Shuai Xu1, Michael Kwa2, Mary E Lohman1, Rachel Evers-Meltzer3,4, Jonathan I Silverberg1,5,6,7. 1. Department of Dermatology, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois. 2. medical student at Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois. 3. School of Medicine, Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana. 4. School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, Tulane University, New Orleans, Louisiana. 5. Department of Medical Social Sciences, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois. 6. Department of Preventive Medicine, Feinberg School of Medicine, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois. 7. Northwestern Medicine Multidisciplinary Eczema Center, Northwestern University, Chicago, Illinois.
Abstract
Importance: Because moisturizer use is critical for the prevention and treatment of numerous dermatological conditions, patients frequently request product recommendations from dermatologists. Objective: To determine the product performance characteristics and ingredients of best-selling moisturizers. Design and Setting: This cohort study involved publicly available data of the top 100 best-selling whole-body moisturizing products at 3 major online retailers (Amazon, Target, and Walmart). Products marketed for use on a specific body part (eg, face, hands, eyelids) were excluded. Main Outcomes and Measures: Pairwise comparisons of median price per ounce on the basis of marketing claims (eg, dermatologist recommended, fragrance free, hypoallergenic) and presence of ingredients represented in the North American Contact Dermatitis Group (NACDG) series were conducted using Wilcoxon rank sum tests. The effect of vehicle type (eg, ointment, lotion, cream, butter) was assessed using the Kruskal-Wallis test. Cross-reactors and botanicals for fragrances were derived from the American Contact Dermatitis Society's Contact Allergen Management Program database. Results: A total of 174 unique best-selling moisturizer products were identified, constituting 109 713 reviews as of August 2016. The median price per ounce was $0.59 (range, $0.10-$9.51 per ounce) with a wide range (9400%). The most popular vehicles were lotions (102 [59%]), followed by creams (22 [13%]), oils (21 [12%]), butters (14 [8%]), and ointments (3 [2%]). Only 12% (n = 21) of best-selling moisturizer products were free of NACDG allergens. The 3 most common allergens were fragrance mix (n = 87), paraben mix (n = 75), and tocopherol (n = 74). Products with the claim "dermatologist recommended" had higher median price per ounce ($0.79; interquartile range [IQR], $0.56-$1.27) than products without the claim ($0.59; IQR, $0.34-$0.92). Products with the claim "phthalate free" had higher median price per ounce ($1.38; IQR, $0.86-$1.63) than products without the claim ($0.59; IQR, $0.35-$0.91). Lotions (median, $0.49; IQR, $0.31-0.68) were statistically less expensive per ounce than butters (median, $1.20; IQR, $0.76-$1.63), creams (median, $0.80; IQR, $0.69-$1.25) and oils (median, $1.30; IQR, $0.64-$2.43). For products with a claim of "fragrance free," 18 (45%) had at least 1 fragrance cross-reactor or botanical ingredient. Products without any ingredients in the NACDG (median, $0.83; IQR, $0.47-$1.69) were not statistically more expensive per ounce than products with 1 or more allergens (median, $0.60; IQR, $0.35-$1.06). Conclusions and Relevance: Best-selling moisturizers vary widely by price and product characteristics. Given the lack of readily available comparison data on moisturizer efficacy, dermatologists should balance consumer preference, price, and allergenicity in their recommendations.
Importance: Because moisturizer use is critical for the prevention and treatment of numerous dermatological conditions, patients frequently request product recommendations from dermatologists. Objective: To determine the product performance characteristics and ingredients of best-selling moisturizers. Design and Setting: This cohort study involved publicly available data of the top 100 best-selling whole-body moisturizing products at 3 major online retailers (Amazon, Target, and Walmart). Products marketed for use on a specific body part (eg, face, hands, eyelids) were excluded. Main Outcomes and Measures: Pairwise comparisons of median price per ounce on the basis of marketing claims (eg, dermatologist recommended, fragrance free, hypoallergenic) and presence of ingredients represented in the North American Contact Dermatitis Group (NACDG) series were conducted using Wilcoxon rank sum tests. The effect of vehicle type (eg, ointment, lotion, cream, butter) was assessed using the Kruskal-Wallis test. Cross-reactors and botanicals for fragrances were derived from the American Contact Dermatitis Society's Contact Allergen Management Program database. Results: A total of 174 unique best-selling moisturizer products were identified, constituting 109 713 reviews as of August 2016. The median price per ounce was $0.59 (range, $0.10-$9.51 per ounce) with a wide range (9400%). The most popular vehicles were lotions (102 [59%]), followed by creams (22 [13%]), oils (21 [12%]), butters (14 [8%]), and ointments (3 [2%]). Only 12% (n = 21) of best-selling moisturizer products were free of NACDG allergens. The 3 most common allergens were fragrance mix (n = 87), paraben mix (n = 75), and tocopherol (n = 74). Products with the claim "dermatologist recommended" had higher median price per ounce ($0.79; interquartile range [IQR], $0.56-$1.27) than products without the claim ($0.59; IQR, $0.34-$0.92). Products with the claim "phthalate free" had higher median price per ounce ($1.38; IQR, $0.86-$1.63) than products without the claim ($0.59; IQR, $0.35-$0.91). Lotions (median, $0.49; IQR, $0.31-0.68) were statistically less expensive per ounce than butters (median, $1.20; IQR, $0.76-$1.63), creams (median, $0.80; IQR, $0.69-$1.25) and oils (median, $1.30; IQR, $0.64-$2.43). For products with a claim of "fragrance free," 18 (45%) had at least 1 fragrance cross-reactor or botanical ingredient. Products without any ingredients in the NACDG (median, $0.83; IQR, $0.47-$1.69) were not statistically more expensive per ounce than products with 1 or more allergens (median, $0.60; IQR, $0.35-$1.06). Conclusions and Relevance: Best-selling moisturizers vary widely by price and product characteristics. Given the lack of readily available comparison data on moisturizer efficacy, dermatologists should balance consumer preference, price, and allergenicity in their recommendations.
Authors: Erin M Warshaw; Howard I Maibach; James S Taylor; Denis Sasseville; Joel G DeKoven; Matthew J Zirwas; Anthony F Fransway; C G Toby Mathias; Kathryn A Zug; Vincent A DeLeo; Joseph F Fowler; James G Marks; Melanie D Pratt; Frances J Storrs; Donald V Belsito Journal: Dermatitis Date: 2015 Jan-Feb Impact factor: 4.845
Authors: Tali Czarnowicki; Dana Malajian; Saakshi Khattri; Joel Correa da Rosa; Riana Dutt; Robert Finney; Nikhil Dhingra; Peng Xiangyu; Hui Xu; Yeriel D Estrada; Xiuzhong Zheng; Patricia Gilleaudeau; Mary Sullivan-Whalen; Mayte Suaréz-Fariñas; Avner Shemer; James G Krueger; Emma Guttman-Yassky Journal: J Allergy Clin Immunol Date: 2015-10-01 Impact factor: 10.793
Authors: Lawrence F Eichenfield; Wynnis L Tom; Timothy G Berger; Alfons Krol; Amy S Paller; Kathryn Schwarzenberger; James N Bergman; Sarah L Chamlin; David E Cohen; Kevin D Cooper; Kelly M Cordoro; Dawn M Davis; Steven R Feldman; Jon M Hanifin; David J Margolis; Robert A Silverman; Eric L Simpson; Hywel C Williams; Craig A Elmets; Julie Block; Christopher G Harrod; Wendy Smith Begolka; Robert Sidbury Journal: J Am Acad Dermatol Date: 2014-05-09 Impact factor: 11.527
Authors: Michelle G Filanovsky; Suwimon Pootongkam; Joan E Tamburro; Mary C Smith; Stephen J Ganocy; Susan T Nedorost Journal: J Pediatr Date: 2015-11-23 Impact factor: 4.406
Authors: Michelle Militello; Ronald A Yang; Jaclyn B Anderson; Mindy D Szeto; Colby L Presley; Melissa R Laughter Journal: Curr Dermatol Rep Date: 2021-09-13
Authors: Yanelli Rodríguez-Carmona; Pahriya Ashrap; Antonia M Calafat; Xiaoyun Ye; Zaira Rosario; Leah D Bedrosian; Gredia Huerta-Montanez; Carmen M Vélez-Vega; Akram Alshawabkeh; José F Cordero; John D Meeker; Deborah Watkins Journal: J Expo Sci Environ Epidemiol Date: 2019-09-03 Impact factor: 5.563
Authors: Jason K Rivers; John P Arlette; Joel DeKoven; Lyn C Guenther; Channy Muhn; Vincent Richer; Nathan Rosen; Jean-François Tremblay; Marni C Wiseman; Catherine Zip; David Zloty Journal: SAGE Open Med Date: 2021-12-08