Literature DB >> 29141979

Measurement Errors in Dietary Assessment Using Self-Reported 24-Hour Recalls in Low-Income Countries and Strategies for Their Prevention.

Rosalind S Gibson1, U Ruth Charrondiere2, Winnie Bell3.   

Abstract

Securing accurate measurements of dietary intake across populations is challenging. Of the methods, self-reported 24-h recalls are often used in low-income countries (LICs) because they are quick, culturally sensitive, do not require high cognitive ability, and provide quantitative data on both foods and nutrients. Measuring intakes via 24-h recalls involves 1) collecting data on food intakes, 2) the appropriate use of relevant food-composition data for calculating nutrient intakes, and 3) statistically converting observed intakes to "usual intakes" for evaluating nutrient adequacy or relations between foods and nutrients and health outcomes. Like all dietary methods, 24-h recalls are subject to random errors that lower the precision and systematic errors that can reduce accuracy at each stage of the measurement protocol. Research has identified the potential sources of measurement errors in 24-h recall protocols and emphasized that sources of random error can be reduced by incorporating standardized quality-control procedures and collecting more than one 24-h recall per person, with the number depending on the study objective. Careful design of the initial 24-h recall protocol can take into account potential sources of systematic error, such as day of the week, season, age, etc. Other sources of systematic error (e.g., energy underreporting) can best be detected by including a reference measure (e.g., doubly labeled water to measure energy expenditure). Alternatively, 24-h recall intakes of energy can be compared with same-day weighed intakes. Nevertheless, very few studies in LICs have assessed the validity of 24-h recalls in their study settings or adopted recommended standardized protocols to mitigate random errors. Hence, efforts should be made to improve the assessment, analysis, and interpretation of self-reported 24-h recall data for population studies in LICs. Accurate and precise dietary intake data at the national level can play an essential role in informing food, nutrition, and agricultural policies; food fortification planning; and compliance to food-based dietary guidelines.
© 2017 American Society for Nutrition.

Entities:  

Keywords:  diet-health relations; dietary assessment; food-composition database; measurement error; nutrient adequacy

Mesh:

Year:  2017        PMID: 29141979      PMCID: PMC5683000          DOI: 10.3945/an.117.016980

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Adv Nutr        ISSN: 2161-8313            Impact factor:   8.701


  77 in total

1.  Taking advantage of the strengths of 2 different dietary assessment instruments to improve intake estimates for nutritional epidemiology.

Authors:  Raymond J Carroll; Douglas Midthune; Amy F Subar; Marina Shumakovich; Laurence S Freedman; Frances E Thompson; Victor Kipnis
Journal:  Am J Epidemiol       Date:  2012-01-24       Impact factor: 4.897

Review 2.  Underreporting of energy intake in developing nations.

Authors:  Fernanda B Scagliusi; Eduardo Ferriolli; Antonio H Lancha
Journal:  Nutr Rev       Date:  2006-07       Impact factor: 7.110

3.  Inadequate intakes of dietary zinc among pregnant women from subsistence households in Sidama, Southern Ethiopia.

Authors:  Yewelsew Abebe; Alemtsehay Bogale; K Michael Hambidge; Barbara J Stoecker; Isabel Arbide; Akilu Teshome; Nancy F Krebs; Jamie E Westcott; Karl B Bailey; Rosalind S Gibson
Journal:  Public Health Nutr       Date:  2007-07-05       Impact factor: 4.022

4.  The 24-hour recall for Senegalese weanlings: a validation exercise.

Authors:  M C Dop; C Milan; C Milan; A M N'Diaye
Journal:  Eur J Clin Nutr       Date:  1994-09       Impact factor: 4.016

5.  Out-of-home food intake is often omitted from mothers' recalls of school children's intake in rural Kenya.

Authors:  Constance A Gewa; Suzanne P Murphy; Charlotte G Neumann
Journal:  J Nutr       Date:  2007-09       Impact factor: 4.798

6.  Simulation model of the impact of biofortification on the absorption of adequate amounts of zinc and iron among Mexican women and preschool children.

Authors:  Edgar Denova-Gutiérrez; Armando García-Guerra; Mario Flores-Aldana; Sonia Rodríguez-Ramírez; Christine Hotz
Journal:  Food Nutr Bull       Date:  2008-09       Impact factor: 2.069

7.  Validity of photographs for food portion estimation in a rural West African setting.

Authors:  L Huybregts; D Roberfroid; C Lachat; J Van Camp; P Kolsteren
Journal:  Public Health Nutr       Date:  2007-08-09       Impact factor: 4.022

8.  Inventory on the dietary assessment tools available and needed in africa: a prerequisite for setting up a common methodological research infrastructure for nutritional surveillance, research, and prevention of diet-related non-communicable diseases.

Authors:  Pedro T Pisa; Edwige Landais; Barrie Margetts; Hester H Vorster; Christine M Friedenreich; Inge Huybrechts; Yves Martin-Prevel; Francesco Branca; Warren T K Lee; Catherine Leclercq; Johann Jerling; Francis Zotor; Paul Amuna; Ayoub Al Jawaldeh; Olaide Ruth Aderibigbe; Waliou Hounkpatin Amoussa; Cheryl A M Anderson; Hajer Aounallah-Skhiri; Madjid Atek; Chakare Benhura; Jephat Chifamba; Namukolo Covic; Omar Dary; Hélène Delisle; Jalila El Ati; Asmaa El Hamdouchi; Karima El Rhazi; Mieke Faber; Alexander Kalimbira; Liisa Korkalo; Annamarie Kruger; James Ledo; Tatenda Machiweni; Carol Mahachi; Nonsikelelo Mathe; Alex Mokori; Claire Mouquet-Rivier; Catherine Mutie; Hilde Liisa Nashandi; Shane A Norris; Oluseye Olusegun Onabanjo; Zo Rambeloson; Foudjo Brice U Saha; Kingsley Ikechukwu Ubaoji; Sahar Zaghloul; Nadia Slimani
Journal:  Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr       Date:  2017-06-02       Impact factor: 11.176

9.  Comparison of the ISU, NCI, MSM, and SPADE Methods for Estimating Usual Intake: A Simulation Study of Nutrients Consumed Daily.

Authors:  Greice H C Laureano; Vanessa B L Torman; Sandra P Crispim; Arnold L M Dekkers; Suzi A Camey
Journal:  Nutrients       Date:  2016-03-15       Impact factor: 5.717

Review 10.  Assessment of the Dietary Intake of Schoolchildren in South Africa: 15 Years after the First National Study.

Authors:  Nelia Steyn; Gabriel Eksteen; Marjanne Senekal
Journal:  Nutrients       Date:  2016-08-19       Impact factor: 5.717

View more
  40 in total

Review 1.  Review of the validity and feasibility of image-assisted methods for dietary assessment.

Authors:  Christoph Höchsmann; Corby K Martin
Journal:  Int J Obes (Lond)       Date:  2020-10-08       Impact factor: 5.095

2.  Indigenous vegetables: a sustainable approach to improve micronutrient adequacy in Tanzanian women of childbearing age.

Authors:  Maria Vittoria Conti; Rachele De Giuseppe; Maria Cristina Monti; Angela G Mkindi; Naelijwa H Mshanga; Silvia Ceppi; John Msuya; Hellas Cena
Journal:  Eur J Clin Nutr       Date:  2021-02-02       Impact factor: 4.016

3.  Valuing the Diversity of Research Methods to Advance Nutrition Science.

Authors:  Richard D Mattes; Sylvia B Rowe; Sarah D Ohlhorst; Andrew W Brown; Daniel J Hoffman; DeAnn J Liska; Edith J M Feskens; Jaapna Dhillon; Katherine L Tucker; Leonard H Epstein; Lynnette M Neufeld; Michael Kelley; Naomi K Fukagawa; Roger A Sunde; Steven H Zeisel; Anthony J Basile; Laura E Borth; Emahlea Jackson
Journal:  Adv Nutr       Date:  2022-08-01       Impact factor: 11.567

4.  The effect of synbiotic supplementation on atherogenic indices, hs-CRP, and malondialdehyde, as major CVD-related parameters, in women with gestational diabetes mellitus: a secondary data-analysis of a randomized double-blind, placebo-controlled study.

Authors:  Zohoor Nabhani; Elham Razmpoosh; Cain C T Clark; Nazanin Goudarzi; Alemeh Hariri Far
Journal:  Diabetol Metab Syndr       Date:  2022-06-21       Impact factor: 5.395

5.  Comparison of the Diet ID Platform to the Automated Self-administered 24-hour (ASA24) Dietary Assessment Tool for Assessment of Dietary Intake.

Authors:  Gabrielle Turner-McGrievy; Brent Hutto; John A Bernhart; Mary J Wilson
Journal:  J Am Nutr Assoc       Date:  2021-03-11

6.  Food Sources and Potential Determinants of Dietary Vitamin C Intake in Chinese Adults: A Cross-Sectional Study.

Authors:  Xiaofang Jia; Zhihong Wang; Bing Zhang; Chang Su; Wenwen Du; Jiguo Zhang; Ji Zhang; Hongru Jiang; Feifei Huang; Yifei Ouyang; Yun Wang; Li Li; Huijun Wang
Journal:  Nutrients       Date:  2018-03-07       Impact factor: 5.717

7.  Food and nutrient gaps in rural Northern Ghana: Does production of smallholder farming households support adoption of food-based dietary guidelines?

Authors:  Ilse de Jager; Ken E Giller; Inge D Brouwer
Journal:  PLoS One       Date:  2018-09-13       Impact factor: 3.240

8.  Alternate Healthy Eating Index is Positively Associated with Cognitive Function Among Middle-Aged and Older Hispanics/Latinos in the HCHS/SOL.

Authors:  Mayra L Estrella; Ramon A Durazo-Arvizu; Josiemer Mattei; Yasmin Mossavar-Rahmani; Krista M Perreira; Anna Maria Siega-Riz; Daniela Sotres-Alvarez; Hector M González; Linda C Gallo; Martha L Daviglus; Melissa Lamar
Journal:  J Nutr       Date:  2020-06-01       Impact factor: 4.798

9.  Promoting Sustainable and Healthy Diets to Mitigate Food Insecurity Amidst Economic and Health Crises in Lebanon.

Authors:  Nahla Hwalla; Lamis Jomaa; Fatima Hachem; Samer Kharroubi; Rena Hamadeh; Lara Nasreddine; Farah Naja
Journal:  Front Nutr       Date:  2021-06-25

10.  Promoting Healthy Eating Habits for College Students Through Creating Dietary Diaries via a Smartphone App and Social Media Interaction: Online Survey Study.

Authors:  Masako Watanabe-Ito; Emiko Kishi; Yoko Shimizu
Journal:  JMIR Mhealth Uhealth       Date:  2020-03-31       Impact factor: 4.773

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.