| Literature DB >> 29910422 |
Anthony P Breitbach1, Scott Reeves2, Simon N Fletcher3.
Abstract
Organizations value teamwork and collaboration as they strive to build culture and attain their goals and objectives. Sports provide a useful and easily accessible means to study teamwork. Interprofessional collaborative practice (IPCP) has been identified as a means of improving patient and population health outcomes. Principles of teamwork in sports can inform health professionals and organizations regarding possible improvement strategies and barriers in the optimization of IPCP. Twenty-eight delegates from the 2017 All Together Better Health Conference in Oxford, UK participated in a World Café to discuss the how teamwork in sports can inform IPCP in healthcare and sports medicine. These discussions were captured, transcribed and coded using the domains developed by the Interprofessional Education Collaborative (IPEC) along with extrapersonal or interpersonal loci. Extrapersonal factors regarding structure of leadership, roles and organizational commitment can be positive factors to promote teamwork. However, interpersonal factors affecting communication, values and lack of commitment to collaboration can serve as barriers. Athletic trainers and other sports medicine professionals can serve as valuable members of interprofessional teams and teamwork is essential in the field of sports medicine.Entities:
Keywords: athletics, teamwork, interprofessional practice, world café
Year: 2017 PMID: 29910422 PMCID: PMC5968948 DOI: 10.3390/sports5030062
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Sports (Basel) ISSN: 2075-4663
Participant Demographics (n = 28).
| Country | Professional Role |
|---|---|
| Canada | Kinesiologist |
| Cyprus | Nurse |
| Denmark | Occupational Therapist |
| Denmark | Physiotherapist |
| Germany/Bavaria | Nurse |
| Indonesia | Medical Doctor |
| Norway | Pharmacist |
| Norway | Political Scientist/Social Worker |
| Norway | Health Promotion/M. Philosophy |
| Sweden | Nurse |
| The Netherlands | Education |
| United Kingdom/Ireland | Medicine/Physician |
| United Kingdom | Nurse |
| United Kingdom | Nurse |
| United Kingdom | Occupational Therapist |
| United Kingdom | Paramedic |
| United Kingdom | Physiotherapist |
| United Kingdom | Physiotherapist |
| United States | Administration |
| United States | Artist |
| United States | Coordinator/Artist |
| United States | Dentist |
| United States | Nurse |
| United States | Nurse |
| United States | Nurse |
| United States | Occupational Therapist |
| United States | Physician |
| United States | Social Worker |
Code Frequency/Question.
| Theme | Q1 ( | Q2 ( | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Interprofessional Communication | 2 | 4.44% | 3 | 6.25% |
| Roles/Responsibilities | 16 | 35.56% | 14 | 29.17% |
| Teams and Teamwork | 18 | 40.00% | 11 | 22.92% |
| Values/Ethics for Interprofessional Practice | 9 | 20.00% | 20 | 41.67% |
| Extrapersonal | 32 | 71.11% | 23 | 47.92% |
| Interpersonal | 13 | 28.89% | 25 | 52.08% |
Code Co-Occurrence.
| IPEC Domain | Locus | Total | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Extrapersonal | Interpersonal | |||||
| Interprofessional Communication | 1 | 20.00% | 4 | 80.00% | 5 | 5.38% |
| Roles/Responsibilities | 17 | 56.67% | 13 | 43.33% | 30 | 32.26% |
| Teams and Teamwork | 23 | 79.31% | 6 | 20.69% | 29 | 31.18% |
| Values/Ethics for IP Practice | 14 | 48.28% | 15 | 51.72% | 29 | 31.18% |
| Total | 55 | 59.14% | 38 | 40.86% | 93 | 100.00% |
Question 1: Themes and Excerpts.
| What Key Features of Collaboration, Which Are Emphasized in Sport, Can Be Applied to Health Care? | |
|---|---|
| Codes Applied | Excerpt |
| Interprofessional Communication, Extrapersonal | Important point is to have time, to have time for communication about the goal, what is the goal, and you need time for training, and you need time probably to go there and work as a team. |
| Interprofessional Communication, Interpersonal | I just thought communication build into it, certainly the power of the communication between each other would be really key for the healthcare professional. |
| Roles/Responsibilities, Extrapersonal | A leader, a leader or a team captain is another important thing that we see I think in both sports and healthcare, and situational leadership could be an important thing. Some teams have the same leader all the time, and other teams will have a leader emerge, depending on the situation. |
| Roles/Responsibilities, Interpersonal | I think clearly defined roles, and especially in teams where everyone’s got that role, everyone knows what they’re doing, and they know where they’re boundaries are, so how you can know which line to go to, which line you can go above. |
| Teams and Teamwork, Extrapersonal | I would also add that in sports they have a coach that’s external to the team, so if you have a disruption or a hierarchy of players, that the coach, who’s external, is the one that can level the playing field, and that can sort of monitor the interactions, and in healthcare most of the time the coach or the leader of the healthcare team is somebody who’s also a member of the team. |
| Teams and Teamwork, Interpersonal | A team is motivated to collaborate because it wants to win, and so a healthcare team is motivated to collaborate because it wants to win, but I think the value based question is what does winning mean (in healthcare)? |
| Values/Ethics for Interprofessional Practice, Extrapersonal | I think sport is more open to new techniques, technology, and also enhancements, whether they’re legal or not, to improve collaborations to make sure the unit works efficiently together. I think sometimes in healthcare we don’t embrace new ideas as quickly, and that’s something that sport certainly does do, and that’s partly because there’s a competitive edge. |
| Values/Ethics for Interprofessional Practice, Interpersonal | That’s true, and I also think for the collaboration part, because I work in sport somewhat, is the trust and support for each other, respect, all of those things, integrity are pretty much important to teams in a sport, so teamwork applies pretty much support to healthcare teams in my experience. |
Question 2: Themes and Excerpts.
| What Barriers Exist to The Inclusion of These Features in Health Care? | |
|---|---|
| Codes Applied | Excerpt |
| Interprofessional Communication, Interpersonal | I find in a sports team everyone plays the same sport they are more like they were the same profession, and in healthcare it’s different professionals that might speak different kind of languages, not understanding as well, and it’s more difficult to collaborate because they come from different places. |
| Roles/Responsibilities, Extrapersonal | Sports teams have this third party person, the coach, because he sits that player who’s out of control and it’s usually the coach who usually says you either get going or you sit down, and I’m going to put somebody else in. But if you’re got a healthcare team and someone’s acting out and you don’t have that third party person, and that person’s sort of the leader, then you have dysfunctionality. |
| Roles/Responsibilities, Interpersonal | It’s interesting how we would expect a football or basketball player and a tennis player coming together and forming a team. We do expect a doctor and nurse and pharmacist and physical therapist to come together. I think it’s different. I mean a football team is a team of footballers coming together, whereas interprofessional team is an entirely different entity in some ways, so that’s one of the, could be one of the barriers. |
| Teams and Teamwork, Extrapersonal | Sports teams have this distinct advantage of coming together and practicing over and over again to be a functional team, to the point that the players gradually understand what everybody’s role is and they have the chance to make mistakes in practice, correct those mistakes. They trust that it’s their passing the ball or hitting the ball or doing whatever the sport is, their teammate is going to be where they’re supposed to be, and that they just have the opportunity to learn to work really synergistically and in harmony with each other, which is really different than healthcare. So a barrier in healthcare is that these desperate people come together on a given day or a given shift or in a given hour and are expected to work together, and they may or may not know each other that well, and may or may not have each other’s back in that same way, and may or may not trust that all of this is going to happen. So I think all of those are really elements of what makes this hard to translate into healthcare provision, along with the complexity and the acuity and the speed of which, as healthcare providers you often have to respond to a situation. That just adds another layer of barrier. |
| Values/Ethics for Interprofessional Practice, Extrapersonal | You might have your neighborhood soccer team that doesn’t have enough kids and they kind of like get things together versus a professional football team, like so, I think that’s a parallel, like we have hospitals that just don’t have enough resources and then hospitals that probably have too many resources. |
| Values/Ethics for Interprofessional Practice, Interpersonal | With a team, I mean the goal, the mental model is I would think is you want to win, and you want to win as many games as you can, because the more games you win the more money you make probably, and the more notoriety you get. In healthcare I do think we’re kind of bound together with the patient having a good outcome, but I think sometimes we go and your own need to achieve gets in the way, because we really should have a common goal, which is the very best outcome possible for our patients, but I think there’s probably more clarity with the goal in the mental model for sports teams than there may be for our healthcare teams. |