OBJECTIVE: Systematically identifying pretreatment characteristics that predict successful weight management is important to improve intervention efficacy and clinical practice. This study provides a comprehensive update of a 2005 review on pretreatment predictors of successful weight management. METHODS: Results of 37 recent original studies from peer-reviewed journals were merged with the results from the 2005 review. A critical appraisal of the 66 studies included was provided, and meta-analyses were performed when feasible. RESULTS: Fewer previous weight loss attempts were the most consistent pretreatment predictor of successful weight management, although with a small effect size. Importantly, several variables were identified as non-significant predictors of weight loss, showing trivial effects (e.g., eating self-efficacy). Many psychosocial factors remain too little studied to allow reliable conclusions regarding their predictive value. CONCLUSION: Previous dieting attempts were identified as the soundest predictor of successful weight management. Several factors, previously considered barriers to successful weight management and now identified as non-predictors, require more investigation given the limitations identified in this review. Importantly, due to a comparably thin empirical basis for many predictors, further research is essential to move the field forward. Implications of the current state of research and necessary steps to improve intervention efficacy and clinical practice are discussed.
OBJECTIVE: Systematically identifying pretreatment characteristics that predict successful weight management is important to improve intervention efficacy and clinical practice. This study provides a comprehensive update of a 2005 review on pretreatment predictors of successful weight management. METHODS: Results of 37 recent original studies from peer-reviewed journals were merged with the results from the 2005 review. A critical appraisal of the 66 studies included was provided, and meta-analyses were performed when feasible. RESULTS: Fewer previous weight loss attempts were the most consistent pretreatment predictor of successful weight management, although with a small effect size. Importantly, several variables were identified as non-significant predictors of weight loss, showing trivial effects (e.g., eating self-efficacy). Many psychosocial factors remain too little studied to allow reliable conclusions regarding their predictive value. CONCLUSION: Previous dieting attempts were identified as the soundest predictor of successful weight management. Several factors, previously considered barriers to successful weight management and now identified as non-predictors, require more investigation given the limitations identified in this review. Importantly, due to a comparably thin empirical basis for many predictors, further research is essential to move the field forward. Implications of the current state of research and necessary steps to improve intervention efficacy and clinical practice are discussed.
Authors: J Stubbs; S Whybrow; P Teixeira; J Blundell; C Lawton; J Westenhoefer; D Engel; R Shepherd; A McConnon; P Gilbert; M Raats Journal: Obes Rev Date: 2011-04-27 Impact factor: 9.213
Authors: Anna Keski-Rahkonen; Benjamin M Neale; Cynthia M Bulik; Kirsi H Pietiläinen; Richard J Rose; Jaakko Kaprio; Aila Rissanen Journal: Obes Res Date: 2005-04
Authors: Jonathan A C Sterne; Alex J Sutton; John P A Ioannidis; Norma Terrin; David R Jones; Joseph Lau; James Carpenter; Gerta Rücker; Roger M Harbord; Christopher H Schmid; Jennifer Tetzlaff; Jonathan J Deeks; Jaime Peters; Petra Macaskill; Guido Schwarzer; Sue Duval; Douglas G Altman; David Moher; Julian P T Higgins Journal: BMJ Date: 2011-07-22
Authors: Ellen S Mitchell; Qiuchen Yang; Heather Behr; Annabell Ho; Laura DeLuca; Christine N May; Andreas Michaelides Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2021-02-10 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Thomas J Altree; Delwyn J Bartlett; Nathaniel S Marshall; Camilla M Hoyos; Craig L Phillips; Callum Birks; Aran Kanagaratnam; Anna Mullins; Yasmina Serinel; Keith K H Wong; Brendon J Yee; Ronald R Grunstein; Elizabeth A Cayanan Journal: Sleep Breath Date: 2021-08-06 Impact factor: 2.816