Literature DB >> 27469352

"I Won't Out Myself Just to Do a Survey": Sexual and Gender Minority Adolescents' Perspectives on the Risks and Benefits of Sex Research.

Kathryn Macapagal1, Ryan Coventry2, Miriam R Arbeit3, Celia B Fisher3, Brian Mustanski2.   

Abstract

Sexual and gender minority (SGM) adolescents under age 18 are underrepresented in sexual health research. Exclusion of SGM minors from these studies has resulted in a lack of knowledge about the risks and benefits youth experience from sexual health research participation. Institutional Review Boards' (IRB) overprotective stances toward research risks and requirements for guardian consent for SGM research are significant barriers to participation, though few have investigated SGM youth's perspectives on these topics. This study aimed to empirically inform decisions about guardian consent for sexuality survey studies involving SGM youth. A total of 74 SGM youth aged 14-17 completed an online survey of sexual behavior and SGM identity, and a new measure that compared the discomfort of sexual health survey completion to everyday events and exemplars of minimal risk research (e.g., behavioral observation). Youth described survey benefits and drawbacks and perspectives on guardian permission during an online focus group. Participants felt about the same as or more comfortable completing the survey compared to other research procedures, and indicated that direct and indirect participation benefits outweighed concerns about privacy and emotional discomfort. Most would not have participated if guardian permission was required, citing negative parental attitudes about adolescent sexuality and SGM issues and not being "out" about their SGM identity. Findings suggest that sexual health survey studies meet minimal risk criteria, are appropriate for SGM youth, and that recruitment would not be possible without waivers of guardian consent. Decreasing barriers to research participation would dramatically improve our understanding of sexual health among SGM youth.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Adolescence; Parental consent; Research ethics; Sexual behavior; Sexual orientation

Mesh:

Year:  2016        PMID: 27469352      PMCID: PMC5274602          DOI: 10.1007/s10508-016-0784-5

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Arch Sex Behav        ISSN: 0004-0002


  36 in total

1.  Assessment of children's capacity to consent for research: a descriptive qualitative study of researchers' practices.

Authors:  Barbara E Gibson; Elaine Stasiulis; Shawna Gutfreund; Maria McDonald; Lauren Dade
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  2011-06-02       Impact factor: 2.903

2.  Family acceptance in adolescence and the health of LGBT young adults.

Authors:  Caitlin Ryan; Stephen T Russell; David Huebner; Rafael Diaz; Jorge Sanchez
Journal:  J Child Adolesc Psychiatr Nurs       Date:  2010-11

3.  Sensitive research with adolescents: just how upsetting are self-report surveys anyway?

Authors:  Jennifer Langhinrichsen-Rohling; Catalina Arata; Natalie O'Brien; David Bowers; Jeffrey Klibert
Journal:  Violence Vict       Date:  2006-08

4.  Determining risk in pediatric research with no prospect of direct benefit: time for a national consensus on the interpretation of federal regulations.

Authors:  Celia B Fisher; Susan Z Kornetsky; Ernest D Prentice
Journal:  Am J Bioeth       Date:  2007-03       Impact factor: 11.229

5.  Intimacy, monogamy, and condom problems drive unprotected sex among young men in serious relationships with other men: a mixed methods dyadic study.

Authors:  George J Greene; Rebecca Andrews; Laura Kuper; Brian Mustanski
Journal:  Arch Sex Behav       Date:  2014-01

6.  A Social Neuroscience Perspective on Adolescent Risk-Taking.

Authors:  Laurence Steinberg
Journal:  Dev Rev       Date:  2008-03

7.  Mental health of lesbian, gay, and bisexual youth: A developmental resiliency perspective.

Authors:  Brian Mustanski; M Newcomb; R Garofalo
Journal:  J Gay Lesbian Soc Serv       Date:  2011-01-01

8.  Distress, need for help, and positive feelings derived from participation in sex research: findings of a population study in The Netherlands.

Authors:  Lisette Kuyper; Ciel Wijsen; John de Wit
Journal:  J Sex Res       Date:  2013-03-29

9.  Capacity to provide informed consent for participation in schizophrenia and HIV research.

Authors:  David J Moser; Susan K Schultz; Stephan Arndt; Michelle L Benjamin; Frank W Fleming; Colleen S Brems; Jane S Paulsen; Paul S Appelbaum; Nancy C Andreasen
Journal:  Am J Psychiatry       Date:  2002-07       Impact factor: 18.112

10.  Emotional risks to respondents in survey research.

Authors:  Susan M Labott; Timothy P Johnson; Michael Fendrich; Norah C Feeny
Journal:  J Empir Res Hum Res Ethics       Date:  2013-10       Impact factor: 1.742

View more
  37 in total

1.  Is Guardian Permission a Barrier to Online Sexual Health Research Among Adolescent Males Interested in Sex With Males?

Authors:  Kimberly M Nelson; Michael P Carey; Celia B Fisher
Journal:  J Sex Res       Date:  2018-06-28

2.  Sexual and Gender Minority Adolescents' Views On HIV Research Participation and Parental Permission: A Mixed-Methods Study.

Authors:  Brian Mustanski; Ryan Coventry; Kathryn Macapagal; Miriam R Arbeit; Celia B Fisher
Journal:  Perspect Sex Reprod Health       Date:  2017-04-26

3.  Adolescent and Parent Perceptions about Participation in Biomedical Sexual Health Trials.

Authors:  Sara E Landers; Jenny K R Francis; Marilyn C Morris; Christine Mauro; Susan L Rosenthal
Journal:  Ethics Hum Res       Date:  2020-05

4.  Bisexual Invisibility and the Sexual Health Needs of Adolescent Girls.

Authors:  Miriam R Arbeit; Celia B Fisher; Kathryn Macapagal; Brian Mustanski
Journal:  LGBT Health       Date:  2016-09-07       Impact factor: 4.151

5.  Parents' Perspectives About Adolescent Boys' Involvement in Biomedical HIV Prevention Research.

Authors:  Brian Mustanski; Kathryn Macapagal; Matthew Thomann; Brian A Feinstein; Michael E Newcomb; Darnell Motley; Celia B Fisher
Journal:  Arch Sex Behav       Date:  2017-09-05

6.  Gay and Bisexual Adolescent Boys' Perspectives on Parent-Adolescent Relationships and Parenting Practices Related to Teen Sex and Dating.

Authors:  Brian A Feinstein; Matthew Thomann; Ryan Coventry; Kathryn Macapagal; Brian Mustanski; Michael E Newcomb
Journal:  Arch Sex Behav       Date:  2017-12-26

7.  "It's Almost Like Gay Sex Doesn't Exist:" Parent-Child Sex Communication According to Gay, Bisexual, and Queer Adolescent Sons.

Authors:  Dalmacio Flores; Sharron L Docherty; Michael V Relf; Ross E McKinney; Julie V Barroso
Journal:  J Adolesc Res       Date:  2018-02-20

8.  Attitudes Toward Fertility and Reproductive Health Among Transgender and Gender-Nonconforming Adolescents.

Authors:  Diane Chen; Margaret Matson; Kathryn Macapagal; Emilie K Johnson; Ilina Rosoklija; Courtney Finlayson; Celia B Fisher; Brian Mustanski
Journal:  J Adolesc Health       Date:  2018-03-02       Impact factor: 5.012

9.  Hookup App Use, Sexual Behavior, and Sexual Health Among Adolescent Men Who Have Sex With Men in the United States.

Authors:  Kathryn Macapagal; David A Moskowitz; Dennis H Li; Andrés Carrión; Emily Bettin; Celia B Fisher; Brian Mustanski
Journal:  J Adolesc Health       Date:  2018-06       Impact factor: 5.012

10.  Risks and Benefits of Adolescent Girls' Participation in Online Sexting Survey Research.

Authors:  Xiangyu Tao; Elise Bragard; Celia B Fisher
Journal:  Arch Sex Behav       Date:  2021-08-10
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.