Amjad Mahasneh1, Fawaz N. Al-Shaheri2, Mohammed N. BaniHani3. 1. Dept. of Applied Biological Sciences,Jordan University of Science and Technology, Irbid 22110, Jordan. 2. Dept. of Medical Laboratory Sciences, Jordan University of Science and Technology, Irbid 22110, Jordan. 3. Dept. of General Surgery and Urology, Jordan University of Science and Technology, Irbid 22110, Jordan.
Abstract
Background: MUTYH DNA glycosylase germline mutations are linked to the recessive inheritance of multiple adenoma. Studies have revealed that germline mutations in this gene are ethnicity related. This study aimed to identify the germline mutations in MUTYH gene and determine their prevalence among Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma. Methods: In this study, 150 colorectal adenoma patients and 150 cancer-free individuals with no previous history of polyps were recruited. Sanger DNA sequencing of the MUTYH gene (accession number NG_008189.1) was carried out using 3130xL Genetic Analyzer. Sequencing results were analyzed by ChromasPro, and mutational effects were predicted by online bioinformatics tools. Results: Two novel variants, g.87C>T and c.1264G>C, were identified. g.87C>T was also found in 60 (40%) patients and 10 (6.7%) controls. However, c.1264G>C was detected in 90 (60%) patients and 7 (4.7%) controls. Thus, a significant association was observed between these two variants and colorectal adenoma (p value for both variants was <0.0001). Moreover, the newly identified germline variant, c.1264G>C, was found to be significantly associated with colorectal adenoma transformation into malignancy (p < 0.0001). Conclusion: The data showed high prevalence of two germline mutations in MUTYH gene among Jordanians with colorectal adenoma, which may make them as potential early biomarkers for diagnosis of colorectal adenoma.
Background: MUTYH DNA glycosylase germline mutations are linked to the recessive inheritance of multiple adenoma. Studies have revealed that germline mutations in this gene are ethnicity related. This study aimed to identify the germline mutations in MUTYH gene and determine their prevalence among Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma. Methods: In this study, 150 colorectal adenomapatients and 150 cancer-free individuals with no previous history of polyps were recruited. Sanger DNA sequencing of the MUTYH gene (accession number NG_008189.1) was carried out using 3130xL Genetic Analyzer. Sequencing results were analyzed by ChromasPro, and mutational effects were predicted by online bioinformatics tools. Results: Two novel variants, g.87C>T and c.1264G>C, were identified. g.87C>T was also found in 60 (40%) patients and 10 (6.7%) controls. However, c.1264G>C was detected in 90 (60%) patients and 7 (4.7%) controls. Thus, a significant association was observed between these two variants and colorectal adenoma (p value for both variants was <0.0001). Moreover, the newly identified germline variant, c.1264G>C, was found to be significantly associated with colorectal adenoma transformation into malignancy (p < 0.0001). Conclusion: The data showed high prevalence of two germline mutations in MUTYH gene among Jordanians with colorectal adenoma, which may make them as potential early biomarkers for diagnosis of colorectal adenoma.
Colorectal adenoma pathogenesis is a multistep process and can induce neoplastic transformation of normal cryptic epithelial cells into neoplasia[[1]]. This stepwise transformation is due to multiple genetic and environmental factors, which disrupt the epithelial cells homeostasis by diminishing cellular apoptosis, persisting DNA replication, and losing the ability for differentiation and maturation[[2]-[4]]. Colorectal adenoma can be classified into tubular, villous, and tubuvillous adenoma[[5]]. The age, gender, smoking, diet, and obesity are environmental factors that contribute to colorectal neoplasia[[6]-[8]]. Genetic mechanisms such as chromosomal instability, CpG island hypermethylation, and microsatellite instability assist in colorectal neoplastic transformation. Microsatellite instability results from defect in DNA mismatch repair system that includes PCNA, MLH1, MSH6, XRCC1, and MUTYH genes[[9]-[11]].MUTYH comprises 16 exons encoding 535 amino acids protein and is mapped to the chromosome 1(1p32.1-p34.3)[[12]]. The MUTYH glycosylase, a base excision repair enzyme[[13]], detects and repairs DNA damage including those generated by normal metabolic reactions such as alkylation, deamination, or oxidation[[14]]. The exposure of reactive oxygen species (produced during aerobic metabolism) to some chemicals/radiation influence the DNA integrity[[15]]. As a consequence, 7,8-dihydroxy-8-oxoguanine (8-oxo-G) often pairs with adenine (A), resulting in transversion of guanine:cytosine into thymidine:adenine (G:C> T:A) after two replication rounds of DNA[[16]]. The 8-oxo-G:A base-pair detection is initiated by MUTYH glycosylase[[14]].MUTYH germline mutations have been linked to multiple colorectal adenomas inheritance in Caucasian populations[[17]]. Therefore, their identification greatly enhances our understanding of the colorectal cancer (CRC) potential causes and attributes in implementation of screening and management measures. Importantly, the early detection of CRC can be effective by establishing panels of genetic biomarkers. There are many genes and proteins currently used in the clinical settings in USA[[18]], but they differ significantly in their predictive and prognostic values among populations[[19]]. Supposing that Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma have a novel germline mutation(s) in MUTYH gene, this study aimed to identify these mutations among those patients and to determine their prevalence in relation to their ethnic background.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Study subjectsColorectal adenomapatients (n = 150) were recruited from King Abdulla University Hospital (Ramtha, Jordan) during the period between January 2016 and February 2017. To select these patients, the biopsy samples from 400 subjects who visited the Endoscopy Unit at King Abdullah University Hospital were examined by a pathologist. Subjects (n = 150) who were confirmed pathologically to have tubular adenoma, villous adenoma, or tubulovillious adenoma were investigated in the study. Inclusion criteria include the number of polyps and the patient's previous treatment status. Patients with more than 10 polyps and without any surgical removal of polyps were enrolled in this study. However, those with a previous history of irritable bowel syndrome or Crohn’s disease were excluded. Clinical data were collected from patient's history files. The study was approved in advance by the Institution Review Board at King Abdullah University Hospital and Jordan University of Science and Technology (Ramtha, Jordan). Informed written consents were obtained from all participants. Besides, 150 cancer-free individuals with no previous family history of polyps were recruited as controls. A structured questionnaire interview was established to collect data on the characteristics of the study participants.Sample collection and handlingOne blood sample was collected from each participant. Five milliliters of whole blood was collected in EDTA tubes. Samples were transported on ice to the DNA extraction laboratory at Princess Haya Biotechnology Center (Ramtha, Jordan) and either processed immediately or stored at 4 C and extracted the next day.Genomic
DNA extractionDNA was extracted from whole blood samples using Qiagen® genomic DNA purification kit (Qiagen, USA) according to the manufacturer’s instructions. The concentration of DNA was determined using Nano Drop 2000 (Thermo Scientific, USA). To check the quality of extracted DNAs, two microliters from each extracted DNA sample was subjected to agarose gel electrophoresis. Extracted DNA samples were stored at -80 C.Polymerase chain reaction
(PCR) procedureAll exons of MUTYH gene were amplified using PCR. The primers were designed using Primer3 Plus (http://www.bioinformatics.nl/cgi-bin/primer3plus/ primer3plus.cgi/). Eight amplicons were designed comprising the whole coding regions of MUTYH gene as well as the 5’ untranslated region and exon-intron boundaries (Fig. 1). Amplification of the target sequences was performed using conventional PCR (VeritiTM Thermal Cycler from Applied Bioscience). PCR was carried out in a reaction volume of 25 L containing 12.5 L commercial 2 Master Mix (2.5 U Taq of DNA polymerase, 3 mM of MgCl2, and 0.5 mM of dNTPs), and buffer (100 mM of KCl, 20 mM of Tris HCl [pH8.3]), as well as 2L of each forward and reverse primer (10µM), 6.5 µl of nuclease-free water, and 2-3 µl of sample DNA. The list of primers and sequences for each amplicon are shown in Table 1.
Fig. 1
Schematic representation of the designed MUTYH amplicons. MUTYH 5′untranslated region, 16 exons, and exons-intron boundaries were amplified in eight amplicons
Table 1
Primer sequences for MUTYH amplicons
Amplicon
Reverse primer
Forward primer
Size (bp)
1
ctttggatcacaacgctcaa
aggagacggaccgcaagt
410
2
gccaagagtaaacccgtgag
cttgggccacaacctagttc
300
3
catactgccacaggctgct
ggtctgacccatgacccttc
590
4
tggctatagaagtggcctaca
accccaacatcctaccagag
593
5
gcagtgttcccttcttttagg
cacgcccagtatccaggta
690
6
agggaatcggcagctgag
aaggaagtacaacaaagacaacaaa
459
7
acaaaagtactgggacatgaagtt
cctggagtggagaatgttca
239
8
gctctacagcattccaggcta
aatcacttgaggccagaatca
410
Gel electrophoresisFive microliters from each PCR product was loaded on 2% agarose gel. The electrophoresis was run at 140 volts for 40 minutes. The running Tris/Borate/EDTA buffer was diluted to 1, and the bands were then detected under a UV light in Gel DocTM XR system (BioRad, USA) using Red Safe stain (iNtRON). Images were processed and analyzed by Quantity One 4.6.9 software.Schematic representation of the designed MUTYH amplicons. MUTYH 5′untranslated region, 16 exons, and exons-intron boundaries were amplified in eight ampliconsCycler sequencing, cleaning and Sanger sequencingPurified PCR products were cycle-sequenced using Big Dye Terminator Ready Reaction (R-R) mix. The reaction components were 4 µL of sequencing buffer, 4 µL of nuclease-free water, 1 µL of R-R, 1 µL of forward or reverse primer, and 4 µL of purified DNA. The excess of Dye DeoxyTM terminator, primer dimmers, and the other impurities were removed from DNA sequencing reaction using Qiagen cleaning kit. Sequencing of cleaned cycle-sequenced products was carried out on an ABI prism 3130xL Genetic Analyzer (Applied Biosystems, USA) in the Genomics Sequencing Laboratory at Princess Haya Biotechnology Center (PHBC).Sequencing data analysisSequence analysis was carried out using ChromasPro software (http://technelysium.com.au/wp/chromas/).Bioinformatics and computational analysis of variantsSeveral bioinformatics tools were used in this study. Primer3Plus online software (http://www. bioinformatics.nl/cgi-bin/primer3plus/primer3plus. cgi/) was used for primer design. MutationTastersoftware (http://www.mutationtaster.org/).PROVEAN (http://provean.jcvi.org/index.php) was applied for mutational effect prediction and PolyPhen-2 (http://genetics.bwh. harvard.edu/pph2/) for protein prediction analyses.Statistical analysisGraphPad Prism 6.0 was used for statistical analyses. In particular, Chi-square test was used. Statistical analyses with p value less than 0.05 were considered statistically significant.
RESULTS
Characteristics of the study participantsThe recruited Jordanian subjects with colorectal adenoma were 81(54%) males and 69 (46%) females, and the controls were 78 (52%) males and 72 (48%) females. There was no age difference between the patients and controls (p = 0.37, Table 2). Tubular adenoma was the most prevalent histopathogical group among 103 (68.6%) patients. Also, 28 subjects (18.6%) had villous adenoma, and 19 (12.7%) had tubuvillous adenoma. There was no significant difference in gender among the study subjects (p = 0.29; Table 3). Regarding the progression of colorectal adenoma into CRC, 107 (71.4%) subjects had progressed to CRC, while 43 (28.6%) had recovered after polypectomy. In addition, there was no significant association between CRC progression and gender (p = 0.31). On the other hand, 86 (80.3%) patients, who progressed into CRC, continued to metastasis, compared to 21 (19.7%) who recovered after surgery and chemotherapy (p = 0.28).
Table 2
General characteristics of the participants (n = 300)
Variable
Controln (%)
Patientn (%)
pvalue
Gender
Male
78 (52)
81 (54.0)
0.73*
Female
72 (48)
69 (46.0)
Total
150
150
Age groups (y)
30-50
84 (56)
80 (53.3)
0.37
51-70
45 (30)
40 (26.7)
<60
21 (14)
30 (20.0)
*Odds ratio: 0.922 and relative risk: 0.960
Table 3
Clinical characteristics of the patients (n =150)
Variable
Malen (%)
Femalen (%)
Totaln (%)
pvalue
Histopathology
Tubular adenoma
60 (58.25)
43 (41.17)
103 (68.6)
0.29
Villous adenoma
13 (46.4)
15 (53.6)
28 (18.6)
Tubuvillous adenoma
8 (42.10)
11 (57.9)
19 (12.7)
Total
81
69
150
CRC progression
Yes
55 (51.5)
52 (48.5)
107 (71.4)
0.31*
No
26 (60.4)
17 (39.6)
43 (28.6)
Total
81
69
150
Metastasis
Yes
42 (48.9)
44 (51.1)
86 (80.3)
No
13 (61.9)
8 (38.1)
21 (19.7)
0.28**
Total
55
52
107
*Odds ratio: 0.692 and relative risk: 0.850;**odds ratio: 0.58 and relative risk: 0.788
Primer sequences for MUTYH ampliconsGeneral characteristics of the participants (n = 300)*Odds ratio: 0.922 and relative risk: 0.960Mutational analysesInterestingly, we identified five germline variants (g.87C>T, c.381A>C, c.724G>A, c.1264G>C, and c.1760C>T) in Jordanian subjects with colorectal adenoma (Table 4); two of which (g.87C>T and c.1760C>T) were novel. The c.1264G>C was the most common variant found in 90 patients (60%) with colorectal adenoma. Three variants (c.381A>C, c.724G>A, and c.1264G>C) were found to be disease predisposing, and two variants (g.87C>T and c.1760C>T) were considered as benign (Table 4). Based on Polyphen-2 protein prediction pipeline, c.724G>A and c.1264G>C were probably damaging to DNA glycosylase. However, c.381A>C and c.1760C>T were benign. These findings are consistent with those obtained from PROVEAN v1.1.3 software (http://provean.jcvi.org/seq_submit.php(, which indicates that c.724G>A and c.1264G>C are predicted to be deleterious to DNA glycosylase.
Table 4
Genotype and allele frequencies of g.87C>T in MUTYH gene among study subjects (n =300).
The heterozygous variant g.87C>T was identified in amplicon 1 in 60 subjects with colorectal adenoma and in 11 controls. Searching the ExAc and 1000 genome databases showed that g.87C>T was a novel variant found in this study. The variant was mapped to the 5′ untranslated region (5′UTR) of MUTYH gene (Fig. 2) and was named according to Human Genome Variation Society guidelines. Table 5 shows that g.87C>T is significantly associated with colorectal adenoma in comparison to the controls (p < 0.0001). Statistical analysis of allele frequencies of both groups showed that the wild-type allele (C) was more common in the control group (96.7%) than the patients group (80%). However, the mutant allele (T) was found in 20% among patients compared to 3.3% among the controls. These data are statistically significant with p < 0.0001.
Fig. 2
Mutational analysis of amplicon 1 of MUTYH gene. (a) Schematic representation of MUTYH gene showing that amplicon 1 contains 5’ untranslated region, exon 1, and the intronic boundaries. (b) The reference sequence of amplicon 1 obtained from Gene Bank (NG_008189.1) and the highlighted sequences are orange for TATA box, green for initiator, blue for downstream promotor elements (DPE), and yellow for exon 1. The red box contains the sequence in which g.87C>T variant was identified. The PCR was run using the forward and reverse primers (sequences above and below the block arrows). The expected PCR product was 410 bp. (c) 2% agarose gel electrophoresis of amplicon 1. The amplicon was successfully amplified and 410 bp bands were visualized using ethidium bromide staining. The size was compared to 100 bp ladder (lane 1), and the negative control (lane 2) was included. Lanes from 3-12 and from 13-18 are representative of patients and controls, respectively. (d) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing of amplicon 1 from normal control, showing wild-type sequence (wt/wt). (e) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing from patients illustrating heterozygous, g.87C>T, variant (wt/vt). (f) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequencing from normal control indicates wild type (wt/wt). (g) Partial Chromatogram for reverse sequencing from patients, showing heterozygous g.87C>T variant (wt/vt)
Table 5
Genotype and allele frequencies of germline mutation c.1264G>C in MUTYH gene in study subjects (n = 300)
Genotypes and Alleles
Controln (%)
Patientn (%)
pvalue
G/G
143 (95.3)
60 (40)
<0.0001
G/C
7 (4.7)
5 (3.3)
C/C
0 (0)
85(56.7)
Total
150
150
Allele G
293 (97.7)
125 (41.7)
<0.0001*
Allele C
7 (3.3)
175 (58.3)
Total
300
300
Familial
6 (85)
63 (70)
0.376**
Sporadic
1 (15)
27 (30)
Total
7
90
*Odds ratio: 58.6 and relative risk: 18.22; **Odds ratio: 2.57 and relative risk: 2.43.
Clinical characteristics of the patients (n =150)*Odds ratio: 0.692 and relative risk: 0.850;**odds ratio: 0.58 and relative risk: 0.788Genotype and allele frequencies of g.87C>T in MUTYH gene among study subjects (n =300).Odds ratio: 7.25and relative risk: 4.26; **odds ratio: 0.642 and relative risk: 0.928Genotype and allele frequencies of germline mutation c.1264G>C in MUTYH gene in study subjects (n = 300)*Odds ratio: 58.6 and relative risk: 18.22; **Odds ratio: 2.57 and relative risk: 2.43.Amplicon 2 contains exon number 2 of MUTYH gene. It has been amplified to yield 300 bp PCR products. The PCR products were purified, and DNA cycle sequencing was carried out using the forward primer. However, no variant was found in this exon in the study subjects. Likewise, we carried out a PCR to amplify amplicon number 3, which contains three exons, 3, 4, and 5. This amplicon spans 590 bp as visualized by 2% gel electrophoresis. Analysis of amplicon 3 showed a reported single-nucleotide polymorphism called c.381A>C in 11 Jordanians with colorectal adenoma. c.381A>C was found to be disease predisposing with Bayes’s probability score of 50 (Table 7). Genotype frequency of both mutant (C) and wild type (A) among the study patients were 12 (8%) and 138 (92%), and their allele frequencies were 288 (96%) and 12 (4%), respectively among study patients (Table 6). Furthermore, amplicon 4 in MUTYH gene contains exons number 6, 7, 8, and 9. Overall, we identified a reported heterozygous variant, c.724G>A, in seven Jordanians with colorectal adenoma[[20]]. c.724G>A was found to be disease causing with a probability score of 61. It was also found probably damaging and deleterious for DNA glycosylase using PolyPhen-2 and PROVEAN pipelines, respectively (Table 7).
Table 7
Characteristics of germline mutations found in Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma (n = 150)
AmpliconNumber
Variant
dbSNP ID(rs)
MutationTasterPrediction(score)
PolyPhen-2 prediction(score)
PROVEAN prediction(score)
1
g.87C>T
Novel
Polymorphism (12)*
-
-
2
-
-
-
-
-
3
c. 381A>C
rs199929178
Disease predisposing (50)*
Benign (0.002)**
-
4
c.724G>A
rs786203212
Disease predisposing (61)*
Probably damaging (1.0)**
Deleterious (-2.863)***
5
c.1264G>C
Novel
Disease predisposing (81)*
Probably damaging (0.58)**
Deleterious (-2.98)***
6
-
-
-
-
-
7
-
-
-
-
-
8
c.1760C>T
rs140118273
Polymorphism (15)*
Benign (0.003)**
Neutral (-1.0)
*Bayes classifier score, which calculates the actual probability that certain alteration causes a disease. The range of result values is between 10 and 100. Therefore, the higher score, the more harmful alteration for human health. **This score indicates the probability that certain mutation is damaging. Hence, variants scores between 0.0 and 0.15 are benign, and variants with scores between 0.15 and 0.40 are possibly damaging. However, variants that score between 0.51 and 1.0 are probably damaging. ***Delta alignment score of PROVEAN: if the score is below or equal to the threshold (-2.5), the alteration is predicted to have deleterious effect. However, if the variant has a score above -2.5, the variant is predicted to be neutral.
Table 6
Genotype and allele frequency of germline variants found in Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma (n =150)
Ampliconnumber
Variantidentified
Nucleotide(wt:vt)
Genotype frequency
Allele frequency(wt:vt) n (%)
(wt/wt)n (%)
(wt/vt)n (%)
(vt/vt)n (%)
1
g.87C>T
C:T
90 (60)
60 (40)
0 (0)
C:240 (80) T:60 (20)
2
-
-
-
-
3
c. 381A>C
A:C
138 (92)
12 (8)
0 (0)
A:288 (96) C:12 (4)
4
c.724G>A
G:A
143 (95)
7 (5)
0 (0)
G:293 (97.6) A:7 (2.4)
5
c.1264G>C
G:C
60 (40)
5 (3.3)
85 (56.7)
G:125 (41.7) C:175 (58.3)
6
-
-
-
7
-
-
-
8
c.1760C>T
C:T
145 (96.7)
5 (3.3)
0 (0)
C:295 (98.3) T:5 (1.7)
Wt, wild type; vt, variant type
Amplicon 5 contains three exons, 10, 11, and 12. The size of PCR products is 690 bp (Fig. 3). Interestingly, the Sanger sequencing revealed a novel variant in 90 (60%) patients with colorectal adenoma from Jordan. As shown in Table 6), c.1264G>C was the highly prevalent variant allele detected in 90 (60%) patients under study. In particular, homozygous allele variant, C/C, was found in 85 (56.7%) patients, while G/C was found in 5 (3.3%) patients. Clearly, a significant association was observed between c.1264G>C variant and colorectal adenomapatients comparable to the controls (p < 0.0001). The mutation was mapped to position 1264 of the coding sequence of MUTYH (transcript usedNG_008189.1). Besides, c.1264G>C was named according to Human Genome Variation Society guidelines. The mutation was predicted to be disease predisposing variant based on PROVEAN and PolyPhen-2. The normal codon, CAG of glutamine, at position 350 was altered into CAC that codes for histidine. PolyPhen-2 protein prediction analysis showed that the altered amino acid (p.Gln350His) would affect the protein structure and function. C.1264G>C was probably damaging and deleterious to DNA glycosylase based on data obtained from PolyPhen2 and PROVEAN, which scored 0.58 and -2.98, respectively (Table 7). The high prevalence of c.1264G>C in Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma stressed the importance of investigating the association between this mutation and the progression of adenoma into carcinoma (Fig. 4). Interestingly, a significant association was observed between c.1264G>C mutation and malignant transformation of colorectal adenoma among patients (p < 0.001). This observation brings the necessity to evaluate the relationship between c.1264G>C and colorectal cancer metastasis. Hence, the disease pattern was followed, and the c.1264G>C was found to be significantly associated with CRC metastasis (Fig. 5).
Fig. 3
Mutational analysis of the amplicon 5 of MUTYH gene. (a) Schematic representation of MUTYH, showing that amplicon 5 contains three exons (10, 11, and 12) and the intronic boundaries. (b) The reference sequence of amplicon 5 obtained from Gene Bank (NG_008189.1) and the yellow highlighted sequences are for exons 10, 11, and 12. The PCR was run using the forward and reverse primers (sequences above and below the block arrows). The expected PCR product was 690 bp. The red box shows the position of c.1264G>C mutation. (c) 2% gel agarose gel electrophoresis for amplicon 5. The amplicon was successfully amplified, and 690 bp bands were visualized using ethidium bromide staining. The size was compared to 100 bp ladder (lane 1), and negative control (lane 2) was included. Lanes from 3-12 and 13-20 are representative patients and controls samples, respectively. (d) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing of amplicon 5 from normal control showing wild-type sequence (wt/wt). (e) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing from patients illustrating heterozygous, c.1264G>C, variant (wt/vt). (f) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing from patient indicates homozygous c.1264 G>C mutation (vt/vt). (g) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequencing from normal control showing wild-type sequence (wt/wt). (h) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequencing from patient with heterozygous, c.1264 C>G, mutation (wt/vt). (i) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequence of amplicon 5 from patient with homozygous mutation, c.1264 C>G (vt/vt)
Fig. 4
Association between c.1264G>C and colorectal adenoma malignant transformation. A strong association was found among the study subjects (p < 0.001). Of 90 subjects, who harbored the c.1264G>C germline mutation, 82 (91.2%) had progressed to colorectal cancer. In contrast, only 25 wild-type patients had progressed into CRC, comparable to 35 subjects who recovered after polypectomy
Fig. 5
The association between c.1264G>C and CRC metastasis. A significant (p < 0.001) association was observed between c.1264G>C and CRC metastasis. Sixty four subjects included in this study with c.1264G>C germline mutation had CRC metastasis, comparable to 12 who had recovered after colectomy and chemotherapy
Mutational analysis of amplicon 1 of MUTYH gene. (a) Schematic representation of MUTYH gene showing that amplicon 1 contains 5’ untranslated region, exon 1, and the intronic boundaries. (b) The reference sequence of amplicon 1 obtained from Gene Bank (NG_008189.1) and the highlighted sequences are orange for TATA box, green for initiator, blue for downstream promotor elements (DPE), and yellow for exon 1. The red box contains the sequence in which g.87C>T variant was identified. The PCR was run using the forward and reverse primers (sequences above and below the block arrows). The expected PCR product was 410 bp. (c) 2% agarose gel electrophoresis of amplicon 1. The amplicon was successfully amplified and 410 bp bands were visualized using ethidium bromide staining. The size was compared to 100 bp ladder (lane 1), and the negative control (lane 2) was included. Lanes from 3-12 and from 13-18 are representative of patients and controls, respectively. (d) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing of amplicon 1 from normal control, showing wild-type sequence (wt/wt). (e) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing from patients illustrating heterozygous, g.87C>T, variant (wt/vt). (f) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequencing from normal control indicates wild type (wt/wt). (g) Partial Chromatogram for reverse sequencing from patients, showing heterozygous g.87C>T variant (wt/vt)Genotype and allele frequency of germline variants found in Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma (n =150)Wt, wild type; vt, variant typeMutational analysis of the amplicon 5 of MUTYH gene. (a) Schematic representation of MUTYH, showing that amplicon 5 contains three exons (10, 11, and 12) and the intronic boundaries. (b) The reference sequence of amplicon 5 obtained from Gene Bank (NG_008189.1) and the yellow highlighted sequences are for exons 10, 11, and 12. The PCR was run using the forward and reverse primers (sequences above and below the block arrows). The expected PCR product was 690 bp. The red box shows the position of c.1264G>C mutation. (c) 2% gel agarose gel electrophoresis for amplicon 5. The amplicon was successfully amplified, and 690 bp bands were visualized using ethidium bromide staining. The size was compared to 100 bp ladder (lane 1), and negative control (lane 2) was included. Lanes from 3-12 and 13-20 are representative patients and controls samples, respectively. (d) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing of amplicon 5 from normal control showing wild-type sequence (wt/wt). (e) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing from patients illustrating heterozygous, c.1264G>C, variant (wt/vt). (f) Partial chromatogram for forward primer sequencing from patient indicates homozygous c.1264 G>C mutation (vt/vt). (g) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequencing from normal control showing wild-type sequence (wt/wt). (h) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequencing from patient with heterozygous, c.1264 C>G, mutation (wt/vt). (i) Partial chromatogram for reverse primer sequence of amplicon 5 from patient with homozygous mutation, c.1264 C>G (vt/vt)Characteristics of germline mutations found in Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma (n = 150)*Bayes classifier score, which calculates the actual probability that certain alteration causes a disease. The range of result values is between 10 and 100. Therefore, the higher score, the more harmful alteration for human health. **This score indicates the probability that certain mutation is damaging. Hence, variants scores between 0.0 and 0.15 are benign, and variants with scores between 0.15 and 0.40 are possibly damaging. However, variants that score between 0.51 and 1.0 are probably damaging. ***Delta alignment score of PROVEAN: if the score is below or equal to the threshold (-2.5), the alteration is predicted to have deleterious effect. However, if the variant has a score above -2.5, the variant is predicted to be neutral.Exon 15 and its intronic boundaries (amplicon 7) were also amplified using the primers listed as 7 in the Table 1. PCR was successfully performed and resulted in amplification of 230-bp products. The products were purified and sequenced using 3130xL Genetic Analyzer (Applied Biosystem, USA). However, no mutation was found in this exon among the study subjects.Finally, exon 16 and its intronic boundaries (amplicon 8) were amplified using the listed primer 8 (Table 1). PCR successfully amplified 410-bp products. The products were purified and sequenced using 3130XL Genetic Analyzer. A reported variant, rs140118273, was successfully identified in Jordanians with colorectal adenoma. However, the variant was found to be neutral.
DISCUSSION
In this study, five variants were found in Jordanian patients with colorectal adenoma, of which three (c.381A>C, c.724G>C, and c.1760 C>T) has previously been reported, and two (g.87C>T and c.1264G>C [Q350H]) were novel. These findings are in contrast to Caucasian populations in which Y165C and G382D are the most common mutations associated with multiple polyposis syndrome[[18]]. The Y165C and G382D mutations have been shown to impair the MUTYH repair activity and significantly contribute to CRC development[[19]]. The missense R245C and the splice site IVS10-2A>G variants have been identified in Japanese and Korean patients[[15],[20]]. In another studies conducted in Korean and Japanese patients (n = 97), 7.2% were bi-allelic carriers for the germline mutations c.1-18G>T, A359V, and R170G in the MUTYH gene[[21],[22]]. After screening the entire gene, Vandrovcováv et al.[[23]] found no mutation in MUTYH in Singaporean population, though this may be a biased result due to the small sample size (n = 63). Furthermore, five unrelated Indians patients with colorectal adenoma were homozygous for the missense mutation E480X[23]. Other MUTYH variants have been found in Italian (A473D), Finnish (p.P391L), Swedish (p.G175E), and Portuguese (E383fsX45)1[[24]-[27]]. In a case-control study and meta-analysis, Win et al.[[26]] have indicated an association between MUTYH gene mutations and the increased CRC risk. Another meta-analysis demonstrated the risk of MUTYH in monallelic and biallelic carriers[28]. MUTYH gene loss has been linked to colorectal carcinogenesis due to immunosuppression and altered immune response[27]. Grasso et al.[[28]] have shown that MUTYH mediates the toxicity of DNA 6-thioguanine and UV radiation. MUTYH-OGG1XRCC1-PARP1-MMP1 is a linear interacting susceptibility locus for CRC[[29]].Association between c.1264G>C and colorectal adenoma malignant transformation. A strong association was found among the study subjects (p < 0.001). Of 90 subjects, who harbored the c.1264G>C germline mutation, 82 (91.2%) had progressed to colorectal cancer. In contrast, only 25 wild-type patients had progressed into CRC, comparable to 35 subjects who recovered after polypectomyThe association between c.1264G>C and CRC metastasis. A significant (p < 0.001) association was observed between c.1264G>C and CRC metastasis. Sixty four subjects included in this study with c.1264G>C germline mutation had CRC metastasis, comparable to 12 who had recovered after colectomy and chemotherapyIn Arabian descent populations, four studies have been performed; one in Tunisia that showed high prevalence of c.1227-1228dup[[30]], the second in Morocco that introduced three variants (c.494A>G, c.1145G>A, and c.1185_1186dup)[[31]], the third in Saudi Arabia that revealed the presence of V22M, Y165C, H324Q, and G382D variants[[32]], and the last in Egypt that found a significant association between G396D and Y179C mutations and colorectal carcinogenicity[[33]]. These results contradict with those obtained from a study involved 360 Arabic patients[[34]]. The best explanation for these discrepancies between data is that these studies only targeted either specific reported mutations, such as G396D and Y179C, or familial cases. However, in the present study, MUTYH gene was sequenced thoroughly for the patients with colorectal adenoma and the controls from the same ethnic group. It has recently been shown that MUTYH interacts with Rad9-Rad1-Hus1 complex (9-1-1 complex) to coordinate the cell cycle checkpoint. The interdomain connector (IDC) of MUTYH (residues between 65 and 350) is critical for 9-1-1 complex and MUTYH interaction[11]. The significance of the interaction between SpMyh1I DC and 9-1-1 has been elucidated by Luncsford et al.[11] who tested in vivo the biological effects of V315 and I261 mutations in the impairment of 9-1-1 complex-MUTYH interaction. Interestingly, they showed that MUTYH IDC is important for MUTYH DNA repair function and interaction with 9-1-1 complex. MUTYH IDC aspartate at the position number 350 interacts with histidine at the position number 18 of 9-1-1 complex[[35]]. Therefore, c.1264G>C missense variant found in Jordanian patients would probably affect MUTYH-9-1-1 complex interaction. This finding explains the strong association between c.1264 G>C and colorectal malignant transformation among mutant colorectal adenomapatients. However, this hypothesis requires further functional testing using cell-based cloning and cell culture manipulation.In conclusion, germline mutations in MUTYH gene are highly prevalent among patients with colorectal adenoma from Jordan. In particular, c.1264 G>C is the most common variant associated with malignant transformation of colorectal adenoma into carcinoma. This variant has a potential to be an early biomarker for diagnosis of CRC in Jordan.
Authors: Anna M Russell; Jian Zhang; Judith Luz; Pierre Hutter; Pierre O Chappuis; Claudine Rey Berthod; Philippe Maillet; Hansjakob Mueller; Karl Heinimann Journal: Int J Cancer Date: 2006-04-15 Impact factor: 7.396
Authors: Antony R Parker; Oliver M Sieber; Chanjuan Shi; Li Hua; Masashi Takao; Ian P Tomlinson; James R Eshleman Journal: Carcinogenesis Date: 2005-06-29 Impact factor: 4.944
Authors: Avrum Spira; Matthew B Yurgelun; Ludmil Alexandrov; Anjana Rao; Rafael Bejar; Kornelia Polyak; Marios Giannakis; Ali Shilatifard; Olivera J Finn; Madhav Dhodapkar; Neil E Kay; Esteban Braggio; Eduardo Vilar; Sarah A Mazzilli; Timothy R Rebbeck; Judy E Garber; Victor E Velculescu; Mary L Disis; Douglas C Wallace; Scott M Lippman Journal: Cancer Res Date: 2017-04-01 Impact factor: 13.312