J A Carr1, C Roiter2, A Alzuhaili2. 1. Division of Trauma Surgery, Hurley Medical Center, 7th Floor, West Tower, One Hurley Plaza, Flint, MI, 48503, USA. heartandbones@yahoo.com. 2. Division of Trauma Surgery, Hurley Medical Center, 7th Floor, West Tower, One Hurley Plaza, Flint, MI, 48503, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Computed tomography (CT) is the standard for grading blunt splenic injuries, but the true accuracy, especially for grade IV or V injuries as compared to pathological findings, is unknown. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective study from 2005 to 2011 was undertaken. RESULTS: There were 214 adults admitted with blunt splenic injury and 170 (79%) were managed nonoperatively. The remaining 44 patients (21%) required surgical intervention. There was a significant difference in the Injury Severity Score (ISS) between those who did and those who did not require splenectomy: median 31 (interquartile [IQ] range 11-51) versus 22 (IQ range 9-35, p = 0.0002). Ten patients presented in shock, had a positive ultrasound, and went to surgery. The remaining 34 had CT scans prior to surgery. Twenty-five (73%) had injury grades IV or V. The CT scan correctly graded the injury in 14 (41%) and was incorrect in 20 (59%). The assigned grade by the CT scan underestimated the true injury grade by one grade in six cases (30%), by two or more grades in nine (45%), and the CT images were obscured by blood and deemed "ungradeable" in five (25%). The CT scan was more accurate for grades I and II (100%) than for grades III-V (25-43%). The reasons for inaccuracy were either inability to visualize that the laceration involved the hilar vessels or excessive perisplenic blood which obscured the injury and/or the hilum. CONCLUSIONS: CT for splenic injury is accurate for grades I and II, but underestimates the true extent of injury for grades III-V. The reasons for the lack of correlation are the inability to determine hilar involvement and excessive perisplenic blood obscuring the injury. Patients with these image characteristics by CT scan should undergo splenectomy earlier if there are any signs of hemodynamic instability.
BACKGROUND: Computed tomography (CT) is the standard for grading blunt splenic injuries, but the true accuracy, especially for grade IV or V injuries as compared to pathological findings, is unknown. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective study from 2005 to 2011 was undertaken. RESULTS: There were 214 adults admitted with blunt splenic injury and 170 (79%) were managed nonoperatively. The remaining 44 patients (21%) required surgical intervention. There was a significant difference in the Injury Severity Score (ISS) between those who did and those who did not require splenectomy: median 31 (interquartile [IQ] range 11-51) versus 22 (IQ range 9-35, p = 0.0002). Ten patients presented in shock, had a positive ultrasound, and went to surgery. The remaining 34 had CT scans prior to surgery. Twenty-five (73%) had injury grades IV or V. The CT scan correctly graded the injury in 14 (41%) and was incorrect in 20 (59%). The assigned grade by the CT scan underestimated the true injury grade by one grade in six cases (30%), by two or more grades in nine (45%), and the CT images were obscured by blood and deemed "ungradeable" in five (25%). The CT scan was more accurate for grades I and II (100%) than for grades III-V (25-43%). The reasons for inaccuracy were either inability to visualize that the laceration involved the hilar vessels or excessive perisplenic blood which obscured the injury and/or the hilum. CONCLUSIONS: CT for splenic injury is accurate for grades I and II, but underestimates the true extent of injury for grades III-V. The reasons for the lack of correlation are the inability to determine hilar involvement and excessive perisplenic blood obscuring the injury. Patients with these image characteristics by CT scan should undergo splenectomy earlier if there are any signs of hemodynamic instability.
Authors: George C Velmahos; Nikos Zacharias; Timothy A Emhoff; James M Feeney; James M Hurst; Bruce A Crookes; David T Harrington; Shea C Gregg; Sheldon Brotman; Peter A Burke; Kimberly A Davis; Rajan Gupta; Robert J Winchell; Steven Desjardins; Reginald Alouidor; Ronald I Gross; Michael S Rosenblatt; John T Schulz; Yuchiao Chang Journal: Arch Surg Date: 2010-05
Authors: M G Ochsner; M M Knudson; H L Pachter; D B Hoyt; T H Cogbill; C E McAuley; F E Davis; S Rogers; A Guth; J Garcia; P Lambert; N Thomson; S Evans; E J Balthazar; G Casola; M A Nigogosyan; R Barr Journal: J Trauma Date: 2000-09
Authors: A B Peitzman; B Heil; L Rivera; M B Federle; B G Harbrecht; K D Clancy; M Croce; B L Enderson; J A Morris; D Shatz; J W Meredith; J B Ochoa; S M Fakhry; J G Cushman; J P Minei; M McCarthy; F A Luchette; R Townsend; G Tinkoff; E F Block; S Ross; E R Frykberg; R M Bell; F Davis; L Weireter; M B Shapiro Journal: J Trauma Date: 2000-08
Authors: Federico Coccolini; Giulia Montori; Fausto Catena; Yoram Kluger; Walter Biffl; Ernest E Moore; Viktor Reva; Camilla Bing; Miklosh Bala; Paola Fugazzola; Hany Bahouth; Ingo Marzi; George Velmahos; Rao Ivatury; Kjetil Soreide; Tal Horer; Richard Ten Broek; Bruno M Pereira; Gustavo P Fraga; Kenji Inaba; Joseph Kashuk; Neil Parry; Peter T Masiakos; Konstantinos S Mylonas; Andrew Kirkpatrick; Fikri Abu-Zidan; Carlos Augusto Gomes; Simone Vasilij Benatti; Noel Naidoo; Francesco Salvetti; Stefano Maccatrozzo; Vanni Agnoletti; Emiliano Gamberini; Leonardo Solaini; Antonio Costanzo; Andrea Celotti; Matteo Tomasoni; Vladimir Khokha; Catherine Arvieux; Lena Napolitano; Lauri Handolin; Michele Pisano; Stefano Magnone; David A Spain; Marc de Moya; Kimberly A Davis; Nicola De Angelis; Ari Leppaniemi; Paula Ferrada; Rifat Latifi; David Costa Navarro; Yashuiro Otomo; Raul Coimbra; Ronald V Maier; Frederick Moore; Sandro Rizoli; Boris Sakakushev; Joseph M Galante; Osvaldo Chiara; Stefania Cimbanassi; Alain Chichom Mefire; Dieter Weber; Marco Ceresoli; Andrew B Peitzman; Liban Wehlie; Massimo Sartelli; Salomone Di Saverio; Luca Ansaloni Journal: World J Emerg Surg Date: 2017-08-18 Impact factor: 5.469
Authors: Federico Coccolini; Raul Coimbra; Carlos Ordonez; Yoram Kluger; Felipe Vega; Ernest E Moore; Walt Biffl; Andrew Peitzman; Tal Horer; Fikri M Abu-Zidan; Massimo Sartelli; Gustavo P Fraga; Enrico Cicuttin; Luca Ansaloni; Michael W Parra; Mauricio Millán; Nicola DeAngelis; Kenji Inaba; George Velmahos; Ron Maier; Vladimir Khokha; Boris Sakakushev; Goran Augustin; Salomone di Saverio; Emanuil Pikoulis; Mircea Chirica; Viktor Reva; Ari Leppaniemi; Vassil Manchev; Massimo Chiarugi; Dimitrios Damaskos; Dieter Weber; Neil Parry; Zaza Demetrashvili; Ian Civil; Lena Napolitano; Davide Corbella; Fausto Catena Journal: World J Emerg Surg Date: 2020-03-30 Impact factor: 5.469