Thomas J Crowley1, Manish S Dalwani2, Joseph T Sakai3, Kristen M Raymond4, Shannon K McWilliams5, Marie T Banich6, Susan K Mikulich-Gilbertson7. 1. Division of Substance Dependence, Psychiatry Department, University of Colorado Denver, Mail Stop F478, 12469 East 17th Place, Denver, CO 80045, United States. Electronic address: thomas.crowley@ucdenver.edu. 2. Division of Substance Dependence, Psychiatry Department, University of Colorado Denver, Mail Stop F478, 12469 East 17th Place, Denver, CO 80045, United States. Electronic address: manish.dalwani@ucdenver.edu. 3. Division of Substance Dependence, Psychiatry Department, University of Colorado Denver, Mail Stop F478, 12469 East 17th Place, Denver, CO 80045, United States. Electronic address: joseph.sakai@ucdenver.edu. 4. Division of Substance Dependence, Psychiatry Department, University of Colorado Denver, Mail Stop F478, 12469 East 17th Place, Denver, CO 80045, United States. Electronic address: kristen.raymond@ucdenver.edu. 5. Division of Substance Dependence, Psychiatry Department, University of Colorado Denver, Mail Stop F478, 12469 East 17th Place, Denver, CO 80045, United States. Electronic address: shannon.mcwilliams@ucdenver.edu. 6. Institute of Cognitive Science, Departments of Psychology and Neuroscience, Campus Box 344, D420 Muenzinger Hall, University of Colorado Boulder, Boulder, CO 80309-0345, United States. Electronic address: marie.banich@colorado.edu. 7. Division of Substance Dependence, Psychiatry Department, University of Colorado Denver, Mail Stop F478, 12469 East 17th Place, Denver, CO 80045, United States. Electronic address: susan.mikulich@ucdenver.edu.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Among young children excessive externalizing behaviors often predict adolescent conduct and substance use disorders. Adolescents with those disorders show aberrant brain function when choosing between risky or cautious options. We therefore asked whether similarly aberrant brain function during risky decision-making accompanies excessive externalizing behaviors among children, hypothesizing an association between externalizing severity and regional intensity of brain activation during risky decision-making. METHOD: Fifty-eight (58) 9-11 year-old children (both sexes), half community-recruited, half with substance-treated relatives, had parent-rated Child Behavior Checklist Externalizing scores. During fMRI, children repeatedly chose between doing a cautious behavior earning 1 point or a risky behavior that won 5 or lost 10 points. Conservative permutation-based whole-brain regression analyses sought brain regions where, during decision-making, activation significantly associated with externalizing score, with sex, and with their interaction. RESULTS: Before risky responses higher externalizing scores were significantly, negatively associated with neural activation (t's: 2.91-4.76) in regions including medial prefrontal cortex (monitors environmental reward-punishment schedules), insula (monitors internal motivating states, e.g., hunger, anxiety), dopaminergic striatal and midbrain structures (anticipate and mediate reward), and cerebellum (where injuries actually induce externalizing behaviors). Before cautious responses there were no significant externalizing:activation associations (except in post hoc exploratory analyses), no significant sex differences in activation, and no significant sex-by-externalizing interactions. CONCLUSIONS: Among children displaying more externalizing behaviors extensive decision-critical brain regions were hypoactive before risky behaviors. Such neural hypoactivity may contribute to the excessive real-life risky decisions that often produce externalizing behaviors. Substance exposure, minimal here, was a very unlikely cause.
OBJECTIVE: Among young children excessive externalizing behaviors often predict adolescent conduct and substance use disorders. Adolescents with those disorders show aberrant brain function when choosing between risky or cautious options. We therefore asked whether similarly aberrant brain function during risky decision-making accompanies excessive externalizing behaviors among children, hypothesizing an association between externalizing severity and regional intensity of brain activation during risky decision-making. METHOD: Fifty-eight (58) 9-11 year-old children (both sexes), half community-recruited, half with substance-treated relatives, had parent-rated Child Behavior Checklist Externalizing scores. During fMRI, children repeatedly chose between doing a cautious behavior earning 1 point or a risky behavior that won 5 or lost 10 points. Conservative permutation-based whole-brain regression analyses sought brain regions where, during decision-making, activation significantly associated with externalizing score, with sex, and with their interaction. RESULTS: Before risky responses higher externalizing scores were significantly, negatively associated with neural activation (t's: 2.91-4.76) in regions including medial prefrontal cortex (monitors environmental reward-punishment schedules), insula (monitors internal motivating states, e.g., hunger, anxiety), dopaminergic striatal and midbrain structures (anticipate and mediate reward), and cerebellum (where injuries actually induce externalizing behaviors). Before cautious responses there were no significant externalizing:activation associations (except in post hoc exploratory analyses), no significant sex differences in activation, and no significant sex-by-externalizing interactions. CONCLUSIONS: Among children displaying more externalizing behaviors extensive decision-critical brain regions were hypoactive before risky behaviors. Such neural hypoactivity may contribute to the excessive real-life risky decisions that often produce externalizing behaviors. Substance exposure, minimal here, was a very unlikely cause.
Authors: Sophia Schneider; Jan Peters; Uli Bromberg; Stefanie Brassen; Stephan F Miedl; Tobias Banaschewski; Gareth J Barker; Patricia Conrod; Herta Flor; Hugh Garavan; Andreas Heinz; Bernd Ittermann; Mark Lathrop; Eva Loth; Karl Mann; Jean-Luc Martinot; Frauke Nees; Tomas Paus; Marcella Rietschel; Trevor W Robbins; Michael N Smolka; Rainer Spanagel; Andreas Ströhle; Maren Struve; Gunter Schumann; Christian Büchel Journal: Am J Psychiatry Date: 2011-09-28 Impact factor: 18.112
Authors: Jimmy Ghaziri; Alan Tucholka; Gabriel Girard; Jean-Christophe Houde; Olivier Boucher; Guillaume Gilbert; Maxime Descoteaux; Sarah Lippé; Pierre Rainville; Dang Khoa Nguyen Journal: Cereb Cortex Date: 2017-02-01 Impact factor: 5.357
Authors: Terrie E Moffitt; Louise Arseneault; Daniel Belsky; Nigel Dickson; Robert J Hancox; Honalee Harrington; Renate Houts; Richie Poulton; Brent W Roberts; Stephen Ross; Malcolm R Sears; W Murray Thomson; Avshalom Caspi Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2011-01-24 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: S E Young; S K Mikulich; M B Goodwin; J Hardy; C L Martin; M S Zoccolillo; T J Crowley Journal: Drug Alcohol Depend Date: 1995-02 Impact factor: 4.492
Authors: Lauren E Kahn; Shannon J Peake; Thomas J Dishion; Elizabeth A Stormshak; Jennifer H Pfeifer Journal: J Cogn Neurosci Date: 2015-01 Impact factor: 3.225