John M Thomas1, Terri R Fried2. 1. Department of Internal Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA; Center of Excellence in Primary Care Education, Veterans Affairs Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven, Connecticut, USA. 2. Section of Geriatrics, Department of Internal Medicine, Yale School of Medicine, New Haven, Connecticut, USA; Clinical Epidemiology Research Center, Veterans Affairs Connecticut Healthcare System, West Haven, Connecticut, USA. Electronic address: terri.fried@yale.edu.
Abstract
CONTEXT: Studies examining the attitudes of clinicians toward prognostication for older adults have focused on life expectancy prediction. Little is known about whether clinicians approach prognostication in other ways. OBJECTIVES: To describe how clinicians approach prognostication for older adults, defined broadly as making projections about patients' future health. METHODS: In five focus groups, 30 primary care clinicians from community-based, academic-affiliated, and Veterans Affairs primary care practices were given open-ended questions about how they make projections about their patients' future health and how this informs the approach to care. Content analysis was used to organize responses into themes. RESULTS: Clinicians spoke about future health in terms of a variety of health outcomes in addition to life expectancy, including independence in activities and decision making, quality of life, avoiding hospitalization, and symptom burden. They described approaches in predicting these health outcomes, including making observations about the overall trajectory of patients to predict health outcomes and recognizing increased risk for adverse health outcomes. Clinicians expressed reservations about using estimates of mortality risk and life expectancy to think about and communicate patients' future health. They discussed ways in which future research might help them in thinking about and discussing patients' future health to guide care decisions, including identifying when and whether interventions might impact future health. CONCLUSION: The perspectives of primary care clinicians in this study confirm that prognostic considerations can go beyond precise estimates of mortality risk and life expectancy to include a number of outcomes and approaches to predicting those outcomes. Published by Elsevier Inc.
CONTEXT: Studies examining the attitudes of clinicians toward prognostication for older adults have focused on life expectancy prediction. Little is known about whether clinicians approach prognostication in other ways. OBJECTIVES: To describe how clinicians approach prognostication for older adults, defined broadly as making projections about patients' future health. METHODS: In five focus groups, 30 primary care clinicians from community-based, academic-affiliated, and Veterans Affairs primary care practices were given open-ended questions about how they make projections about their patients' future health and how this informs the approach to care. Content analysis was used to organize responses into themes. RESULTS: Clinicians spoke about future health in terms of a variety of health outcomes in addition to life expectancy, including independence in activities and decision making, quality of life, avoiding hospitalization, and symptom burden. They described approaches in predicting these health outcomes, including making observations about the overall trajectory of patients to predict health outcomes and recognizing increased risk for adverse health outcomes. Clinicians expressed reservations about using estimates of mortality risk and life expectancy to think about and communicate patients' future health. They discussed ways in which future research might help them in thinking about and discussing patients' future health to guide care decisions, including identifying when and whether interventions might impact future health. CONCLUSION: The perspectives of primary care clinicians in this study confirm that prognostic considerations can go beyond precise estimates of mortality risk and life expectancy to include a number of outcomes and approaches to predicting those outcomes. Published by Elsevier Inc.
Entities:
Keywords:
Prognosis; elderly; focus groups; health outcomes; primary care; qualitative research
Authors: Cyrus Ahalt; Louise C Walter; Lindsey Yourman; Catherine Eng; Eliseo J Pérez-Stable; Alexander K Smith Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2011-11-30 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Shivani K Jindal; Maria Karamourtopoulos; Alicia R Jacobson; Adlin Pinheiro; Alexander K Smith; Mary Beth Hamel; Mara A Schonberg Journal: J Am Geriatr Soc Date: 2022-02-28 Impact factor: 7.538