Erik Vindbjerg1,2, Guido Makransky2, Erik Lykke Mortensen3, Jessica Carlsson1. 1. 1 Competence Centre for Transcultural Psychiatry, Mental Health Centre Ballerup, Copenhagen, Denmark. 2. 2 Department of Psychology, University of Southern Denmark, Odense, Denmark. 3. 3 Department of Public Health and Center for Healthy Aging, University of Copenhagen, Denmark.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) is considered the gold standard measure of depression. The factor structure of the HDRS is generally unstable, but 4 to 8 items appear to form a general depression factor. As transcultural studies of the HDRS have received little attention, and as most of the studies have taken a data-driven approach with a tendency to yield fragmented results, it is not clear if an HDRS general depression factor can also be found in non-Western populations. This is an important issue in deciding on the appropriateness of the scale as a gold standard in transcultural psychiatry. METHOD: A systematic review was carried out to compare previously reported factor structures of the HDRS in non-Western cultures. Overlapping clusters across studies were identified and subsequently tested with confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) of responses from an independent sample. RESULTS: Fourteen relevant studies were identified, 12 of which were obtained. A general depression factor was identified, consisting of the following symptoms: depressed mood, guilt, loss of interests, retardation, suicide, and psychological anxiety. The subsequent CFA analysis supported the fit of this model. CONCLUSIONS: This study indicates that a general depression cluster is manifest in responses to the HDRS across cultures. While psychometric properties of the full-length HDRS are still debated, the general depression cluster appears pertinent to the assessment of depression across cultures. We recommend that cross-cultural clinicians and researchers focus on the use of unidimensional depression scales, which are in agreement with this cluster.
OBJECTIVE: The Hamilton Depression Rating Scale (HDRS) is considered the gold standard measure of depression. The factor structure of the HDRS is generally unstable, but 4 to 8 items appear to form a general depression factor. As transcultural studies of the HDRS have received little attention, and as most of the studies have taken a data-driven approach with a tendency to yield fragmented results, it is not clear if an HDRS general depression factor can also be found in non-Western populations. This is an important issue in deciding on the appropriateness of the scale as a gold standard in transcultural psychiatry. METHOD: A systematic review was carried out to compare previously reported factor structures of the HDRS in non-Western cultures. Overlapping clusters across studies were identified and subsequently tested with confirmatory factor analysis (CFA) of responses from an independent sample. RESULTS: Fourteen relevant studies were identified, 12 of which were obtained. A general depression factor was identified, consisting of the following symptoms: depressed mood, guilt, loss of interests, retardation, suicide, and psychological anxiety. The subsequent CFA analysis supported the fit of this model. CONCLUSIONS: This study indicates that a general depression cluster is manifest in responses to the HDRS across cultures. While psychometric properties of the full-length HDRS are still debated, the general depression cluster appears pertinent to the assessment of depression across cultures. We recommend that cross-cultural clinicians and researchers focus on the use of unidimensional depression scales, which are in agreement with this cluster.
Entities:
Keywords:
Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; cross-cultural; depression; factor structure
Authors: T A Furukawa; D L Streiner; H Azuma; T Higuchi; K Kamijima; S Kanba; N Ozaki; A Aoba; M Murasaki; S Miura Journal: Acta Psychiatr Scand Date: 2005-10 Impact factor: 6.392
Authors: Marcelo Pio de Almeida Fleck; Márcia Lorena Fagundes Chaves; Marie France Poirier-Littré; Marie Chantal Bourdel; Henri Loo; Julien Daniel Guelfi Journal: J Nerv Ment Dis Date: 2004-02 Impact factor: 2.254
Authors: Valentina Bianchi; Leslie Rescorla; Eleonora Rosi; Silvia Grazioli; Maddalena Mauri; Alessandra Frigerio; Thomas M Achenbach; Masha Y Ivanova; Ladislav Csemy; Jeroen Decoster; Johnny R J Fontaine; Yasuko Funabiki; David M Ndetei; Kyung Ja Oh; Marina M da Rocha; Roma Šimulioniene; Elvisa Sokoli; Massimo Molteni; Maria Nobile Journal: Int J Clin Health Psychol Date: 2022-04-04
Authors: Arnaud Philippot; Vincent Dubois; Kate Lambrechts; Denis Grogna; Annie Robert; Ugo Jonckheer; Wagdan Chakib; Alexandre Beine; Yannick Bleyenheuft; Anne G De Volder Journal: Data Brief Date: 2022-04-12
Authors: Elisabeth Schramm; Christoph Breuninger; Rainer Wohlfarth; Moritz Elsaesser; Hannah Piosczyk; Thomas Fangmeier Journal: Front Psychiatry Date: 2022-07-14 Impact factor: 5.435