BACKGROUND: Dietary recall accuracy is related to retention interval (RI) (i.e., time between to-be-reported meals and the interview), and possibly to prompts. To the best of our knowledge, no study has evaluated their combined effect. OBJECTIVE: The combined influence of RI and prompts on children's recall accuracy was investigated in this study. Two RIs [short (prior-24-h recall obtained in afternoon) and long (previous-day recall obtained in morning)] were crossed with 4 prompts [forward (distant-to-recent), meal-name (breakfast, lunch, etc.), open (no instructions), and reverse (recent-to-distant)], creating 8 conditions. METHODS: Fourth-grade children (n = 480; 50% girls) were randomly selected from consenting children at 10 schools in 4 districts in a southern state during 3 school years (2011-2012, 2012-2013, and 2013-2014). Each child was observed eating school-provided breakfast and lunch, and interviewed one time under 1 of the 8 conditions. Condition assignment was constrained so that each had 60 children (30 girls). Accuracy measures were food-item omission and intrusion rates, and energy correspondence rate and inflation ratio. For each measure, linear models determined effects of RI, prompt, gender, and interactions (2-way, 3-way); race/ethnicity, school year, and district were control variables. RESULTS: RI (P values < 0.015) and prompt (P values < 0.005) were significant for all 4 accuracy measures. RI × prompt (P values < 0.001) was significant for 3 accuracy measures (not intrusion rate). Prompt × gender (P = 0.005) was significant for omission rate. RI × prompt × gender was significant for intrusion rate and inflation ratio (P values < 0.001). For the short vs. long RI across prompts and genders, accuracy was better by 33-50% for each accuracy measure. CONCLUSIONS: To obtain the most accurate recalls possible from children, studies should be designed to use a short rather than long RI. Prompts affect children's recall accuracy, although the effectiveness of different prompts depends on RI and varies by gender: at a short RI, the choice of prompts has little systematic effect on accuracy, whereas at a long RI, reverse prompts may elicit the most accurate recalls.
BACKGROUND: Dietary recall accuracy is related to retention interval (RI) (i.e., time between to-be-reported meals and the interview), and possibly to prompts. To the best of our knowledge, no study has evaluated their combined effect. OBJECTIVE: The combined influence of RI and prompts on children's recall accuracy was investigated in this study. Two RIs [short (prior-24-h recall obtained in afternoon) and long (previous-day recall obtained in morning)] were crossed with 4 prompts [forward (distant-to-recent), meal-name (breakfast, lunch, etc.), open (no instructions), and reverse (recent-to-distant)], creating 8 conditions. METHODS: Fourth-grade children (n = 480; 50% girls) were randomly selected from consenting children at 10 schools in 4 districts in a southern state during 3 school years (2011-2012, 2012-2013, and 2013-2014). Each child was observed eating school-provided breakfast and lunch, and interviewed one time under 1 of the 8 conditions. Condition assignment was constrained so that each had 60 children (30 girls). Accuracy measures were food-item omission and intrusion rates, and energy correspondence rate and inflation ratio. For each measure, linear models determined effects of RI, prompt, gender, and interactions (2-way, 3-way); race/ethnicity, school year, and district were control variables. RESULTS: RI (P values < 0.015) and prompt (P values < 0.005) were significant for all 4 accuracy measures. RI × prompt (P values < 0.001) was significant for 3 accuracy measures (not intrusion rate). Prompt × gender (P = 0.005) was significant for omission rate. RI × prompt × gender was significant for intrusion rate and inflation ratio (P values < 0.001). For the short vs. long RI across prompts and genders, accuracy was better by 33-50% for each accuracy measure. CONCLUSIONS: To obtain the most accurate recalls possible from children, studies should be designed to use a short rather than long RI. Prompts affect children's recall accuracy, although the effectiveness of different prompts depends on RI and varies by gender: at a short RI, the choice of prompts has little systematic effect on accuracy, whereas at a long RI, reverse prompts may elicit the most accurate recalls.
Authors: Nicole M Shaffer; Suzanne Domel Baxter; William O Thompson; Michelle L Baglio; Caroline H Guinn; Francesca H A Frye Journal: J Am Diet Assoc Date: 2004-10
Authors: Michelle L Baglio; Suzanne Domel Baxter; Caroline H Guinn; William O Thompson; Nicole M Shaffer; Francesca H A Frye Journal: J Am Diet Assoc Date: 2004-09
Authors: T Byers; F Trieber; E Gunter; R Coates; A Sowell; S Leonard; A Mokdad; S Jewell; D Miller; M Serdula Journal: Epidemiology Date: 1993-07 Impact factor: 4.822
Authors: Suzanne D Baxter; Caroline H Guinn; Albert F Smith; David B Hitchcock; Julie A Royer; Megan P Puryear; Kathleen L Collins; Alyssa L Smith Journal: Br J Nutr Date: 2016-02-11 Impact factor: 3.718
Authors: Suzanne D Baxter; David B Hitchcock; Julie A Royer; Albert F Smith; Caroline H Guinn Journal: J Acad Nutr Diet Date: 2016-10-05 Impact factor: 4.910
Authors: Suzanne D Baxter; Albert F Smith; David B Hitchcock; Kathleen L Collins; Caroline H Guinn; Alyssa L Smith; Christopher J Finney Journal: J Hunger Environ Nutr Date: 2017-06-19
Authors: Suzanne D Baxter; Albert F Smith; David B Hitchcock; Kathleen L Collins; Caroline H Guinn; Christopher J Finney; Julie A Royer; Patricia H Miller Journal: J Nutr Educ Behav Date: 2015 Sep-Oct Impact factor: 3.045