Qiongshi Lu1, Xinwei Yao2, Yiming Hu1, Hongyu Zhao3. 1. Department of Biostatistics, Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, CT, USA. 2. Yale College, New Haven, CT, USA. 3. Department of Biostatistics, Yale School of Public Health, New Haven, CT, USA, Program of Computational Biology and Bioinformatics, Yale University, New Haven, CT, USA and VA Cooperative Studies Program Coordinating Center, West Haven, CT, USA.
Abstract
MOTIVATION: Genome-wide association study (GWAS) has been a great success in the past decade. However, significant challenges still remain in both identifying new risk loci and interpreting results. Bonferroni-corrected significance level is known to be conservative, leading to insufficient statistical power when the effect size is moderate at risk locus. Complex structure of linkage disequilibrium also makes it challenging to separate causal variants from nonfunctional ones in large haplotype blocks. Under such circumstances, a computational approach that may increase signal replication rate and identify potential functional sites among correlated markers is urgently needed. RESULTS: We describe GenoWAP, a GWAS signal prioritization method that integrates genomic functional annotation and GWAS test statistics. The effectiveness of GenoWAP is demonstrated through its applications to Crohn's disease and schizophrenia using the largest studies available, where highly ranked loci show substantially stronger signals in the whole dataset after prioritization based on a subset of samples. At the single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) level, top ranked SNPs after prioritization have both higher replication rates and consistently stronger enrichment of eQTLs. Within each risk locus, GenoWAP may be able to distinguish functional sites from groups of correlated SNPs. AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION: GenoWAP is freely available on the web at http://genocanyon.med.yale.edu/GenoWAP.
MOTIVATION: Genome-wide association study (GWAS) has been a great success in the past decade. However, significant challenges still remain in both identifying new risk loci and interpreting results. Bonferroni-corrected significance level is known to be conservative, leading to insufficient statistical power when the effect size is moderate at risk locus. Complex structure of linkage disequilibrium also makes it challenging to separate causal variants from nonfunctional ones in large haplotype blocks. Under such circumstances, a computational approach that may increase signal replication rate and identify potential functional sites among correlated markers is urgently needed. RESULTS: We describe GenoWAP, a GWAS signal prioritization method that integrates genomic functional annotation and GWAS test statistics. The effectiveness of GenoWAP is demonstrated through its applications to Crohn's disease and schizophrenia using the largest studies available, where highly ranked loci show substantially stronger signals in the whole dataset after prioritization based on a subset of samples. At the single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) level, top ranked SNPs after prioritization have both higher replication rates and consistently stronger enrichment of eQTLs. Within each risk locus, GenoWAP may be able to distinguish functional sites from groups of correlated SNPs. AVAILABILITY AND IMPLEMENTATION: GenoWAP is freely available on the web at http://genocanyon.med.yale.edu/GenoWAP.
Authors: Lucia A Hindorff; Praveen Sethupathy; Heather A Junkins; Erin M Ramos; Jayashri P Mehta; Francis S Collins; Teri A Manolio Journal: Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A Date: 2009-05-27 Impact factor: 11.205
Authors: John D Eicher; Christa Landowski; Brian Stackhouse; Arielle Sloan; Wenjie Chen; Nicole Jensen; Ju-Ping Lien; Richard Leslie; Andrew D Johnson Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2014-11-26 Impact factor: 16.971
Authors: John D Rioux; Ramnik J Xavier; Kent D Taylor; Mark S Silverberg; Philippe Goyette; Alan Huett; Todd Green; Petric Kuballa; M Michael Barmada; Lisa Wu Datta; Yin Yao Shugart; Anne M Griffiths; Stephan R Targan; Andrew F Ippoliti; Edmond-Jean Bernard; Ling Mei; Dan L Nicolae; Miguel Regueiro; L Philip Schumm; A Hillary Steinhart; Jerome I Rotter; Richard H Duerr; Judy H Cho; Mark J Daly; Steven R Brant Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2007-04-15 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: J Raphael Gibbs; Marcel P van der Brug; Dena G Hernandez; Bryan J Traynor; Michael A Nalls; Shiao-Lin Lai; Sampath Arepalli; Allissa Dillman; Ian P Rafferty; Juan Troncoso; Robert Johnson; H Ronald Zielke; Luigi Ferrucci; Dan L Longo; Mark R Cookson; Andrew B Singleton Journal: PLoS Genet Date: 2010-05-13 Impact factor: 5.917
Authors: Andre Franke; Dermot P B McGovern; Jeffrey C Barrett; Kai Wang; Graham L Radford-Smith; Tariq Ahmad; Charlie W Lees; Tobias Balschun; James Lee; Rebecca Roberts; Carl A Anderson; Joshua C Bis; Suzanne Bumpstead; David Ellinghaus; Eleonora M Festen; Michel Georges; Todd Green; Talin Haritunians; Luke Jostins; Anna Latiano; Christopher G Mathew; Grant W Montgomery; Natalie J Prescott; Soumya Raychaudhuri; Jerome I Rotter; Philip Schumm; Yashoda Sharma; Lisa A Simms; Kent D Taylor; David Whiteman; Cisca Wijmenga; Robert N Baldassano; Murray Barclay; Theodore M Bayless; Stephan Brand; Carsten Büning; Albert Cohen; Jean-Frederick Colombel; Mario Cottone; Laura Stronati; Ted Denson; Martine De Vos; Renata D'Inca; Marla Dubinsky; Cathryn Edwards; Tim Florin; Denis Franchimont; Richard Gearry; Jürgen Glas; Andre Van Gossum; Stephen L Guthery; Jonas Halfvarson; Hein W Verspaget; Jean-Pierre Hugot; Amir Karban; Debby Laukens; Ian Lawrance; Marc Lemann; Arie Levine; Cecile Libioulle; Edouard Louis; Craig Mowat; William Newman; Julián Panés; Anne Phillips; Deborah D Proctor; Miguel Regueiro; Richard Russell; Paul Rutgeerts; Jeremy Sanderson; Miquel Sans; Frank Seibold; A Hillary Steinhart; Pieter C F Stokkers; Leif Torkvist; Gerd Kullak-Ublick; David Wilson; Thomas Walters; Stephan R Targan; Steven R Brant; John D Rioux; Mauro D'Amato; Rinse K Weersma; Subra Kugathasan; Anne M Griffiths; John C Mansfield; Severine Vermeire; Richard H Duerr; Mark S Silverberg; Jack Satsangi; Stefan Schreiber; Judy H Cho; Vito Annese; Hakon Hakonarson; Mark J Daly; Miles Parkes Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2010-12 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Harm-Jan Westra; Marjolein J Peters; Tõnu Esko; Hanieh Yaghootkar; Claudia Schurmann; Johannes Kettunen; Mark W Christiansen; Bruce M Psaty; Samuli Ripatti; Alexander Teumer; Timothy M Frayling; Andres Metspalu; Joyce B J van Meurs; Lude Franke; Benjamin P Fairfax; Katharina Schramm; Joseph E Powell; Alexandra Zhernakova; Daria V Zhernakova; Jan H Veldink; Leonard H Van den Berg; Juha Karjalainen; Sebo Withoff; André G Uitterlinden; Albert Hofman; Fernando Rivadeneira; Peter A C 't Hoen; Eva Reinmaa; Krista Fischer; Mari Nelis; Lili Milani; David Melzer; Luigi Ferrucci; Andrew B Singleton; Dena G Hernandez; Michael A Nalls; Georg Homuth; Matthias Nauck; Dörte Radke; Uwe Völker; Markus Perola; Veikko Salomaa; Jennifer Brody; Astrid Suchy-Dicey; Sina A Gharib; Daniel A Enquobahrie; Thomas Lumley; Grant W Montgomery; Seiko Makino; Holger Prokisch; Christian Herder; Michael Roden; Harald Grallert; Thomas Meitinger; Konstantin Strauch; Yang Li; Ritsert C Jansen; Peter M Visscher; Julian C Knight Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2013-09-08 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Anshul Kundaje; Wouter Meuleman; Jason Ernst; Misha Bilenky; Angela Yen; Alireza Heravi-Moussavi; Pouya Kheradpour; Zhizhuo Zhang; Jianrong Wang; Michael J Ziller; Viren Amin; John W Whitaker; Matthew D Schultz; Lucas D Ward; Abhishek Sarkar; Gerald Quon; Richard S Sandstrom; Matthew L Eaton; Yi-Chieh Wu; Andreas R Pfenning; Xinchen Wang; Melina Claussnitzer; Yaping Liu; Cristian Coarfa; R Alan Harris; Noam Shoresh; Charles B Epstein; Elizabeta Gjoneska; Danny Leung; Wei Xie; R David Hawkins; Ryan Lister; Chibo Hong; Philippe Gascard; Andrew J Mungall; Richard Moore; Eric Chuah; Angela Tam; Theresa K Canfield; R Scott Hansen; Rajinder Kaul; Peter J Sabo; Mukul S Bansal; Annaick Carles; Jesse R Dixon; Kai-How Farh; Soheil Feizi; Rosa Karlic; Ah-Ram Kim; Ashwinikumar Kulkarni; Daofeng Li; Rebecca Lowdon; GiNell Elliott; Tim R Mercer; Shane J Neph; Vitor Onuchic; Paz Polak; Nisha Rajagopal; Pradipta Ray; Richard C Sallari; Kyle T Siebenthall; Nicholas A Sinnott-Armstrong; Michael Stevens; Robert E Thurman; Jie Wu; Bo Zhang; Xin Zhou; Arthur E Beaudet; Laurie A Boyer; Philip L De Jager; Peggy J Farnham; Susan J Fisher; David Haussler; Steven J M Jones; Wei Li; Marco A Marra; Michael T McManus; Shamil Sunyaev; James A Thomson; Thea D Tlsty; Li-Huei Tsai; Wei Wang; Robert A Waterland; Michael Q Zhang; Lisa H Chadwick; Bradley E Bernstein; Joseph F Costello; Joseph R Ecker; Martin Hirst; Alexander Meissner; Aleksandar Milosavljevic; Bing Ren; John A Stamatoyannopoulos; Ting Wang; Manolis Kellis Journal: Nature Date: 2015-02-19 Impact factor: 69.504
Authors: Chun Chieh Fan; Olav B Smeland; Andrew J Schork; Chi-Hua Chen; Dominic Holland; Min-Tzu Lo; V S Sundar; Oleksandr Frei; Terry L Jernigan; Ole A Andreassen; Anders M Dale Journal: Hum Mol Genet Date: 2018-05-01 Impact factor: 6.150
Authors: Bixiao Zhao; Qiongshi Lu; Yuwei Cheng; Justin M Belcher; Edward D Siew; David E Leaf; Simon C Body; Amanda A Fox; Sushrut S Waikar; Charles D Collard; Heather Thiessen-Philbrook; T Alp Ikizler; Lorraine B Ware; Charles L Edelstein; Amit X Garg; Murim Choi; Jennifer A Schaub; Hongyu Zhao; Richard P Lifton; Chirag R Parikh Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2017-02-15 Impact factor: 21.405