| Literature DB >> 29127275 |
Benjamin J Burwitz1,2, Helen L Wu1,2, Shaheed Abdulhaqq1,2, Christine Shriver-Munsch2, Tonya Swanson2, Alfred W Legasse2, Katherine B Hammond1,2, Stephanie L Junell3, Jason S Reed1,2, Benjamin N Bimber2, Justin M Greene1,2, Gabriela M Webb1,2, Mina Northrup1,2, Wolfram Laub3, Paul Kievit2, Rhonda MacAllister2, Michael K Axthelm1,2, Rebecca Ducore2, Anne Lewis2, Lois M A Colgin2, Theodore Hobbs2, Lauren D Martin2, Betsy Ferguson2, Charles R Thomas3, Angela Panoskaltsis-Mortari4, Gabrielle Meyers5, Jeffrey J Stanton2, Richard T Maziarz5, Jonah B Sacha6,7.
Abstract
Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HSCT) is a critically important therapy for hematological malignancies, inborn errors of metabolism, and immunodeficiency disorders, yet complications such as graft-vs.-host disease (GvHD) limit survival. Development of anti-GvHD therapies that do not adversely affect susceptibility to infection or graft-vs.-tumor immunity are hampered by the lack of a physiologically relevant, preclinical model of allogeneic HSCT. Here we show a spectrum of diverse clinical HSCT outcomes including primary and secondary graft failure, lethal GvHD, and stable, disease-free full donor engraftment using reduced intensity conditioning and mobilized peripheral blood HSCT in unrelated, fully MHC-matched Mauritian-origin cynomolgus macaques. Anti-GvHD prophylaxis of tacrolimus, post-transplant cyclophosphamide, and CD28 blockade induces multi-lineage, full donor chimerism and recipient-specific tolerance while maintaining pathogen-specific immunity. These results establish a new preclinical allogeneic HSCT model for evaluation of GvHD prophylaxis and next-generation HSCT-mediated therapies for solid organ tolerance, cure of non-malignant hematological disease, and HIV reservoir clearance.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2017 PMID: 29127275 PMCID: PMC5681693 DOI: 10.1038/s41467-017-01631-z
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Nat Commun ISSN: 2041-1723 Impact factor: 14.919
Summary of hematopoietic stem cell transplants in MHC-matched Mauritian cynomolgus macaques
| Recipient | Donor | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| ID | MHC haplotypes | Sex | ID | MHC haplotypes | Sex | Total cells transplanted | CD34 dose/kg | CD3 dose/kg | Outcome |
| 32851 | M1/M1 | M | 32847 | M1/M1 | M | 2.20 × 109 | 1.55 × 106 | N.D. | Primary engraftment failure |
| 32846 | M2/M3 | M | 32843 | M2/M3 | M | 8.50 × 109 | 5.26 × 106 | 3.74 × 108 | Secondary engraftment failure |
| 32849 | M3/M3 | M | 32843 | M3/M3 | M | 4.90 × 109 | 9.42 × 106 | 2.80 × 108 | Secondary engraftment failure |
| 32846* | M2/M3 | M | 32843 | M2/M3 | M | 1.49 × 109 | 4.43 × 106 | 6.40 × 107 | Primary engraftment failure |
| 33450 | M1/M3 | F | 33452 | M1/M3 | M | 1.05 × 1010 | 3.33 × 107 | 4.05 × 108 | Lethal GvHD |
| 33455 | M1/M3 | M | 33452 | M1/M3 | M | 6.27 × 109 | 1.06 × 107 | 3.73 × 108 | Lethal GvHD |
| 33454 | M2/M4 | F | 33461 | M2/M4 | M | 4.80 × 108 | 7.80 × 106 | 5.18 × 107 | Stable Chimerism |
| 34666 | M2/M6 | F | 33456 | M2/M6 | F | 1.60 × 109 | 8.84 × 106 | 1.06 × 108 | Stable Chimerism |
N.D. not determined
Table summarizes the eight HSCTs performed in this study, listed in chronological order. Asterisk (*) indicates the second transplant of recipient macaque 32846
Fig. 1Primary and secondary engraftment failure in MHC-matched MCM post-allogeneic HSCT. a, b Longitudinal white blood cell (WBC), T cell, and platelet absolute counts in recipient macaques 32851 (a), 32846 (b), and 32849 (b). Immune conditioning regimens are indicated in top panels (Bu = busulfan, Flu = fludarabine, TBI = total body irradiation, CD3-IT = CD3-immunotoxin). CD8 depleting mAb was administered only to 32849, indicated by an asterisk (*). Colored circumflexes (^) indicate time points at which donor-derived cells were detected in whole blood by chimerism assays. Crosses (†) indicate time of necropsy. Normal WBC reference range = 5,600–184,000/μl; normal platelet reference range = 134,000–564,000/μl. Shaded gray boxes in a–c indicate tacrolimus treatment period. Vertical dotted line in b indicates second transplant of 32846. c Longitudinal donor chimerism levels in 32846 and 32849 as measured by Illumina sequencing whole blood genomic DNA across SNPs differing between donor and recipient. Graphs display mean ± SEM frequencies of donor-derived cells as measured by sequencing two (32849) or three (32846) SNPs. d Mixed lymphocyte reactions assessing levels of CD4+ and CD8+ T cell alloreactivity in recipient macaque 32846 pre-HSCT and 28 days post-HSCT. Plots display proliferation of CFSE-labeled recipient T cells in response to irradiated donor cells, as measured by frequency of CFSE-lo cells. Plots are gated on live, CD3+ singlets, and either CD4+ or CD8+ cells. Recipient cells cultured alone (no stim) or with Staphylococcus enterotoxin B (SEB) served as negative and positive controls, respectively.
Fig. 2Lethal GvHD in fully MHC-matched MCM post-allogeneic HSCT. a Longitudinal white blood cell (WBC), T cell, and platelet absolute counts in recipient macaques 33450 and 33455. Immune conditioning regimens are indicated in top panels (Bu = busulfan, Flu = fludarabine, TBI = total body irradiation, CD3-IT = CD3-immunotoxin). *Fludarabine was administered only to 33450. Colored circumflexes (^) indicate timepoints at which donor-derived cells were detected in whole blood by chimerism assays. Crosses (†) indicate time of necropsy. Normal WBC reference range = 5,600–18,4000/μl; normal platelet reference range = 134,000–564,000/μl. Shaded gray boxes in a, b indicate tacrolimus treatment period. b Longitudinal donor chimerism levels as measured by Illumina sequencing whole blood genomic DNA across SNPs differing between donor and recipient. Graphs display mean ± SEM frequencies of donor-derived cells as measured by two SNPs. c Longitudinal clinical GvHD scoring. Scoring criteria described in Methods section. d Multifocally extensive exfoliative dermatitis of thoracic limb of recipient macaque 33450. e Blinded tissue histopathology GvHD scoring at time of necropsy. Scoring criteria described in Methods section. f Tissue donor chimerism levels at time of necropsy as measured by Illumina sequencing genomic DNA across SNPs differing between donor and recipient. Graphs display mean ± SEM frequencies of donor-derived cells as measured by sequencing two SNPs. To eliminate non-immune cell contamination, colon, jejunum, and liver cell preparations were sorted for CD45+ cells prior to genomic DNA extraction. g Frequencies of Ki67+ T cells in tissues at time of necropsy, as determined by intracellular Ki67 flow cytometric staining. h Mixed lymphocyte reactions assessing levels of CD4+ and CD8+ T cell alloreactivity in recipient macaques 33450 and 33455 post-HSCT (at time of necropsy). Plots display proliferation of CFSE-labeled recipient T cells in response to irradiated donor or pre-HSCT recipient cells, as measured by frequency of CFSE-lo cells. Plots are gated on live, CD3+ singlets, and either CD4+ or CD8+ cells. Recipient cells cultured alone (no stim) or with SEB served as negative and positive controls, respectively.
Fig. 3Stable, multi-lineage donor chimerism in MHC-matched MCM post-allogeneic HSCT. a Longitudinal white blood cell (WBC), T cell, and platelet absolute counts in recipient macaques 33454 and 34666. Immune conditioning regimens are indicated in top panels (Bu = busulfan, TBI = total body irradiation, CD3-IT = CD3-immunotoxin). Normal WBC reference range = 5,600–184,000/μl; normal platelet reference range = 134,000–564,000/μl. Shaded gray boxes in a, b indicate tacrolimus treatment period. b, c Donor chimerism levels as measured by Illumina sequencing genomic DNA across SNPs differing between donor and recipient. Specific populations were isolated by flow cytometric cell sorting of ACK-treated whole blood prior to genomic DNA extraction. Longitudinal whole blood (WB), granulocyte, and T cell donor chimerism levels shown in b. Timepoints of donor lymphocyte infusions (DLIs) into 33454 are indicated with arrows in b (bottom panel); DLI #1 = 1 × 107 CD3+ cells/kg, DLI #2 = 5 × 107 CD3+ cells/kg, DLI #3 = 5 × 107 CD3+ cells/kg. Comprehensive immune cell subset donor chimerism levels in whole blood (top) and lymph node (bottom) shown in c, measured 428 days (33454) or 193 days (34666) post-HSCT. N.D. = not determined due to insufficient cell numbers. d Mixed lymphocyte reactions assessing levels of CD4+ and CD8+ T cell alloreactivity in recipient macaques 33454 and 34666 post-HSCT (354 and 298 days post-HSCT, respectively). Plots display proliferation of CFSE-labeled recipient T cells in response to irradiated donor or pre-HSCT recipient cells, as measured by frequency of CFSE-lo cells. Plots are gated on live, CD3+ singlets, and either CD4+ or CD8+ cells. Recipient cells cultured alone (no stim) or with SEB served as negative and positive controls, respectively.