Jan Stutz1, Remo Eiholzer1, Christina M Spengler2. 1. Exercise Physiology Laboratory, Institute of Human Movement Sciences and Sport, ETH Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057, Zurich, Switzerland. 2. Exercise Physiology Laboratory, Institute of Human Movement Sciences and Sport, ETH Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, 8057, Zurich, Switzerland. christina.spengler@hest.ethz.ch.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Current recommendations advise against exercising in the evening because of potential adverse effects on sleep. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this systematic review was to investigate the extent to which evening exercise affects sleep and whether variables such as exercise intensity or duration modify the response. METHODS: A systematic search was performed in PubMed, Cochrane, EMBASE, PsycINFO, and CINAHL databases. Studies evaluating sleep after a single session of evening physical exercise compared to a no-exercise control in healthy adults were included. All analyses are based on random effect models. RESULTS: The search yielded 11,717 references, of which 23 were included. Compared to control, evening exercise significantly increased rapid eye movement latency (+ 7.7 min; p = 0.032) and slow-wave sleep (+ 1.3 percentage points [pp]; p = 0.041), while it decreased stage 1 sleep (- 0.9 pp; p = 0.001). Moderator analyses revealed that a higher temperature at bedtime was associated with lower sleep efficiency (SE) (b = - 11.6 pp; p = 0.020) and more wake after sleep onset (WASO; b = + 37.6 min; p = 0.0495). A higher level of physical stress (exercise intensity relative to baseline physical activity) was associated with lower SE (- 3.2 pp; p = 0.036) and more WASO (+ 21.9 min; p = 0.044). Compared to cycling, running was associated with less WASO (- 12.7 min; p = 0.037). All significant moderating effects disappeared after removal of one study. CONCLUSION: Overall, the studies reviewed here do not support the hypothesis that evening exercise negatively affects sleep, in fact rather the opposite. However, sleep-onset latency, total sleep time, and SE might be impaired after vigorous exercise ending ≤ 1 h before bedtime.
BACKGROUND: Current recommendations advise against exercising in the evening because of potential adverse effects on sleep. OBJECTIVES: The aim of this systematic review was to investigate the extent to which evening exercise affects sleep and whether variables such as exercise intensity or duration modify the response. METHODS: A systematic search was performed in PubMed, Cochrane, EMBASE, PsycINFO, and CINAHL databases. Studies evaluating sleep after a single session of evening physical exercise compared to a no-exercise control in healthy adults were included. All analyses are based on random effect models. RESULTS: The search yielded 11,717 references, of which 23 were included. Compared to control, evening exercise significantly increased rapid eye movement latency (+ 7.7 min; p = 0.032) and slow-wave sleep (+ 1.3 percentage points [pp]; p = 0.041), while it decreased stage 1 sleep (- 0.9 pp; p = 0.001). Moderator analyses revealed that a higher temperature at bedtime was associated with lower sleep efficiency (SE) (b = - 11.6 pp; p = 0.020) and more wake after sleep onset (WASO; b = + 37.6 min; p = 0.0495). A higher level of physical stress (exercise intensity relative to baseline physical activity) was associated with lower SE (- 3.2 pp; p = 0.036) and more WASO (+ 21.9 min; p = 0.044). Compared to cycling, running was associated with less WASO (- 12.7 min; p = 0.037). All significant moderating effects disappeared after removal of one study. CONCLUSION: Overall, the studies reviewed here do not support the hypothesis that evening exercise negatively affects sleep, in fact rather the opposite. However, sleep-onset latency, total sleep time, and SE might be impaired after vigorous exercise ending ≤ 1 h before bedtime.
Authors: Michael T Smith; Michael L Perlis; Amy Park; Michelle S Smith; JaeMi Pennington; Donna E Giles; Daniel J Buysse Journal: Am J Psychiatry Date: 2002-01 Impact factor: 18.112
Authors: Neal D Kohatsu; Rebecca Tsai; Terry Young; Rachel Vangilder; Leon F Burmeister; Ann M Stromquist; James A Merchant Journal: Arch Intern Med Date: 2006-09-18
Authors: Daniel J Gottlieb; Naresh M Punjabi; Ann B Newman; Helaine E Resnick; Susan Redline; Carol M Baldwin; F Javier Nieto Journal: Arch Intern Med Date: 2005-04-25
Authors: Indira Gurubhagavatula; Laura K Barger; Christopher M Barnes; Mathias Basner; Diane B Boivin; Drew Dawson; Christopher L Drake; Erin E Flynn-Evans; Vincent Mysliwiec; P Daniel Patterson; Kathryn J Reid; Charles Samuels; Nita Lewis Shattuck; Uzma Kazmi; Gerard Carandang; Jonathan L Heald; Hans P A Van Dongen Journal: J Clin Sleep Med Date: 2021-11-01 Impact factor: 4.062
Authors: Chiara E G Castiglione-Fontanellaz; Tammy T Timmers; Stefan Lerch; Christoph Hamann; Michael Kaess; Leila Tarokh Journal: BMC Public Health Date: 2022-07-12 Impact factor: 4.135
Authors: Jennifer M Blankenship; Rebecca C Rosenberg; Corey A Rynders; Edward L Melanson; Victoria A Catenacci; Seth A Creasy Journal: Int J Sports Med Date: 2021-05-25 Impact factor: 2.997
Authors: Christopher E Kline; Charles H Hillman; Bonny Bloodgood Sheppard; Bethany Tennant; David E Conroy; Richard F Macko; David X Marquez; Steven J Petruzzello; Kenneth E Powell; Kirk I Erickson Journal: Sleep Med Rev Date: 2021-04-09 Impact factor: 11.401
Authors: Dina C Janse van Rensburg; Audrey Jansen van Rensburg; Peter M Fowler; Amy M Bender; David Stevens; Kieran O Sullivan; Hugh H K Fullagar; Juan-Manuel Alonso; Michelle Biggins; Amanda Claassen-Smithers; Rob Collins; Michiko Dohi; Matthew W Driller; Ian C Dunican; Luke Gupta; Shona L Halson; Michele Lastella; Kathleen H Miles; Mathieu Nedelec; Tony Page; Greg Roach; Charli Sargent; Meeta Singh; Grace E Vincent; Jacopo A Vitale; Tanita Botha Journal: Sports Med Date: 2021-07-14 Impact factor: 11.928
Authors: Leah M Schumacher; J Graham Thomas; Hollie A Raynor; Ryan E Rhodes; Dale S Bond Journal: Exerc Sport Sci Rev Date: 2020-10 Impact factor: 6.642