Yihuan Lu1, Kathryn Fontaine2, Tim Mulnix2, John A Onofrey2, Silin Ren3, Vladimir Panin4, Judson Jones4, Michael E Casey4, Robert Barnett5, Peter Kench5, Roger Fulton5, Richard E Carson2,3, Chi Liu2,3. 1. Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut yihuan.lu@yale.edu. 2. Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut. 3. Department of Biomedical Engineering, Yale University, New Haven, Connecticut. 4. Siemens Medical Solutions, Knoxville, Tennessee; and. 5. Discipline of Medical Radiation Sciences, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Sydney, Sydney, Australia.
Abstract
Respiratory motion degrades the detection and quantification capabilities of PET/CT imaging. Moreover, mismatch between a fast helical CT image and a time-averaged PET image due to respiratory motion results in additional attenuation correction artifacts and inaccurate localization. Current motion compensation approaches typically have 3 limitations: the mismatch among respiration-gated PET images and the CT attenuation correction (CTAC) map can introduce artifacts in the gated PET reconstructions that can subsequently affect the accuracy of the motion estimation; sinogram-based correction approaches do not correct for intragate motion due to intracycle and intercycle breathing variations; and the mismatch between the PET motion compensation reference gate and the CT image can cause an additional CT-mismatch artifact. In this study, we established a motion correction framework to address these limitations. Methods: In the proposed framework, the combined emission-transmission reconstruction algorithm was used for phase-matched gated PET reconstructions to facilitate the motion model building. An event-by-event nonrigid respiratory motion compensation method with correlations between internal organ motion and external respiratory signals was used to correct both intracycle and intercycle breathing variations. The PET reference gate was automatically determined by a newly proposed CT-matching algorithm. We applied the new framework to 13 human datasets with 3 different radiotracers and 323 lesions and compared its performance with CTAC and non-attenuation correction (NAC) approaches. Validation using 4-dimensional CT was performed for one lung cancer dataset. Results: For the 10 18F-FDG studies, the proposed method outperformed (P < 0.006) both the CTAC and the NAC methods in terms of region-of-interest-based SUVmean, SUVmax, and SUV ratio improvements over no motion correction (SUVmean: 19.9% vs. 14.0% vs. 13.2%; SUVmax: 15.5% vs. 10.8% vs. 10.6%; SUV ratio: 24.1% vs. 17.6% vs. 16.2%, for the proposed, CTAC, and NAC methods, respectively). The proposed method increased SUV ratios over no motion correction for 94.4% of lesions, compared with 84.8% and 86.4% using the CTAC and NAC methods, respectively. For the 2 18F-fluoropropyl-(+)-dihydrotetrabenazine studies, the proposed method reduced the CT-mismatch artifacts in the lower lung where the CTAC approach failed and maintained the quantification accuracy of bone marrow where the NAC approach failed. For the 18F-FMISO study, the proposed method outperformed both the CTAC and the NAC methods in terms of motion estimation accuracy at 2 lung lesion locations. Conclusion: The proposed PET/CT respiratory event-by-event motion-correction framework with motion information derived from matched attenuation-corrected PET data provides image quality superior to that of the CTAC and NAC methods for multiple tracers.
Respiratory motion degrades the detection and quantification capabilities of PET/CT imaging. Moreover, mismatch between a fast helical CT image and a time-averaged PET image due to respiratory motion results in additional attenuation correction artifacts and inaccurate localization. Current motion compensation approaches typically have 3 limitations: the mismatch among respiration-gated PET images and the CT attenuation correction (CTAC) map can introduce artifacts in the gated PET reconstructions that can subsequently affect the accuracy of the motion estimation; sinogram-based correction approaches do not correct for intragate motion due to intracycle and intercycle breathing variations; and the mismatch between the PET motion compensation reference gate and the CT image can cause an additional CT-mismatch artifact. In this study, we established a motion correction framework to address these limitations. Methods: In the proposed framework, the combined emission-transmission reconstruction algorithm was used for phase-matched gated PET reconstructions to facilitate the motion model building. An event-by-event nonrigid respiratory motion compensation method with correlations between internal organ motion and external respiratory signals was used to correct both intracycle and intercycle breathing variations. The PET reference gate was automatically determined by a newly proposed CT-matching algorithm. We applied the new framework to 13 human datasets with 3 different radiotracers and 323 lesions and compared its performance with CTAC and non-attenuation correction (NAC) approaches. Validation using 4-dimensional CT was performed for one lung cancer dataset. Results: For the 10 18F-FDG studies, the proposed method outperformed (P < 0.006) both the CTAC and the NAC methods in terms of region-of-interest-based SUVmean, SUVmax, and SUV ratio improvements over no motion correction (SUVmean: 19.9% vs. 14.0% vs. 13.2%; SUVmax: 15.5% vs. 10.8% vs. 10.6%; SUV ratio: 24.1% vs. 17.6% vs. 16.2%, for the proposed, CTAC, and NAC methods, respectively). The proposed method increased SUV ratios over no motion correction for 94.4% of lesions, compared with 84.8% and 86.4% using the CTAC and NAC methods, respectively. For the 2 18F-fluoropropyl-(+)-dihydrotetrabenazine studies, the proposed method reduced the CT-mismatch artifacts in the lower lung where the CTAC approach failed and maintained the quantification accuracy of bone marrow where the NAC approach failed. For the 18F-FMISO study, the proposed method outperformed both the CTAC and the NAC methods in terms of motion estimation accuracy at 2 lung lesion locations. Conclusion: The proposed PET/CT respiratory event-by-event motion-correction framework with motion information derived from matched attenuation-corrected PET data provides image quality superior to that of the CTAC and NAC methods for multiple tracers.
Authors: Gerhard W Goerres; Cyrill Burger; Ehab Kamel; Burkhardt Seifert; Achim H Kaim; Alfred Buck; Tobias C Buehler; Gustav K Von Schulthess Journal: Radiology Date: 2003-03 Impact factor: 11.105
Authors: Medhat M Osman; Christian Cohade; Yuji Nakamoto; Laura T Marshall; Jeff P Leal; Richard L Wahl Journal: J Nucl Med Date: 2003-02 Impact factor: 10.057
Authors: Ahmadreza Rezaei; Michel Defrise; Girish Bal; Christian Michel; Maurizio Conti; Charles Watson; Johan Nuyts Journal: IEEE Trans Med Imaging Date: 2012-08-09 Impact factor: 10.048
Authors: Marc D Normandin; Kitt F Petersen; Yu-Shin Ding; Shu-Fei Lin; Sarita Naik; Krista Fowles; Daniel M Skovronsky; Kevan C Herold; Timothy J McCarthy; Roberto A Calle; Richard E Carson; Judith L Treadway; Gary W Cline Journal: J Nucl Med Date: 2012-05-09 Impact factor: 10.057
Authors: F Lamare; M J Ledesma Carbayo; T Cresson; G Kontaxakis; A Santos; C Cheze Le Rest; A J Reader; D Visvikis Journal: Phys Med Biol Date: 2007-08-09 Impact factor: 3.609
Authors: Luyao Shi; Yihuan Lu; Jing Wu; Jean-Dominique Gallezot; Nabil Boutagy; Stephanie Thorn; Albert J Sinusas; Richard E Carson; Chi Liu Journal: IEEE Trans Med Imaging Date: 2019-06-10 Impact factor: 10.048
Authors: Takuya Toyonaga; Dan Shao; Luyao Shi; Jiazhen Zhang; Enette Mae Revilla; David Menard; Joseph Ankrah; Kenji Hirata; Ming-Kai Chen; John A Onofrey; Yihuan Lu Journal: Eur J Nucl Med Mol Imaging Date: 2022-03-12 Impact factor: 10.057
Authors: Luyao Shi; Yihuan Lu; Nicha Dvornek; Christopher A Weyman; Edward J Miller; Albert J Sinusas; Chi Liu Journal: IEEE Trans Med Imaging Date: 2021-11-30 Impact factor: 10.048