Pressure-driven dome-shaped superconductivity and electronic structural evolution in tungsten ditelluride.

Tungsten ditelluride has attracted intense research interest due to the recent discovery of its large unsaturated magnetoresistance up to 60 T. Motivated by the presence of a small, sensitive Fermi surface of 5d electronic orbitals, we boost the electronic properties by applying a high pressure, and introduce superconductivity successfully. Superconductivity sharply appears at a pressure of 2.5 GPa, rapidly reaching a maximum critical temperature (Tc) of 7 K at around 16.8 GPa, followed by a monotonic decrease in Tc with increasing pressure, thereby exhibiting the typical dome-shaped superconducting phase. From theoretical calculations, we interpret the low-pressure region of the superconducting dome to an enrichment of the density of states at the Fermi level and attribute the high-pressure decrease in Tc to possible structural instability. Thus, tungsten ditelluride may provide a new platform for our understanding of superconductivity phenomena in transition metal dichalcogenides.

As a new class of two-dimensional (2D) materials, transition metal dichalcogenides (TMDs) MX2, where M is a transition metal (Mo, W, Re and so on) and X is a chalcogen (S, Se and Te), have attracted tremendous attention due to their rich physics and promising potential applications123456789101112. Sizable band gaps that can change from indirect to direct in single layers have been found in many TMDs, including WS2, WSe2, MoS2 and MoSe2. This property allows for the development of nanosized electrical transistors, and of electroluminescent and photodetector devices4. Field-effect transistors using thin films of TMDs as channel materials are found to exhibit an extremely high on–off current ratio6. Charge-density waves and superconductivity have also been observed in TMDs1314. Of particular interest is the dome-shaped superconducting phase observed in a gate-tuned MoS2 device, and this effect is also commonly seen in many unconventional superconductors15.

Most recently, an extremely large positive magnetoresistance (MR) was discovered at low temperatures in non-magnetic tungsten ditelluride (WTe2) TMD1. In contrast to other materials, the MR of WTe2 remains unsaturated even at extremely high applied magnetic fields of 60 T1. It has been observed that at low temperatures the hole and electron pockets are approximately the same size13, and that disruption in the balance between the two results in strong suppression of the MR2. A perfect balance between the electron and hole populations may therefore be the primary source of these novel and unwavering MR effects123. As a semimetal13, the density of states at the Fermi level (N(EF)) is rather low16, and no superconductivity has ever been detected down to 0.3 K (ref. 2).

High pressure has been shown to be a clean and powerful means of generating novel physical states17, having been particularly effective not only in tuning the Tc of the superconductivity in elements18 and compounds1920 but also in inducing superconductivity with ferromagnetic or antiferromagnetic orders as their ground states at ambient pressure. Moreover, in the case of WTe2, the Te-5p and W-5d orbitals are spatially extended, thus making it very sensitive to variations caused by external pressure and strain. This property could shed some light on the high-pressure induction of superconducting transport in WTe2. Here we observe the pressure-induced superconductivity, which exhibits a critical temperature (Tc) of 7 K at the pressure of 16.8 GPa. A dome-shaped Tc–P phase diagram is demonstrated. It is interpreted by the theoretical calculations.

Results

Pressure-induced superconductivity

As shown in Fig. 1a, WTe2 is a layered TMD material and the layer stacking results in a unit cell with four formula units and orthorhombic symmetry (its space group is Pnm21)21. The Te–Te bonds between the Te–W–Te sandwich layers are weak; therefore, nanoflakes with thicknesses down to several nanometres can be exfoliated using a scotch tape-based mechanical method. Moreover, the W atoms form zigzag chains along the a axis resulting in a one-dimensional substructure within a 2D material1. We grew single crystals of WTe2 using a vapour transport method, in which the structural parameters were obtained by X-ray diffraction. As seen in the Supplementary Tables 1 and 2, WTe2 exhibits similar atomic structures to those reported previously21. At ambient pressure, the resistivity decreases smoothly with decreasing temperature as shown in Fig. 1b. No phase transition was observed down to 2 K. Figure 1c shows the magnetic field-dependent transport measured for various temperatures at ambient pressure, which confirms the large MR reported recently12.

Figure 1

WTe2 transport measurements at ambient pressure.

(a) The atomic structure of the WTe2 crystal. Blue and green circles represent W and Te, respectively. (b) Temperature dependence of electrical resistivity at ambient pressure. The inset shows detail of data below 50 K with no hint of any superconductivity. (c) The magnetoresistance (upper plot) and Hall resistivity (down plot) at different temperatures at ambient pressure. Different colours represent different temperatures as marked.

Figure 2a,b shows the evolution of the resistance as a function of temperature in a single crystal of WTe2 at various pressures. The pressure was increased from 2.5 to 16.1 GPa in run no. 1 as shown in Fig. 2a, and from 9.3 to 68.5 GPa for another crystal in run no. 2 as shown in Fig. 2b. In run no. 1, at a pressure of 2.5 GPa, the resistance decreased monotonically with decreasing temperature, exhibiting typical metallic behaviour (inset of Fig. 2a). A superconducting transition was observed at Tc=3.1 K. Here we define Tc to be the onset temperature at which the drop in resistance occurs. At pressures up to 16.1 GPa, Tc increased with increasing applied pressure. In the pressure curves for 2.5, 4.9 and 8.45 GPa, zero resistance was not seen because the superconducting transition was not complete at the lowest temperatures achievable using our equipment. If one check Fig. 2a carefully, it can be seen that the broadening widths at higher pressures are around 2 K. If such broadening keeps in the low pressure <8.45 GPa, the zero-resistance temperature will be extended below 1.8 K, which is the low limit of our equipment. At 11 GPa, however, zero resistance was observed for some temperatures. In the case of run no. 2, with pressures starting at 9.3 GPa, Tc first increased slightly to a maximum of 7 K at 16.8 GPa, where it began to decrease monotonically with increasing pressure as shown in Fig. 2b. A suppression of two to three orders of magnitude of the MR emerged once superconductivity appeared, as evidenced by the MR curves at 10 K shown in Fig. 2c. To demonstrate that the zero resistance represented superconductivity, we also performed a.c. susceptibility measurements as shown in Fig. 2d, where the diamagnetic signal was observed at 8.3 and 12.5 GPa. This is in good agreement with the resistance measurements. The onset of MR suppression and superconductivity under pressure were thus demonstrated.

Figure 2

Experimental evidence of pressure-induced superconductivity.

(a) The temperature-dependent resistance under different pressures up to 16.1 GPa in run no. 1. The inset shows the temperature-dependent resistance from 1.8 to 300 K at 2.5 GPa. The onset of superconductivity can be seen from the drop in resistance. (b) Temperature dependence of resistance under various pressures from 9.3 to 68.5 GPa in run no. 2. (c) Magnetoresistance comparison at 10 K between ambient pressure and 2.5 GPa. Magnetoresistance is strongly suppressed with increasing pressure when superconductivity becomes predominant. (d) The real part of the a.c. susceptibility versus temperature at different pressures.

The dome-shaped superconductivity behaviour

We also carried out measurements of resistance around Tc for various external magnetic fields. As seen in Fig. 3a, the zero-resistance state at 24.6 GPa gradually lifted with increasing field, resulting in a decrease in Tc. This gave complimentary evidence of the superconducting transition. A magnetic field of 1.5 T almost smears out the superconducting transition. Deviating from the Werthamer–Helfand–Hohenberg theory based on the single-band model, the upper critical field (Hc2(T)) of WTe2 has a positive curvature close to Tc (H=0) as shown in Fig. 3b. This is similar to the case for NbS2 and NbSe2 (refs 22, 23). As shown in Fig. 3b, our experimental curve of Hc2(T) can be well approximated by a simple relationship of the form Hc2(T)=Hc2*(1−T/Tc)1+ (ref. 24), where the estimated value of Hc2(0) (2.72 T) is similar to that of NbS2 and NbSe2 (refs 22, 23). It is also worth noting that our estimated value of Hc2(0) is well less than the Bardeen, Cooper and Schrieffer (BCS) weak-coupling Pauli limit.

Figure 3

The upper critical field analysis of the WTe2 superconductor.

(a)Temperature dependence of the resistance under different fields up to 1.5 T at 24.6 GPa. (b) The Tc–H phase diagram at 24.6 GPa. The black curve is the best-fit line.

The dome-like evolution of Tc was constructed based on the pressure-dependent transport data shown in Fig. 2. It is clear that Tc increased up to a pressure of 16.1 GPa in run no. 1. In the second run, Tc first increased and later decreased with increasing pressure up to a pressure of 68.5 GPa, with a maximum Tc of 7 K at 16.8 GPa. Slight discrepancy can be seen between runs 1 and 2. This is reasonable after considering the situation that the sample size is small (200 × 40 × 5 μm). It is very hard for us to keep the ab plane of WTe2 ideally parallel to the diamond culet. A small deviation from the parallel configuration will cause the pressure applied in different directions. We repeated the experiment using the pressure-transmitting medium of Daphne oil in the third run, which revealed the entire Tc dependence against pressure as shown in Fig. 5a. Here we see the Tc–P phase diagram, where Tc starts at 2–3 K at a pressure of 2–4 GPa and increases up to a maximum Tc of 7 K. A dome-shaped superconducting phase is clearly evident. We note the discrepancy between runs 2 and 3 at high pressure. It is well known that measurements using a transmitting medium are normally regarded as quasi-hydrostatic pressure applications, while measurements made without a transmitting medium are regarded as being under uniaxial pressure. The different pressure environments may contribute to some discrepancies252627, as observed here.

Figure 5

The dome-shaped superconducting Tc–P phase diagram and possible interpretation.

(a) Onset temperature of the superconductivity plotted against applied pressure. A maximum Tc of 7 K occurs near 20 GPa. In runs no. 1 and 2, no pressure-transmitting medium was used while for run no. 3, Daphne oil was used as the pressure medium. The right-hand axis is the magnetoresistance ratio, which is strongly suppressed by the pressure. (b) The calculated density of states at the Fermi level plotted against pressure.

The interpretation by theoretical calculations

We carried out density functional theory (DFT) calculations to better interpret the physics of the observed superconductivity. On the basis of the experimental lattice parameters shown in the Supplementary Table 1 and our optimized internal atomic coordinates, we performed calculations on the electronic structure of WTe2. Due to strong hybridization, the W-5d and Te-5p bands were found to be highly mixed and distributed mainly in the energy range from –6.5 to 3 eV, while all other bands made only a negligible contribution as shown in Supplementary Figs 1 and 2. Crystal field splitting was found to be very small and all the Te-5p and W-5d electrons participate in the electronic states near the Fermi surface. The band structure of WTe2 under ambient conditions is anisotropic with slight dispersion along the Г-z and greater dispersion along the in-plane directions. Consistent with previous studies13, our calculation also shows that WTe2 is a semimetal with quite small N(EF) (0.497 states per eV per unit cell), which may explain why WTe2 does not exhibit superconductivity even down to 0.3 K at ambient pressure2.

We performed total energy calculations for a number of different volumes to simulate the high pressure conditions in WTe2. We optimized the lattice parameters and all the independent internal atomic coordinates for each volume. The obtained volumes versus the total energy behaviour were found to be in good agreement with the Murnaghan equation of state as shown in the Supplementary Fig. 3 (ref. 28). Our theoretical equilibrium unit cell volume (314 Å3) is only about 2.6% larger than the experimental value (306 Å3). Such deviation exists normally in generalized gradient approximation calculations. Our numerical bulk modulus at equilibrium B0 was 56 GPa, slightly larger than that of MoS2 (ref. 29). In Fig. 4a, we show the pressure dependence of the lattice parameter and the c/a ratio. The 2D nature of this compound is clearly exemplified from the different rates of compressibility along the c axis and in the ab plane. The numerical c/a ratio first decreases with pressure until a minimum value is reached at 30 GPa. An upward shift can then be seen, similar to the case for MoS2 (ref. 17). In MoS2, this abnormality was attributed to the occurrence of an isostructural phase transition17.

Figure 4

Density functional theory calculations.

(a) The pressure dependence of the lattice parameters (upper) and c/a ratio obtained from geometry optimization (lower). (b) The calculated evolution of the Fermi surface contour at various pressures (marked in the plot).

Our numerical phonon spectrum at zero pressure is in good agreement with the results of Raman spectroscopy measurements3031 as shown in the Supplementary Table 3. We also investigated the pressure-induced phonon evolution, suggesting that a possible structural instability may occur under compression, again as shown in the supplementary Fig. 4. The phonon softening found in the finite-displacement method phonon calculation may be related to the c/a abnormality found in the structural optimization as shown in Fig. 4a.

We now turn our attention to the electronic structure under compression. We show the numerical Fermi surface at the Kz=0 plane in Fig. 4b. Our zero-pressure Fermi surface is slightly different from the previous one, as shown in the upper plot of Fig. 4b. There is a small Fermi pocket along the Г-y direction in our results, which was absent in some previous studies123. Applying pressure enlarges the hybridization and increases the bandwidth as shown in the Supplementary Figs 1 and 2. Consequently, the size of the electron and hole pockets at ambient pressure increases. Moreover, high pressure also introduces additional Fermi pockets as demonstrated in Fig. 4b. Thus, N(EF) increases rapidly with pressure as shown in Fig. 5b. As discussed above, applying pressure increases the phonon frequencies, thereby increasing the Debye temperature T. Figure 5a implies that the presence of superconductivity at around 2.5 GPa, together with the sharp increase in Tc, can be explained by the increases in N(EF) and Tθ. N(EF) continues to increase with pressure owing to the enlargement of existing pockets as well as the appearance of new pockets, and the decrease of Tc above 16.8 GPa may be related to structural abnormalities.

Discussion

The MR suppression and the appearance of superconductivity can be considered as follows. The large MR is attributed to the perfect compensation between the opposite carriers, where the balance is too delicate to survive the intense pressures used in our experiments. As seen in the simulation, the applied pressure significantly increases the difference between the hole and electronic Fermi pockets as shown in the Supplementary Fig. 1. At the same time, N(EF) rapidly increases with increasing pressure as shown in Fig. 5b, which is the essential condition of the onset of superconductivity. The applied pressure tunes the carrier balance and the electronic conditions near the Fermi surface and leads to simultaneous MR suppression and the appearance of superconductivity. Interestingly, Hc2(T) usually increases with increasing Tc and decreases with increasing Fermi velocity. The numerical Fermi velocity increases with pressure as shown in the Supplementary Table 4 and Supplementary Note. In combination with the dome-like evolution of Tc–P (Fig. 5a), we expect that Hc2(T) may show complex pressure-dependent behaviour around the optimized pressure, while at high pressure, Hc2(T) decreases with increasing pressure.

In summary, superconductivity was successfully induced in WTe2 by the application of high pressure with a maximum Tc of 7 K at 16.8 GPa. The Tc -P phase diagram shows a dome-like superconducting phase, which we attribute to an enrichment of N(EF) for the low-pressure regime and a possible structural instability at high pressures as suggested by DFT calculations. The semimetal-like electronic dispersion, unsaturated large MR and superconductivity were all observed in WTe2, all contributing to the extremely interesting physics seen in this TMD material.

Methods

Crystal growth and characterization

WTe2 single crystals were grown using a chemical vapour transport technique. Stoichiometric W and Te powders were ground together and loaded into a quartz tube with a small amount of TeBr4 (transport agent). All weighing and mixing was carried out in a glove box. The tube was sealed under vacuum and placed in a two-zone furnace. The hot zone was maintained at 800 °C for 10 days and the cold zone was maintained at 700 °C. A Bruker SMART diffractometer equipped with a charge-coupled device-type area detector was used to determine the crystal structure. The data were collected at room temperature with graphite monochromated Mo-Kα radiation (λ=0.71073 Å). SADABS32 supplied by Bruker was used to perform the absorption correction. The Patterson method was used to resolve the structure33, which we then refined using full-matrix least squares on all F2 data with the SHELXL-97 program32. All atoms were refined anisotropically.

Transport measurements and high-pressure experiments

The resistance data were collected in a screw-pressure-type diamond anvil cell (DAC) made of non-magnetic Cu–Be alloy. The diamond culet was 300 μm in diameter. A T301 stainless-steel gasket was pre-indented from a thickness of 200 to 30 μm, leaving a pit inside the gasket. A hole with a diameter of 280 μm was drilled at the centre of the pit using laser ablation. The pit of the indented gasket was then covered with a mixture of epoxy and fine cubic boron nitride (cBN) powder and compressed firmly to insulate the electrode leads from the metallic gasket. For runs 1 and 2, we used the standard four-probe method to obtain the resistance measurements. The cBN-covered pit served as a sample chamber, into which a WTe2 single crystal of dimensions 200 × 40 × 5 μm was inserted without a pressure-transmitting medium. For run 3, a hole with diameter of 100 μm was further drilled at the centre of the cBN-covered pit, and then a single-piece sample with dimensions 40 × 40 × 5 μm was loaded simultaneously using Daphne 7373 oil as the pressure-transmitting medium. We used van der Pauw-like topology to arrange the four probes. The current was introduced into one side and the drop in voltage along the other side was recorded. Some ruby powder at the top of the sample for runs 1 and 2 and a ruby ball next to the sample for run 3 served as pressure markers. The pressure was determined using the ruby fluorescence method at room temperature. Platinum (Pt) foil with a thickness of 5 μm was used for the electrodes. The gasket surface outside the pit was insulated from the electrode leads using a layer of Scotch tape. The DAC was placed inside a homemade multifunctional measurement system (1.8–300 K, JANIS Research Company Inc.; 0–9 T, Cryomagnetics Inc.) with helium (He) as the medium for heat convection to obtain a high efficiency of heat transfer and precise temperature control. Two Cernox resistors (CX-1050-CU-HT-1.4L) located near the DAC were used to ensure the accuracy of the temperature in the presence of a magnetic field. The ambient pressure electrical transport were carried out in a Cryomagnetics cryostat with an SR830 (Stanford Research Systems) digital lock-in amplifier. Ohmic contacts were made using gold wires and silver paste.

The a.c. susceptibility was measured using a magnetic inductance technique based on the ideal diamagnetism of a superconductor. One signal coil was wound around a diamond tip with an additional identical compensating coil tightly adjacent to it. These two coils are known as a pick-up coil. Outside the pick-up coil was an exciting coil, into which the a.c. current was fed with a magnitude of 100 μA and a frequency of 997 Hz. The diamond culet was 800 μm in size and a Be–Cu gasket was pre-indented from 450 to 150 μm. A piece of WTe2 single crystal sample with dimensions 500 × 500 × 20 μm was inserted into the pre-indented Be–Cu gasket chamber without a pressure-transmitting medium. Ruby powder placed at the top of the sample served as a pressure marker. The pressure was determined using the ruby fluorescence method at room temperature.

Density functional calculations

The electronic structure was calculated based on DFT as implemented in the Vienna ab initio simulation package code3435. The Perdew–Becke–Erzenhof parameterization of the generalized gradient approximation was adopted as the exchange-correlation function36. A plane-wave basis set was employed within the framework of the projector augmented wave method37 and the cutoff energy of 500 eV had been tested to ensure it was sufficient for convergence. The Brillouin zone was sampled using the Monkhorst-Pack method38 with a k-point grid 14 × 7 × 3. The relaxations of cell geometry and atomic positions were carried out using a conjugate gradient algorithm until the Hellman–Feynman force on each of the unconstrained atoms was <0.001 eV Å−1. The convergence criterion of the self-consistent calculations was 10−5 eV between two consecutive steps. We adopted the Gaussian smearing scheme39 using a smearing width of 0.05 eV. We also included spin-orbital coupling in our calculations.

The calculations of phonon spectrum were performed in a 3 × 2 × 1 supercell, with interatomic forces being computed using the Vienna ab initio simulation package code code with the small displacements method40. From these, force-constant matrices and phonon frequencies were extracted using the PHONOPY code41. The cutoff energy of 500 eV and the Gaussian smearing method with a 0.05 V smearing width were used in the phonon calculations. Our numerical calculations showed that the phonon frequency difference between k-meshes of 3 × 3 × 2 and 5 × 4 × 4 was quite small. Hence, a 3 × 3 × 2 k-point grid was used for the phonon calculations for all the pressures. The effect of the exchange-correlation function pseudopotential, cutoff value and smearing value were also carefully checked. It is worth mentioning that our band structure was consistent with previous results and our numerical Raman frequencies were also in good agreement with the experimental results. These again justify the quality of our numerical electronic structure and phonon results.

Additional information

How to cite this article: Pan, X-C. et al. Pressure-driven dome-shaped superconductivity and electronic structural evolution in tungsten ditelluride. Nat. Commun. 6:7805 doi: 10.1038/ncomms8805 (2015).