Literature DB >> 29628870

Intubation over a bougie: Nasal is not novel.

Ron O Abrons1, Randy W Loftus1.   

Abstract

Entities:  

Year:  2018        PMID: 29628870      PMCID: PMC5875248          DOI: 10.4103/sja.SJA_779_17

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Saudi J Anaesth


× No keyword cloud information.
Dear Sir, We are writing in regards to a case series in the October-December issue titled “Gum elastic bougie as a guide in nasotracheal intubation: A novel technique.” The authors described five cases in which difficult passage of a nasotracheal tube was overcome by the use of a nasally placed bougie as part of a Seldinger-based technique. Bhat Pai et al. correctly point out that the use of an airway bougie can facilitate nasotracheal intubation in a variety of difficult clinical scenarios. The suggestion that this is a novel technique, though, is of question. As early as 1997, Cossham described the routine use of bougies in nasotracheal intubation.[1] In 2006, Arora et al. presented a series of three pediatric cases in which a gum-elastic bougie was used to facilitate blind nasotracheal intubation in children.[2] Also in 2006, Morimoto et al. described the use of a curve-tipped suction catheter as a guide for nasotracheal intubation, showing a significant decrease in nasal bleeding with the technique.[3] In 2010, Arisaka et al. described the successful use of a similar technique in 16 patients who had failed nasotracheal intubation through conventional methods.[4] In 2008 and 2014, Inoue and Kitano, respectively, described the use of gum-elastic bougies as guides in cases of challenging nasotracheal intubation.[56] In 2013, Staar et al. studied the use of modified Magill forceps for glottic navigation of nasally placed bougies.[7] In 2015, Abrons et al. presented a case series in which pediatric bougies, guided by nasal trumpets, were utilized as guides for successful nasal intubation under challenging conditions.[8] In 2017, Abrons et al. prospectively studied this technique of nasotracheal intubation over a bougie passed through a nasopharyngeal airway in 257 patients, showing a significant decrease in both the incidence and severity of nasal trauma, with less need for Magill forceps, than with the conventional technique of blind nasal passage and external tube manipulation.[9] The above literature outlines the increasing knowledge of, and experience with, nasotracheal intubation over bougies. With this evidence-based foundation, the goal of achieving atraumatic nasal intubation inches closer. While the contribution of Bhat Pai et al. to the lexicon is appreciated, the above-cited works clearly show that the suggestion of novelty is questionable.

Financial support and sponsorship

Nil.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts of interest.
  9 in total

1.  Nasotracheal intubation under curve-tipped suction catheter guidance reduces epistaxis.

Authors:  Yoshinari Morimoto; Mitsutaka Sugimura; Yohsuke Hirose; Kunitaka Taki; Hitoshi Niwa
Journal:  Can J Anaesth       Date:  2006-03       Impact factor: 5.063

2.  Nasotracheal tube placement over a bougie.

Authors:  P S Cossham
Journal:  Anaesthesia       Date:  1997-02       Impact factor: 6.955

3.  Seldinger technique for nasal intubation: a case series.

Authors:  Ron O Abrons; Ryan A Vansickle; Jean-Pierre P Ouanes
Journal:  J Clin Anesth       Date:  2016-07-19       Impact factor: 9.452

4.  [Successful nasotracheal intubation with the Pentax-AWS Airwayscope and gum-elastic bougie in a patient with recurrent tongue cancer].

Authors:  Manabu Kitano; Nobuyasu Komasawa; Junko Nakahira; Shunsuke Fujiwara; Shinichi Tatsumi; Toshiaki Minami
Journal:  Masui       Date:  2014-04

5.  Nasotracheal intubation over a bougie vs. non-bougie intubation: a prospective randomised, controlled trial in older children and adults using videolaryngoscopy.

Authors:  R O Abrons; M B Zimmerman; Y M S El-Hattab
Journal:  Anaesthesia       Date:  2017-09-15       Impact factor: 6.955

6.  Application of gum elastic bougie to nasal intubation.

Authors:  Hirofumi Arisaka; Shigeki Sakuraba; Munetaka Furuya; Kazutoshi Higuchi; Hitoshi Yui; Shuya Kiyama; Kazu-Ichi Yoshida
Journal:  Anesth Prog       Date:  2010

7.  Nasotracheal intubation with three indirect laryngoscopes assisted by standard or modified Magill forceps.

Authors:  S Staar; I Biesler; D Müller; R Pförtner; C Mohr; H Groeben
Journal:  Anaesthesia       Date:  2013-03-11       Impact factor: 6.955

8.  Use of a gum elastic bougie to facilitate blind nasotracheal intubation in children: a series of three cases.

Authors:  M K Arora; K Karamchandani; A Trikha
Journal:  Anaesthesia       Date:  2006-03       Impact factor: 6.955

9.  [Successful nasal intubation using airway scope with gum elastic bougie in a case of difficult airway].

Authors:  Hisashi Inoue; Tomoyuki Saito; Keiichiro Kamishima; Takatoshi Okano; Yuichiro Kuno; Takero Arai; Yasuhisa Okuda
Journal:  Masui       Date:  2008-04
  9 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.