Qian Feng1,2, Jiankun Xu3, Kunyu Zhang2, Hao Yao3, Nianye Zheng3, Lizhen Zheng3, Jiali Wang3, Kongchang Wei2,4, Xiufeng Xiao1, Ling Qin3, Liming Bian2,5,6,7,8. 1. Fujian Provincial Key Laboratory of Advanced Materials Oriented Chemical Engineering, College of Chemistry and Materials Science, Fujian Normal University, Fuzhou 350007, China. 2. Department of Biomedical Engineering, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, William M.W. Mong Building, Shatin, Hong Kong SAR, China. 3. Department of Orthopaedic and Traumatology and Innovative Orthopaedic Biomaterial and Drug Translational Research Laboratory of Li Ka Shing Institute of Health, Faculty of Medicine, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China. 4. Laboratory for Biomimetic Membranes and Textiles, Empa, Swiss Federal Laboratories for Materials Science and Technology, 9014 St., Gallen, Switzerland. 5. Translational Research Centre of Regenerative Medicine and 3D Printing Technologies of Guangzhou Medical University, The Third Affiliated Hospital of Guangzhou Medical University, Guangzhou, Guangdong 510150, China. 6. Shenzhen Research Institute, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Shenzhen 518172, China. 7. China Orthopedic Regenerative Medicine Group (CORMed), Hangzhou 310058, China. 8. Centre for Novel Biomaterials, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China.
Abstract
Biopolymeric hydrogels have been widely used as carriers of therapeutic cells and drugs for biomedical applications. However, most conventional hydrogels cannot be injected after gelation and do not support the infiltration of cells because of the static nature of their network structure. Here, we develop unique cell-infiltratable and injectable (Ci-I) gelatin hydrogels, which are physically cross-linked by weak and highly dynamic host-guest complexations and are further reinforced by limited chemical cross-linking for enhanced stability, and then demonstrate the outstanding properties of these Ci-I gelatin hydrogels. The highly dynamic network of Ci-I hydrogels allows injection of prefabricated hydrogels with encapsulated cells and drugs, thereby simplifying administration during surgery. Furthermore, the reversible nature of the weak host-guest cross-links enables infiltration and migration of external cells into Ci-I gelatin hydrogels, thereby promoting the participation of endogenous cells in the healing process. Our findings show that Ci-I hydrogels can mediate sustained delivery of small hydrophobic molecular drugs (e.g., icaritin) to boost differentiation of stem cells while avoiding the adverse effects (e.g., in treatment of bone necrosis) associated with high drug dosage. The injection of Ci-I hydrogels encapsulating mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and drug (icaritin) efficiently prevented the decrease in bone mineral density (BMD) and promoted in situ bone regeneration in an animal model of steroid-associated osteonecrosis (SAON) of the hip by creating the microenvironment favoring the osteogenic differentiation of MSCs, including the recruited endogenous cells. We believe that this is the first demonstration on applying injectable hydrogels as effective carriers of therapeutic cargo for treating dysfunctions in deep and enclosed anatomical sites via a minimally invasive procedure.
Biopolymeric hydrogels have been widely used as carriers of therapeutic cells and drugs for biomedical applications. However, most conventional hydrogels cannot be injected after gelation and do not support the infiltration of cells because of the static nature of their network structure. Here, we develop unique cell-infiltratable and injectable (Ci-I) gelatin hydrogels, which are physically cross-linked by weak and highly dynamic host-guest complexations and are further reinforced by limited chemical cross-linking for enhanced stability, and then demonstrate the outstanding properties of these Ci-I gelatin hydrogels. The highly dynamic network of Ci-I hydrogels allows injection of prefabricated hydrogels with encapsulated cells and drugs, thereby simplifying administration during surgery. Furthermore, the reversible nature of the weak host-guest cross-links enables infiltration and migration of external cells into Ci-I gelatin hydrogels, thereby promoting the participation of endogenous cells in the healing process. Our findings show that Ci-I hydrogels can mediate sustained delivery of small hydrophobic molecular drugs (e.g., icaritin) to boost differentiation of stem cells while avoiding the adverse effects (e.g., in treatment of bone necrosis) associated with high drug dosage. The injection of Ci-I hydrogels encapsulating mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and drug (icaritin) efficiently prevented the decrease in bone mineral density (BMD) and promoted in situ bone regeneration in an animal model of steroid-associated osteonecrosis (SAON) of the hip by creating the microenvironment favoring the osteogenic differentiation of MSCs, including the recruited endogenous cells. We believe that this is the first demonstration on applying injectable hydrogels as effective carriers of therapeutic cargo for treating dysfunctions in deep and enclosed anatomical sites via a minimally invasive procedure.
Various
natural and synthetic materials have been used as potential
carrier biomaterials of cell or therapeutic agents for tissue regeneration.[1−6] Hydrogels with highly hydrated polymeric networks are ideal carriers
for encapsulating cells and drugs.[7−12] However, most conventional hydrogels that allow cells encapsulation
are based on static chemical cross-linking and lack dynamic properties
such as self-healing and injectability.[13−15] These limitations preclude
the delivery of cargo agents by the hydrogel carriers to anatomically
deep and enclosed defects via minimally invasive procedures, which
have become increasingly popular because of demands for aesthetic
appearance and expeditious postsurgery recovery.[16] Furthermore, the rigid and nondegradable nature of chemically
cross-linked hydrogels hinders the recruitment and infiltration of
host cells into implanted hydrogels, thereby limiting the extent of in situ regeneration and integration of implanted biomaterials
into host tissues.[17,18]Many previous studies have
demonstrated the fabrication of dynamic
hydrogels stabilized by reversible physical cross-linking including
hydrogen bonds, hydrophobic interactions, ionic interactions, ligand–ion
coordination, dipole–dipole interactions, and host–guest
complexations.[19−37] These physically cross-linked hydrogels exhibit many desirable properties
including self-healing and injectability.[38−44] However, because of the weak nature of physical cross-linking and
the stringent demands of cell-friendly preparation, few studies have
reported physical hydrogels that are sufficiently cytocompatible and
stable to allow for encapsulation and long-term culture of cells and
to provide continued support to the encapsulated cells in
vivo after delivery.In this study, we develop unique
cell-infiltratable and injectable
(Ci-I) gelatin hydrogels, which are stabilized largely by the physical
cross-linking of host–guest complexation and are further reinforced
by limited chemical cross-linking (Scheme ), and then demonstrate the outstanding properties
of these Ci-I gelatin hydrogels. Our Ci-I gelatin hydrogels can be
preformed with encapsulated therapeutic cells and drugs first, maintained
under culture conditions for a desired period, and injected to target
sites in the gel form at a prescribed time because of their excellent
injectability and remoldability. Furthermore, the reversible physical
cross-links of the Ci-I hydrogels also support infiltration of cells
into the hydrogels that are loaded with chemoattractant drugs. These
unique capabilities of Ci-I hydrogels offer great convenience during
surgical procedures and significantly expedite clinical operations.
We further evaluated the efficacy of the Ci-I gelation hydrogels as
carriers of therapeutic drugs and cells for treating an enclosed bone
abnormality in steroid-associated osteonecrosis (SAON) of the femoral
head.
Scheme 1
Preparation of the Cell-Infiltratable and Injectable (Ci-I)
Gelatin
Hydrogels and the Treatment of SAON with Ci-I Hydrogels as the Carrier
of Therapeutic Cargoes (Cells and Drug) in the Rat Model
Steroids are widely used for
treating various clinical conditions,
such as rheumatoid arthritis, organ transplantation, and respiratory
syndrome.[45−49] However, long-term steroid treatments may lead to SAON, commonly
affecting large joints such as the hip.[50−52] A surgical core decompression
(CD) procedure is typically performed on patients with early stage
SAON to remove the necrotic bone and implant bone substitute in the
drilled tunnel to prevent subsequent decreases in bone mineral density
and support bone regeneration.[53,54] Since the lack of endogenous
stem cells and aberrant accumulation of adipose tissues were recognized
as main characteristics of SAON in previous studies,[55,56] here, we evaluated the feasibility of the Ci-I gelatin hydrogels
encapsulating mesenchymal stem cells (MSCs) and a hydrophobic small
molecule, icaritin, as a bone substitute to treat ratSAON (Scheme ). Our in
vivo animal research showed that the MSCs and icaritin-laden
Ci-I gelatin hydrogels can prevent a decrease in bone mineral density
(BMD) and promote in situ bone regeneration. Moreover,
the icaritin-laden hydrogels enhanced the recruitment and infiltration
of cells from the surrounding host tissues to the implantation sites,
further confirming the efficacy of our Ci-I hydrogels for promoting in situ regeneration. To the best of our knowledge, this
is the first study demonstrating the feasibility of using injectable
hydrogels encapsulating stem cells and small molecules to treat bone
disorders in deep and enclosed anatomical locations, e.g., SAON at
the hip.
Results and Discussion
Prefabricated Ci-I Hydrogels Adapt to Injection
Site Geometry
and Maintain Initial Mechanical Properties after Injection
Gelatin has been extensively used for various biomedical applications
because of its biocompatibility, bioactivity, biodegradability, and
availability.[57,58] Gelatin hydrogels are especially
useful as carrier materials of therapeutic cells and drugs.[59−61] However, the preparation of conventional chemically cross-linked
gelatin hydrogels entails chemical modifications of the gelatin, and
the obtained hydrogels are brittle with restricted network dynamics.[62−64] Therefore, in this study, we developed a strategy to prepare gelatin
hydrogels containing both chemical and physical cross-linking based
on unmodified gelatin. First, the synthesized free diffusing photo-cross-linkable
Ac-β-CDs (acryloyl β-cyclodextrin, 1.5 acryloyl groups
per Ac-β-CD molecule on average, i.e., a fraction of Ac-β-CDs
bear more than one acryloyl group, Figure S1) were coupled to the aromatic residues of gelatin (e.g., phenylalanine,
tyrosine, and tryptophan) via host–guest interactions. Subsequently,
UV-initiated polymerization of the Ac-β-CDs led to the formation
of gelatin hydrogels containing two types of cross-links: (1) the
physical host–guest complexations between the aromatic residues
of the gelatin and oligomerized Ac-β-CDs, which are distributed
throughout the entire hydrogel network; and (2) the chemical cross-links
(due to the fraction of Ac-β-CDs bearing more than one acryloyl
group) among the oligomerized Ac-β-CDs, the distribution of
which is sparse and localized because of the inefficient reaction
among the bulky Ac-β-CDs. The following experiments demonstrated
that these gelatin hydrogels not only possessed unique dynamic properties
including self-healing, shear-thinning, injectability, and cell infiltration
capability due to the physical host–guest cross-linking but
also showed adequate stability because of the localized chemical cross-linking
for supporting long-term 3D culture of encapsulated cells. These hydrogels
are therefore referred to as the “cell-infiltratable and injectable
gelatin hydrogels” (Ci-I gelatin hydrogels) in the following
sections.The rheological measurements further demonstrated
the presence of both physical and chemical cross-linking within the
Ci-I gelatin hydrogels. The Ci-I hydrogels showed an obvious frequency-dependent
increase in the modulus (Figure a), indicating the involvement of the physical host–guest
complexation between gelatinous aromatic groups and β-CDs in
stabilizing the hydrogel network. The further rheological studies
revealed a “sol–gel” transition of the Ci-I hydrogels
under alternating high/low shear strain (Scheme ). The Ci-I hydrogels switched to the “sol”
state (G″ > G′)
under
a high shear strain of ∼1000% and immediately recovered to
the “gel” state (G′ > G″) under a subsequent low shear strain of 1% (Figure b). Moreover, even
after repeated high/low shear loading cycles, the storage modulus
(G′) of the Ci-I hydrogels consistently recovered
to ∼80% (1050 Pa) of that of the freshly prepared unloaded
samples (1373 Pa) (Figure b). This slight reduction in storage modulus is likely attributed
to the partial disruption of chemical cross-linking under loading.
This excellent shear-thinning and self-healing capability enables
the injection of Ci-I hydrogels without significantly compromising
their mechanical properties. The prefabricated Ci-I hydrogel disks
injected through a G21 needle into cylindrical models were efficiently
remolded to regain the original disk morphology (Figure c). Moreover, the compression
test showed that the injection did not significantly affect the mechanical
properties of the Ci-I gelatin hydrogels, and the injected hydrogels
could still sustain over 95% compressive strain without rupture as
could the noninjected hydrogels (Figure d). Furthermore, after the first loading–unloading
cycle, the Ci-I hydrogels exhibited almost coinciding loading–unloading
stress versus strain curves obtained from the remaining loading cycles
(peak strain: 60%), suggesting excellent resistance to excessive cyclic
compression (Figure e). Previous studies[65−68] proved that well-designed injectable hydrogels could prevent encapsulated
cells from damage of shear force during the injection through the
syringe needle. To study whether our Ci-I gelatin hydrogels could
maintain the viability of the encapsulated cell during the injection,
we cultured hMSC-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels in vitro for 1 day before injecting the hydrogels through a G21 needle, and
the injected hydrogels were further cultured in vitro for another 5 days. Figure S3 shows that
the cell viability is still >90% even after injection, demonstrating
the effective protection of the encapsulated cells by the injectable
Ci-I gelatin hydrogels.
Figure 1
(a) Ci-I gelatin hydrogels displayed a frequency-dependent
response
in the rheological frequency sweep test at a strain of 0.1% and 37
°C. (b) Ci-I hydrogels exhibited a sol–gel transition
during switching between alternating high (1000%, unshaded region)
and low (1%, shaded region) shear strain in the rheological test at
37 °C. (c) A preformed Ci-I gelatin hydrogel was drawn into a
syringe and then injected through a G21 needle into a culture plate
well (used as the mold) to be remolded to the shape of the cell culture
well. (d) Ci-I gelatin hydrogels sustained over 95% of compressive
strain without rupture before or after injection. (e) Stress vs strain
curves from a cyclic compression test of Ci-I hydrogels (peak strain,
60%; loading speed, 1 mm/s) at 37 °C (inset: plot in the strain
range 50–60%).
(a) Ci-I gelatin hydrogels displayed a frequency-dependent
response
in the rheological frequency sweep test at a strain of 0.1% and 37
°C. (b) Ci-I hydrogels exhibited a sol–gel transition
during switching between alternating high (1000%, unshaded region)
and low (1%, shaded region) shear strain in the rheological test at
37 °C. (c) A preformed Ci-I gelatin hydrogel was drawn into a
syringe and then injected through a G21 needle into a culture plate
well (used as the mold) to be remolded to the shape of the cell culture
well. (d) Ci-I gelatin hydrogels sustained over 95% of compressive
strain without rupture before or after injection. (e) Stress vs strain
curves from a cyclic compression test of Ci-I hydrogels (peak strain,
60%; loading speed, 1 mm/s) at 37 °C (inset: plot in the strain
range 50–60%).
Ci-I Hydrogels Mediate Sustained Delivery of a Hydrophobic Chemoattractant
and Support Infiltration of Cells
Sustained delivery of small
hydrophobic molecules via hydrogels is typically challenging because
the hydrophilic nature and large mesh size of hydrogel networks make
loading and long-term release of small hydrophobic molecules rather
difficult. Because a significant excess of Ac-β-CDs (compared
with gelatinous aromatic residues) were used to fabricate Ci-I hydrogels,
there were a considerable number of unoccupied β-CD moieties
conjugated to the hydrogel network. β-CD is commonly used in
the pharmaceutical industry to improve the solubility of hydrophobic
drugs.[69−71] We utilized the empty β-CD cavities in Ci-I
hydrogels to deliver a small hydrophobic chemical molecule, icaritin,
which can reduce SAON incidence by inhibiting both thrombosis and
lipid deposition.[72] The icaritin-laden
Ci-I gelatin hydrogels were capable of releasing icaritin continuously
for up to 2 weeks (Figure a). Therefore, these findings demonstrate that the injectable
Ci-I gelation hydrogels can serve as a promising delivery vehicle
of small hydrophobic molecular drugs for treating pathological conditions
including SAON in a minimally invasive fashion.
Figure 2
(a) Kinetics of small-molecule
icaritin release from the Ci-I gelatin
hydrogels at 37 °C. The confocal micrographs show the 3D distribution
of DAPI-stained human mesenchymal stem cell (hMSC) nuclei within the
Ci-I hydrogels without (b) or with (c) icaritin encapsulation after
24 h of in vitro culture. (d) Schematic illustration
of a cell migration experiment at 37 °C. hMSCs seeded on the
surface of the icaritin-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels infiltrated into
the hydrogels within 24 h. (e) Invasion distance of DAPI-stained hMSC
nuclei clusters within the Ci-I gelatin hydrogels without icaritin
and Ci-I gelatin hydrogels with icaritin. The thickness of the Ci-I
hydrogels used for the cell migration test is 1 mm, and the scanning
depth of the Ci-I hydrogels is 500 μm in the cell migration
experiments. Scale bar: 100 μm (parts b and c).
(a) Kinetics of small-molecule
icaritin release from the Ci-I gelatin
hydrogels at 37 °C. The confocal micrographs show the 3D distribution
of DAPI-stained human mesenchymal stem cell (hMSC) nuclei within the
Ci-I hydrogels without (b) or with (c) icaritin encapsulation after
24 h of in vitro culture. (d) Schematic illustration
of a cell migration experiment at 37 °C. hMSCs seeded on the
surface of the icaritin-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels infiltrated into
the hydrogels within 24 h. (e) Invasion distance of DAPI-stained hMSC
nuclei clusters within the Ci-I gelatin hydrogels without icaritin
and Ci-I gelatin hydrogels with icaritin. The thickness of the Ci-I
hydrogels used for the cell migration test is 1 mm, and the scanning
depth of the Ci-I hydrogels is 500 μm in the cell migration
experiments. Scale bar: 100 μm (parts b and c).Our previous research also showed that an anabolic
and potent molecule
icaritin can function as a chemoattractant to induce the directed
migration of MSCs within a short time frame.[72] The dynamic and weak cross-links based on host–guest complexation
of our Ci-I gelatin hydrogel can potentially support cell infiltration
and migration. To demonstrate this, we seeded MSCs on the surface
of Ci-I hydrogels with or without the loaded icaritin. After 24 h
of culture, most MSCs still remained on top of the hydrogels without
icaritin (Figure b,e
and Movie S1), whereas nearly all MSCs
infiltrated and migrated into the hydrogels loaded with icaritin (Figure c–e and Movie S2). The degradation of the hydrogels by
cell-secreted catabolic enzymes might not be significant enough to
support such extensive cell infiltration within the short period of
24 h. We speculated that the cell infiltration was likely facilitated
by the disruption of the weak host–guest cross-links in Ci-I
hydrogels by cellular forces. Therefore, we speculate that, once implanted
into the defect sites, the icaritin-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels can
promote the recruitment and infiltration of endogenous cells into
the hydrogel matrix, thereby speeding up the repair and regeneration
of bone defects.
Ci-I Hydrogel Attenuates the Adverse Effect
of High-Dosage Corticosteroid
during Stem Cell Differentiation
We then evaluated the efficacy
of the Ci-I hydrogel as an injectable carrier of therapeutic cells
to treat SAON by examining the osteogenesis of MSCs encapsulated in
the Ci-I gelatin hydrogels in the presence of a high concentration
of corticosteroid. The majority of MSCs encapsulated in the Ci-I gelatin
hydrogels were viable and spread to adopt a stellate morphology after
2 weeks of culture (Figure a), indicating that the dynamic Ci-I hydrogel network provides
a permissive 3D environment to facilitate cell–matrix interactions.
Then, we evaluated the differentiation of MSCs encapsulated in hydrogels
under different culture conditions. Previous studies showed that dexamethasone
(Dex), a clinically used corticosteroid, improved the osteogenesis
of MSCs at low concentration but promoted the adipogenesis of MSCs
at high concentration.[73,74] Our RT-PCR data indeed showed
that a low media concentration of Dex (100 nM, “100Dex”)
promoted the expression of osteogenic markers (ALP and Runx2), whereas
a high media concentration (500 nM, “500Dex”) of Dex
up-regulated the expression of adipogenic markers of the MSCs encapsulated
in hydrogels (CEBPα and PPARγ) (Figure b). In contrast, media supplementation of
icaritin effectively suppressed the expression of adipogenic marker
genes and promoted that of osteogenic marker gene, alkaline phosphatase
(ALP), of the encapsulated MSCs under a high media concentration of
Dex (Figure b, “500Dex+icaritin
(M)”). The upregulation of another osteogenic marker gene Runx2
is insignificant. We speculated that it was because the Runx2 gene
expression data were collected at late time points, day 7 and 14,
while the Runx2 is typically upregulated in MSCs at early time points
upon osteogenic induction, and correlation between osteogenesis of
MSCs and Runx2 expression becomes less significant at late time points.[75] Furthermore, the Ci-I gelatin hydrogels that
were loaded with a bolus dose of icaritin (“500Dex+icaritin
(H)”) without icaritin supplementation produced similar expression
levels of the differentiation marker genes as those of “500Dex+icaritin
(M)”, which received fresh icaritin supplementation after each
media change (Figure b). Von Kossa staining (Figure c) and the Runx2, OCN, CEBPα, and PPARγ
immunohistochemical staining (Figure d) showed trends consistent with that of the RT-PCR.
These results demonstrate that the Ci-I gelatin hydrogels are likely
capable of mediating sustained delivery of small hydrophobic molecular
drugs (e.g., icaritin) to counteract the adverse effects (e.g., bone
necrosis) of high-concentration corticosteroids in the long term.
Figure 3
(a) Cell
viability staining (green corresponds to live cells, and
red corresponds to dead cells) of MSC-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels
after 1 week and 2 weeks of culture. (b) Gene expression of selected
osteogenic markers (alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and Runx2) and adipogenic
markers (CEBPα and PPARγ) of MSCs encapsulated in Ci-I
gelatin hydrogels after 7 and 14 days of culture. Each sample was
internally normalized to GAPDH, and every group was compared to the
expression levels of group 100Dex on day 7, the quantitative value
of which was set to unity. The data were analyzed with two-way ANOVA
with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 4, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01,
***P < 0.001, compared to the 500Dex group). (c)
Von Kossa staining; (d) immunohistochemical staining of Runx2, OCN, CEBPα, and PPARγ of the hMSCs loaded in Ci-I gelatin hydrogels
after 7 and 14 days of culture. 100Dex, 100 nM dexamethasone (Dex)
in media; 500Dex, 500 nM Dex in media; 500Dex+icaritin (M), 500 nM
Dex and 1 mM icaritin in media; 500Dex+icaritin (H), 500 nM Dex in
media and 1.3 mM icaritin in the hydrogel. The total amount of icaritin
in the 500Dex+icaritin (M) group is the same as that in the 500Dex+icaritin
(H) group. Scale bar: 100 μm (parts a, c, and d).
(a) Cell
viability staining (green corresponds to live cells, and
red corresponds to dead cells) of MSC-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels
after 1 week and 2 weeks of culture. (b) Gene expression of selected
osteogenic markers (alkaline phosphatase (ALP) and Runx2) and adipogenic
markers (CEBPα and PPARγ) of MSCs encapsulated in Ci-I
gelatin hydrogels after 7 and 14 days of culture. Each sample was
internally normalized to GAPDH, and every group was compared to the
expression levels of group 100Dex on day 7, the quantitative value
of which was set to unity. The data were analyzed with two-way ANOVA
with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 4, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01,
***P < 0.001, compared to the 500Dex group). (c)
Von Kossa staining; (d) immunohistochemical staining of Runx2, OCN, CEBPα, and PPARγ of the hMSCs loaded in Ci-I gelatin hydrogels
after 7 and 14 days of culture. 100Dex, 100 nM dexamethasone (Dex)
in media; 500Dex, 500 nM Dex in media; 500Dex+icaritin (M), 500 nM
Dex and 1 mM icaritin in media; 500Dex+icaritin (H), 500 nM Dex in
media and 1.3 mM icaritin in the hydrogel. The total amount of icaritin
in the 500Dex+icaritin (M) group is the same as that in the 500Dex+icaritin
(H) group. Scale bar: 100 μm (parts a, c, and d).
Codelivery of MSC and Icaritin via Ci-I Hydrogels
Enhances Bone
Regeneration in SAON Model
We further evaluated the efficacy
of Ci-I gelatin hydrogels encapsulated with MSCs and icaritin to boost
bone regeneration in a SAON model. Figure a showed that the injection of Ci-I gelatin
hydrogels helped to prevent a decrease in BMD around the tunnel compared
to the nontreated control group (no hydrogel implantation, “Blank”).
The “icaritin+MSC+Gel” group showed significantly enhanced
new bone formation in the tunnel (Figure a). Quantitative measurement of the micro-CT
images showed that the “icaritin+MSC+Gel” group exhibited
significant elevation in BV/TV, trabecular number, while trabecular
thickness and a reduction in trabecular separation, as compared to
the other groups, in both the peri-tunnel native bone (Figure b) and neobone tissue inside
the tunnel (Figure c). Using Goldener’s Trichrome staining, we also further confirmed
that the bone tunnel was filled with neobone in the “icaritin+MSC+Gel”
group (Figure d).
In contrast, only fibrous tissue was formed in the other groups without
supplementation of icaritin (Figure d).
Figure 4
(a) Micro-CT images and HE staining of the native bone
around the
tunnel and the new bone inside the tunnel after 3 and 6 weeks postinjection
of Ci-I hydrogels in SAON rats. Quantitative analysis of micro-CT
for the bone in the “peri-tunnel” (b) and “within
tunnel” (c) space. One-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc tests were used to analyze the data (n = 6, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01,
***P < 0.001). (d) Goldener’s Trichrome
staining of the bonelike tissue within the bone tunnel. Scale bar:
500 μm (micro-CT images in part a); 100 μm (HE staining
in part a and Goldener’s staining in part d).
(a) Micro-CT images and HE staining of the native bone
around the
tunnel and the new bone inside the tunnel after 3 and 6 weeks postinjection
of Ci-I hydrogels in SAONrats. Quantitative analysis of micro-CT
for the bone in the “peri-tunnel” (b) and “within
tunnel” (c) space. One-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc tests were used to analyze the data (n = 6, *P < 0.05, **P < 0.01,
***P < 0.001). (d) Goldener’s Trichrome
staining of the bonelike tissue within the bone tunnel. Scale bar:
500 μm (micro-CT images in part a); 100 μm (HE staining
in part a and Goldener’s staining in part d).We further examined the harvested samples to assess
the bone regeneration
within the drilled tunnel. Immunofluorescent staining against Ki67,
a marker widely used to identify proliferating cells, showed significantly
more Ki67 positive cells in the tunnel region injected with the Ci-I
gelatin hydrogels, which were loaded with both MSCs and icaritin (“icaritin+MSC+Gel”),
as compared to that of either hydrogel alone (“Gel”)
or hydrogel plus icaritin (“icaritin+Gel”) treatment
groups (Figure a).
Moreover, the “icaritin+MSC+Gel” group also exhibited
the most intense staining against key osteogenic markers, Runx2 and
Osterix (Figure b,c).
At week 3 after the hydrogel implantation, the expressions of active
β-catenin and OCN were upregulated in the “icaritin+MSC+Gel”
group (Figure d and Figure S6a) compared to those of the other groups,
and this may have contributed to the enhanced bone formation. In contrast,
PPARγ expression was dramatically decreased (Figure e and Figure S6b), indicating suppressed adipogenesis, and this is consistent
with our previous in vitro findings (Figure d). The icaritin-laden hydrogels
(“icaritin+MSC+Gel” and “icaritin+Gel”)
also exhibited significantly elevated expression of another proliferation
marker, proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), in addition to
Ki67 at week 6 (Figure a and Figure S4), regardless of MSC supplementation.
In addition, the “icaritin+MSC+Gel” group showed slightly
reduced expression of c-Src, a detrimental factor that has been identified
as a therapeutic target for osteonecrosis.[55] CSF-1R, a tyrosine-kinase transmembrane receptor,[76] was greatly reduced in the “icaritin+MSC+Gel”
and “icaritin+Gel” groups, indicating the potential
immunoregulative effect of icaritin, as reported by a previous study.[77] More importantly, this finding suggests that
icaritin and MSCs delivered by Ci-I hydrogels can potentially mitigate
the foreign body response to biomaterial implantations, thereby facilitating
further translational applications.[76] By
using calcein green (CG) and xylenol orange (XO) to dynamically assess
the bone formation rate, at week 3 and 6 postsurgery we found that
treatment with hydrogel alone (“Gel”) did not affect
bone formation within the bone tunnel (Figure f–i). Incorporation of icaritin in
the injected hydrogels (“icaritin+Gel”) significantly
increased the bone formation rate compared to either blank repair
or the “Gel” group (Figure f–i). The encapsulation of both exogenous
MSCs and icaritin in the hydrogels (“icaritin+MSC+Gel”)
further enhanced bone formation in the defect site (Figure f–i). These data demonstrate
that the Ci-I gelatin hydrogel is an excellent carrier of cells and
hydrophobic drugs for promoting in situ bone regeneration
and treating SAON.
Figure 5
(a) Quantitative analysis of cells positive for Ki67 (Figure S4 for corresponding images) and (b) cells
positive for both Osterix and Runx2 using immunofluorescent staining.
The data were analyzed with one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 4). (c) Immunofluorescent
staining at week 6 after SAON surgical treatment in SD rats (negative
control group in Figure S5). Representative
Western Blot images from three independent experiments for osteogenic
markers (osteocalcin and active β-catenin) (d), and adipogenic
markers (CEBPα and PPARγ), proliferative marker (PCNA),
inflammatory marker (tyrosine-kinase transmembrane receptor for CSF1),
and indicator for osteonecrosis (c-Src) (e) (n =
3 per condition; Lane 1, blank repair; Lane 2, Gel; Lane 3, icaritin+Gel;
Lane 4, icaritin+MSC+Gel). Injection of Ci-I gelatin hydrogels, which
were loaded with both MSCs and icaritin (“icaritin+MSC+Gel”),
activated β-catenin and osteocalcin signaling but inhibited
the inflammatory response and adipogenesis. The quantitative data
are shown in Figure S6. (f) Sequential
labeling of newly formed bone with calcein green (CG) and xylenol
orange (XO) in the methyl methacrylate-embedded icaritin+MSC+Gel sample
at week 3 postsurgery. OB, old bone; T, bone tunnel. (g) Representative
images of CG and XO staining (n = 4 images per group)
for calculating the bone formation rate. OB, old bone; T, bone tunnel.
The quantitative analyses of the bone formation rate at week 3 (h)
and week 6 (i) postsurgery were obtained by analyzing the images in
part g. The data were analyzed with one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 4). ***P < 0.001; scale bar, 100 μm (part c).
(a) Quantitative analysis of cells positive for Ki67 (Figure S4 for corresponding images) and (b) cells
positive for both Osterix and Runx2 using immunofluorescent staining.
The data were analyzed with one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 4). (c) Immunofluorescent
staining at week 6 after SAON surgical treatment in SD rats (negative
control group in Figure S5). Representative
Western Blot images from three independent experiments for osteogenic
markers (osteocalcin and active β-catenin) (d), and adipogenic
markers (CEBPα and PPARγ), proliferative marker (PCNA),
inflammatory marker (tyrosine-kinase transmembrane receptor for CSF1),
and indicator for osteonecrosis (c-Src) (e) (n =
3 per condition; Lane 1, blank repair; Lane 2, Gel; Lane 3, icaritin+Gel;
Lane 4, icaritin+MSC+Gel). Injection of Ci-I gelatin hydrogels, which
were loaded with both MSCs and icaritin (“icaritin+MSC+Gel”),
activated β-catenin and osteocalcin signaling but inhibited
the inflammatory response and adipogenesis. The quantitative data
are shown in Figure S6. (f) Sequential
labeling of newly formed bone with calcein green (CG) and xylenol
orange (XO) in the methyl methacrylate-embedded icaritin+MSC+Gel sample
at week 3 postsurgery. OB, old bone; T, bone tunnel. (g) Representative
images of CG and XO staining (n = 4 images per group)
for calculating the bone formation rate. OB, old bone; T, bone tunnel.
The quantitative analyses of the bone formation rate at week 3 (h)
and week 6 (i) postsurgery were obtained by analyzing the images in
part g. The data were analyzed with one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 4). ***P < 0.001; scale bar, 100 μm (part c).
Delivery of Icaritin by Ci-I Hydrogels Facilitates the Recruitment
of Endogenous Cells To Expedite the Healing of SAON in Vivo
Our in vitro data have demonstrated that
icaritin-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels can attract MSCs to infiltrate
and migrate into hydrogels (Figure b). To evaluate the cell recruitment in vivo, immediately after the core decompression surgery and treatment
with hydrogel injections in the created tunnel, we injected SPIO-labeled
MSCs (1 million cells in 100 μL of media) in the ipsilateral
tibia of the same limb. Six weeks postsurgery, the SPIO-labeled MSCs
were hardly found within and around the tunnels with no hydrogel implantation
(“Blank”) or with blank hydrogel implantation (“Gel”)
(Figure ). However,
significantly more SPIO-labeled MSCs were found within and around
the tunnels which were injected with hydrogels containing either icaritin
alone (“icaritin+Gel”) or both MSCs and icaritin (“icaritin+MSC+Gel”)
(Figure ). This is
consistent with our previous finding that icaritin can directly promote
the migration of MSCs by upregulating the expression of vascular cell
adhesion molecule-1 (VCAM-1).[54] These data
further demonstrated that the icaritin-laden Ci-I gelatin hydrogels
can recruit endogenous MSCs from the surrounding tissues to migrate
to the bone defects, thereby promoting new bone formation.
Figure 6
(a) Prussian
blue and nuclear fast red staining of the histological
sections of the femoral heads treated with MSCs and icaritin-laden
Ci-I hydrogels. SPIO positive cells are indicated by green arrows.
SPIO positive cells within the tunnel (b) and around the tunnel (c)
were counted. The data were analyzed with one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 6, ***P < 0.001).
(a) Prussian
blue and nuclear fast red staining of the histological
sections of the femoral heads treated with MSCs and icaritin-laden
Ci-I hydrogels. SPIO positive cells are indicated by green arrows.
SPIO positive cells within the tunnel (b) and around the tunnel (c)
were counted. The data were analyzed with one-way ANOVA with Tukey’s post hoc test (n = 6, ***P < 0.001).
Conclusions
Collectively,
we demonstrate a unique injectable hydrogel with
desirable properties including ease of preparation, unscathed mechanical
properties after injection, sustained delivery of small hydrophobic
molecular drugs, and injection with encapsulated cells. Furthermore,
the dynamic physical cross-links in this hydrogel enable the infiltration
and migration of cells from the surrounding environment to speed up
the in situ bone regeneration in a SAON animal model.
This injectable hydrogel can be easily customized to carry different
portfolios of therapeutic drugs and cells for treating a wide array
of clinical conditions via minimally invasive procedures in deep and
enclosed anatomical locations.
Authors: Christopher B Rodell; John W MacArthur; Shauna M Dorsey; Ryan J Wade; Leo L Wang; Y Joseph Woo; Jason A Burdick Journal: Adv Funct Mater Date: 2014-12-12 Impact factor: 18.808