Engineered Mott ground state in a LaTiO(3+δ)/LaNiO3 heterostructure.

In pursuit of creating cuprate-like electronic and orbital structures, artificial heterostructures based on LaNiO3 have inspired a wealth of exciting experimental and theoretical results. However, to date there is a very limited experimental understanding of the electronic and orbital states emerging from interfacial charge transfer and their connections to the modified band structure at the interface. Towards this goal, we have synthesized a prototypical superlattice composed of a correlated metal LaNiO3 and a doped Mott insulator LaTiO(3+δ), and investigated its electronic structure by resonant X-ray absorption spectroscopy combined with X-ray photoemission spectroscopy, electrical transport and theory calculations. The heterostructure exhibits interfacial charge transfer from Ti to Ni sites, giving rise to an insulating ground state with orbital polarization and e(g) orbital band splitting. Our findings demonstrate how the control over charge at the interface can be effectively used to create exotic electronic, orbital and spin states.

Understanding and controlling the interactions between charge, spin, orbital and structural degrees of freedom in transition-metal oxides is at the centre of modern condensed matter physics123. In recent years, inspired by the tremendously successful research on physics and applications of ultra-thin semiconductor heterostructures, multilayers of correlated complex oxides have become a platform of choice to generate the emergent electronic and magnetic states, unattainable in the bulk compounds4567891011121314. The inherent many-body nature of the correlated states, however, raises many fundamental questions that demand experimental validation and expansibility about the applicability of the concepts and formulas developed for semiconductor heterointerfaces6. Recent experimental work on complex oxide interfaces567891011121314 revealed a remarkable importance of the electronic configurations of partially filled d-shell transition-metal ions for understanding the emerging many-body phenomena123, including the Ti 3d1 configuration in the SrTiO3-based two-dimensional electron gases5, Cu 3d9L configuration in the orbitally and magnetically reconstructed states at the manganate-cuprates interfaces (here L denotes a ligand hole on the oxygen ion)615 and Ni 3d8L configuration in self-doped and orbitally polarized nickelate heterojunctions2616171819. To induce a specific electronic configuration at the interface, charge transfer (or electron doping) has been proven to be a particularly powerful tool to achieve this goal202122. Even more so than in the doped semiconductors23242526, charge transfer with strong electron–electron correlations and frustrated spin and orbital interactions at the interface may give rise to unexpected collective quantum states not attainable with semiconductor heterojunctions456. Understanding the mechanism of charge redistribution between layers of Mott materials and the implications of a specific electron reconfiguration arising from the charge transfer is therefore of a great necessity towards the rational design of applications based on strongly correlated electrons6202122.

In semiconductor heterostrutures, the charge transfer can be successfully rationalized in terms of single-electron energy states to profile the energy band bending and the band alignments across the interface2627. Following this notion, we recap that within the class of complex oxides with 3d electrons there are two types of Mott insulating behaviour parameterized in the Zaanen–Sawatzky–Allen scheme by the relative magnitude of on-site Coulomb repulsion energy Udd between d-shell electrons versus charge-transfer energy ΔCT between oxygen p-shell and the TM d-state28; based on this, one can distinguish between Mott–Hubbard insulators (MHI, Udd<ΔCT) and charge-transfer insulators or charge-transfer metals (CTM, Udd>ΔCT)12. To date, the vast majority of experimental and theoretical work has been focused on charge doping at the interfaces between MHI and MHI2930, and MHI and normal metal31323334. Some of the most remarkable physical phenomena such as high-TC superconductivity and colossal magnetoresistance, however, are observed in charge-transfer compounds characterized by the strong hybridization between oxygen 2p and transition metal 3d states, complex electronic configurations (for example, mixing between d and dL states) and small or even negative charge excitation gap ΔCT (refs 1, 2, 28, 35). In these materials, the role of the lower Hubbard band is replaced by the oxygen states, which in turn implies a very asymmetric physical character for the doped holes (mainly in oxygen levels) and doped electrons (mainly in transition metal d levels), for example, correlated metal LaNiO3 (LNO). With the original motivation to create a cuprate-like electronic and orbital structures63637, LNO-based perovskite heterostructures have attracted continuous interest616171819202122383940414243 in spite of the intriguing bulk properties of charge-transfer materials. However, experimentally very little is known about the Mott carrier redistribution and their electronic reconfigurations at the heterointerface between MHI and CTM202122.

Towards this goal, we have synthesized and investigated a prototypical MHI/CTM heterostructure (2 u.c. LaTiO3+/2 u.c. LaNiO3) × 10 (2LTO/2LNO thereafter, u.c.=unit cells, δ∼0.34 is the concentration of oxygen excess from the ideal Ti3+ state). The resulting 2LTO/2LNO heterostructure exhibits an exotic Mott ground state. To quantify this phenomenon, we investigated the interfacial charge transfer from Ti to Ni sites and the reconstruction of the electronic structure by resonant soft X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) at Ti, Ni L2,3− and O K-edges combined with X-ray photoemission spectroscopy (XPS), electrical transport and first-principles calculations. X-ray linear dichroism (XLD) spectroscopy was carried out to reveal the orbital polarization and unexpected Ni e band splitting. Our findings highlight how the control over charge at the interface can be effectively used to create exotic electronic, orbital and spin states.

Results

Interfacial charge transfer

As shown in Fig. 1, driven by the difference between Fermi levels EF or chemical potentials in constituent layers across the junction 2LTO/2LNO (see Fig. 1a and Supplementary Fig. 1), in a conventional view the charge redistributes near the interface. As the components of 2LTO/2LNO superlattice (SL), the electronic configuration of CTM LaNi3+O3 is a mixture of low-spin 3d7 and high-spin 3d8L states with the Fermi energy passing though the strongly mixed Ni–O valence states4445, whereas as an archetypal MHI (∼0.2 eV gap) bulk LaTi3+O3 has only one electron (3d1) occupying the lower Hubbard band4647 and its Fermi energy level EF is much higher than that of LNO (∼2 eV difference)48, as schematically shown in Fig. 1b. By aligning the interfacial bands with respect to the continuing oxygen p states on either side of the interface2049, the resulting Ti 3d band energy position becomes significantly higher than the Fermi energy of the LNO; this in turn implies a one-way charge redistribution from the Ti 3d band of LTO into the partially filled Ni d and O p states of LNO. Recent density functional theory (DFT+U) calculations20 further tested this naive picture and suggested a full electron charge transfer, that is, Ti d1+Ni d7→Ti d0+Ni d8 (Fig. 1c). On the other hand, as the experimental electronic configuration of LNO is a mixture of Ni d7 and d8L states, the charge transfer may also result in the appearance of additional interfacial electronic states, that is, Ti d1+Ni d8L→Ti d0+Ni d8 and Ti d1+Ni d8L→Ti d0+Ni d9L.

Figure 1

Crystal and band structures of 2LTO/2LNO.

(a) Schematic view of the atomic arrangement. Sketch of the energy bands before (b) and after (c) the formation of 2LTO/2LNO interface. The cyan solid arrows in a,b indicate the direction of interfacial charge transfer (electron, e−1) from Ti to Ni sites. Here, E (or E), charge gap between the highest occupied state (a mixture of oxygen 2p and Ni 3d states20) and the bottom of empty Ti 3d (or Ni 3d) state; ΔTi−Ni, relative energy difference between empty Ti and Ni 3d states; LHB, lower Hubbard band; UHB, upper Hubbard band.

To investigate the experimental veracity of the theory, we measured the electronic structures of Ti and Ni, to track the charge transfer by element-specific XAS in total fluorescence yield mode (with the bulk probing depth) and by in-situ XPS. As seen in Fig. 2a, the features of the Ti L2,3-edge in the 2LTO/2LNO sample show excellent agreement with the Ti4+ charge and are remarkably different from the spectra of Ti3+. This result provides a strong evidence for the occurrence of the charge-transfer Ti d(1−2→Ti d0 and implies that almost all of the t2 electrons from Ti sites are transferred elsewhere. The flow of the charge is further verified by the complimentary XAS measurements at the Ni L2,3-edge, which clearly shows a strong increase of the Ni charge state, that is, Ni d7→Ni d(8−2 (see Fig. 2b). A comparison with the bulk reference spectra of Ni2+ (double peaks at ∼870.2 and 871.2 eV) and Ni3+ (single main peak at ∼871.6 eV) attests that in the 2LTO/2LNO SL the Ni final state is indeed a mixture of Ni2+/Ni3+ (double peaks), which is also affirmed by the calculated XAS lineshape dependence on the Ni electronic configuration (see Supplementary Fig. 2). To further corroborate these findings, the interfacial charge-transfer phenomenon was studied by measuring the core-level electronic structures of Ti and Ni with in-situ XPS (see Supplementary Fig. 3); as determined by XPS, the resulting charge states of Ni and Ti in the 2LTO/2LNO sample are in excellent agreement with those obtained by XAS at Ti L2,3- and Ni L2,3-edges. Moreover, as revealed by the angle-dependent (ex situ) XPS (see Supplementary Fig. 4), the pronounced Ni2+ peak near the interface of metallic 2LTO/8LNO (see Supplementary Fig. 5) further confirmed the interfacial charge transfer from Ti to Ni sites.

Figure 2

XAS of 2LTO/2LNO.

(a) Ti L2,3-edge. The reference spectra for Ti4+ and Ti3+ were measured on a SrTi4+O3 single crystal and YTi3+O3 film (∼100 nm on TbScO3 substrate59), respectively. (b) Ni L2,3-edge. The reference samples are bulk Ni2+O and LaNi3+O3. Out-of-plane (I(c), dark blue solid line, E || c and E is the linear polarization vector of the photon) and in-plane (I(ab), dark blue dashed line, E || ab) linearly polarized X-ray were used to measure XAS of 2LTO/2LNO at Ni L2,3-edge. Black dashed lines are guidelines for peak positions. All spectra were collected and repeated more than two times with bulk-sensitive total fluorescence yield (TFY) detection mode at room temperature.

Electronic reconstruction

With the confirmed large interfacial charge transfer from Ti to Ni sites, an important question arises: how does the interfacial charge transfer alter the fundamental physical properties (that is, electronic configuration and band structure) of the 2LTO/2LNO SL? First, we discussed the emergent electronic configuration. As mentioned above, the channels of interfacial charge-transfer Ti d1+Ni d7→Ti d0+Ni d8 and Ti d1+Ni d8L→Ti d0+Ni d8 are both open at the interface. Experimentally, owing to the strong hybridization between Ni 3d states and oxygen 2p states at the Fermi level, XAS at O K-edge becomes another important way to probe the charge states of Ni and Ti mixed with ligand holes. As seen in Fig. 3a and Supplementary Fig. 6, in 2LTO/2LNO the oxygen K-edge spectra clearly show a characteristic low-energy pre-peak at ∼528.5 eV, which arises from the ligand holes18. In sharp contrast, a direct comparison with the LTO and LNO reference samples immediately shows that the pre-peak at the 2LTO/2LNO interface is strongly suppressed due to the filling oxygen ligand holes with the transferred electrons from Ti sites (also see Supplementary Fig. 6). Based on the absence of the pre-peak feature in the LaTi3+O3 and Ni2+O reference samples, these data imply that the strong suppression of the pre-peak intensity results from the filling of holes on oxygen by the interfacial charge transfer into the Ni d-band. As a result, this process induces the formation of the d8 state and the strong suppression of the d8L configuration. In addition, we point out at the expected difference between the theory (full charge transfer of one electron)20 and the experimental observation of less than one electron transfer, that is, (1−2δ) electron; the observed deviation from the full charge transfer in theory is due to the reduced electron filling from unity, 2δ of the Ti d-band. Combined with the mixed d7 and d8L ground state of bulk LNO, this factor results in the observed peculiar electronic configuration of d8, d7 and d8L states, which appears at the interfacial NiO2 layer in 2LTO/2LNO.

Figure 3

Oxygen K-edge spectra and electrical transport of 2LTO/2LNO.

(a) Normalized XAS spectra at O K-edge. The black dashed lines indicate the assignments of three key features: the pre-peak (∼528.5 eV) and hybridized Ti 3d-O (∼530.5 eV) and Ni e−O (∼531.8 eV) states by comparing with the spectra of four reference samples LaNi3+O3 film (10 u.c. on SrTiO3 substrate), bulk LaNi3+O3, LaTi3+O3 film (20 u.c. on TbScO3 substrate59) and bulk Ni2+O (the data of NiO was adapted from ref. 60). (b) Temperature-dependent sheet resistances of the SL 2LTO/2LNO and the reference LaNiO3 film (20 u.c.). It is noteworthy that the sheet resistance of LNO film is × 200. Inset: resulting fit of the conductance of 2LTO/2LNO (black solid line) yielding an activation gap E∼0.2±0.01 eV (ref. 61).

Next, we discuss the reconstructed band structure at the interface. Because of the observed strong reconstruction of electronic configuration, it is natural to anticipate a similarly strong modification of the band structure near the interface. As predicted by the theory20 and illustrated in Fig. 1c, two opening gaps E and ΔTi−Ni are expected to appear at the interface. First, we estimated a magnitude of the charge gap E by measuring the temperature-dependent electrical transport properties of the 2LTO/2LNO and LNO reference films. As immediately seen in Fig. 3b, the LNO thin film grown at the same conditions as the SL shows a metallic bulk-like behaviour (∼280 Ω per □ at 2 K) from room temperature down to 2 K. In sharp contrast, the SL 2LTO/2LNO displays a highly insulating behaviour with a very large sheet resistance increasing from ∼175 kΩ per □ at 300 K to ∼1 MΩ per □ at 200 K, exceeding the measurement range of the transport setup. This insulating behaviour of the 2LTO/2LNO implies the charge excitations gap opening in 2LTO/2LNO. The resulting fit to the transport data shown in inset of Fig. 3b yields a value of E∼0.20±0.01 eV; this is in a accord with the theoretical prediction of the ∼0.4 eV charge-transfer gap20.

Next, we estimate the value of the gap ΔTi−Ni between empty Ti t2 and Ni e bands by measuring XAS of the 2LTO/2LNO film at O K-edge. In a simple ionic model, the configuration of oxygen is O 1s22s22p6 and thus the transition 1s→2p is blocked in the absorption process, because it is a fully occupied 2p shell for the O ion. In real materials, however, owing to the strong hybridization the covalent bonding between the transition metal ion and oxygen can introduce a sizable spectral weight of oxygen 2p character in the total unoccupied density of states50515253. As a result, O K-edge XAS provides a complimentary way to probe the relative energy position of the TM ion. We also point out that in comparison with the L2,3-edge XAS reflecting the absorption process for the specific TM ion, O K-edge provides a convenient way to measure the relative energy position of the unoccupied bands of both TM ions (Ti and Ni) present in the 2LTO/2LNO heterostructure52. A direct comparison with the reference samples allows to assign the two peaks at ∼530.5 and ∼531.8 eV shown in Fig. 3a to the hybridized oxygen 2p with Ti 3d and Ni e bands, respectively, and then to extract the value of the Mott gap ΔTi−Ni∼1.3 eV. Assuming that the bandwidth of Ti 3d-O and Ni e-O bands is roughly the same (see Fig. 3a) and with the known value of E∼0.2 eV the estimated value of the correlated gap E=(E+ΔTi−Ni) is ∼1.5 eV, this value is in a remarkable agreement with the theoretically predicted value of ∼1.5 eV (ref. 20). The above observation of the two gaps opening in the excitation spectrum lends strong support to the notion of a strong modification of the band structure at the interface triggered by the redistribution of correlated charges. It is also noted that some additional contributions (for example, disorder effect, electron–electron interactions and charge/spin order)445455 may be involved in the enhanced carrier localization of 2LTO/2LNO. However, their contributions are not dominant in comparison with the large ∼1.5 eV correlated gap of 2LTO/2LNO. As demonstrated by the angle-dependent XPS on 2LTO/8LNO (see Supplementary Fig. 4), the formation of Ni2+ accompanied with the strongly suppressed density of states near the Fermi energy level is primarily driven by the interfacial charge transfer from Ti to Ni sites.

Orbital reconstruction

With the established strongly altered d-band filling on Ni and Ti, we investigated the orbital properties of these engineered states on Ni sites. To this end, the orbital polarization has been measured by XLD16181956 on several LNO-based hetrostructures and the result for the LTO/LNO SL is shown in Fig. 4a. Based on the measured electronic state of Ni, one can anticipate that contribution to the XLD signal on Ni L2-edge arises largely from the unoccupied Ni (I(ab)) and (I(c)) states. As illustrated in Fig. 4a, those orbital configurations can be probed with in-plane (E || ab, E is the polarization vector of the photon) and out-of-plane (E || c) linearly polarized photons, respectively. In a good agreement with this expectation, the XLD spectra shown in Fig. 4a show an ample degree of orbital polarization of ∼9.3% at L2-edge with the d-electron occupancy consistent with the first principle calculation prediction of ∼9% (see Calculation details in Methods).

Figure 4

Linear dichroism and reconstructed states.

(a) XLD (I(ab)−I(c)) of 2LTO/2LNO interface (extracted from Fig. 2b). Green (in-plane) and red (out-of-plane) arrows label the direction of linear polarization vector (E) of the photon. (b,c) XAS of 2LTO/2LNO at Ni L2,3-edge showing the Ni e band splitting (∼0.12 for L2 and 0.15 eV for L3, respectively) of (lower) and (higher) orbitals. Black dashed lines are guidelines for peak centre positions. (d,e) Sketch of the engineered electronic, orbital and spin states via interfacial charge transfer for bulk LNO18 and SL 2LTO/2LNO, respectively. In SL 2LTO/2LNO, it forms peculiar electronic configuration (Ni 3d7, 3d8 and 3d8L), orbital polarization and e band splitting (Δ e∼0.15 eV). Blue arrows indicate the spin configurations of Ni sites.

The surprising feature of the XLD data for 2LTO/2LNO is the presence of e band splitting (Fig. 4b,c) that was not observed in tensile-strained ultra-thin LNO films or SL (1 u.c.)LNO/(1 u.c.)LaAlO3 (refs 18, 19). It is noteworthy that the band splitting is generally estimated by the peak energy shift of XAS (between I(ab) and I(c)) with linearly polarized photons and the lineshape of XLD (I(ab)-I(c)) with multiple peak features does not infer the size of the band splitting directly. In the case of 2LTO/2LNO, however, small tensile strain of +1.04% causes the sizable e band splitting. Specifically, as seen in inset of Fig. 4b,c, a direct inspection of the energy position for in-plane (∼853.15 eV) and out-of-plane (∼853.0 eV) absorption curves reveal that the out-of-plane absorption is ∼0.15 eV (0.12 eV) lower in energy than the in-plane absorption at Ni L3(L2)-edge. The difference implies the e band splitting Δe∼0.15 eV between the states with Ni and orbital character, as schematically illustrated in Fig. 4d,e. This observation lends a strong support to that recently predicted by theory (see Calculation details in Methods), that both band splitting and orbital polarization arise from the structural distortions at the interface. The apical oxygen atom of out-of-plane Ni–O–Ti bond approaches Ti and leaves away from Ni atoms, whereas the in-plane Ni–O bond length is changed a little and smaller than the out-of-plane Ni–O bond length. This extended out-of-plane Ni–O bond leads to the lowering of Ni central band energy; on the other hand, it also obviously weakens the hybridization between O 2p and Ni bands with suppressed virtual electron hopping. Therefore, the larger hybridization between O 2p and Ni bands results in a higher electron occupancy at higher Ni (minority spin) orbital band , which is very unusual.

In conclusion, by synthesizing the 2LTO/2LNO interface as a prototypical system, we investigated the reconstruction of the local electronic structure on Ni and Ti at the interface between a doped MHI and a charge-transfer metal. Our findings reveal the occurrence of large charge transfer from the Ti to Ni sites across the interface that results in the unusual electronic configurations of Ni 3d electrons and lead to the strong modification of the band structure in the vicinity of the interface. In addition, the XLD data show the presence of the large orbital polarization and energy splitting of the Ni e band at the vicinity of the interface characteristic of the Jahn–Teller distortion absent in either bulk rare-earth nickelates or other ultra-thin LNO-based heterojunctions. We anticipate that these results will pave the way for follow-up theoretical and experimental work with other important classes of charge-transfer interfaces, to establish a discovery platform for exotic many-body quantum phenomena.

Methods

Experiment details

High-quality SLs (2LTO/nu.c. LNO) × 10 (n=2 and 8, 2LTO/2LNO and 2LTO/8LNO) and reference samples were epitaxially grown by pulsed laser deposition on 5 × 5 × 0.5 mm3 (001)-oriented single crystal substrates (LaAlO3)0.3−(Sr2AlTaO6)0.7 (cubic, a=3.87 Å), using a KrF excimer laser operating at λ=248 nm and 2 Hz pulse rate with 2 J cm−2 fluence. The layer-by-layer growth was monitored by in-situ high-pressure reflection high-energy electron diffraction (see Supplementary Fig. 1). To match the growth conditions for both LaTiO3+ and LNO, the SLs 2LTO/2LNO and 2LTO/8LNO were grown under oxygen pressure ∼50 mTorr and the temperature of the substrates was held at 580 °C during the growth. After growth, all samples were cooled at ∼15 °C min−1 rate to room temperature keeping oxygen pressure constant. A Mg anode was used for in-situ XPS measurements with double-pass cylindrical mirror analysers (STAIB Instruments) at room temperature, whereas for ex-situ angle-dependent XPS measurements with a hemispherical electron analyser an Al anode with monochromator (PHI VersaProbe II) was applied. The sheet resistances of the films were measured in van-der-Pauw geometry by Physical Properties Measurement System (Quantum Design) from 300 to 2 K. XAS/XLD with total fluorescence yield mode and X-ray diffraction measurements (room temperature) were carried out at the 4-ID-C and 6-ID-B beamlines, respectively, of the Advanced Photon Source (Argonne National Laboratory).

Calculation details

Calculated XAS at Ni L2,3- and O K-edges of rhombohedral (R-3cH space group) LNO57 were carried out with the finite difference method near-edge structure code58. In finite difference method near-edge structure calculations we used the full-multiplet scattering (Green function) mode with a large cluster radius of 6 Å around the absorbing Ni atom. The XAS calculations were performed for various Ni 3dL(7LNO (see Supplementary Fig. 2). To confirm the consistency of the calculated XAS spectra, we also performed XAS calculations using the multi-electron time-dependent DFT (+U) with an on-site Coulomb energy on Ni of 6 eV. On the other hand, in the calculation of SL 2LaTiO3/2LNO by the DFT+U method (UNi=6 eV and UTi=4 eV), the orbital polarization of unoccupied states is , where and are total electron occupancy (spin up plus spin down) with the and orbital characters of the e band, respectively; it is noteworthy that the central energy position of band is higher than that of the band (personal communication with A.J. Millis and H. Chen).

Additional information

How to cite this article: Cao, Y. et al. Engineered Mott ground state in LaTiO3+/LaNiO3 heterostructure. Nat. Commun. 7:10418 doi: 10.1038/ncomms10418 (2016).