| Literature DB >> 30717810 |
S Gwynne1,2, E Higgins3, A Poon King3, G Radhakrishna4, L Wills5, S Mukherjee6, Maria Hawkins6, G Jones5, J Staffurth5,7, T Crosby8.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The SCOPE trials (SCOPE 1, NeoSCOPE and SCOPE 2) have been the backbone of oesophageal RT trials in the UK. Many changes in oesophageal RT techniques have taken place in this time. The SCOPE trials have, in addition to adopting these new techniques, been influential in aiding centres with their implementation. We discuss the progress made through the SCOPE trials and include details of a questionnaire sent to participating centres. to establish the role that trial participation played in RT changes in their centre.Entities:
Keywords: Oesophagus; Quality assurance; Radiotherapy
Mesh:
Year: 2019 PMID: 30717810 PMCID: PMC6360789 DOI: 10.1186/s13014-019-1225-0
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Radiat Oncol ISSN: 1748-717X Impact factor: 3.481
RT developments in each of the three SCOPE trials
| RT development | Trial 1st introduced |
|---|---|
| Iv contrast for TVD | SCOPE 1 |
| Consensus protocol for target volume delineation | SCOPE 1 |
| 3d conformal planning /single phase plan | SCOPE 1 |
| EUS and PET for TVD | SCOPE 1 |
| Use of prospective dose volume constraints | SCOPE 1 |
| RTTQA programme | |
| Benchmark case for middle 1/3 only, retrospective review of selected on-trial cases | SCOPE 1 |
| Benchmark case for both middle 1/3 and lower 1/3 case, real time review of 1st on-trial case and all cases up until toxicity assessment, timely retrospective review of all remaining on-trial cases, outlining atlas, outlining workshop | NeoSCOPE |
| Elective nodal irradiation | NeoSCOPE |
| Stomach filling protocol | NeoSCOPE |
| Type B algorithms | NeoSCOPE |
| CBCT | NeoSCOPE |
| 4DCT | NeoSCOPE |
| IMRT/use of simultaneous integrated boost | SCOPE 2 |
Results of questionnaire
| Development | Use prior to respective trials | Use currently | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Consensus protocol for target volume delineation | Not specifically assessed in questionnaire | 100% | Prior to SCOPE 1 trial there was wide variation in practice across the UK [ |
| Use of prospective dose constraints | Not specifically assessed in questionnaire | 96% | In 88% of centres these are based on the corresponding SCOPE trial |
| 3d conformal planning | 29% | 100% | Now replaced by IMRT in SCOPE 2 |
| Stomach filling protocol | 12.5% | 50% | |
| CBCT | 66.7% | 87.5% | |
| 4D CT | 42% | 71% | |
| Use of type b algorithm | 79.9% | 83.3% | pre NeoSCOPEa |
| IMRT | 75% [ | 79% | [ |
aOnly 14/36 (39%) benchmark cases in SCOPE 1 used a type be algorithm [12]
4DCT acquisition options in the NeoSCOPE trial
| 4DCT method 1 | 4DCT method 2 | |
|---|---|---|
| Pre-delineation | From the 4DCT data sets, identify the extreme phases of motion (MaxIn and MaxEx). Also identify the phase that best represents the time-weighted average (Mid). | From the 4DCT data sets, identify the extreme phases of motion (MaxIn and MaxEx). |
| GTV | Contour as per the 3D protocol on each of the three phases as defined above, giving: | Contour as per the 3D protocol on the 3D contrast enhanced CT scan and label it GTV3D. Also contour the GTV in the extreme phases of the 4D scan, giving GTVMaxIn and GTVMaxEx. Combine these three to obtain a composite structure, label GTVmotion. Review GTVmotion on all 4DCT phases and manually increase the contour for any areas not covered. |
| CTVA | Contour as per the 3D protocol on each of the three phases, giving: | Contour as per the 3D protocol on the 3D contrast enhanced CT scan using GTVmotion as the starting point. Label CTVA3D. |
| CTVB | Contour as per the 3D protocol on each of the three phases, giving: | Create CTVB3D from CTVA3D as per the 3D protocol on the 3D contrast enhanced CT. Make two copies of CTVB3D, labelled CTVBMaxIn and CTVBMaxEx then proceed to manually increase these on their respective respiration phases for any areas not covered. |
| ITV | The ITV is defined as the composite CTVB volumes. Review the ITV on all 4DCT phases and manually increase the contour for any areas not covered. | The ITV is made by combining CTVBMaxIn and CTVBMaxEx. Check that this volume covers any unusual motion patterns noted in the respiratory phases above. |
| PTV | Apply the margin to the ITV | Apply the PTV margin to the ITV |
| Planning | The mid phase CT is used for planning the dose distribution | The 3D CT is used for planning the dose distribution |
Target volumes for SCOPE 2
| Structure name | Description | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| GTVp | Includes: | ||
| GTVn | Includes any involved nodes below GOJ or > 30 mm from primary tumour (GTVp). | ||
| GTVpn | Union of GTVp and GTVn, and the circumference of the intervening oesophagus/proximal stomach, to include only GTVn above the diaphragm. | ||
| CTVA | GTVpn extended along the axis of the oesophagus: | ||
| CTVn | GTVn + 5 mm isotropically | ||
| CTVB | CTVA + 10 mm circumferentially: | ||
| CTVC | CTVA+ 5 mm circumferential margin. | ||
| ITV | Composite of CTV volumes (from reference 3D, max end-inhale and max end-exhale scans), grown to account for any additional motion seen from all other 4DCT phases. | ||
| PTV_5000 | Proximal Tumours (4DCT not permitted) | CTVB + 10 mm sup, 10 mm inf, 5 mm circumferentially. | |
| Distal tumours | CTVB + 10 mm sup, 15 mm inf, 5 mm circumferentially. | ||
| Distal tumours | ITV + 5 mm isotropically. | ||
| PTV_6000 | Proximal and distal tumours (where 4DCT not used) | GTVp + 5 mm isotropically | |
| Distal tumours (4DCT used) | GTVp_Ref + 5 mm isotropically | ||
GTV gross tumour volume, CTV clinical target volume, ITV internal target volume, PTV planning target volume
Dose constraints in the SCOPE 2 trial
| Structure name | Constraint | Optimal | Mandatory |
|---|---|---|---|
| PTV_6000 | V95% (57Gy) | > 95% | ≥ 90% |
| Dmedian | 100% (60Gy) | The median should be between 98 and 102% of the prescription dose (i.e., 60Gy). | |
| PTV_5000 | V95% (47.5Gy) | > 95% | ≥ 90% |
| Dmedian | 100% (50Gy, standard dose arm only) | The median should be between 98 and 102% of the prescription dose (i.e., 50Gy, standard dose arm only). | |
| External | D1.8 cc | < 107% of highest prescribed dose | |
| SpinalCord_PRV | D0.1 cc | < 40Gy | < 42 Gy |
| Heart | Dmean | < 25Gy |
|
| V30Gy | < 45% |
| |
| Lungs | Dmean | < 17Gy | <19Gy |
| (Combined lungs) | V20Gy | < 20 | ≤25 |
| Stomach_excl_PTV_5000 | V50Gy | < 16 cc | < 25 cc |
| Liver | Dmean | ≤28Gy | ≤30Gy |
| V30Gy | V30Gy < 30% | - | |
| Kidney_L and Kidney_R | V20Gy | < 25% | ≤30% |