Feasibility and Safety of Transcutaneous Vagus Nerve Stimulation Paired with Notched Music Therapy for the Treatment of Chronic Tinnitus.

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES: A recent study demonstrated that tinnitus could be eliminated by vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) paired with notched sounds in a rat tinnitus model. The aims of this clinical study were to investigate the effects and safety of transcutaneous VNS (tVNS) by patch-type electrode paired with notched music for treating chronic tinnitus. SUBJECTS AND METHODS: Thirty patients with refractory chronic tinnitus for >12 months were included in this study. A patch-type electrode was attached to the auricular concha of the patient's left ear and tVNS was performed for 30 min (pulse rate 25 Hz, pulse width 200 µs, and amplitude 1-10 mA) using a transcutaneous electric nerve stimulation eco2. During tVNS, the patients listened to notched music cleared of the frequency spectrum corresponding to the tinnitus with a 0.5 octave notch width.
RESULTS: After 10 treatment sessions, 15/30 patients (50%) reported symptom relief in terms of a global improvement questionnaire. The mean tinnitus loudness (10-point scale) and the mean tinnitus awareness score (%) improved significantly from 6.32±2.06 to 5.16±1.52 and from 82.40±24.37% to 65.60±28.15%, respectively (both p<0.05). None of the patients had any specific side effects, such as changes in heart rate or blood pressure.
CONCLUSIONS: This study has demonstrated the feasibility and safety of tVNS paired with notched music therapy in patients with chronic tinnitus, with the use of a pad-type electrode attached to the auricular concha.

Introduction

Neuromodulation by vagus nerve stimulation (VNS) stimulates the cholinergic nucleus basalis, generating powerful and prolonged changes in cortical organization [1]. Therefore, electrical stimulation of the vagus nerve could increase alertness [23], and enhance the recovery of motor and cognitive functions in animal models of traumatic brain injury [4]. VNS has been used to treat a variety of maladaptive neuronal plasticity disorders such as epilepsy, depression, and chronic pain [234]. There is abundant data showing the safety of cervical vagal nerve stimulation using implanted electrodes, and the United States Food and Drug Administration has approved VNS for the treatment for drug-resistant epilepsy and depression.

Maladaptive neuronal plasticity of the central auditory system triggered by preceding cochlear damage is a general neurophysiologic model that can explain selective tinnitus following cochlear damage. Reduced signal transduction from damaged hair cells may cause a reduction in the lateral inhibition of the central auditory system, followed by increased synchronous firing or spontaneous activity in the auditory neurons at the edge of the characteristic frequency [56]. Therefore, the onset of tinnitus is dependent on the plastic changes in the central auditory system induced by deafferentation rather than the degree of end-organ damage. In this context, neuromodulation by VNS has emerged as a new treatment option for tinnitus. In fact, in recent years, various other neuromodulation strategies have been used to treat tinnitus, including transcranial magnetic stimulation of the auditory cortex or cingulate cortex, transcranial direct current stimulation, transcutaneous electric nerve stimulation (TENS), and implantation of electrodes into the auditory cortex [78910]. However, these approaches only temporarily disrupted ongoing activity and did not provide long-term control of tinnitus.

A new therapeutic concept of neuromodulation in which VNS is paired with a specific tone was recently reported [11]. The authors demonstrated that pairing brief pulses of cervical VNS with a variety of tones that excluding the tinnitus frequency had the effect of increased frequency selectivity and decreased synchronization, and completely eliminated tinnitus in noise-exposed rats. However, surgical implantation of an electrode into the neck to treat tinnitus is a difficult procedure in human owing to its invasiveness, surgical risks, and high costs. Moreover, side effects such as disturbed cardiac rhythm or coughing may occur during stimulation. Therefore, transcutaneous VNS (tVNS) is emerging as an alternative treatment option. Transcutaneous electrical stimulation of the cutaneous branch of the vagus nerve, also called Arnold's nerve, in the external ear was proposed as an alternative, non-invasive modality for VNS [12]. A functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) and electroencephalography (EEG) study revealed that the central vagal pathway could be stimulated by tVNS [1314]. In the current study, we used tVNS instead of cervical VNS and aimed to investigate the effects and safety of tVNS by the patch-type electrode paired with notched music for treating refractory chronic tinnitus.

Subjects and Methods

Patients

Thirty patients (21 males, 9 females, mean age 58.47±15.85 years) with idiopathic subjective tinnitus were included in this study. Patients were eligible if they met the following criteria: 1) symptom duration of >12 months; 2) discomfort affecting their daily lives; 3) ongoing symptoms refractory to pharmacotherapy or tinnitus-retraining therapy; 4) consistent tinnitus frequency measured by pitch matching in three tests performed on different days; 5) no history of otologic disease; 6) no history of ototoxic drug use; 7) no accompanying retrocochlear tumor, otitis media, or Meniere's disease; and 8) no history of temporomandibular joint or cervical problems. All of the patients underwent audiologic tests including pure-tone audiometry, tinnitus pitch matching, loudness matching, impedance audiometry, auditory brainstem response tests, and otoacoustic emission tests. Tinnitus pitch matching was performed three times on different days, and we excluded patients whose pitch matching data were not consistent in all three tests. We excluded patients with subjective tinnitus accompanied by sudden sensorineural hearing loss of ≥30 dB on three contiguous audiometric frequencies in <72 h. We also excluded patients who were suspected of having objective tinnitus or somatic tinnitus based on physical examination of the head and neck. Electrocardiograms and blood pressure were measured to exclude patients with possible cardiac problems, and we excluded patients with cardiac arrhythmia or asthma because these may present safety issues for VNS.

Of the 30 patients, 22 had unilateral tinnitus and 8 had bilateral tinnitus. In patients with unilateral tinnitus, the right ear was affected in 13 patients and the left ear was affected in 9 patients. Before treatment, the mean pure-tone average was 29.50±18.22 dB HL for the right ear and 32.83±25.51 dB HL for the left ear. This study was approved by the Institutional Review Board of the Eulji Medical Center, South Korea (MD_IRB_2015-12).

Electrical and sound stimuli

Each patient underwent a total of 10 sessions (30 min/session), and each session was performed at intervals of 1-4 days depending on the patient's condition. The patch-type electrode was attached to the auricular concha of the left ear and tVNS was performed for 30 min (pulse rate 25 Hz, pulse width 200 µs, and intensity 1-10 mA) using a TENS eco2 (Schwa-medico, Ehringshausen, Germany). We attached a silicon electrical pad (2 cm in diameter) as closely as possible to the concha and outer part of the external meatus. The intensities of stimuli used in each session were set at the highest levels the patient could endure. During tVNS, the patients listened to tailored notched music after removal of the frequency spectrum corresponding to the tinnitus at a 1/2 octave notch width. The patients selected their favorite piece of music from four samples of classical music.

Outcome measures

The patients completed four different questionnaires before treatment and again immediately after the end of the 10th session. Subjective improvements in tinnitus were measured by determining the changes in the following four variables: 1) global improvement (GI) index in subjective tinnitus severity (Table 1) [15]; 2) Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) of tinnitus loudness (a 10-point scale where 0=no tinnitus and 10=the loudest tinnitus imaginable); 3) tinnitus awareness score (patients were asked to describe the percentage of time aware of tinnitus over 1 day at intervals of 10%); and 4) Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI) [16]. Thirty patients completed the GI index after treatment, 25 patients completed the VAS of tinnitus loudness and tinnitus awareness score after treatment because 5 patients did not take the pre-treatment questionnaires, and 24 patients completed the THI after treatment because one more patient refused to reply to the pretreatment THI.

Table 1

Global improvement in tinnitus severity

Statistical analyses

Data were analyzed using SPSS statistical software (SPSS, version 22.0 for Windows; SPSS Inc., Chicago, IL, USA). Wilcoxon's signed-ranks test were used to compare the pre- and post-treatment mean VAS of tinnitus loudness, mean tinnitus awareness score, and mean THI score. To determine which factors could influence symptom improvement, multiple linear regression analyses of the post-treatment GI index were performed with various factors: pure-tone average of the affected side, tinnitus duration, initial VAS of tinnitus loudness, initial tinnitus awareness score, and initial THI. Correlations between the time to symptom relief in terms of the number of treatment sessions and the variables of GI index, the improvement (post score-pre score) in VAS of the tinnitus loudness, tinnitus awareness score, and THI were analyzed using Pearson's correlation coefficient.

Results

Characteristics of tinnitus

The mean duration of tinnitus was 42.40±45.64 months (range 12-240 months), and other characteristics of tinnitus and patients are listed in Table 2. In cases of bilateral tinnitus, characteristics of dominant side were included.

Table 2

Characteristics of tinnitus in all patients

In cases of bilateral tinnitus, characteristics of dominant side were included. *tinnitus awareness score is defined as the percentage of the time the patient is aware of tinnitus for a day. THI: Tinnitus Handicap Inventory, VAS: Visual Analogue Scale, BDI: Beck Depression Inventory

GI index

When improvement was defined as GI ≥ grade 5, of the 30 patients with refractory chronic tinnitus, 15 patients (50%) reported symptom relief in terms of the GI index after 10 treatment sessions. In these 15 patients, the mean time to symptom relief was 4.60th±3.20 sessions (range 1-10 sessions) (Table 3). However, no one reported complete elimination of tinnitus. The mean GI index was 4.63±0.89, and 6/30 patients (20.0%) reported "somewhat better" in symptoms (grade 6), 9/30 patients (30.0%) reported "marginally better" (grade 5), 13/30 patients (43.3%) reported "same" (grade 4), and 2/30 patients (6.6%) reported "marginally worse" (grade 3) in symptoms, as shown in Fig. 1.

Table 3

Treatment results in individual questionnaires

*time to symptom relief in terms of the number of treatment sessions in 15 subjects who reported symptom relief in the GI index. VAS: Visual Analogue Scale, GI: global improvement, ND: not determined

Fig. 1

Global improvement (GI) index and change in Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) of tinnitus loudness (10-point), tinnitus awareness score (TAS, %), and Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI) score immediately after the end of the 10th session. Of the 30 patients, 15 patients reported an improvement in symptom (grade 5 and 6), 13 patients reported no change (grade 4), and 2 patients reported mild worsening of symptoms (grade 3). In 16/25 patients (64.0%), the VAS of tinnitus loudness decreased (i.e., improved), five patients (20.0%) reported no change in subjective loudness and 4 patients (16.0%) reported an increase in loudness. The tinnitus awareness score decreased (i.e., improved) in 13/25 patients (52.0%), was unchanged in 8/25 patients (32.0%), and increased in 4/25 patients (16.0%). The THI score decreased from baseline to after treatment in 11/24 patients (45.8%), was unchanged in 3 patients (12.5%), and worsened in 10 patients (41.7%).

Changes in subjective tinnitus loudness

Twenty-five patients completed the follow-up questionnaire on subjective tinnitus loudness. The mean VAS of tinnitus loudness decreased significantly (i.e., improved) from 6.32±2.06 at baseline to 5.16±1.52 after tVNS paired with notched music therapy (p=0.005). In 16/25 patients (64.0%), the VAS of tinnitus loudness decreased from baseline to after tVNS, with a change from pre-treatment to post-treatment (post score-pre score) of -4 in 3 patients, -3 in 3 patients, -2 in 4 patients, and -1 in 6 patients. Five patients (20.0%) reported no change in subjective loudness and 4 patients (16.0%) reported an increase in loudness (+1 in 3 patient and +3 in 1 patients) (Fig. 1).

Changes in subjective tinnitus awareness

Twenty-five patients completed the follow-up questionnaire on subjective tinnitus awareness. The mean tinnitus awareness score (%) decreased significantly from 82.40±24.37% at baseline to 65.60±28.15% after treatment (p=0.020). The tinnitus awareness score decreased (i.e., improved) in 13/25 patients (52.0%), was unchanged in 8/25 patients (32.0%), and increased in 4/25 patients (16.0%) (Fig. 1). The mean change in the tinnitus awareness score in the 13 patients who reported a reduction in this variable was 41.54±21.15% (range 10-80%).

Changes in THI score

Twenty-four patients completed the THI after treatment. Although the mean THI score decreased from 41.50±29.64 at baseline to 35.46±23.30 after treatment, this change was not statistically significant (p=0.339). The THI score decreased from baseline to after treatment in 11/24 patients (45.8%), was unchanged in 3 patients (12.5%), and worsened in 10 patients (41.7%) (Fig. 1).

Multiple linear regression analyses

About 45.7% of R2 for the model was explained by clinically relevant factors including pure-tone average of the affected side, duration, initial VAS of tinnitus loudness, initial tinnitus awareness score, and initial THI. The GI index after treatment, as the outcome variables for symptom improvement, was significantly associated with only tinnitus (p=0.007) (Table 4).

Table 4

Multiple linear regression analyses of various factors and global improvement after tinnitus treatment

*p<0.05. PTA: pure-tone average, VAS: Visual Analogue Scale, THI: Tinnitus Handicap Inventory

Correlation analyses

Fig. 2 shows that the time to symptom relief was not significantly correlated with the improvement (post score-pre score) in initial VAS of the tinnitus loudness, tinnitus awareness score, and THI, or with the GI index in the 15 patients who reported improvements in their symptoms (all p>0.05).

Fig. 2

Time to symptom relief was not significantly correlated with the improvement (post score-pre score) in Visual Analogue Scale (VAS) of the tinnitus loudness, tinnitus awareness score (TAS), and Tinnitus Handicap Inventory (THI), or with the global improvement (GI) index in the 15 patients who reported improvements in their symptoms (all p>0.05).

Safety

None of the patients experienced specific side effects, such as changes in their heart rate or blood pressure.

Discussion

In this study, we enrolled patients with idiopathic subjective tinnitus lasting for >12 months (mean 42.40±45.64 months) despite conventional therapies, including pharmacotherapy or tinnitus retraining therapy. After 10 sessions of tVNS paired with notched music, the GI index, which consists of eight grades reflecting the overall change in subjective symptom severity, improved in 50% of the patients. The mean tinnitus loudness and awareness scores also improved significantly after treatment.

Many previous studies reported that maximal improvement rates from the placebo effect were 30% to 40% when using various questionnaires [171819]. In the current study, the improvement rates were 50%, 64%, and 52% in GI index, subjective tinnitus loudness and tinnitus awareness respectively, and all of them far exceeded 40% of the maximal placebo effect. On the basis of this fact, we believe that tVNS paired with notched music has a high possibility of a therapeutic effect exceeding the placebo effect in patients with refractory chronic tinnitus, although we did not compare to controls. The only variable that was not significantly improved was the THI score, which may be due to the relatively short study duration. Because we enrolled patients with refractory chronic tinnitus, it may take longer to observe a significant reduction in the THI score. Additionally, the THI comprises several questions covering functional, emotional, and catastrophic subscales, which are more complex than the questions in the other questionnaires.

A recent animal study laid the foundation for using VNS with tone to treat tinnitus [11]. The authors reported that pairing a brief burst of VNS with a 9 kHz or 19 kHz tone in normal rats significantly increased the fraction of the primary auditory cortex site responding to these frequencies. This implies that the combined tones could lead the VNS-induced neural responses to the exact tonotopic maps in the auditory cortex, and concentrate the effects of VNS to the target region. They demonstrated restoration of the distorted tonotopic maps in the auditory cortex and elimination of tinnitus under behavioral observation in all cases. Unlike the animal study [11], all patients did not get the benefit in the current study. We could expect several reasons for the difference. One of the reasons could be the difference of onset time of treatment (over 12 months after tinnitus in our subjects vs. 4 weeks after noise exposure to make tinnitus in the animal study). Indeed, several studies demonstrated that early onset of neuromodulation made better results [2021]. Another possible reason is the difference of device for VNS (tVNS in our study vs. direct cervical stimulation via surgically implanted electrode in the animal study). Moreover, the rat received more intensive treatment, 2.5 hours per day for 20 day than our treatment. The inter-species characteristic could be another possible reason. De Ridder, et al. [22] have tried cervical VNS with an implanted electrode to treat tinnitus in humans, and they also demonstrated only 40% (4/10 patients) improvement rate.

Although none of the cases showed complete remission of their tinnitus, this is unsurprising because tVNS paired with notched music therapy is intended to gradually correct the maladapted neuronal plasticity in the central auditory system. It is possible that the symptoms would have been cured if the patients received more treatment sessions or if they were followed up for longer. Multiple regression analyses showed that the duration of symptoms was the most important and only factor associated with the overall change in subjective symptom severity (i.e., GI index). In other words, we could predict that the efficacy of the treatment protocol is better in patients with shorter duration of symptoms.

Two patients (6.6%) reported mild worsening of symptoms in terms of the GI index. In 4/25 patients (16.0%), including both patients who reported worsening of symptoms on the GI index, an increase in tinnitus loudness was reported after treatment. In addition, another 4 patients (16.0%) reported an increase in tinnitus awareness. This indicates that tVNS paired with notched music therapy could have adverse effects on tinnitus in some patients, although the severity of symptom worsening was not severe.

Ventureyra originally proposed a new concept for tVNS rather than direct nerve stimulation via an implanted cervical electrode to control seizures [23]. Fallgatter, et al. [24] demonstrated the feasibility of a non-invasive technique targeting the sensory auricular branch of the vagus nerve by recording sensory-evoked potentials originating from the brainstem of healthy patients. A subsequent fMRI study revealed that tVNS robustly increased the blood oxygenation level in various cortical regions relating with emotion, and tVNS started to be applied for the treatment affective disorders [13]. Like neuromodulation for the treatment of affective disorders, tVNS paired with notched music is predicted to correct maladapted neural plasticity in the auditory cortex by decreasing central synchronization or increasing lateral inhibition in deafferentiated cortical regions.

In the current study, none of the patients experienced any specific side effects, including changes in heart rate or blood pressure. Although tVNS is expected to selectively stimulate the afferent fibers of the vagus nerve, it may stimulate efferent fibers, which could result in potentially dangerous events such as cardiac bradycardia or hypotension. Because the efferent fibers of the vagus nerve are more likely to be located on the right side, some researchers have recommended that the electrode should be placed on the left side [2526]. For this reason, we placed the electrode on the left auricular concha in all of the patients, regardless of the affected side. We believe that left auricular stimulation can modulate the bilateral auditory cortex via central decussation of the auditory tract covering either side of the lesion. Electrocardiogram and blood pressure were assessed before starting treatment to exclude patients with potential cardiac problems. Patients with asthma were also excluded from our study. An earlier study examining the safety of tVNS also confirmed it had no side effects on heart rhythm for up to 24 weeks of treatment, although two adverse cardiac events, which were very unlikely to be caused by tVNS, occurred in that study [27].

Notched music plays an important role as a carrier to transfer the electrical stimulation of the vagus nerve to the target area (i.e., auditory cortex). Okamoto, et al. [28] reported that listening to spectrally notched music in which a frequency band with a one octave width centered on the individual tinnitus frequency can reduce subjective tinnitus loudness, and evoked activity in the auditory cortex area corresponding to the patient's tinnitus frequency. Audio therapy using music excluding the spectrum corresponding to the tinnitus frequency seems to be a reasonable approach. Because the cortical areas characterized by less lateral inhibition may generate tinnitus via overstimulation or synchronization of neural activity, the target area should be spared from audio stimuli. Instead, it seems reasonable that stimulating the neighboring frequency area of the auditory cortex could induce lateral inhibition of the tinnitus-affected area, and alleviate the tinnitus. However, we do not know the ideal width of the notch yet. If the notch is too wide, it might decrease the effectiveness of lateral inhibition of the target area in the auditory cortex. By contrast, if the notch is too narrow, it might stimulate the tinnitus-generating area. One study has compared the therapeutic effects of notched music with bandwidths of 0.5, 1, and 1.5 octaves, and the best results were obtained with the 0.5 octave bandwidth [29]. Therefore, we used a 0.5 octave notch bandwidth in our study. Because it is essential to determine the precise tinnitus frequency to prepare music with a 0.5 octave notch, we excluded patients with inconsistent pitchmatching results in tests performed on 3 days. Further studies would have been necessary to determine the ideal notch width in such patients.

Polak, et al. [14] suggested that the optimal stimulation intensity of tVNS that did not elicit pain was 8 mA, as determined by vagus somatosensory-evoked potentials measured across the scalp. Another study recommended low-frequency stimuli for treating tinnitus, and suggested that frequencies >100 Hz should be avoided [30]. Considering these studies, we used alternating currents with a frequency of 25 Hz and the stimulus intensity was set at the highest level that the patient could endure. The current intensity varied from 1 to 10 mA among patients, and also varied between sessions in individual patients. Generally, the amplitude tended to increase over time. However, the maximum intensity of the electrical stimulation and the difference between the minimum and maximum intensities were not correlated with the GI index in multiple regression analysis. Because the optimal conditions differ among individual laboratories, further studies are needed to determine the optimal conditions for electrical stimulation.

Lehtimäki, et al. [31] reported a successful pilot study of tVNS using a clip-type electrode attached to the patient's left tragus. The mean tinnitus questionnaire score decreased (i.e., improved) following treatment. The auricular branch of the vagus nerve passes through the tympanomastoid fissure and is distributed along part of the skin on the cranial surface of the auricle and posterior part of the external auditory meatus [12]. Therefore, clip-type stimulators attached to the tragus may not cover enough of the area innervated by Arnold's nerve. To address this deficiency, we attached a soft and flexible adhesive electrical pad to the curved skin of the auricle. We believe that our system can stimulate more cutaneous branches of the vagus nerve than does a clip-type electrode. However, vagus nerve branches in the ear canal could not be stimulated using the patch electrode. We might expect to see greater therapeutic effects by using a customized electrode manufactured to fit the individual patient's ear canal and auricle.

The current study has several limitations. First, it is a single-group, uncontrolled pilot study. Therefore, a follow-up study with a control group is needed to confirm the effectiveness of the therapeutic approach used here. Second, we did not use objective tools, such as neuroimaging or electrophysiological studies (e.g., fMRI, EEG, or magnetoencephalogram) to assess the changes in neural activity. Instead, we used patient-reported questionnaires to evaluate the therapeutic outcomes. Third, this study was relatively short, because the outcomes were measured after 10 treatment session. The longer-term outcomes of tVNS paired with notched music therapy are still unclear.

Conclusion

In this study, we evaluated the feasibility and safety of tVNS paired with notched music therapy to treat patients with refractory chronic tinnitus. tVNS was applied using a pad-type electrode attached to the auricular concha. This therapeutic approach reduced subjective symptom severity, tinnitus intensity, and tinnitus awareness in some of the patients. tVNS is unlikely to elicit unwanted side effects if patients with cardiac arrhythmia or asthma are excluded before treatment, and if the left auricular concha is selectively stimulated.