BACKGROUND: Many weight-loss interventions are delivered in groups but evidence on their effectiveness, and characteristics associated with effectiveness, is limited. We synthesised evidence on (1) design and delivery of group-based weight-loss interventions; (2) effectiveness; and (3) associations between intervention characteristics, change techniques, and effectiveness. METHODS: Five online databases were searched to May 2017 for randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of group-based diet and/or physical activity interventions for overweight/obese adults (BMI ≥ 25). Intervention characteristics were synthesised narratively. Mean differences (MD) in weight loss were calculated using a random-effects meta-analysis, and sub-group analyses were conducted to identify moderators of effectiveness. RESULTS: Forty-seven RCTs reporting 60 evaluations of group-based interventions were included. MD in weight loss between intervention and control groups was -3.49 [95% CI -4.15, -2.84], -3.44 [-4.23, -2.85], and -2.56 kg [-3.79, -1.33] at follow-ups closest to 6, 12, and 24 months, respectively. Explicitly targeting weight loss, men-only groups providing feedback and dietary goals were significantly associated with greater effectiveness (p < .05). CONCLUSIONS: Diet and physical activity interventions delivered in groups are effective in promoting clinically meaningful weight loss at 12 months. Intervention design and effectiveness vary considerably between studies, and evidence on what optimises the effectiveness of group-based weight-loss interventions remains limited.
BACKGROUND: Many weight-loss interventions are delivered in groups but evidence on their effectiveness, and characteristics associated with effectiveness, is limited. We synthesised evidence on (1) design and delivery of group-based weight-loss interventions; (2) effectiveness; and (3) associations between intervention characteristics, change techniques, and effectiveness. METHODS: Five online databases were searched to May 2017 for randomised controlled trials (RCTs) of group-based diet and/or physical activity interventions for overweight/obese adults (BMI ≥ 25). Intervention characteristics were synthesised narratively. Mean differences (MD) in weight loss were calculated using a random-effects meta-analysis, and sub-group analyses were conducted to identify moderators of effectiveness. RESULTS: Forty-seven RCTs reporting 60 evaluations of group-based interventions were included. MD in weight loss between intervention and control groups was -3.49 [95% CI -4.15, -2.84], -3.44 [-4.23, -2.85], and -2.56 kg [-3.79, -1.33] at follow-ups closest to 6, 12, and 24 months, respectively. Explicitly targeting weight loss, men-only groups providing feedback and dietary goals were significantly associated with greater effectiveness (p < .05). CONCLUSIONS: Diet and physical activity interventions delivered in groups are effective in promoting clinically meaningful weight loss at 12 months. Intervention design and effectiveness vary considerably between studies, and evidence on what optimises the effectiveness of group-based weight-loss interventions remains limited.
Authors: Christie A Befort; Jeffrey J VanWormer; Cyrus Desouza; Edward F Ellerbeck; Byron Gajewski; Kim S Kimminau; K Allen Greiner; Michael G Perri; Alexandra R Brown; Ram D Pathak; Terry T-K Huang; Leslie Eiland; Andjela Drincic Journal: JAMA Date: 2021-01-26 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Emma S George; Aymen El Masri; Dominika Kwasnicka; Alannah Romeo; Sarah Cavallin; Andrew Bennie; Gregory S Kolt; Justin M Guagliano Journal: Sports Med Date: 2022-06-16 Impact factor: 11.928
Authors: Qiaochu Xue; Xiang Li; Hao Ma; Zhou Tao; Yoriko Heianza; Jennifer C Rood; George A Bray; Frank M Sacks; Lu Qi Journal: Diabetes Obes Metab Date: 2022-02-15 Impact factor: 6.577
Authors: Madison Milne-Ives; Dawn Swancutt; Lorna Burns; Jonathan Pinkney; Mark Tarrant; Raff Calitri; Arunangsu Chatterjee; Edward Meinert Journal: JMIR Res Protoc Date: 2021-06-30
Authors: Emma R Lawlor; Nazrul Islam; Sarah Bates; Simon J Griffin; Andrew J Hill; Carly A Hughes; Stephen J Sharp; Amy L Ahern Journal: Obes Rev Date: 2020-03-17 Impact factor: 9.213
Authors: Julia Browne; Claudio Battaglini; L Fredrik Jarskog; Paschal Sheeran; Ana M Abrantes; Jessica McDermott; Tonya Elliott; Oscar Gonzalez; David L Penn Journal: Ment Health Phys Act Date: 2021-04-20