Karen L Bierman1, Brenda S Heinrichs1, Janet A Welsh1, Robert L Nix2, Scott D Gest1. 1. Department of Psychology, The Pennsylvania State University, University Park, PA, USA. 2. Department of Human Development and Family Studies, University of Wisconsin-Madison, Madison, WS, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Growing up in poverty undermines healthy development, producing disparities in the cognitive and social-emotional skills that support early learning and mental health. Preschool and home-visiting interventions for low-income children have the potential to build early cognitive and social-emotional skills, reducing the disparities in school readiness that perpetuate the cycle of poverty. However, longitudinal research suggests that the gains low-income children make during preschool interventions often fade at school entry and disappear by early elementary school. METHODS: In an effort to improve the benefits for low-income children, the REDI program enriched Head Start preschool classrooms (study one) and home visits (study two) with evidence-based programming, documenting positive intervention effects in two randomized trials. In this study, REDI participants were followed longitudinally, to evaluate the sustained impact of the classroom and home-visiting enrichments 3 years later, when children were in second grade. The combined sample included 556 children (55% European American, 25% African American, 19% Latino; 49% male): 288 children received theclassroom intervention, 105 children received the classroom intervention plus the home-visiting intervention, and 173 children received usual practice Head Start. RESULTS: The classroom intervention led to sustained benefits in social-emotional skills, improving second grade classroom participation, student-teacher relationships, social competence, and peer relations. The coordinated home-visiting intervention produced additional benefits in child mental health (perceived social competence and peer relations) and cognitive skills (reading skills, academic performance). Significant effects ranged from 25% to 48% of a standard deviation, representing important effects of small to moderate magnitude relative to usual practice Head Start. CONCLUSIONS:Preschool classroom and home-visiting programs for low-income children can be improved with the use of evidence-based programming, reducing disparities and promoting complementary benefits that sustain in elementary school.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: Growing up in poverty undermines healthy development, producing disparities in the cognitive and social-emotional skills that support early learning and mental health. Preschool and home-visiting interventions for low-income children have the potential to build early cognitive and social-emotional skills, reducing the disparities in school readiness that perpetuate the cycle of poverty. However, longitudinal research suggests that the gains low-income children make during preschool interventions often fade at school entry and disappear by early elementary school. METHODS: In an effort to improve the benefits for low-income children, the REDI program enriched Head Start preschool classrooms (study one) and home visits (study two) with evidence-based programming, documenting positive intervention effects in two randomized trials. In this study, REDIparticipants were followed longitudinally, to evaluate the sustained impact of the classroom and home-visiting enrichments 3 years later, when children were in second grade. The combined sample included 556 children (55% European American, 25% African American, 19% Latino; 49% male): 288 children received the classroom intervention, 105 children received the classroom intervention plus the home-visiting intervention, and 173 children received usual practice Head Start. RESULTS: The classroom intervention led to sustained benefits in social-emotional skills, improving second grade classroom participation, student-teacher relationships, social competence, and peer relations. The coordinated home-visiting intervention produced additional benefits in child mental health (perceived social competence and peer relations) and cognitive skills (reading skills, academic performance). Significant effects ranged from 25% to 48% of a standard deviation, representing important effects of small to moderate magnitude relative to usual practice Head Start. CONCLUSIONS: Preschool classroom and home-visiting programs for low-income children can be improved with the use of evidence-based programming, reducing disparities and promoting complementary benefits that sustain in elementary school.
Authors: Frances A Campbell; Elizabeth P Pungello; Margaret Burchinal; Kirsten Kainz; Yi Pan; Barbara H Wasik; Oscar A Barbarin; Joseph J Sparling; Craig T Ramey Journal: Dev Psychol Date: 2012-01-16
Authors: Karen L Bierman; Celene E Domitrovich; Robert L Nix; Scott D Gest; Janet A Welsh; Mark T Greenberg; Clancy Blair; Keith E Nelson; Sukhdeep Gill Journal: Child Dev Date: 2008 Nov-Dec
Authors: Michael Robling; Marie-Jet Bekkers; Kerry Bell; Christopher C Butler; Rebecca Cannings-John; Sue Channon; Belen Corbacho Martin; John W Gregory; Kerry Hood; Alison Kemp; Joyce Kenkre; Alan A Montgomery; Gwenllian Moody; Eleri Owen-Jones; Kate Pickett; Gerry Richardson; Zoë E S Roberts; Sarah Ronaldson; Julia Sanders; Eugena Stamuli; David Torgerson Journal: Lancet Date: 2015-10-22 Impact factor: 79.321
Authors: Giulia A Borriello; Amanda M Ramos; Misaki N Natsuaki; David Reiss; Daniel S Shaw; Leslie D Leve; Jenae M Neiderhiser Journal: Dev Sci Date: 2020-05-05