| Literature DB >> 27657531 |
Xavier Moisset1,2, Valentina Calbacho3, Pilar Torres3, Christelle Gremeau-Richard1,4, Radhouane Dallel1,4.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Burning mouth syndrome (BMS) is a chronic and spontaneous oral pain with burning quality in the tongue or other oral mucosa without any identifiable oral lesion or laboratory finding. Pathogenesis and etiology of BMS are still unknown. However, BMS has been associated with other chronic pain syndromes including other idiopathic orofacial pain, the dynias group and the family of central sensitivity syndromes. This would imply that BMS shares common mechanisms with other cephalic and/or extracephalic chronic pains. The primary aim of this systematic review was to determine whether BMS is actually associated with other pain syndromes, and to analyze cephalic and extracephalic somatosensory sensitivity in these patients.Entities:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27657531 PMCID: PMC5033415 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0163449
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
PICOS criteria for inclusion and exclusion of studies.
| Parameter | Inclusion criteria | Exclusion criteria |
|---|---|---|
| Patients | • Patients ≥ 15 years. | Patients under 15 years of age |
| Intervention | Not applicable | |
| Comparator | Studies with control/comparison groups | |
| Outcome | 1. Presence of other chronic cephalic and/or extracephalic pain | Studies focusing solely on psychological or potentially allergic factors. Studies on animals |
| Study Design | Randomized controlled trials, retrospective, prospective, or concurrent cohort studies, cross sectional studies | • Reviews, expert opinion, comments, letter to editor, case reports, conference reports. |
PICOS = patients, intervention, comparator, outcomes, study design.
Fig 1PRISMA flow diagram of process of identification and screening of articles for inclusion in this review.
Summary of studies reporting co-occurrent pain symptoms in burning mouth syndrome (BMS) patients.
| Study | Type of study | Sample size(% female) | Mean age in years (SD/range) | Pain duration | Inclusion criteria | Co-occurrent pain | Quality assessment score (max 30) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Bergdahl | Consecutive | 17 (ND) | 53 (34–79) | ND | + | 6 TMD, several headache (ND) | 16 |
| Corsalini | Consecutive | 44 (86) | 67 (45–89) | ND | + | 29 TMD | 20 |
| Forssell | Consecutive | 52 (88) | 60 | > 4 m | + | 10 back pain, joint pain or fibromyalgia | 20 |
| Forssell | Consecutive | 52 (100) | 63 (33–82) | ≥ 3 m | + | 6 headache, 7 joint pain, 4 fibromyalgia | 19 |
| Grushka | Consecutive | 72 (85) | ? (33–84) | > 3 m | + | 38 headache | 17 |
| Hakeberg | Epidemiology survey | 47 (100) | 68 (38–84) | ≥ 6 m | - | 19 headache, 5 AFP | 22 |
| Lamey | Questionnary | 84 (88) | 65 (25–97) | <12–> 132 m | + | 37 back pain | 25 |
| Mignogna | Prospective | 124 (73) | 57 (12) | ≥ 6 m | + | 23 back pain, 21 abdominal pain, 20 headaches, 8 joint pain, 7 muscle pain, 4 vulvodynia, 3 rectal pain | 26 |
| Nasri | Consecutive | 66 (85) | 62 (35–83) | 1–360 m | + | 2 trigeminal neuralgia, 4 fibromyalgia | 20 |
| Netto | Case-control | 32 (72) | 61 (27–87) | ND | + | No difference for TMD | 27 |
| Thorstensson and Hugoson, 1996 [ | Epidemiology survey | 18 (89) | 51 (20–70) | ND | - | 11 TMD (association between burning sensation and TMD) | 24 |
| Woda | Consecutive | 25 (84) | 62 (39–83) | ≥ 4 m | + | 9 back pain, 3 vulvodynia, 2 AFP, 1 diffuse myalgia, 1 TTH, 1 post-herpetic pain | 15 |
AFP, Atypical facial pain; TMD, Temporomandibular disorder; TTH, Tension-type headache; ND, Not determined
*Median
-, poor definition of BMS
+, correct enough definition of BMS.
Somatosensory sensitivity in patients with burning mouth syndrome (BMS).
| Study | • Sample size (% female) | Pain duration | Thermode size (mm) | Cephalic skin | Extra-cephalic skin | Quality assessment score (max 30) | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patients | Controls | WDT | HPT | CDT | CPT | MPT | HPT | ||||
| • 8 (100) | • 8 (100) | > 24 m | 30x30 | NS | 28 | ||||||
| • 20 (100) | • 20 (100) | ≥ 4 m | 25x50 | NS | hyper | 27 | |||||
| • 40 (?) | • 23 (?) | ≥ 3 m | 7x7 | NS | NS | NS | 17 | ||||
| • 20 (100) | • 20 (100) | > 36 m | ? | NS | 18 | ||||||
| • 26 (?) | • 24 (?) | ND | 20x20 | NS | NS | NS | NS | 21 | |||
| • 15 (73) | • 15 (73) | ND | NA (radiant heat) | NS | 7 | ||||||
| • 8 (100) | • 41 (46) | ≥ 6 m | 9x9 | NS | NS | 26 | |||||
| • 20 (80) | • 30 (33) | > 36 m | ? | hypo | NS | • hypo V2 | 25 | ||||
| • 23 (96) | • 23 (91) | ND | NA (Laser) | hypo | hypo | hypo | 21 | ||||
CDT, cold detection threshold; CPT, cold pain threshold; HPT, heat pain threshold; hypo, hyposensitivity; hyper, hypersensitivity; M: mechanical; NA, Not applicable; NS, no significant difference compared to the control group;?, missing information.
Prevalence of co-occurrent pain symptoms in burning mouth syndrome (BMS) patients’ samples and in the general population.
| Pain syndromes | Prevalence of the pain symptom in the study sample | Prevalence of the pain symptom in the general population of equivalent age |
|---|---|---|
| Temporomandibular disorders | 12 to 66% [ | 44 to 50% [ |
| Headaches | 4 to 40% [ | 46% with active headache [ |
| Abdominal pain | 17% [ | IBS in 6–18% [ |
| Genital pain | 2 to 12% [ | 7 to 8% [ |
| Back pain | 19 to 44% [ | 29% [ |
| Widespread musculoskeletal pain (fibromyalgia) | 4 to 8% [ | 2 to 8% [ |
Evolution of burning mouth syndrome (BMS) diagnostic criteria.
| 1988 | ICHD 1 | Absent | |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1994 | IASP | Glossodynia and sore mouth | • |
| 2004 | ICHD 2 | BMS | • A. Pain in the mouth present daily and persisting for most of the day. |
| 2013 | ICHD 3 | BMS | • A. Oral pain fulfilling criteria B and C. |
ICHD, International Classification of Headache Disorders; IASP, International Association for the Study of Pain.