N Guibert1, Y Hu2, N Feeney3, Y Kuang3, V Plagnol4, G Jones4, K Howarth4, J F Beeler4, C P Paweletz3, G R Oxnard5. 1. Translational Research Laborator, Belfer Center for Applied Cancer Science, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, USA; Lowe Center for Thoracic Oncology, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, USA. 2. Lowe Center for Thoracic Oncology, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, USA. 3. Translational Research Laborator, Belfer Center for Applied Cancer Science, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, USA. 4. Inivata Ltd, Morrisville, USA. 5. Lowe Center for Thoracic Oncology, Dana-Farber Cancer Institute, Boston, USA; Harvard Medical School, Boston, USA. Electronic address: geoffrey_oxnard@dfci.harvard.edu.
Abstract
Background: Genomic analysis of plasma cell-free DNA is transforming lung cancer care; however, available assays are limited by cost, turnaround time, and imperfect accuracy. Here, we study amplicon-based plasma next-generation sequencing (NGS), rather than hybrid-capture-based plasma NGS, hypothesizing this would allow sensitive detection and monitoring of driver and resistance mutations in advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Patients and methods: Plasma samples from patients with NSCLC and a known targetable genotype (EGFR, ALK/ROS1, and other rare genotypes) were collected while on therapy and analyzed blinded to tumor genotype. Plasma NGS was carried out using enhanced tagged amplicon sequencing of hotspots and coding regions from 36 genes, as well as intronic coverage for detection of ALK/ROS1 fusions. Diagnostic accuracy was compared with plasma droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) and tumor genotype. Results: A total of 168 specimens from 46 patients were studied. Matched plasma NGS and ddPCR across 120 variants from 80 samples revealed high concordance of allelic fraction (R2 = 0.95). Pretreatment, sensitivity of plasma NGS for the detection of EGFR driver mutations was 100% (30/30), compared with 87% for ddPCR (26/30). A full spectrum of rare driver oncogenic mutations could be detected including sensitive detection of ALK/ROS1 fusions (8/9 detected, 89%). Studying 25 patients positive for EGFR T790M that developed resistance to osimertinib, 15 resistance mechanisms could be detected including tertiary EGFR mutations (C797S, Q791P) and mutations or amplifications of non-EGFR genes, some of which could be detected pretreatment or months before progression. Conclusions: This blinded analysis demonstrates the ability of amplicon-based plasma NGS to detect a full range of targetable genotypes in NSCLC, including fusion genes, with high accuracy. The ability of plasma NGS to detect a range of preexisting and acquired resistance mechanisms highlights its potential value as an alternative to single mutation digital PCR-based plasma assays for personalizing treatment of TKI resistance in lung cancer.
Background: Genomic analysis of plasma cell-free DNA is transforming lung cancer care; however, available assays are limited by cost, turnaround time, and imperfect accuracy. Here, we study amplicon-based plasma next-generation sequencing (NGS), rather than hybrid-capture-based plasma NGS, hypothesizing this would allow sensitive detection and monitoring of driver and resistance mutations in advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Patients and methods: Plasma samples from patients with NSCLC and a known targetable genotype (EGFR, ALK/ROS1, and other rare genotypes) were collected while on therapy and analyzed blinded to tumor genotype. Plasma NGS was carried out using enhanced tagged amplicon sequencing of hotspots and coding regions from 36 genes, as well as intronic coverage for detection of ALK/ROS1 fusions. Diagnostic accuracy was compared with plasma droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) and tumor genotype. Results: A total of 168 specimens from 46 patients were studied. Matched plasma NGS and ddPCR across 120 variants from 80 samples revealed high concordance of allelic fraction (R2 = 0.95). Pretreatment, sensitivity of plasma NGS for the detection of EGFR driver mutations was 100% (30/30), compared with 87% for ddPCR (26/30). A full spectrum of rare driver oncogenic mutations could be detected including sensitive detection of ALK/ROS1 fusions (8/9 detected, 89%). Studying 25 patients positive for EGFRT790M that developed resistance to osimertinib, 15 resistance mechanisms could be detected including tertiary EGFR mutations (C797S, Q791P) and mutations or amplifications of non-EGFR genes, some of which could be detected pretreatment or months before progression. Conclusions: This blinded analysis demonstrates the ability of amplicon-based plasma NGS to detect a full range of targetable genotypes in NSCLC, including fusion genes, with high accuracy. The ability of plasma NGS to detect a range of preexisting and acquired resistance mechanisms highlights its potential value as an alternative to single mutation digital PCR-based plasma assays for personalizing treatment of TKI resistance in lung cancer.
Authors: Adrian G Sacher; Cloud Paweletz; Suzanne E Dahlberg; Ryan S Alden; Allison O'Connell; Nora Feeney; Stacy L Mach; Pasi A Jänne; Geoffrey R Oxnard Journal: JAMA Oncol Date: 2016-08-01 Impact factor: 31.777
Authors: Maria C Schwaederlé; Sandip P Patel; Hatim Husain; Megumi Ikeda; Richard B Lanman; Kimberly C Banks; AmirAli Talasaz; Lyudmila Bazhenova; Razelle Kurzrock Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2017-05-24 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Lynette M Sholl; Khanh Do; Priyanka Shivdasani; Ethan Cerami; Adrian M Dubuc; Frank C Kuo; Elizabeth P Garcia; Yonghui Jia; Phani Davineni; Ryan P Abo; Trevor J Pugh; Paul van Hummelen; Aaron R Thorner; Matthew Ducar; Alice H Berger; Mizuki Nishino; Katherine A Janeway; Alanna Church; Marian Harris; Lauren L Ritterhouse; Joshua D Campbell; Vanesa Rojas-Rudilla; Azra H Ligon; Shakti Ramkissoon; James M Cleary; Ursula Matulonis; Geoffrey R Oxnard; Richard Chao; Vanessa Tassell; James Christensen; William C Hahn; Philip W Kantoff; David J Kwiatkowski; Bruce E Johnson; Matthew Meyerson; Levi A Garraway; Geoffrey I Shapiro; Barrett J Rollins; Neal I Lindeman; Laura E MacConaill Journal: JCI Insight Date: 2016-11-17
Authors: Sarah-Jane Dawson; Dana W Y Tsui; Muhammed Murtaza; Heather Biggs; Oscar M Rueda; Suet-Feung Chin; Mark J Dunning; Davina Gale; Tim Forshew; Betania Mahler-Araujo; Sabrina Rajan; Sean Humphray; Jennifer Becq; David Halsall; Matthew Wallis; David Bentley; Carlos Caldas; Nitzan Rosenfeld Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2013-03-13 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Helena A Yu; Maria E Arcila; Natasha Rekhtman; Camelia S Sima; Maureen F Zakowski; William Pao; Mark G Kris; Vincent A Miller; Marc Ladanyi; Gregory J Riely Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2013-03-07 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Cloud P Paweletz; Adrian G Sacher; Chris K Raymond; Ryan S Alden; Allison O'Connell; Stacy L Mach; Yanan Kuang; Leena Gandhi; Paul Kirschmeier; Jessie M English; Lee P Lim; Pasi A Jänne; Geoffrey R Oxnard Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2015-10-12 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Bing M Zhang; Alexin Aleshin; Chieh Y Lin; James Ford; James L Zehnder; Carlos J Suarez Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2017-05-18 Impact factor: 176.079
Authors: Jeffrey C Thompson; Stephanie S Yee; Andrea B Troxel; Samantha L Savitch; Ryan Fan; David Balli; David B Lieberman; Jennifer D Morrissette; Tracey L Evans; Joshua Bauml; Charu Aggarwal; John A Kosteva; Evan Alley; Christine Ciunci; Roger B Cohen; Stephen Bagley; Susan Stonehouse-Lee; Victoria E Sherry; Elizabeth Gilbert; Corey Langer; Anil Vachani; Erica L Carpenter Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2016-09-06 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: B T Li; F Janku; B Jung; C Hou; K Madwani; R Alden; P Razavi; J S Reis-Filho; R Shen; J M Isbell; A W Blocker; N Eattock; S Gnerre; R V Satya; H Xu; C Zhao; M P Hall; Y Hu; A J Sehnert; D Brown; M Ladanyi; C M Rudin; N Hunkapiller; N Feeney; G B Mills; C P Paweletz; P A Janne; D B Solit; G J Riely; A Aravanis; G R Oxnard Journal: Ann Oncol Date: 2019-04-01 Impact factor: 32.976
Authors: Charu Aggarwal; Jeffrey C Thompson; Taylor A Black; Sharyn I Katz; Ryan Fan; Stephanie S Yee; Austin L Chien; Tracey L Evans; Joshua M Bauml; Evan W Alley; Christine A Ciunci; Abigail T Berman; Roger B Cohen; David B Lieberman; Krishna S Majmundar; Samantha L Savitch; Jennifer J D Morrissette; Wei-Ting Hwang; Kojo S J Elenitoba-Johnson; Corey J Langer; Erica L Carpenter Journal: JAMA Oncol Date: 2019-02-01 Impact factor: 31.777
Authors: Ibiayi Dagogo-Jack; Marguerite Rooney; Rebecca J Nagy; Jessica J Lin; Emily Chin; Lorin A Ferris; Jennifer Ackil; Jochen K Lennerz; Richard B Lanman; Justin F Gainor; Alice T Shaw Journal: J Thorac Oncol Date: 2019-01-18 Impact factor: 15.609
Authors: Pei N Ding; Therese Becker; Victoria Bray; Wei Chua; Yafeng Ma; Bo Xu; David Lynch; Paul de Souza; Tara Roberts Journal: Thorac Cancer Date: 2019-08-15 Impact factor: 3.500
Authors: Adam J Schoenfeld; Joseph M Chan; Daisuke Kubota; Hiroki Sato; Hira Rizvi; Yahya Daneshbod; Jason C Chang; Paul K Paik; Michael Offin; Maria E Arcila; Monika A Davare; Ujwal Shinde; Dana Pe'er; Natasha Rekhtman; Mark G Kris; Romel Somwar; Gregory J Riely; Marc Ladanyi; Helena A Yu Journal: Clin Cancer Res Date: 2020-01-07 Impact factor: 12.531
Authors: Søren M Karst; Ryan M Ziels; Rasmus H Kirkegaard; Emil A Sørensen; Daniel McDonald; Qiyun Zhu; Rob Knight; Mads Albertsen Journal: Nat Methods Date: 2021-01-11 Impact factor: 28.547
Authors: Geoffrey R Oxnard; Yuebi Hu; Kathryn F Mileham; Hatim Husain; Daniel B Costa; Philip Tracy; Nora Feeney; Lynette M Sholl; Suzanne E Dahlberg; Amanda J Redig; David J Kwiatkowski; Michael S Rabin; Cloud P Paweletz; Kenneth S Thress; Pasi A Jänne Journal: JAMA Oncol Date: 2018-11-01 Impact factor: 31.777