Literature DB >> 28592542

Gender Parity Trends for Invited Speakers at Four Prominent Virology Conference Series.

Robert F Kalejta1,2, Ann C Palmenberg3,4.   

Abstract

Scientific conferences are most beneficial to participants when they showcase significant new experimental developments, accurately summarize the current state of the field, and provide strong opportunities for collaborative networking. A top-notch slate of invited speakers, assembled by conference organizers or committees, is key to achieving these goals. The perceived underrepresentation of female speakers at prominent scientific meetings is currently a popular topic for discussion, but one that often lacks supportive data. We compiled the full rosters of invited speakers over the last 35 years for four prominent international virology conferences, the American Society for Virology Annual Meeting (ASV), the International Herpesvirus Workshop (IHW), the Positive-Strand RNA Virus Symposium (PSR), and the Gordon Research Conference on Viruses & Cells (GRC). The rosters were cross-indexed by unique names, gender, year, and repeat invitations. When plotted as gender-dependent trends over time, all four conferences showed a clear proclivity for male-dominated invited speaker lists. Encouragingly, shifts toward parity are emerging within all units, but at different rates. Not surprisingly, both selection of a larger percentage of first-time participants and the presence of a woman on the speaker selection committee correlated with improved parity. Session chair information was also collected for the IHW and GRC. These visible positions also displayed a strong male dominance over time that is eroding slowly. We offer our personal interpretation of these data to aid future organizers achieve improved equity among the limited number of available positions for session moderators and invited speakers.IMPORTANCE Politicians and media members have a tendency to cite anecdotes as conclusions without any supporting data. This happens so frequently now, that a name for it has emerged: fake news. Good science proceeds otherwise. The underrepresentation of women as invited speakers at international scientific conferences exemplifies a present-day discussion topic usually occurring without facts to support or refute the arguments. We now provide records profiling four prominent virology conferences over the years 1982 to 2017 with the intention that the trends and accompanying analyses of the gender parity of invited speakers may allow the ongoing discussions to be informed.
Copyright © 2017 American Society for Microbiology.

Entities:  

Keywords:  conference programs; gender; implicit bias; scientific visibility; speaker lists

Year:  2017        PMID: 28592542      PMCID: PMC5533912          DOI: 10.1128/JVI.00739-17

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  J Virol        ISSN: 0022-538X            Impact factor:   5.103


  5 in total

1.  How the American Society for Virology was founded.

Authors:  Wolfang K Joklik; Sidney E Grossberg
Journal:  Virology       Date:  2006-01-05       Impact factor: 3.616

2.  The presence of female conveners correlates with a higher proportion of female speakers at scientific symposia.

Authors:  Arturo Casadevall; Jo Handelsman
Journal:  MBio       Date:  2014-01-07       Impact factor: 7.867

3.  Ten simple rules to achieve conference speaker gender balance.

Authors:  Jennifer L Martin
Journal:  PLoS Comput Biol       Date:  2014-11-20       Impact factor: 4.475

4.  Achieving Speaker Gender Equity at the American Society for Microbiology General Meeting.

Authors:  Arturo Casadevall
Journal:  MBio       Date:  2015-08-04       Impact factor: 7.867

5.  Fewer invited talks by women in evolutionary biology symposia.

Authors:  J Schroeder; H L Dugdale; R Radersma; M Hinsch; D M Buehler; J Saul; L Porter; A Liker; I De Cauwer; P J Johnson; A W Santure; A S Griffin; E Bolund; L Ross; T J Webb; P G D Feulner; I Winney; M Szulkin; J Komdeur; M A Versteegh; C K Hemelrijk; E I Svensson; H Edwards; M Karlsson; S A West; E L B Barrett; D S Richardson; V van den Brink; J H Wimpenny; S A Ellwood; M Rees; K D Matson; A Charmantier; N Dos Remedios; N A Schneider; C Teplitsky; W F Laurance; R K Butlin; N P C Horrocks
Journal:  J Evol Biol       Date:  2013-06-20       Impact factor: 2.411

  5 in total
  15 in total

1.  The Science and Value of Diversity: Closing the Gaps in Our Understanding of Inclusion and Diversity.

Authors:  Talia H Swartz; Ann-Gel S Palermo; Sandra K Masur; Judith A Aberg
Journal:  J Infect Dis       Date:  2019-08-20       Impact factor: 5.226

2.  Defining the Barriers to Women Publishing in High-Impact Journals.

Authors:  Julie Overbaugh
Journal:  J Virol       Date:  2018-03-14       Impact factor: 5.103

3.  Women from some under-represented minorities are given too few talks at world's largest Earth-science conference.

Authors:  Heather L Ford; Cameron Brick; Margarita Azmitia; Karine Blaufuss; Petra Dekens
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2019-12       Impact factor: 49.962

4.  Gender disparities in colloquium speakers at top universities.

Authors:  Christine L Nittrouer; Michelle R Hebl; Leslie Ashburn-Nardo; Rachel C E Trump-Steele; David M Lane; Virginia Valian
Journal:  Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A       Date:  2017-12-18       Impact factor: 11.205

5.  Public Discussion Affects Question Asking at Academic Conferences.

Authors:  Natalie Telis; Emily C Glassberg; Jonathan K Pritchard; Chris Gunter
Journal:  Am J Hum Genet       Date:  2019-06-27       Impact factor: 11.025

6.  Females Are Less Likely Invited Speakers to the International Stroke Conference: Time's Up to Address Sex Disparity.

Authors:  Lauren E Fournier; Grant C Hopping; Liang Zhu; Miguel A Perez-Pinzon; Bruce Ovbiagele; Louise D McCullough; Anjail Z Sharrief
Journal:  Stroke       Date:  2020-01-06       Impact factor: 7.914

7.  Gender Can Influence Student Experiences in MD-PhD Training.

Authors:  Anna S Heffron; Katarina M Braun; Cora Allen-Savietta; Amarette Filut; Chelsea Hanewall; Anna Huttenlocher; Jo Handelsman; Molly Carnes
Journal:  J Womens Health (Larchmt)       Date:  2020-04-28       Impact factor: 2.681

8.  An Update on Gender Parity Trends for Invited Speakers at Four Prominent Virology Conference Series.

Authors:  Ann C Palmenberg; Robert F Kalejta
Journal:  J Virol       Date:  2021-03-24       Impact factor: 5.103

9.  Speaking up for balance: analysis of the gender of invited speakers at UK dental conferences.

Authors:  Claudia Heggie; Sarah L McKernon; Laura Gartshore
Journal:  Br Dent J       Date:  2021-06-25       Impact factor: 2.727

10.  Assessing Contemporary Trends in Female Speakership within Urologic Oncology.

Authors:  Ruchika Talwar; Adrien Bernstein; Amanda Jones; Juanita Crook; Andrea B Apolo; Jennifer M Taylor; Lauren M Burke; Elizabeth R Plimack; Sima P Porten; Kirsten L Greene; Sarah P Psutka; Angela B Smith
Journal:  Urology       Date:  2020-08-13       Impact factor: 2.633

View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.