Mary Segal1. 1. Research Center for Health Care Decision-making, Inc., 706 East Hartwell Lane, Wyndmoor, PA, 19038, USA. msegal@healthcaredecisions.org.
Abstract
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: This review summarizes the experimental literature on behavioral outcomes and psychological effects of genetic testing for obesity. Such tests, although of dubious value, are increasingly marketed to the public, and there has been concern that while results may encourage some consumers to increase the healthfulness of their lifestyles, others may interpret feedback in maladaptive ways. RECENT FINDINGS: Hypothetical vignettes have been used in artificial settings; few studies have investigated outcomes of actual test results. At present, the effects of genetic testing for obesity seem limited to improving consumers' weight control intentions and motivation rather than actual dietary behavior. Evidence for negative psychological consequences is scarce and seems of greater concern for normal weight persons than for those who are overweight. Better research designs carried out in the field rather than the laboratory with more diverse samples are needed.
PURPOSE OF REVIEW: This review summarizes the experimental literature on behavioral outcomes and psychological effects of genetic testing for obesity. Such tests, although of dubious value, are increasingly marketed to the public, and there has been concern that while results may encourage some consumers to increase the healthfulness of their lifestyles, others may interpret feedback in maladaptive ways. RECENT FINDINGS: Hypothetical vignettes have been used in artificial settings; few studies have investigated outcomes of actual test results. At present, the effects of genetic testing for obesity seem limited to improving consumers' weight control intentions and motivation rather than actual dietary behavior. Evidence for negative psychological consequences is scarce and seems of greater concern for normal weight persons than for those who are overweight. Better research designs carried out in the field rather than the laboratory with more diverse samples are needed.
Authors: Susanne F Meisel; Rebecca J Beeken; Cornelia H M van Jaarsveld; Jane Wardle Journal: Obesity (Silver Spring) Date: 2014-12-17 Impact factor: 5.002