| Literature DB >> 29301382 |
Giovanni Vladilo1, Ali Hassanali2.
Abstract
The scientific community is allocating more and more resources to space missions and astronomical observations dedicated to the search for life beyond Earth. This experimental endeavor needs to be backed by a theoretical framework aimed at defining universal criteria for the existence of life. With this aim in mind, we have explored which chemical and phyEntities:
Keywords: habitability; hydrogen bonding; life in the universe; molecular processes
Year: 2018 PMID: 29301382 PMCID: PMC5871933 DOI: 10.3390/life8010001
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Life (Basel) ISSN: 2075-1729
Figure 1Idealized representation of life as a stratification of levels of increasing functional complexity (green box). Due to the lack of a unified description of life, the different levels are investigated by different scientific disciplines (red boxes). The upper levels are heavily affected by unpredictable events that take place during the evolutionary history of life. The chemical interactions taking place between molecular constituents can be described using the universal laws of physics and chemistry.
Figure 2Conceptual framework for the origin and evolution of life adopted in this work. Life is postulated to originate from a prebiotic process of natural selection that leads to the emergence of functional molecules with genetic and catalytic capabilities (Section 2). Subsequent episodes of Darwinian evolution may add structural and functional complexity, always preserving functional molecules as an underlying, essential ingredient of life processes.
Figure 3Graphic representation of small portions of functional chains involved in genetic and catalytic tasks. The sketch shows examples of the directional chemical interactions needed for the operation of these tasks. Solid lines: type-1 bonds holding chemical groups (filled circles) along functional chains. Dashed lines: type-2 bonds connecting a sequence of chemical groups along adjacent chains (“chain pairing”). Dotted arrows: type-3 interactions needed for intermolecular recognition. See Section 3.1.
Classification of chemical interactions according to the role played in functional molecules.
| Interaction | Type 1 | Type 2 | Type 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Description | Bonds betweennearby atoms alongfunctional chains | Bonds involved in theassociation of portionsof functional chains | Transient interactionsbetween external sitesof functional molecules |
| Nature | Intra-chain | Inter-chain (intramolecularor intermolecular) | Intermolecular |
| Biological role | Structural | Encoding of instructions—Folding of catalytic molecules | Intermolecular recognition |
| Formation/destruction | Synthesis/disposalof functional molecules | Chain pairing/unpairing | Approach/removal of functional molecules |
| Requirements | Resilient to type-2 andtype-3 interactions | Resilient to type-3 interactions—Non-invasive (to preserve type-1 bonds) | Non-invasive (to preservetype-1 and type-2 bonds) |
Figure 4Left side: schematic representation of the hierarchy of chemical of interactions predicted to exist in functional molecules (Section 3). Right side: impact of thermal energy, , on the chemical interactions (Section 7). Upper red boxes: is too high, leading to the disruption or denaturation of functional molecules. Green box: is in an optimal range to energize type-3 interactions without disrupting type-2 bonds. Lowest red box: is too low to energize intermolecular interactions.
Chemical bonds and interactions that play a major role in life molecular processes.
| Forces/Chemical Bonds | Covalent Bonds | Hydrogen Bonds (HB) | van der Waals (vdW) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physical nature | Quantum mechanical | Mixed (see | Electrostatic/polarization |
| Dissociation energy (−kcal/mol) | ≃ 40–250 | ≃ 1–40 | ≃ 0.5–a few |
| Directionality | Directional | Directional | Nearly isotropic |
| Decay with distance | Complicated, short range | Roughly | Typically ∼ |
Approximate dependence of the interaction energy on intermolecular distance, r [38]. Ions like NH and COO can form salt bridges where the effective interaction scales as ; these ions can interact with water which forms an effective charge-dipole interaction scaling as ; the weakest hydrogen bond is the dipole-dipole interaction such as between water molecules which scales as .
Main types of van der Waals forces.
| Keesom Forces | Debye Forces | London Forces | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Physical nature | Dipole−dipole | Dipole−induced dipole | Fluctuating dipoles |
| Partners | Permanent dipoles | Polar molecule & any other molecule | Any pair of molecules |
| Attraction | Attractive or repulsive | Always attractive | Always attractive |
| Decay with distance | ∼ | ∼ | ∼ |
| ∼ | ∼ |
Approximate dependence of the interaction energy of two molecules as a function of intermolecular distance, r [38].
Main properties of Hydrogen Bonds [44,45]. The definitions of weak and strong bonds may change from author to author.
| Weak | Strong | Very Strong | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Electrostatics/polarization contribution | Moderate | Dominant | Significant |
| Quantum-mechanical contribution | Vanishing | Weak | Pronounced |
| Dissociation energy (−kcal/mol) | ≈1–4 | ≃4–15 | ≃15–40 |
| Examples | C–H⋯O | O–H⋯O=C | [F⋯H⋯F] |
| C–H⋯N | N–H⋯O=C | [N⋯H⋯N] | |
| O–H | O–H⋯O–H |
Figure 5A hydrogen bond, sketched in this figure, is an attractive interaction between a hydrogen atom from a molecule or a molecular fragment E–H in which E is more electronegative than H, and an atom or a group of atoms, A, in the same or a different molecule [39]. Due to the difference in electronegativity, the proton in the hydrogen nucleus is partially unshielded and the group E–H, called the donor, is polarized. The group A, called the acceptor, must possess at least one electron-rich region (e.g., a lone-pair-possessing atom or a system).
Figure 6A halogen bond, sketched in this figure, is an attractive interaction between an electrophilic region associated with a halogen atom in a molecular entity and a nucleophilic region in another, or the same, molecular entity [46,47,48]. The halogen atom, X, is covalently bonded to the atom/chemical group R. The donor R–X must have an electrophilic region on its electrostatic potential surface. The acceptor Y must possess at least one nucleophilic region (e.g., a lone-pair-possessing atom or a system).
Hydrogen bond (HB) and other properties of cosmically abundant, small molecules.
| HB Strength & Directionality | Potential HB Partners | HB Network | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Methane | Weak | 4 | 0 | Only acceptors | Absent | 1.7 | 98.5 |
| Ammonia | Strong | 3 | 1 | Acceptors & donors | Present (1D) | 25 | 3.42 |
| Water | Strong | 2 | 2 | Acceptors & donors | Present (3D) | 78 | 0.72 |
| Formamide | Strong | 3 | 3 | Acceptors & donors | Present (3D) | 109 | 0.52 |
Number of donor hydrogen atoms in each molecule. Number of lone pairs of electrons in the outer shells of C, N or O. Value of the relative dielectric constant at a temperature in the liquid-phase interval: 100 K, 195 K, 298 K and 293 K for methane, ammonia, water and formamide, respectively.
Figure 7Cosmic abundance by number [50] versus electronegativity [72] of chemical elements more electronegative than hydrogen; van der Waals radii of the elements [49] are color-coded as indicated in the legend. Local concentrations ore depletions of elemental abundances may yield significant deviations relative to the cosmic abundances displayed in the figure.
Figure 8Activation energy of chemical reactions, , plotted as a function of temperature, T, and normalized reaction rate, . Chemical bonds with strengths comparable to are more quickly disrupted in the cyan region and are stable in the magenta region. Light blue vertical strips: liquid-phase temperature limits for pure methane, ammonia and water, with boiling points calculated at pressure p = 1 bar; light red vertical strips: interval of boiling points for pure methane, ammonia and water calculated between p = 1 bar and p = 3 bar. Red dotted line: approximate lower boundary of weak hydrogen bonds (Table 4). Blue dashed line: minimum strength of hydrogen bonds critical for inter-chain stability. See Section 3.2 and Section 7.1.