamine infusions once every fourth day and underwent operant self-administration of 0.5 mg/kg/infusion ketamine. Measures of anhedonia (or lack of pleasure, a signature feature of depression), anxiety-induced neophagia, motivation to obtain ketamine, and craving were assessed using the sucrose intake test, novelty-suppressed feeding test, progressive ratio schedule of reinforcement, and incubation of craving following abstinence, respectively. Finally, dendritic spine density in the nucleus accumbens core was measured. RESULTS: Ketamine infusions reduced anxiety-induced neophagia in both male rats and female rats but had no effect on measures of anhedonia. Female rats with prior exposure to chronic mild stress had greater motivation to obtain ketamine compared to nonstressed female rats, an effect not observed in male rats. Additionally, female rats who received antidepressant ketamine infusions had a higher threshold for displaying ketamine addiction-like behavior than saline-treated female rats as well as increased thin spine density in the nucleus accumbens core. These effects were not observed in male rats. CONCLUSION: This study shows that repeated low-dose ketamine does not increase abuse potential of subsequent ketamine. It also highlights an important female-specific effect of stress to increase ketamine addiction-like behavior, which requires further investigation for clinical populations.
BACKGROUND: Ketamine has rapid antidepressant effects and shows great promise as a novel treatment for depression, but its limitations including its abuse potential are poorly understood. Given that the prevalence of depression is twice as high in women as in men and that depression and substance use disorders are highly comorbid, we hypothesized that a sex-specific responsivity to behavioral assays that characterize addiction-like behavior may arise in rats with prior exposure to chronic stress and therapeutically relevant ketamine. METHODS: Male and female rats that underwent chronic mild stress were treated with four 1.47 mg/kg intravenous ketamine infusions once every fourth day and underwent operant self-administration of 0.5 mg/kg/infusion ketamine. Measures of anhedonia (or lack of pleasure, a signature feature of depression), anxiety-induced neophagia, motivation to obtain ketamine, and craving were assessed using the sucrose intake test, novelty-suppressed feeding test, progressive ratio schedule of reinforcement, and incubation of craving following abstinence, respectively. Finally, dendritic spine density in the nucleus accumbens core was measured. RESULTS: Ketamine infusions reduced anxiety-induced neophagia in both male rats and female rats but had no effect on measures of anhedonia. Female rats with prior exposure to chronic mild stress had greater motivation to obtain ketamine compared to nonstressed female rats, an effect not observed in male rats. Additionally, female rats who received antidepressant ketamine infusions had a higher threshold for displaying ketamine addiction-like behavior than saline-treated female rats as well as increased thin spine density in the nucleus accumbens core. These effects were not observed in male rats. CONCLUSION: This study shows that repeated low-dose ketamine does not increase abuse potential of subsequent ketamine. It also highlights an important female-specific effect of stress to increase ketamine addiction-like behavior, which requires further investigation for clinical populations.
Entities:
Keywords:
chronic stress; dendritic spines; ketamine; self-administration; sex differences
Depression carries the highest global burden of disease of any mental
illness.[1,2]
Treatment options are limited due, in part, to its heterogeneous symptomatology and
high comorbidity with other conditions including substance use disorders.[3] The etiology of depression and substance use disorders is poorly understood,
especially with respect to females who, despite having a twofold increased risk for
depression, have been historically underrepresented in neuroscience
research.[4,5]
Additionally, both human and rodent studies indicate that females escalate drug use
more rapidly than males and may be more prone to relapse, depending on drug
type.[6,7] Preclinical
research must address these intersecting factors underlying disease
susceptibility.The discovery of the rapid antidepressant effects of subanesthetic intravenous (i.v.)
ketamine (KET) invigorated a field limited by monoaminergic antidepressant drugs
that require several weeks of treatment to produce effects.[8-10] However, KET’s therapeutic
benefits are hindered by its abuse potential at high doses in humans,[11] and the fact that rats readily self-administer KET.[12-15] Questions regarding KET’s
safety require careful consideration before widespread integration into medical
practice as an antidepressant.[9] This current work attempts to address two factors that may underlie
susceptibility to KET’s effects: sex and prior exposure to chronic stress as a
precipitating factor for both drug relapse and depression. We utilized the
unpredictable chronic mild stress (CMS) model[16,17] to induce a depressive-like
behavioral profile in male and female rats, followed by i.v. slow, passive infusions
of KET and subsequent operant KET self-administration to test the hypothesis that
subjects—especially females—with a history of CMS and KET treatment would have an
increased propensity to abuse KET.Most behavioral models studying KET’s antidepressant-like effects have utilized
intraperitoneal (i.p.) injections. In clinics, patients typically receive 0.5 mg/kg
KET i.v. delivered over a 40-min period, two to three times per week.[9] Therefore, to more closely recapitulate clinical approaches, we used an i.v.
dose of 1.47 mg/kg/40 min, previously shown to match N-methyl-D-aspartate receptor
occupancy in rats equivalently to clinically relevant doses.[18]Dendritic spines are highly plastic structures that correlate with changes in
synaptic strength. Both stress and exposure to drugs of abuse dynamically mediate
spine density within corticolimbic structures, including the nucleus accumbens
(NAc), where an increase is typically observed.[19,20] Our laboratory demonstrated
that sensitization to low-dose KET increases spine density in the NAc shell
subregion of males and females, whereas only females had an increase in the NAc core (NAcc).[21] NAc spine density alterations following incubation of KET craving are
unknown, but incubated cocaine craving results in persistent induction of NAc spine
formation over the course of withdrawal,[22] associated with increased excitability and thought to mediate the persistence
of craving.[23] Therefore, we assessed NAcc dendritic spine density following incubation of
KET craving in stressed and KET pretreated rats.In this work, we therefore asked whether or not limited and repeated treatments with
low doses of KET enhance vulnerability to KET addiction-like behavior in both sexes
of rats.
Materials and Methods
Drugs
Ketathesia (Henry Schein, Melville, NY) was diluted in sterile saline (SAL) from
a 100 mg/mL racemic solution. For therapeutic infusions, KET was diluted to
1.47 mg/mL by body weight. For operant KET self-administration,
0.5 mg/kg/infusion in a 50 µL volume was used.
Subjects
Adult male and female Sprague-Dawley rats (initially seven to eight weeks old,
weighing 226–250 g and 161–180 g, respectively) from Charles River (Raleigh, NC)
were used. Animals were given four days to acclimate to the vivarium and were
handled twice to acclimate to the experimenter handling. Males and females were
same-sex double-housed in the same room (except where noted) in
43 × 21.5 × 25.5 cm Plexiglas cages on a 12/12 h light/dark cycle. Food and
water were provided ad libitum except where noted. Behavioral experiments were
conducted in six cohorts with each experimental group represented. All
experiments were carried out in accordance with the National Institutes of
Health Guide for Care and Use of Laboratory Animals[24], and all protocols were approved by the Florida State University
Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee.
Surgical Procedures
Jugular Catheterization and Catheter Maintenance
Surgery and catheter maintenance were performed as previously described,[12] with minor modifications, described in Supplementary Methods. Rats
were allowed three to five days postoperative recovery before behavioral
testing resumed.
Intra-NAcc Viral-Mediated Gene Transfer
Anesthetized rats were prepared for stereotactic surgery under standard
sterile conditions. Two small craniotomies were made corresponding to NAcc
coordinates: AP + 1.5, ML ± 1.2, and DV − 7.6. The viral construct herpes
simplex virus (HSV)–cytomegalovirus–green fluorescent protein (GFP)
(obtained from the McGovern Institute Viral Core Facility) was bilaterally
delivered, 1 µL per side (1 × 109 units/mL), at 0.1 µL/min. After
5 min for virus distribution, the needles were raised, craniotomies were
covered, and the incision was closed. Rats were allowed three days rest to
allow for optimal HSV-GFP expression.
Experimental Procedures
Experimental Time line
See Figure 1 for
layout of behavioral experiment and Supplementary Methods.
Table 1.
Unpredictable chronic mild stress procedure.
Stressor
Duration
Day
Swim stress
10 min
1, 3, 13, 20
Restraint stress
1 h
5, 8, 17
Lights off
3 h
2, 11, 18
Lights on overnight
12 h
1,8, 15
Aversive odor
12 h
2, 7, 11, 20
Isolation
12 h
4, 13, 21
Strobe light
12 h
7, 11, 16, 19
Crowded cage
12 h
5, 12, 19
Cage tilt
12 h
3, 9, 16
Wet bedding
12 h
4, 9, 15, 21
Food and water deprivation
24 h
6, 10, 17
Sucrose Pellet Operant Training
Rats were shaped in operant chambers as previously described (see also
Supplementary Methods).[12]
Sucrose Intake Test
During testing, rats were separated into individual cages with two
counterbalanced bottles: one containing water and one containing 1% w/v
sucrose solution. Bottle weights were taken before and after the 12 h access
period during the dark cycle. Three baseline measurements were taken before
CMS onset, three tests occurred each week of CMS, and four tests occurred
after each therapeutic KET infusion. Intake values are expressed as
percentage change from the average of each animal’s three baseline
measurements.
CMS Procedure
Rats underwent CMS or nonstressed (NS) conditions. The CMS procedure
(outlined in Table
1 and adapted from Li et al.[25]) utilized several different stressors presented pseudorandomly over
21 days, two stressors per day. Sucrose intake tests were conducted on days
of social isolation. NS rats were single-housed and tested on matched days.
For details, see Supplementary Methods.
Therapeutic KET Infusions
After CMS and jugular catheterization, rats underwent four i.v. KET or SAL
infusions every fourth day for a total of 16 days. A 1 × 1 × 1 meter acrylic
open-field arena divided into four quadrants was used as a neutral setting
to administer infusions. Rats were tethered to drug delivery lines and given
5 min to habituate. KET (1.47 mg/kg/40 min) or SAL was delivered using a
variable-speed syringe pump.
Novelty-Suppressed Feeding Test
This test was administered as previously described,[26] 24 h after the first KET infusion. See Supplementary Methods for a
detailed description.
KET Self-Administration
Twenty-four hours after the final sucrose intake test, rats began i.v.
self-administration. The seven daily sessions consisted of 2 h access to
0.5 mg/kg/infusion KET under a fixed-ratio 1 (FR1) schedule of
reinforcement, with 100 maximum possible infusions. The active nose-poke
hole delivered i.v. KET and drug-paired cues identical to the sucrose pellet
training sessions, while the inactive hole had no programmed response. This
was followed by three daily progressive ratio (PR) sessions, where the
response requirement for one infusion increased by 5 × e(0.2 n)−5, where n
equals the infusion number.[27] Therefore, one infusion of KET required 1, 2, 4, 6, 9, 12, 15, 20,
25, 32, 40, … active nose pokes. The session ended if rats failed to
complete a ratio in 1 h. Three more FR1 sessions followed, then rats
underwent a period of home cage abstinence. Rats were returned to the
operant chambers 1, 7, and 21 days after their final FR1 session to test for
incubation of KET craving in 2 h sessions, where discrete cues were
presented upon active nose poke, but KET was not available. Twenty-four
hours after the final test for incubation of craving, intra-NAcc HSV-GFP was
delivered as described above to animals randomly selected across each
cohort.
Immunohistochemistry, Confocal Imaging, and Dendritic Spines Analysis
See Supplementary Methods for details. Briefly, animals were transcardially
perfused three days after HSV-GFP injections, and tissue was processed for
immunohistochemical detection of GFP. Z-stack projections were acquired on a
laser-scanning confocal microscope, and dendritic branches were
three-dimensional-reconstructed using Neurolucida 360 (version 2017.01.1; MBF
Biosciences, Williston, VT). Automatic classification of spine type (thin,
stubby, and mushroom type) was based on established parameters.[28] Data are presented as number of spines per 10 µm of dendrite segment.
Statistical Analysis
Two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) was used to analyze cumulative body weight
gain during CMS as well as novelty-suppressed feeding test (NSFT) feeding
latency. For sucrose intake and self-administration data, mixed-model ANOVAs
were used. Where appropriate, sex, stress, and treatment were the
between-subjects factors and sessions were the within-subjects factor. To
determine whether an increase in intake during FR1 KET self-administration
occurred, the parameter estimates of the mixed model output were observed.
Tukey’s post hoc was used when appropriate. Grubb’s outlier test was conducted
for each behavioral test, and animals that were statistical outliers for one
test were removed. Prism (GraphPad, version 8.01) and R (3.3.1) with the
packages nlme[29] and lsmeans[30] were used for all statistical analyses and figures. Significance was set
at α = 0.05.
Results
Sucrose Pellet Training
Rats reach criteria in three to six days; therefore, the last three sessions per
rat were analyzed. Main effects of both sex and sessions were observed for
sucrose pellet intake (F(1, 125) = 44.224, p < 0.0001; F(2, 254) = 77.431,
p < 0.0001, Supplementary Figure 1A), active nose pokes (F(1, 125) = 33.815,
p < 0.0001; F(2, 254) = 34.07, p < 0.0001), and inactive nose pokes (F(1,
125) = 30.937, p < 0.0001; F(2, 254) = 13.065, p < 0.0001), respectively
(Supplementary Figure 1B, n = 26–41 per group). Therefore, while all rats
increased their intake over time, females displayed overall heightened operant
responding. Importantly, there were no significant differences a priori between
stressed (CMS) and NS groups. Subsequent analyses of operant behavior were split
by sex.
Weight Gain and Estrous Cycle During CMS
For weight gain during CMS, a significant interaction between sex and stress was
observed (F(1, 123) = 26.81, p < 0.0001, n = 26–41 per group, Figure 2(a), such that CMS
males gained less weight than NS males (p < 0.0001), while CMS females and NS
females were not statistically different. Additionally, vaginal lavage of
females during the last week of CMS/NS indicated that a majority of CMS females
lost regularity in their estrous cycle (data not shown).
Figure 2.
Consequences of CMS and subsequent KET treatment on depressive-like
behaviors. (a) Cumulative weight gain during the CMS/NS procedure
resulted in decreased weight gain in CMS males (***p < 0.0001,
n = 26–41 per group). (b) Novelty-suppressed feeding test revealed
an increased latency in CMS rats, which was abolished in KET-treated
rats (*p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, pairwise group comparisons,
n = 9–18 per group). Sucrose intake in males (c) and females (d),
expressed as percentage change from baseline, shows that CMS reduced
both males’ and females’ intake (*p < 0.05, n = 7–15 per group).
Data are presented as mean ± standard error of the mean. CMS:
chronic mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL:
saline.
Time line of experiment. Depression-like behavioral assays including
NSFT and sucrose intake test (S1–K4) are indicated in blue, while
incubation tests D1, D7, and D21 are indicated in red. CMS: chronic
mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL: saline; FR1:
fixed-ratio 1 schedule of reinforcement; PR: progressive ratio; GFP:
green fluorescent protein; HSV: herpes simplex virus; NSFT:
novelty-suppressed feeding test.Consequences of CMS and subsequent KET treatment on depressive-like
behaviors. (a) Cumulative weight gain during the CMS/NS procedure
resulted in decreased weight gain in CMS males (***p < 0.0001,
n = 26–41 per group). (b) Novelty-suppressed feeding test revealed
an increased latency in CMS rats, which was abolished in KET-treated
rats (*p < 0.05, **p < 0.01, pairwise group comparisons,
n = 9–18 per group). Sucrose intake in males (c) and females (d),
expressed as percentage change from baseline, shows that CMS reduced
both males’ and females’ intake (*p < 0.05, n = 7–15 per group).
Data are presented as mean ± standard error of the mean. CMS:
chronic mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL:
saline.Unpredictable chronic mild stress procedure.
Novelty-Suppressed Feeding Test
Latency to approach, the food at the center of the arena (Figure 2(b)) revealed an interaction
between stress and treatment for both males and females together (F(1,
119) = 7.35, p = 0.008, n = 9–18 per group). Since no effect of sex was
observed, this factor was collapsed. Pairwise comparisons with Tukey-adjusted p
values were conducted to analyze effects within levels. CMS + KET-treated rats
had significantly shorter latencies than CMS+SAL-treated rats (p = 0.0002).
CMS+SAL-treated rats had significantly longer latencies to approach the food
than NS+SAL-treated rats (p = 0.017). Importantly, there were no differences
between NS+SAL and NS+KET (p = 0.683) and CMS+KET versus NS+KET (p = 0.804).
Together, this indicates that KET reduced NSFT latency in both sexes exposed to
CMS.
Sucrose Intake Test
To determine if CMS induced anhedonia and if KET infusions ameliorated this
effect, percentage change in sucrose intake compared to pre-stress baseline
during CMS/NS and KET/SAL infusions (S1-3 and K1-4, respectively) was analyzed,
shown in Figure 2(c)for
males and (d) for females (n = 7–15 per group). There was a stress × sessions
interaction for males and females (F(6, 263) = 6.163, p < 0.0001; F(6,
144) = 2.485, p = 0.026, respectively). Post hoc analyses revealed that CMS
males had a significantly reduced intake compared to NS males during S2 and S3
(p < 0.05), and CMS females had a reduced intake versus NS females during all
three sessions (p < 0.05). There were no differences between NS and CMS
animals during the infusion period (K1–K4). Additionally, there was no effect of
KET treatment for males or females, nor were there differences in water intake
(data not shown). To account for body weight differences due to sex and/or
stress conditions, we also analyzed sucrose intake normalized to body weight
(data not shown). A main sex effect was observed (F(1,83) = 30.370,
p < 0.0001). Females had a stress × sessions interaction (F(9, 334) = 2.548,
p = 0.008), such that CMS had a lower intake than NS on S1, S2, and S3
(p < 0.05). Males had a significant stress × sessions interaction (F(9,
401) = 3.797, p < 0.0001), such that CMS had a lower intake than NS on S2
(p < 0.05). Together, this indicates that CMS resulted in decreased sucrose
intake not explained by body weight, and that cessation of CMS resulted in a
rescue of sucrose intake rather than an effect of KET treatment.
KET Self-Administration
For all KET self-administration comparisons, the number of subjects were
n = 11–15 per group. For infusions during the first seven sessions, a main sex
effect was observed (F(1, 103) = 14.043, p = 0.003). For males (Figure 3(a)), a main
sessions effect was observed (F(6, 318) = 18.876, p < 0.0001), without stress
or treatment effects, indicating an increase over time regardless of condition.
For females (Figure
3(b)), a treatment × sessions interaction was observed (F(6,
275) = 7.276, p < 0.0001, right), such that SAL-treated females had higher
intake than KET-treated females on sessions 6 and 7 (p = 0.034, p = 0.001,
respectively), trending on session 5 (p = 0.082). Additionally, an overall
stress effect was observed (F(1,48) = 6.391, p = 0.015), such that CMS females
had a higher intake than NS females. For active nose pokes (Figure 3(c) and (d)), both males and
females had a main sessions effect (F(6, 318) = 18.876, p < 0.0001; F(6,
275) = 18.695, p < 0.0001, respectively), without stress or treatment
effects, indicating that active responding increased over time regardless of
experimental manipulation. When comparing inactive and active nose pokes for
both males and females (Figure
3(e) and (f)), nose poke type × sessions interactions were indicated
(F(6, 689) = 8.659, p < 0.0001; F(6, 596) = 7.716, p < 0.0001,
respectively). Post hoc comparisons indicated that at each session, active nose
pokes were higher than inactive nose pokes (p < 0.01 for all time points),
indicating a meaningful discrimination between the reinforced and nonreinforced
operanda. Taken together, both sexes found KET reinforcing, but KET pretreated
females administered less than SAL-treated females and CMS increased KET intake
in females.
Figure 3.
First seven days of FR1 KET self-administration. KET infusions for
males (a) and females (b) indicate that CMS females have a higher
intake and KET-treated females have a lower intake. Active nose
pokes for males (c) and females (d). Inactive nose pokes for males
(e) and females (f). **p < 0.001, main stress effect;
*p < 0.05, KET- versus SAL-treated females within each session.
Data are presented as mean + standard error of the mean, n = 11–15
per group. CMS: chronic mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine;
SAL: saline.
First seven days of FR1 KET self-administration. KET infusions for
males (a) and females (b) indicate that CMS females have a higher
intake and KET-treated females have a lower intake. Active nose
pokes for males (c) and females (d). Inactive nose pokes for males
(e) and females (f). **p < 0.001, main stress effect;
*p < 0.05, KET- versus SAL-treated females within each session.
Data are presented as mean + standard error of the mean, n = 11–15
per group. CMS: chronic mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine;
SAL: saline.For active nose pokes during the PR sessions (Figure 4(a) and (b)), a main effect of
sex was observed (F(1, 101) = 15.424, p < 0.0001). Males had a
stress × treatment interaction (F(1,52) = 10.883, p = 0.002; post hoc tests show
that KET-treated NS males had higher responses than KET-treated CMS males,
p = 0.001), and females had a stress × sessions interaction (F(2,83) = 4.154,
p = 0.019; post hoc tests indicates significantly greater response from CMS
females than NS, particularly on session 2, p = 0.002). Both sexes successfully
discriminated between active and inactive nose pokes (F(1, 506) = 48.933,
p < 0.0001). Together, this indicates that the CMS procedure differentially
affected males and females, where CMS females displayed higher motivation to
obtain KET, an effect not observed in CMS males.
Figure 4.
Motivation to obtain KET. Active nose pokes during PR sessions for
males (a) and females (b). (a) **p < 0.005, stress × treatment
interaction and (b) **p < 0.005, stress effect. Data are
presented as mean + standard error of the mean, n = 11–15 per group.
CMS: chronic mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL:
saline; PR: progressive ratio.
Motivation to obtain KET. Active nose pokes during PR sessions for
males (a) and females (b). (a) **p < 0.005, stress × treatment
interaction and (b) **p < 0.005, stress effect. Data are
presented as mean + standard error of the mean, n = 11–15 per group.
CMS: chronic mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL:
saline; PR: progressive ratio.For infusions during the last three FR1 sessions (Figure 5), parameter estimates of the
linear mixed model indicated that intake increased for both males and females
over the course of the three sessions. Males had a main sessions effect F(2,
104) = 4.321, p = 0.016), and females had main stress, treatment, and sessions
effects (F(1,44) = 9.398, p < 0.0001; F(1,44) = 9.335, p = 0.004;
F(2,86) = 12.848, p < 0.0001), such that KET-treated females maintained their
reduced intake compared to SAL-treated females (p < 0.001), regardless of
stress condition. Active nose pokes revealed a main sessions effect for males
(F(2, 104) = 6.783, p = 0.002) and a stress effect for females (F(1,44) = 7.618,
p = 0.008). Inactive nose pokes were significantly lower than active nose pokes
(F(1, 476) = 552.298, p < 0.0001), indicative of continued discrimination
between reinforced and nonreinforced operant behavior.
Figure 5.
Last three days of FR1 KET self-administration after PR tests. (a and
b) Infusions, (c and d) active nose pokes, and (e and f) inactive
nose pokes for males (a, c, and e) and females (b, d, and f). While
all rats increase their intake over time, CMS females continue to
have an increased KET intake compared to NS females. (a to c)
***p < 0.0001, main effect across sessions and (b and c)
*p < 0.05, stress effect for females. Data are presented as
mean + standard error of the mean, n = 11–15 per group. CMS: chronic
mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL: saline; FR1:
fixed-ratio 1 schedule of reinforcement.
Last three days of FR1 KET self-administration after PR tests. (a and
b) Infusions, (c and d) active nose pokes, and (e and f) inactive
nose pokes for males (a, c, and e) and females (b, d, and f). While
all rats increase their intake over time, CMS females continue to
have an increased KET intake compared to NS females. (a to c)
***p < 0.0001, main effect across sessions and (b and c)
*p < 0.05, stress effect for females. Data are presented as
mean + standard error of the mean, n = 11–15 per group. CMS: chronic
mild stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL: saline; FR1:
fixed-ratio 1 schedule of reinforcement.Active nose pokes during the three incubation tests were analyzed (Figure 6(a) and (b)). A
main sex effect was observed (F(1,93) = 22.815, p < 0.0001). Males and
females both had main effects across sessions (F(2, 105) = 25.577,
p < 0.0001; F(2,84) = 16.703, p < 0.0001, respectively). There were also
significant sessions effects for males’ inactive nose pokes (F(2, 110) = 5.402,
p = 0.006) but not females. Importantly, an interaction between sessions and
nose poke type was observed across all time points (F(1, 512) = 12.675,
p < 0.0001). Taken together, both sexes show incubated craving of KET.
Figure 6.
Incubation of KET craving. Males (a) and females (b) both show
persistent craving for KET with each test. ***p < 0.0001,
sessions effect. Data are presented as mean + standard error of the
mean, n = 11–15 per group. CMS: chronic mild stress; NS:
nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL: saline.
Incubation of KET craving. Males (a) and females (b) both show
persistent craving for KET with each test. ***p < 0.0001,
sessions effect. Data are presented as mean + standard error of the
mean, n = 11–15 per group. CMS: chronic mild stress; NS:
nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL: saline.
Spine Density and Morphology
Representative z-stack composite images from each group were analyzed (Figure 7(a), n = 4–6 per
group). For total spine density (data not shown), there was no main effect of
sex, stress, or self-administration. When separated by spine type (thin, stubby,
and mushroom; Figure 7(b) and
(c)), analyzing thin spines revealed a main effect of treatment
(F(1,41) = 4.519, p = 0.039) such that KET treatment increased spine density,
with no sex or stress effects. Split by sex, females had a trending effect of
treatment (F(1,19) = 4.049, p = 0.059), while males had no significant group
effects. There were no differences in mushroom-type or stubby-type spine
densities as a function of sex, treatment, or stress conditions. Taken together,
these results indicate that KET pretreatment increases dendritic spine density
in the NAcc, an effect driven by thin spine formation.
Figure 7.
Dendritic spine density in the nucleus accumbens core (NAcc). (a)
Representative images of z-stack composites featuring dendritic
spines in the NAcc. Scale bar = 10 µm. Stress (+= CMS,−= NS), KET
treatment (− = SAL, + = KET), and KET self-admin (− = SAL
self-administration, + = KET self-administration). (b and c) Spine
density broken down by subtypes for males (b) and females (c).
p = 0.05, main KET effect for females. When collapsed by sex, a main
KET effect was observed (p < 0.05). Data are expressed as number
of spines per 10 µm of dendrite + standard error of the mean.
n = 4–6 rats per group, eight branches per rat. CMS: chronic mild
stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL: saline.
Dendritic spine density in the nucleus accumbens core (NAcc). (a)
Representative images of z-stack composites featuring dendritic
spines in the NAcc. Scale bar = 10 µm. Stress (+= CMS,−= NS), KET
treatment (− = SAL, + = KET), and KET self-admin (− = SAL
self-administration, + = KET self-administration). (b and c) Spine
density broken down by subtypes for males (b) and females (c).
p = 0.05, main KET effect for females. When collapsed by sex, a main
KET effect was observed (p < 0.05). Data are expressed as number
of spines per 10 µm of dendrite + standard error of the mean.
n = 4–6 rats per group, eight branches per rat. CMS: chronic mild
stress; NS: nonstressed; KET: ketamine; SAL: saline.
Discussion
The purpose of this study was to assess the effects of stress exposure and KET
pretreatment in males and females on measures of KET addiction-like behavior and
changes in dendritic spine density in the NAcc. KET treatment resulted in a partial
amelioration of depression-related behaviors and an increase in thin spine density
in the NAcc. CMS enhanced KET addictive-like behavior in females only. Finally,
females with prior KET treatment displayed decreased FR1 KET intake. This is the
first study to investigate sex differences in KET addictive-like behaviors within
the context of stress.In the current study, first-pass indicators of CMS impact included reduced body
weight gain in males and estrous cycle disruptions in females. The lack of body
weight gain changes in females was expected and has been previously demonstrated, as
females do not gain as much body weight as their age-matched male counterparts.[31] Anehdonia, a hallmark of depression, was assessed using the sucrose intake
test, where a decrease in consumption of a sweet solution is usaally reduced after CMS.[16] In the present study, CMS reduced total sucrose intake in both males and
females as compared to same-sex NS counterparts. This is a significant indicator of
CMS’s impact on hedonic consummatory behavior and is in line with findings from
other species exposed to stressful stimuli.[32] Importantly, the decreased intake was still observed after normalizing intake
by body weight, suggesting the effect is not due to secondary impacts of CMS.KET treatment had no effect on sucrose intake; rather, cessation of CMS returned
sucrose intake to levels comparable to NS counterparts. Our 21-day CMS protocol was
adopted from Li et al.[25], where acute KET (10 mg/kg i.p.) increased sucrose preference in CMS male
rats lasting up to 7 days. Similar findings were seen with male mice and sucrose
intake.[33,34] However, others found no effect of KET in male or female mice
on CMS-induced anhedonia,[35] and only a transient effect of KET on sucrose preference in socially isolated
males, but not females.[36] Another depression model, vicarious social defeat,[37] produces a depressive-like behavioral profile (including anhedonia) that is
reversed by KET in female mice,[38] suggesting that stressor type can impact KET’s effectiveness. There are
notable methodological differences among these studies that could explain these
discrepancies. Drugs delivered via i.p. injection undergo initial absorption in the
liver before reaching the brain,[39] therefore introducing greater possible effects of drug metabolites. Together,
KET’s effects on anhedonia in preclinical studies remain unclear. As these measures
were originally developed to test the efficacy of traditional (i.e., monoaminergic)
antidepressants predominantly in males, more work is needed to optimize procedures
testing rapid-acting antidepressants in females.The NSFT demonstrated KET’s ameliorating effects on CMS-induced neophagia in both
males and females, in line with previous findings.[25,26,40] While these studies utilized
i.p. injections of acute KET, this study uses i.v. infusions at a clinically
relevant dose to reverse CMS-induced behavioral deficits in both sexes.Rats underwent operant KET self-administration. Due to females’ higher sucrose pellet
intake during initial shaping, analysis for males and females was conducted
separately. Pharmacokinetic sex differences lend further support for separating the
analysis for self-administration by sex, as females have slower clearance and longer
elimination half-lives than males.[41] Females previously exposed to CMS displayed greater addiction-like behavior
than NS females, demonstrated by increased intake during FR1 and enhanced motivation
during PR sessions, an effect absent in CMS males. The dose of KET used for
self-administration (0.5 mg/kg/inf) is a high dose commonly used.[13,15,42,43] However, none
of the aforementioned studies included females or tested incubation of craving. This
is the first study to demonstrate persistent, incubated craving of KET after 7 to 21
days of forced abstinence. Animals show incubation of craving to many other drugs of
abuse with differing temporal profiles.[44] In the current study, the expression of craving plateaus between the D7 and
D21. It is well known that stress is a potent trigger for drug craving and
precipitation of relapse in humans, especially for women.[45] Furthermore, female rodents are more susceptible to stress-induced
augmentation of addiction-related behavior.[46-49] This could be due to a
positive interaction between circulating estradiol and extracellular dopamine in the
NAc following chronic stress.[48] Indeed, behavioral responsivity to KET is influenced by gonadal
hormones.[50,51] More work is needed to understand the role of gonadal hormones
in mediating stress-induced drug-seeking behavior, especially regarding KET.During FR1 sessions, all animals increased their KET intake over time and maintained
those levels after PR testing, indicating robust reinforcement. Among males, there
were no differences due to stress conditions or prior KET treatment. Conversely,
KET-treated females (regardless of stress condition) reduced their KET intake
relative to SAL-treated females after the fifth FR1 session that persisted after PR
testing. This suggests that KET pretreatment may have enhanced the motivation to
obtain high doses of KET, since their PR and incubation of craving were similar to
animals with high intake during FR1. Future studies involving extended access
paradigms will help to further characterize this effect.KET preexposed animals also had increased density of thin spines in the NAcc
following incubation of KET craving. Immature spines (thin and stubby subtypes) are
more motile and dynamically regulated as compared to the more stable mushroom spines.[52] These alterations correlate with increased synaptic excitability, as more
synapses form and more glutamate receptors are inserted into the postsynaptic membrane,[53] thereby altering subsequent responsivity to drug- or stress-paired stimuli.
NAc medium spiny neurons undergo robust structural and physiological changes
following exposure to both drugs and chronic stress: in both cases generally, thin
and/or stubby dendritic spine densities increase.[20,54-56] While our results for males
are in accordance with a previous study using socially defeated rats,[57] our results in females were unexpected because the last therapeutic KET
infusion occurred 40 days prior to analysis. Additionally, another study with CMS
males found decreased NAc spine density[58] as well as a clinical study showing decreased NAc volume following KET infusion.[59] In addition to methodological differences, our effect in females may be an
additive result of KET treatment and KET self-administration. Previously, we
reported increased spine density in the NAcc only in females, while both sexes had
increases in the shell 2 h after an acute KET challenge (i.p.).[21] This effect of KET pretreatment on NAcc spines suggests long-lasting
neuroadaptations, possibly due to upstream regulation of the medial prefrontal
cortex and hippocampus, where KET reverses stress-induced deficits in spineogenesis.[60] Although these changes appear to be independent of the expression of KET
addiction-like behavior, they may be related to the decreased FR1 intake observed in
females and are unlikely to be linked to a specific antidepressant/therapeutic
behavioral effect due to lack of specificity to stressed females and males.Taken together, we have demonstrated a sex-specific responsivity to KET
addiction-like behavior following exposure to chronic stress in females, an effect
not observed in male counterparts. Additionally, using a novel i.v. KET treatment
protocol similar to clinically relevant dosing, we showed that KET treatment
partially ameliorates depression-related effects of CMS in both sexes without
increasing propensity to self-administer KET as well as increased NAcc dendritic
spine density. Finally, KET-treated females displayed decreased KET FR1 intake.
Together, these findings suggest a differential response to KET self-administration
that was not manifested in the expression of addiction-like behaviors but may still
underlie neuroadaptations in reward circuitry relevant to responsivity to stress or
drug-related stimuli. While these findings highlight an important question regarding
the abuse potential of repeated low-dose therapeutic KET in rats, these factors
require investigation in clinical population.Click here for additional data file.Supplemental material, Supplemental Material1 for Sex-Dependent Ketamine
Addiction-Like Behavior Profile Following Exposure to Chronic Mild Stress by
Katherine N. Wright, Devin P. Hagarty, Caroline E. Strong, Kristin J. Schoepfer
and Mohamed Kabbaj in Chronic StressClick here for additional data file.Supplemental material, Supplemental Material2 for Sex-Dependent Ketamine
Addiction-Like Behavior Profile Following Exposure to Chronic Mild Stress by
Katherine N. Wright, Devin P. Hagarty, Caroline E. Strong, Kristin J. Schoepfer
and Mohamed Kabbaj in Chronic Stress
Authors: R M Berman; A Cappiello; A Anand; D A Oren; G R Heninger; D S Charney; J H Krystal Journal: Biol Psychiatry Date: 2000-02-15 Impact factor: 13.382
Authors: C Dalla; K Antoniou; G Drossopoulou; M Xagoraris; N Kokras; A Sfikakis; Z Papadopoulou-Daifoti Journal: Neuroscience Date: 2005-08-26 Impact factor: 3.590
Authors: Ko-Woon Lee; Yong Kim; Amie M Kim; Kathryn Helmin; Angus C Nairn; Paul Greengard Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2006-02-21 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: Paul J Fitzgerald; Savannah K Kounelis-Wuillaume; Ali Gheidi; Jonathan D Morrow; Joanna L Spencer-Segal; Brendon O Watson Journal: Stress Date: 2021-02-01 Impact factor: 3.493