| Literature DB >> 26770768 |
Gregory Hansen1, Ari R Joffe2, Stephen M Bowman3, Lawrence Richer2.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: It remains uncertain whether nonconvulsive seizures and nonconvulsive status epilepticus in pediatric traumatic brain injury are deleterious to the brain and/or impact the recovery from injury. Consequently, optimal electroencephalographic surveillance and management is unknown. We aimed to determine specialists' opinion regarding the detection and treatment of nonconvulsive seizures or nonconvulsive status epilepticus in pediatric traumatic brain injury, regardless of their practice.Entities:
Keywords: Nonconvulsive seizures; children; nonconvulsive status epilepticus; survey; traumatic brain injury
Year: 2015 PMID: 26770768 PMCID: PMC4679225 DOI: 10.1177/2050312115573817
Source DB: PubMed Journal: SAGE Open Med ISSN: 2050-3121
Description of the survey instrument.
| Scenarios |
|---|
| 1. Basic scenario: A 13-year-old pedestrian-MVC with scene GCS 5, small SDH on CT scan and ICP monitor. On day 2 has a GCS 3–4 with no spontaneous movements. |
| 2. ICP spikes: Later on day 2, several ICP spikes >25 mmHg occur each hour despite maximal therapy including normothermia, PaCO2 35 mmHg, sodium 145 mmol/L, BP 115/75, oxygen saturation 99%, and two mannitol doses of 0.25 g/kg. |
| 3. Paralysis and cooling: Due to continued rises in ICP > 25 mmHg, patient is paralyzed and cooled to 34°–35° to control raised ICP. |
| 4. Generalized seizure: Later on day 2, his ICP has been stable at 18 mmHg, and paralysis is stopped. A generalized tonic clonic seizure is observed. After two doses of lorazepam, the seizure ceased. |
| Questions asked for each scenario: main question and subsequent embedded logic questions |
MVC: motor vehicle collision; GCS: Glasgow Coma Scale; SDH: subdural hematoma; BP: blood pressure; CT: computed tomography; ICP: intracranial pressure; EEG: electroencephalography; cEEG: continuous electroencephalography; NCS: nonconvulsive seizures; NCSE: nonconvulsive status epilepticus.
Responses to the first question in four TBI scenarios: would you ask for an EEG?.
| Survey question | Scenario | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic scenario | ICP spikes | Paralysis and cooling | Generalized seizure | |
| Would you ask for an EEG? | Yes 53/78 (68%) | Yes 53/77 (69%) | Yes 61/79 (77%) | Yes 59/78 (76%) |
| How urgently would you ask for the EEG? | ||||
| Within the hour | 19/53 (36%) | 19/53 (36%) | 20/61 (33%) | 18/58 (31%) |
| Today, regardless of the hour | 19/53 (36%) | 27/53 (51%) | 34/61 (56%) | 29/58 (50%) |
| Today, if during daytime hours or the next morning | 14 (26%) | 7/53 (13%) | 7/61 (12%) | 11/58 (19%) |
| Within 48 h | 1/53 (2%) | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| What type of EEG do you ask for? | ||||
| Standard 30-min EEG | 29/53 (55%) | 121/53 (23%) | 9/61 (15%) | 24/59 (41%) |
| Longer than usual (1- to 2-h EEG) | 3/53 (6%) | 14/53 (26%) | 16/61 (26%) | 18/59 (31%) |
| cEEG for 24 h | 13/53 (25%) | 20/53 (38%) | 17/61 (28%) | 14/59 (24%) |
| cEEG for more than 24 h | 8/53 (15%) | 7/53 (13%) | 19/61 (31%) | 3/59 (5%) |
TBI: traumatic brain injury; ICP: intracranial pressure; EEG: electroencephalography; cEEG: continuous electroencephalography.
Responses to the second question in four TBI scenarios: NCS are detected on the EEG, when would you decide to treat these NCS?.
| Survey question | Scenario | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic scenario | ICP spikes | Paralysis and cooling | Generalized seizure | |
| NCS are detected on the EEG. When would you treat these NCS? | ||||
| For any NCS seen | 35/53 (66%) | 37/53 (70%) | 38/60 (63%) | 38/59 (64%) |
| For multiple, 2–5 NCS in 24 h | 11/53 (21%) | 9/53 (17%) | 13/60 (22%) | 10/59 (17%) |
| For multiple, >5 NCS in 24 h | 7/53 (13%) | 7/53 (13%) | 9/60 (15%) | 1/59 (19%) |
| What would your first-line treatment be? | ||||
| Phenobarbital | 11/53 (21%) | 13/53 (25%) | 17/59 (29%) | 10/59 (17%) |
| Benzodiazepines | 24/53 (45%) | 24/53 (45%) | 27/59 (46%) | 30/59 (51%) |
| Phenytoin | 17/53 (32%) | 15/53 (28%) | 14/59 (24%) | 18/59 (31%) |
| Other | 1/53 (2%) | 1/53 (2%) | 1/59 (2%) | 1/59 (2%) |
| What would the therapeutic goal of treatment be? | ||||
| Until all NCS stop | 37/51 (73%) | 40/53 (76%) | 40/57 (70%) | 39/59 (66%) |
| Until there are <5 NCS in 24 h | 14/51 (28%) | 13/53 (25%) | 16/57 (28%) | 20/59 (34%) |
| Why did you decide to treat this NCS activity? | ||||
| To lower harmful elevations in ICP | 2/52 (4%) | 21/53 (40%) | 14/58 (24%) | 2/59 (3%) |
| To decrease excitotoxic or other brain injury | 46/52 (89%) | 31/53 (59%) | 43/58 (74%) | 57/59 (97%) |
| To reverse coma | 4/52 (8%) | 1/53 (2%) | 1/58 (2%) | 0 |
| For this scenario only, do you believe that NCS is a cause for poor neurological outcomes? | Yes 46/76 (61%) | Yes 51/78 (65%) | Yes 56/77 (73%) | Yes 50/76 (66%) |
TBI: traumatic brain injury; NCS: nonconvulsive seizures; ICP: intracranial pressure; EEG: electroencephalography.
Responses to the third question in four TBI scenarios: NCSE is detected on the EEG; would you treat this NCSE?.
| Survey question | Scenario | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Basic scenario | ICP spikes | Paralysis and cooling | Generalized seizure | |
| NCSE is detected on the EEG; would you treat this NCSE? | Yes 52/52 (100%) | Yes 53/53 (100%) | Yes 60/60 (100%) | Yes 58/58 (100%) |
| What would your first-line treatment be? | ||||
| Phenobarbital | 11/50 (22%) | 14/53 (26%) | 17/60 (28%) | 10/58 (17%) |
| Benzodiazepines | 26/50 (52%) | 25/53 (47%) | 27/60 (45%) | 32/58 (72%) |
| Barbiturate infusion | 3/50 (6%) | 3/53 (6%) | 7/60 (12%) | 3/58 (5%) |
| Phenytoin | 9/50 (18%) | 10/53 (19%) | 9/60 (15%) | 13/58 (22%) |
| Other | 1/50 (2%) | 1/53 (2%) | 0 | 0 |
| What would the therapeutic goal of treatment be? | ||||
| Until electroencephalographic NCSE stops | 48/51 (94%) | 49/53 (93%) | 51/58 (88%) | 53/57 (93%) |
| To burst suppression | 3/51 (6%) | 4/53 (8%) | 7/58 (12%) | 4/57 (7%) |
| Why did you decide to treat this seizure activity? | ||||
| To lower harmful elevations in ICP | 2/50 (4%) | 12/53 (23%) | 12/60 (20%) | 3/58 (5%) |
| To decrease excitotoxic or other brain injury | 45/50 (90%) | 40/53 (76%) | 47/60 (78%) | 55/58 (95%) |
| To reverse coma | 3/50 (6%) | 1/53 (2%) | 1/60 (2%) | 0 |
| If stopping NCSE requires inducing burst suppression, would you recommend this be done? | Yes 50/51 (98%) | Yes 52/53 (98%) | Yes 58/59 (98%) | Yes 56/57 (98%) |
| A pentobarbital infusion was used to stop the NCSE. For how long would you continue the pentobarbital infusion after the NCSE has stopped? | ||||
| <24 h | 12/52 (23%) | 9/53 (17%) | 9/59 (15%) | 13/58 (22%) |
| 24–36 h | 26/52 (50%) | 29/53 (55%) | 31/59 (53%) | 30/58 (52%) |
| 36–48 h | 12/52 (23%) | 14/53 (26%) | 16/59 (27%) | 13/58 (22%) |
| >48 h | 2/52 (4%) | 1/53 (2%) | 3/59 (5%) | 2/58 (3%) |
| The pentobarbital infusion was stopped after the NCSE was controlled. For how long after stopping pentobarbital infusion would you continue EEG monitoring to detect any relapse of NCSE? | ||||
| <24 h | 1/51 (2%) | 4/53 (8%) | 3/58 (5%) | 5/56 (9%) |
| 24–36 h | 25/51 (49%) | 25/53 (47%) | 27/58 (47%) | 28/56 (50%) |
| 36–48 h | 18/51 (35%) | 16/53 (30%) | 18/58 (31%) | 13/56 (23%) |
| >48 h | 7/51 (14%) | 8/53 (15%) | 10/58 (17%) | 10/56 (18%) |
| For this scenario only, do you think NCSE is a cause of adverse neurological outcomes? | Yes 62/77 (81%) | Yes 64/78 (82%) | Yes 65/76 (86%) | Yes 65/75 (87%) |
TBI: traumatic brain injury; NCSE: nonconvulsive status epilepticus; ICP: intracranial pressure; EEG: electroencephalography.
Post hoc subgroup analysis to determine whether asking for an EEG is associated with the opinion that NCS or NCSE cause adverse neurological outcome.
| Scenario | NCS or NCSE are a cause of adverse neurological outcomes | Ask for an EEG | p-value (Fisher’s exact) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yes | No | |||
| Basic scenario | NCS, yes | 39 | 7 | <0.001 |
| NCS, no | 12 | 18 | ||
| NCSE, yes | 51 | 11 | <0.001 | |
| NCSE, no | 1 | 14 | ||
| ICP spikes | NCS, yes | 43 | 7 | <0.001 |
| NCS, no | 10 | 17 | ||
| NCSE, yes | 52 | 1 | <0.001 | |
| NCSE, no | 1 | 13 | ||
| Paralysis and cooling | NCS, yes | 50 | 10 | <0.001 |
| NCS, no | 6 | 11 | ||
| NCSE, yes | 57 | 3 | <0.001 | |
| NCSE, no | 8 | 8 | ||
| Generalized seizure | NCS, yes | 43 | 15 | 0.008 |
| NCS, no | 7 | 11 | ||
| NCSE, yes | 55 | 2 | <0.001 | |
| NCSE, no | 10 | 8 | ||
EEG: electroencephalography; NCS: nonconvulsive seizures; NCSE: nonconvulsive status epilepticus; ICP: intracranial pressure.