Literature DB >> 26980822

The Challenge of Reproducibility and Accuracy in Nutrition Research: Resources and Pitfalls.

Barbara C Sorkin1, Adam J Kuszak2, John S Williamson3, D Craig Hopp3, Joseph M Betz2.   

Abstract

Inconsistent and contradictory results from nutrition studies conducted by different investigators continue to emerge, in part because of the inherent variability of natural products, as well as the unknown and therefore uncontrolled variables in study populations and experimental designs. Given these challenges inherent in nutrition research, it is critical for the progress of the field that researchers strive to minimize variability within studies and enhance comparability between studies by optimizing the characterization, control, and reporting of products, reagents, and model systems used, as well as the rigor and reporting of experimental designs, protocols, and data analysis. Here we describe some recent developments relevant to research on plant-derived products used in nutrition research, highlight some resources for optimizing the characterization and reporting of research using these products, and describe some of the pitfalls that may be avoided by adherence to these recommendations.
© 2016 American Society for Nutrition.

Keywords:  natural product integrity; orthogonal methods; phytochemical; quantitative analysis; reproducibility

Mesh:

Substances:

Year:  2016        PMID: 26980822      PMCID: PMC4785474          DOI: 10.3945/an.115.010595

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Adv Nutr        ISSN: 2161-8313            Impact factor:   8.701


  35 in total

1.  Implausible results in human nutrition research.

Authors:  John P A Ioannidis
Journal:  BMJ       Date:  2013-11-14

2.  Cell Biology. Fixing problems with cell lines.

Authors:  Jon R Lorsch; Francis S Collins; Jennifer Lippincott-Schwartz
Journal:  Science       Date:  2014-12-19       Impact factor: 47.728

3.  Effects of green tea catechins with or without caffeine on glycemic control in adults: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials.

Authors:  Xin-Xin Zheng; Yan-Lu Xu; Shao-Hua Li; Rutai Hui; Yong-Jian Wu; Xiao-Hong Huang
Journal:  Am J Clin Nutr       Date:  2013-02-20       Impact factor: 7.045

Review 4.  Universal quantitative NMR analysis of complex natural samples.

Authors:  Charlotte Simmler; José G Napolitano; James B McAlpine; Shao-Nong Chen; Guido F Pauli
Journal:  Curr Opin Biotechnol       Date:  2013-09-14       Impact factor: 9.740

5.  Comparisons of large (Vaccinium macrocarpon Ait.) and small (Vaccinium oxycoccos L., Vaccinium vitis-idaea L.) cranberry in British Columbia by phytochemical determination, antioxidant potential, and metabolomic profiling with chemometric analysis.

Authors:  Paula N Brown; Christina E Turi; Paul R Shipley; Susan J Murch
Journal:  Planta Med       Date:  2012-02-15       Impact factor: 3.352

6.  Guidance from an NIH workshop on designing, implementing, and reporting clinical studies of soy interventions.

Authors:  Marguerite A Klein; Richard L Nahin; Mark J Messina; Jeanne I Rader; Lilian U Thompson; Thomas M Badger; Johanna T Dwyer; Young S Kim; Carol H Pontzer; Pamela E Starke-Reed; Connie M Weaver
Journal:  J Nutr       Date:  2010-04-14       Impact factor: 4.798

7.  Probability of identification: a statistical model for the validation of qualitative botanical identification methods.

Authors:  Robert A LaBudde; James M Harnly
Journal:  J AOAC Int       Date:  2012 Jan-Feb       Impact factor: 1.913

8.  AOAC INTERNATIONAL guidelines for validation of botanical identification methods.

Authors: 
Journal:  J AOAC Int       Date:  2012 Jan-Feb       Impact factor: 1.913

9.  Policy: NIH plans to enhance reproducibility.

Authors:  Francis S Collins; Lawrence A Tabak
Journal:  Nature       Date:  2014-01-30       Impact factor: 49.962

10.  The Economics of Reproducibility in Preclinical Research.

Authors:  Leonard P Freedman; Iain M Cockburn; Timothy S Simcoe
Journal:  PLoS Biol       Date:  2015-06-09       Impact factor: 8.029

View more
  12 in total

1.  Prospective clinical trial examining the impact of genetic variation in FADS1 on the metabolism of linoleic acid- and ɣ-linolenic acid-containing botanical oils.

Authors:  Susan Sergeant; Brian Hallmark; Rasika A Mathias; Tammy L Mustin; Priscilla Ivester; Maggie L Bohannon; Ingo Ruczinski; Laurel Johnstone; Michael C Seeds; Floyd H Chilton
Journal:  Am J Clin Nutr       Date:  2020-05-01       Impact factor: 7.045

Review 2.  Current regulatory guidelines and resources to support research of dietary supplements in the United States.

Authors:  Regan L Bailey
Journal:  Crit Rev Food Sci Nutr       Date:  2018-11-13       Impact factor: 11.176

3.  Nutrition and Cancer Research: Resources for the Nutrition and Dietetics Practitioner.

Authors:  Nancy J Emenaker; Ashley J Vargas
Journal:  J Acad Nutr Diet       Date:  2017-12-28       Impact factor: 4.910

Review 4.  The role of the IACUC in ensuring research reproducibility.

Authors:  Jerald Silverman; James Macy; Patricia A Preisig
Journal:  Lab Anim (NY)       Date:  2017-03-22       Impact factor: 12.625

5.  Ketogenic and low-sugar diets for patients with cancer: perceptions and practices of medical oncologists in Canada.

Authors:  Pamela N Klassen; Benjamin A Goldenberg; Pascal Lambert; Kathy Vagianos; Christina A Kim
Journal:  Support Care Cancer       Date:  2020-02-23       Impact factor: 3.603

Review 6.  Date Palm Fruit (Phoenix dactylifera): Effects on Vascular Health and Future Research Directions.

Authors:  Yousef A Al-Dashti; Roberta R Holt; Carl L Keen; Robert M Hackman
Journal:  Int J Mol Sci       Date:  2021-04-28       Impact factor: 5.923

7.  A guide for authors and readers of the American Society for Nutrition Journals on the proper use of P values and strategies that promote transparency and improve research reproducibility.

Authors:  John D Sorkin; Mark Manary; Paul A M Smeets; Amanda J MacFarlane; Arne Astrup; Ronald L Prigeon; Beth B Hogans; Jack Odle; Teresa A Davis; Katherine L Tucker; Christopher P Duggan; Deirdre K Tobias
Journal:  Am J Clin Nutr       Date:  2021-10-04       Impact factor: 8.472

8.  Improving natural product research translation: From source to clinical trial.

Authors:  Barbara C Sorkin; Adam J Kuszak; Gregory Bloss; Naomi K Fukagawa; Freddie Ann Hoffman; Mahtab Jafari; Bruce Barrett; Paula N Brown; Frederic D Bushman; Steven J Casper; Floyd H Chilton; Christopher S Coffey; Mario G Ferruzzi; D Craig Hopp; Mairead Kiely; Daniel Lakens; John B MacMillan; David O Meltzer; Marco Pahor; Jeffrey Paul; Kathleen Pritchett-Corning; Sara K Quinney; Barbara Rehermann; Kenneth D R Setchell; Nisha S Sipes; Jacqueline M Stephens; D Lansing Taylor; Hervé Tiriac; Michael A Walters; Dan Xi; Giovanna Zappalá; Guido F Pauli
Journal:  FASEB J       Date:  2019-12-10       Impact factor: 5.834

Review 9.  Comparative Medicine: An Inclusive Crossover Discipline.

Authors:  James Macy; Tamas L Horvath
Journal:  Yale J Biol Med       Date:  2017-09-25

10.  Developing a Rational, Optimized Product of Centella asiatica for Examination in Clinical Trials: Real World Challenges.

Authors:  Kirsten M Wright; Janis McFerrin; Armando Alcázar Magaña; Joanne Roberts; Maya Caruso; Doris Kretzschmar; Jan F Stevens; Claudia S Maier; Joseph F Quinn; Amala Soumyanath
Journal:  Front Nutr       Date:  2022-01-14
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.