Phacidium and Ceuthospora (Phacidiaceae) are congeneric: taxonomic and nomenclatural implications.

The morphologically diverse genus Ceuthospora has traditionally been linked to Phacidium sexual morphs via association, though molecular or cultural data to confirm this relationship have been lacking. The aim of this study was thus to resolve the relationship of these two genera by generating nucleotide sequence data for three loci, ITS, LSU and RPB2. Based on these results, Ceuthospora is reduced to synonymy under the older generic name Phacidium. Phacidiaceae (currently Helotiales) is suggested to constitute a separate order, Phacidiales (Leotiomycetes), as sister to Helotiales, which is clearly paraphyletic. Phacidiaceae includes Bulgaria, and consequently the family Bulgariaceae becomes a synonym of Phacidiaceae. Several new combinations are introduced in Phacidium, along with two new species, P. pseudophacidioides, which occurs on Ilex and Chamaespartium in Europe, and Phacidium trichophori, which occurs on Trichophorum cespitosum subsp. germanicum in The Netherlands. The generic name Allantophomopsiella is introduced to accommodate A. pseudotsugae, a pathogen of conifers, while Gremmenia is resurrected to accommodate the snow-blight pathogens of conifers, G. abietis, G. infestans, and G. pini-cembrae.

INTRODUCTION

The generic name Phacidium was introduced by Fries (1815) for P. coronatum and P. integerrimum. Phacidium integerrimum was subsequently transferred to Excipula, and P. coronatum to Coccomyces. Phacidium lacerum, a species described later by Fries (1818), was therefore considered the type species of the genus (von Höhnel 1917), even though it was not one of the two species originally described by Fries. Subsequent authors have accepted this typification (Terrier 1942, von Arx & Müller 1954, Reid & Cain 1962, Korf 1973, Dennis 1978). In order to regularise this situation, Hawksworth & Sherwood (1981) proposed the conservation of Phacidium with P. lacerum as the conserved type species; this proposal was accepted by the Committee for Fungi and Lichens and incorporated into the appendices of the Berlin Code of 1988 (Greuter ). While the proposal to conserve the type was under discussion, DiCosmo followed Höhnel (1917) and accepted P. lacerum as the type. Under the Melbourne Code (McNeill ), types for sanctioned names can be selected either from the original protologue (in this case Fries 1815) or the sanctioning work (in this case Fries 1823, where P. lacerum was included), so there would be no objection now to the acceptance of P. lacerum as type species of Phacidum but that option was not available in 1981.

Tulasne & Tulasne (1861–65) recognised that Phacidium ilicis was a single fungus with two morphs (pleomorphic), and the conidiomatal states to be representative of Cytisporae (spermatial) and Ceuthosporae (asexual). Ceuthospora has been linked as an asexual morph to Phacidium (Sutton 1980, Nag Raj 1993). As with Phacidium, however, the typification of the asexual name was also beset by problems.

The generic name Ceuthospora was published by Fries (1825) with two species, Sphaeria phaeocomes and Sclerotium inclusum. Greville (1828) included another three species, C. phacidioides, C. lauri, and C. phaeocomes, all accepted by Fries (1832). Fries (1849) introduced the generic name Pyrenophora, and referred both Sphaeria phaeocomes and Sclerotia inclusum to that genus. The genus Ceuthospora, was thus not clearly typified. Fries (1832) effectively selected Sphaeria phaeocomes as type, when he excluded Sclerotium inclusum from the genus. However, Pyrenophora phaeocomes was selected as type species of Pyrenophora by Shoemaker (1961), which effectively leaves Pyrenophora as a later nomenclatural synonym of Ceuthospora. To resolve this situation, Sutton (1972) proposed the conservation of Ceuthospora Grev. 1826 with C. lauri as type, over Ceuthospora Fr. 1825 with C. phaeocomes as type; this was accepted by the Committee for Fungi and Lichens and the name included in the appendices to the Leningrad Code (Stafleu ).

The family name Phacidiaceae was introduced by Fries (1849) and accepted by Karsten (1871) who stressed that members had a particular apothecium type with a reduced exciple. Nannfeldt (1932) recognised 14 genera in the family, but Terrier (1942) felt that the family contained different elements, and probably should only include five genera. Von Arx & Müller (1954) regarded eight genera as belonging to the family. The circumscription remained a bone of contention, as Kreisel (1969) recognised four genera, Korf (1973) nine, Dennis (1978) 13, and Lanier seven. DiCosmo listed 24 genera in Phacidiaceae, stating that it was heterogeneous and in need of further study. In a recent phylogenetic study of Leotiomycetes (Wang ), Helotiales (incl. Phacidiaceae) was left untreated as a large, polyphyletic assemblage, due to inadequate molecular data and sampling. However, they did refer to Phacidiaceae, based on analyses including a LSU sequence of Phacidium lacerum (data not shown), which suggested a sister group relationship with Phacidiopycnis pyri (sexual morph: Potebniamyces pyri), previously questionably placed in Rhytismatales). In the SSU-LSU-5.8S phylogeny (Wang ), P. pyri formed a strongly supported monophyletic group with Bulgaria inquinans (Bulgariaceae), and P. pyri together with Holwaya mucida (although without support) was moved to Bulgariaceae. Bulgaria has large, brown-black to black, turbinate, gelatinous apothecia with brown-walled ascospores, and is thus quite different from Phacidium and Potebniamyces in morphology. In the LSU & SSU phylogeny generated by Lantz , however, these three genera clustered together in a well-supported clade.

Given the recent decision to abolish dual nomenclature for fungi (Hawksworth 2011, Hawksworth , Wingfield ), we wanted to resolve the issue of whether Phacidium and Ceuthospora were really congeneric (Johnston ) and fix the application of these names using genetic data, and further to determine the phylogenetic position of Phacidiaceae within Helotiales.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Isolates

Isolates used in this study were obtained from the culture collection of the CBS-KNAW Fungal Biodiversity Centre (CBS). Utrecht, The Netherlands (Table 1). Colonies were established on Petri dishes containing 2 % malt extract agar (MEA), potato-dextrose agar (PDA), and oatmeal agar (OA) (Crous ), and incubated at 25 °C under continuous near-ultraviolet light to promote sporulation.

Table 1.

Collection details and GenBank accession numbers of isolates included in this study.

Species	Isolate no.1	Host	Location	Collector	GenBank accession no.2
					LSU	ITS	RPB2
Allantophomopsiella pseudotsugae	CBS 288.37	Picea abies	United Kingdom	–	KJ663863	KJ663824	KJ663904
	CBS 320.53	Pseudotsuga menziesii	Norway	H. Robak	KJ663864	KJ663825	KJ663905
	CBS 321.53	Picea abies	Norway	H. Robak	KJ663865	KJ663826	KJ663906
	CBS 437.71	Pinus sylvestris	Netherlands	J. Gremmen	KJ663866	KJ663827	KJ663907
	CBS 562.63	Pinus sylvestris	Norway	F. Roll-Hansen	KJ663867	KJ663828	KJ663908
	CBS 841.91	Pinus sp.	Germany	P. Schumacher	KJ663868	KJ663829	KJ663909
Allantophomopsis cytisporea	CBS 262.85	Roots of Conifer species	Germany	H. Courtois	KJ663869	KJ663830	KJ663910
‘Allantophomopsis’ sp.	CBS 109.22	Oxycoccus macrocarpos	USA	C.L. Shear	KJ663861	KJ663822	KJ663902
Allantophomopsis sp.	CBS 322.36	Pinus radiata	New Zealand	P.C. Birch	KJ663880	KJ663839	KJ663921
Bulgaria inquinans	CBS 118.31	Forest floor	Germany	BIHM	KJ663870	KJ663831	KJ663911
	CBS 129.58	Forest floor	Germany	–	KJ663871	KJ663832	KJ663912
	CBS 145.55	–	Germany	H. Lyr	KJ663872	KM216394	KJ663913
	CBS 315.71	Quercus robur	Switzerland	E. Müller	KJ663873	KJ663833	KJ663914
Coleophoma sp.	CBS 449.70	Liriodendron tulipifera	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663874	KJ663834	KJ663915
Gremmenia infestans	CBS 396.48	–	Sweden	E. Björkman	KJ663876	KM216393	KJ663917
Hyaloscypha sp.	CBS 109453	Miconia sp.	Venezuela	I. Hernandez	KJ663875	KJ663835	KJ663916
Neofabraea sp.	CBS 135481 = CPC 22154	Polygonatum sp.	Netherlands	U. Damm	KF251745	KF251242	KJ663942
Phacidium calderae	CBS 287.72	Arbutus unedo	Italy	W. Gams & J.A. Stalpers	KJ663878	KJ663837	KJ663919
	CBS 372.81	Pistacia terebinthus	Spain	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663879	KJ663838	KJ663920
Phacidium fennicum	CBS 457.83	Pinus sylvestris	Finland	H. Butin	KJ663881	KJ663840	KJ663922
Phacidium lacerum	CBS 130.30	Pinus sylvestris	Netherlands	J.Y. van Vliet	KJ663882	KJ663841	KJ663923
	CBS 338.70	Ilex aquifolium	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663883	KJ663842	KJ663924
	CBS 400.81	Juniperus communis	France	O. Petrini	KJ663884	KJ663843	KJ663925
	CBS 540.70	Pinus sylvestris	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663885	KJ663844	KJ663926
	CBS 557.70	Sciadopitys verticillata	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663886	KJ663845	KJ663927
	CBS 761.73	Pinus sylvestris	France	M. Morelet	KJ663887	KJ663846	KJ663928
Phacidium lauri	CBS 198.68	Vinca minor	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663890	KJ663849	KJ663930
	CBS 308.68	Prunus laurocerasus	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663891	KJ663850	KJ663931
	CBS 443.71	Ilex aquifolium	Netherlands	L. Marvanová	KM216397	KM216392	KM216396
	CBS 589.67	Ilex aquifolium	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663892	KJ663851	KJ663932
Phacidium mollerianum	CBS 365.72	Eucalyptus sp.	Italy	W. Gams	KJ663888	KJ663847	KJ663929
	CBS 574.66	Polygonatum odoratum	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663889	KJ663848	KM216395
Phacidium pseudophacidioides	CBS 497.72	Chamaespartium sagittale	Switzerland	E. Müller	KJ663893	KJ663852	KJ663933
	CBS 590.69	Ilex aquifolium	Netherlands	H.A. van der Aa	KJ663894	KJ663853	KJ663934
Phacidium trichophori	CBS 138246 = CPC 22952	Trichophorum cespitosum subsp. germanicum	Netherlands	W. Quaedvlieg	KJ663895	KJ663854	KJ663935
Phacidium vaccinii	CBS 444.71	Vaccinium vitis-idaea	Netherlands	L. Marvanová	KJ663896	KJ663855	KJ663936
Phlyctema vincetoxici	CBS 123726	Vincetoxicum officinale	Czech Republic	G. Verkley	KJ663897	KJ663856	KJ663937
	CBS 123727	Vincetoxicum officinale	Czech Republic	G. Verkley	KJ663898	KJ663857	KJ663938
	CBS 123743	Vincetoxicum officinale	Czech Republic	G. Verkley	KJ663899	KJ663858	KJ663939
Potebniamyces pyri	CBS 282.55	Pyrus communis	Netherlands	Zweede	KJ663862	KJ663823	KJ663903
	CBS 322.63	Pyrus communis	Netherlands	G.S. Roosje	KJ663900	KJ663859	KJ663940
Pseudophacidium ledi	CBS 377.59	Picea abies	Switzerland	J. Gremmen	KJ663901	KJ663860	KJ663941
Sarcotrochila longispora	CBS 273.74	Pinus contorta	British Columbia	W.G. Ziller & A. Funk	KJ663877	KJ663836	KJ663918

1CBS: CBS-KNAW Fungal Biodiversity Centre, Utrecht, The Netherlands; CPC: Culture collection of Pedro Crous, housed at CBS.

2LSU: large subunit (28S) of the nrRNA gene; ITS: internal transcribed spacers and intervening 5.8S nrDNA; RPB2: partial RNA polymerase II second largest subunit gene.

DNA isolation, amplification and analyses

Genomic DNA was extracted from fungal colonies growing on MEA using the UltraCleanTM Microbial DNA Isolation Kit (MoBio Laboratories, Solana Beach, CA) according to the manufacturer’s protocol. The primers LSU1Fd (Crous ) and LR5 (Vilgalys & Hester 1990) were used to amplify the partial 28S rRNA gene (LSU), ITS5 and ITS4 (White ) were used to amplify the internal transcribed spacer region (ITS), fRPB2-5F (Liu ), and fRPB2-414R (Quaedvlieg ) were used to amplify the partial RNA polymerase II second largest subunit locus (RPB2). A basic alignment of the obtained sequence data was first done using MAFFT v. 7 (http://mafft.cbrc.jp/alignment /server/index. html; Katoh ) and if necessary, manually improved in BioEdit v. 7.0.5.2 (Hall 1999). To check the congruency of the individual datasets, a 70 % neighbour-joining (NJ) reciprocal bootstrap was performed (Mason-Gamer & Kellogg 1996, Lombard ). A Bayesian analysis (critical value for the topological convergence diagnostic set to 0.01) was performed on both the Multi order LSU (Fig. 1) and the concatenated ITS, LSU and RPB2 (Fig. 2) datasets using MrBayes v. 3.2.1 (Huelsenbeck & Ronquist 2001) as described by Crous using nucleotide substitution models that were selected using the Akaike Information Criterion implemented in MrModeltest v. 2.3 (Nylander 2004). Novel sequences derived from this study were lodged at GenBank, and the alignments and phylogenetic trees in TreeBASE (www.treebase.org/treebase/index.html).

Fig. 1.

A Bayesian 50 % majority rule LSU consensus tree containing representative isolates belonging to Leotiomycetes and related classes. Bayesian posterior probabilities support values for the respective nodes are displayed in the tree. A stop rule (set to 0.01) for the critical value for the topological convergence diagnostic was used for the Bayesian analysis. The tree was rooted to Saccharomyces cerevisiae (GenBank J01355). The scale bar indicates 0.1 expected changes per site

Fig. 2.

A Bayesian 50 % majority rule combined ITS, LSU and RPB2 consensus tree containing representative isolates belonging to the Phacidiales and related orders. Bayesian posterior probabilities support values for the respective nodes are displayed in the tree. A stop rule (set to 0.01) for the critical value for the topological convergence diagnostic was used for the Bayesian analysis. The tree was rooted to Sarcotrochila longispora (CBS 273.74). The scale bar indicates 0.01 expected changes per site

Morphology

Observations were made with a Zeiss V20 Discovery stereo-microscope, and with a Zeiss Axio Imager 2 light microscope using differential interference contrast (DIC) illumination and an AxioCam MRc5 camera and Zen software. Colony characters and pigment production were noted after 2 wk of growth on MEA, PDA and OA incubated at 25 °C. Colony colours (surface and reverse) were rated according to the colour charts of Rayner (1970). Morphological descriptions were based on cultures sporulating on PDA, and taxonomic novelties and metadata were deposited in MycoBank (www.MycoBank.org; Crous ).

RESULTS

Phylogeny

The ITS, RPB2 and LSU sequence datasets of 43 sequences (including the outgroup) did not show any conflicts in their tree topology for the 70 % reciprocal bootstrap trees, allowing us to combine them in the multigene analyses. For Fig. 1, the LSU overview dataset of 160 sequences (including the outgroup) contained 830 characters, of which 461 contained unique site patterns. For Fig. 2, the LSU dataset contained 819 characters, of which 101 contained unique site patterns, the RPB2 dataset contained 355 characters, of which 155 contained unique site patterns, and the ITS dataset contained 537 characters, of which 203 contained unique site patterns.

For the combined dataset, all data partitions used the GTR model but the LSU partition was analysed with MrBayes using dirichlet (1,1,1,1) state frequency distribution and inverse gamma-shaped rate variation across sites, the ITS partition was analysed using a fixed (equal) state frequency distribution and gamma-shaped rate variation across sites, and the RPB2 partition was analysed using fixed (equal) state frequency distribution and inverse gamma-shaped rate variation across sites. For the LSU overview tree, MrModeltest suggested the same Bayesian parameters as for the LSU partition in the combined dataset. During the generation of Fig. 1, 72 262 trees were generated of which 54 198 (75 %) were sampled for the final tree; for Fig. 2, 2 672 trees were generated of which 2 004 (75 %) were sampled for the final tree.

TAXONOMY

The genus Phacidium represents inoperculate discomycetes characterised by erumpent, cleistohymenial apothecia with a covering layer splitting into teeth or lobes, an externally black stroma with vertically arranged pseudoparenchymatous cells, asci that are clavate, (4–)8-spored, with amyloid dehiscence rings, and aseptate, ellipsoid, hyaline ascospores lacking sheaths or appendages. Paraphyses extend above the asci, frequently anastomose, are embedded in mucilage, and arise from the subhymenium. The Ceuthospora asexual morphs have phialidic conidiogenesis, and subcylindrical, hyaline conidia with funnel-shaped, mucoid apical appendages.

Leotiomycetes, Phacidiales, Phacidiaceae

Phacidiales Höhn., Ber. Deutsch. Bot. Ges. 34: 416 (1917).

Saprobic or plant pathogenic. Ascomata circular, superficial, discoid, or immersed, becoming erumpent, opening by irregular tears in upper layer. Asci clavate, unitunicate with or without apical dehiscence ring. Ascospores aseptate, ellipsoid to subcylindrical or irregularly so, straight to curved, hyaline or brown, without sheath. Paraphyses branched or simple, septate, hyaline, anastomosing, invested in mucilage. Conidiomata uni- to multilocular, single to aggregated. Conidiophores hyaline, smooth, branched, or reduced to conidiogenous cells. Conidiogenous cells phialidic, at times proliferating percurrently, invested in mucilage. Conidia subcylindrical, ellipsoid-oblong or subreniform, aseptate, with or without appendages.

Type family: Phacidiaceae Fr. 1849.

Phacidiaceae Fr., Summa veg. Scand. 2: 367 (1849); as “Phacidicei”.

Synonym: Bulgariaceae Fr., Summa veg. Scand. 2: 357 (1849); as “Bulgariacei”.

Foliicolous, caulicolous, corticicolous, parasitic or saprobic (endophytic). Ascomata apothecial, discoid, or circular, initially immersed, becoming erumpent, opening by irregular tears in upper layer, teeth opening to expose hymenium; wall of textura globulosa to textura angularis; inner layer of smooth-walled, hyaline periphysoids invested in mucilage; basal stroma of textura angularis to textura globulosa. Asci arising from croziers, clavate, (4–)8-spored, unitunicate, with or without amyloid dehiscence ring staining blue in Melzer’s reagent. Ascospores aseptate, ellipsoid, fusoid, subcylindrical or irregularly so, hyaline or brown, with or without germ slit, straight to curved, lacking gelatinous appendages. Paraphyses branched or simple, septate hyaline, anastomosing, invested in mucilage or not. Conidiomata uni- to multilocular, single to aggregated, with one to several ostioles. Walls of textura angularis to textura globulosa. Conidiophores hyaline, smooth, branched, or reduced to conidiogenous cells, arising from inner layer of conidioma. Conidiogenous cells phialidic, at times proliferating percurrently, invested in mucilage. Conidia hyaline, smooth, subcylindrical, ellipsoid-oblong or subreniform, with or without apical, mucoid funnel-shaped appendage.

Notes: Bulgaria inquinans (formerly Bulgariaceae) forms a strongly supported monophyletic group with members of the Phacidiaceae, and although its exact placement within this group is unresolved, Bulgariaceae is reduced to synonymy because it is genetically very close to these taxa (Figs 1–2). Holwaya mucida, placed in Bulgariaceae by Lumbsch & Huhndorf (2010) based on the results of Wang (2006b), groups outside Phacidiaceae and does not appear to be closely related (Fig. 1). Morphologically Bulgariaceae resembles the Phacidiaceae in its cleistohymenial development (Bellemère 1968), but is distinguished by having ascomata with a brownish outer exciple, a thick gelatinous medullary exciple, and four of the eight ascospores being dark brown, with a longitudinal germ-slit. Potebniamyces pyri (syn. Phacidiopycnis pyri), which was also placed in Bulgariaceae, clusters in the same clade. The family name Phacidiaceae was published in the same publication as Bulgariaceae, but is chosen here over the latter, as the family name Phacidiaceae is better established in the literature, and has more members.

Type genus: Phacidium Fr. 1815. Other genera accepted in Phacidiaceae based on DNA data include Allantophomopsiella, Allantophomopsis, Bulgaria, Potebniamyces, and Pseudophacidium.

Allantophomopsiella Crous, gen. nov.

MycoBank MB809673

Etymology: Named after its morphological similarity to the genus Allantophomopsis.

Diagnosis: Distinct from Apostrasseria and Allantophomopsis in lacking percurrent proliferation and in having inequilaterally fusiform or naviculate conidia.

Description: Conidiomata pycnidial, immersed, becoming erumpent, irregularly multilocular, dark brown, ostiolate; wall of 3–4 layers of dark brown textura angularis. Conidiophores arising from inner layer of conidioma, at times reduced to conidiogenous cells, branched, septate. Conidiogenous cells integrated or discrete, ampulliform to subcylindrical or lageniform, hyaline, smooth with minute periclinal thickening at apex. Conidia ellipsoid to fusiform, hyaline, smooth, aseptate, guttulate, bearing mucoid apical appendages (Type C sensu Nag Raj 1993), flabelliform to irregular in shape.

Type species: Allantophomopsiella pseudotsugae (M. Wilson) Crous 2014.

Allantophomopsiella pseudotsugae (M. Wilson) Crous, comb. nov.

MycoBank MB809674

(Fig. 3)

Fig. 3.

Allantophomopsiella pseudotsugae (CBS 841.91). A. Conidiomata forming on autoclaved barley leaves. B–E. Conidiogenous cells giving rise to conidia. F. Conidia. Bars: A = 300 μm, all others = 10 μm

Basionym: Phomopsis pseudotsugae M. Wilson, Trans. R. Scottish Arboricult. Soc. 34(2): 147 (1920).

Synonyms: Allantophomopsis pseudotsugae (M. Wilson) Nag Raj, Coelom. Anam. App. Conidia: 116 (1993).

Phacidiella coniferarum G.G. Hahn, Mycologia 49: 227 (1957).

Phacidium coniferarum (G.G. Hahn) DiCosmo, et al., Canad. J. Bot. 61: 37 (1983).

Additional synonyms are provided in Nag Raj (1993).

Specimens examined: Germany: on Pinus wood, Dec. 1991, P. Schumacher (CBS 841.91). – The Netherlands: Groesbeek, on needles of Pinus sylvestris, Nov. 1970, J. Gremmen (CBS 437.71). – Norway: on needles of Pinus sylvestris, July 1963, F. Roll-Hansen (CBS H-15946, culture CBS 562.63); Førde in Sunnfjord, shoot of Pseudotsuga menziesii, Apr. 1948, H. Robak (CBS 320.53); Gyl in Nordmøre, dead bark of Picea abies, June 1948, H. Robak (CBS 321.53). – UK: near Dumfries, dieback of 30-yr-old Picea abies, Oct. 1937, Peace (CBS 288.37).

Sporulating on PNA: Conidiomata pycnidial, immersed, becoming erumpent, irregularly multilocular, to 600 μm diam, dark brown, ostiolate; wall of 3–4 layers of dark brown textura angularis. Conidiophores arising from inner layer of conidioma, at times reduced to conidiogenous cells, branched, septate, 5–15 × 2.5–3.5 μm. Conidiogenous cells integrated or discrete, ampulliform to subcylindrical or lageniform, hyaline, smooth with minute periclinal thickening at apex, 5–8 × 2.5–3 μm. Conidia (4–)5–6(–7) × (2–)3 μm, ellipsoid to fusiform, hyaline, smooth, aseptate, guttulate, bearing mucoid apical appendages (Type C sensu Nag Raj 1993, only visible in water), flabelliform to irregular in shape.

Culture characteristics: Colonies spreading, flat with sparse aerial mycelium and feathery margins. On PDA surface olivaceous grey, reverse iron-grey. On OA surface olivaceous grey with patches of iron-grey.

Notes: Distinct from Apostrasseria and Allantophomopsis in that it lacks percurrent proliferation on its conidiogenous cells, and has inequilaterally fusiform or naviculate conidia.

Gremmenia: snow-blight pathogens of conifers

Gremmen (1953) described Phragmonaevia gigaspora as a new pathogen associated with needle blight (snow mould disease) of Pinus cembra in Europe. In his revision of Helotiales occurring on conifers, Korf (1962) established the genus Gremmenia to accommodate this pathogen, as it was clearly distinct from Phacidium s. str., lacking a distinct upper stroma in its apothecia. He also disagreed with Petrak (1957), who concluded that P. gigaspora represented old and abnormal material of Phacidium infestans, which occurs on Pinus sylvestris, and its synonym, Phacidium pini-cembrae, which occurs on Pinus cembra. Korf (1962) distinguished these two species based on the fact that Phacidium pini-cembrae frequently has less than eight ascospores in its asci, a feature not observed in P. infestans. In a detailed comparison of the two species made by DiCosmo , G. gigaspora was reduced to synonymy with Phacidium infestans. Phacidium infestans and P. pini-cembrae are morphologically similar, but can be distinguished based on different hosts, as well as ascus and ascospore morphologies (DiCosmo ). Ascospores of P. infestans are elongate-ellipsoid, straight, curved, or curved-fusiform, eight per ascus, with apothecia formed on needles of two-needled pines. In contrast, ascospores of P. pini-cembrae are slightly narrower, elongate-ellipsoid, frequently less than eight per ascus, and apothecia occur on needles of five-needled pines. Although DiCosmo listed Phragmonaevia gigaspora as synonym of Phacidium infestans, this was incorrect, as a Phragmonaevia gigaspora occurs on Pinus cembra, and frequently has less than 8-ascospores (clearly illustrated by Gremmen 1953), and thus is more correctly placed in synonymy with Phacidium pini-cembrae. A third species of this complex is P. abietis, which causes disease on Abies and Pseudotsuga. Although further research is required to define the host range of these species, they are clearly not members of Phacidium s. str. (Fig. 2), and thus the genus Gremmenia is herewith resurrected to accommodate them.

Gremmenia Korf, Mycologia 54: 27 (1962).

Plant pathogenic, foliicolous. Ascomata scattered, gregarious or separate, circular to elliptical in outline, subepidermal, raising host tissue, bursting open via 4–8 teach that curve backwards, exposing the creamy hymenium at maturity; apothecial roof of textura globulosa, brown, appearing like a clypeus when viewed in section when ascomata are immature, becoming hyaline towards interior, with inner layer giving rise to periphysoids, invested in mucilage; subhymenium of hyaline smooth-walled hyphae, forming a textura angularis. Paraphyses simple or branched, septate, hyaline, smooth-walled, invested in mucilage, sometimes slightly swollen at the tip. Asci club-shaped, (1–)8-spored, tapering towards base, stipitate, flattened at apex, giving blue reaction in Melzer’s reagent. Ascospores biseriate, ellipsoid-elongate, straight to curved or reniform, aseptate, finely guttulate, hyaline, smooth.

Type species: Gremmenia gigaspora (Gremmen) Korf 1962 (i.e. G. pini-cembrae (Rehm) Crous 2014).

Gremmenia abietis (Dearn.) Crous, comb. nov.

MycoBank MB809676

Basionym: Phacidium infestans var. abietis Dearn., Mycologia 18: 237 (1926).

Synonym: Phacidium abietis (Dearn.) J. Reid & Cain, Mycologia 54: 482 (1963) [“1962”] (nom. illegit., Art. 53.1; non P. abietis Rabenh. 1844).

Notes: Gremmenia abietis causes snow-blight of Abies spp. and Pseudotsuga menziesii (Dearness 1926, Faull 1930). Bega (1978) reported that the disease could reach epidemic proportions in Idaho and Oregon. No cultures are presently available of this pathogen, and it will have to be recollected to clarify its phylogenetic position.

Gremmenia infestans (P. Karst.) Crous, comb. nov.

MycoBank MB809677

(Fig. 4)

Fig. 4.

Gremmenia infestans (S-F207441). A, B. Ascomata on needles. C, D. Vertical section through ascomata. E–G. Asci and ascospores (F in Meltzer’s solution). H. Ascospores. Bars: A = 1 mm, B = 0.5 mm, all others = 10 μm

Basionym: Phacidium infestans P. Karst., Hedwigia 25: 232 (1886).

Description and illustrations: DiCosmo .

Specimens examined: Sweden, Vindeln, host unknown, 1946, E. Björkman, CBS 396.48; location unknown, on needles of Abies balsamea, Oct 1931, J.H. Faull, CBS 265.31; on needles of A. balsamea, 30 Nov. 1928, J.H. Faull, CBS 264.31; on needles of Picea, 22 Nov. 1928, J.H. Faull, CBS 263.31. Lappland, Jokkmokk, Kassavare, on dead needles of Pinus sylvestris, still attached to a young tree, 31 Aug. 2011, K. Hansen & I. Olariaga (S).

Notes: The isolates listed here show variation in the DNA sequence data, suggesting that they could represent more than one taxon. As the cultures proved to be sterile, fresh collections and epitypification is required to settle the application of the name.

Gremmenia pini-cembrae (Rehm) Crous, comb. nov.

MycoBank MB809678

Basionym: Phacidium lacerum f. pini-cembrae Rehm, Ber. Bayer. Bot. Ges. 13: 124 (1912).

Synonyms: Phacidium pini-cembrae (Rehm) Terrier, Beitr. Kryptog-fl. Schweiz 9: 73 (1942).

Phragmonaevia gigaspora Gremmen, Sydowia 7: 141 (1953).

Gremmenia gigaspora (Gremmen) Korf, Mycologia 54: 27 (1962).

Description and illustrations: DiCosmo .

Phacidium Fr., Observ. mycol. 1: 167 (1815); nom. cons.

Synonyms: Phacidiostroma Höhn., Ber. dt. bot. Ges. 35: 420 (1917).

Ceuthospora Grev., Scot. Crypt. Flora 5: 253 (1827); nom. cons.

Foliicolous or caulicolous. Ascomata amphigenous, scattered or gregarious, circular, immersed, becoming erumpent, rupturing host tissue by irregular stellate splits, of dark brown pseudoparenchymatal cells of textura globulosa, inner layer with periphysoids, invested in mucilage. Hymenium of asci and paraphyses; basal stroma present or absent. Asci clavate, (4–)8-spored, with amyloid (staining blue in Melzer’s reagent) apical discharge mechanism. Ascospores aseptate, ellipsoid to ellipsoid-fusoid, uni- to biseriate, hyaline, smooth, lacking mucoid appendages. Paraphyses septate, hyaline, smooth, branched, anastomosing, invested in mucilage. Conidiomata pycnidial, immersed, becoming erumpent, uni- to multilocular, brown, with ostiole; wall of textura angularis to textura globulosa. Conidiophores branched or simple, septate, hyaline, smooth, invested in mucilage. Conidiogenous cells phialidic, at times proliferating percurrently, subcylindrical to ampulliform, smooth, hyaline, invested in mucilage. Conidia subcylindrical, aseptate, hyaline, smooth, with irregular funnel-shaped apical mucilaginous appendage.

Type species: Phacidium lacerum Fr. 1818, typ. cons.

Phacidium calderae (Urries) Crous, comb. nov.

MycoBank MB809679

(Fig. 5)

Fig. 5.

Phacidium calderae (CBS 372.81). A, B. Conidiomata. C, D. Conidiogenous cells. E, F. Conidia. Bars: A, B = 200 μm, all others = 10 μm

Basionym: Ceuthospora calderae Urries, An. Inst. bot. A.J. Cavanilles 14: 165 (1956) [“1955”].

Description: Conidiomata multilocular, with large central ostiole, papillate. Conidiophores frequently reduced to conidiogenous cells, branched, 1–3-septate, up to 30 μm long, 3–4 μm diam. Conidiogenous cells hyaline, smooth, terminal and subterminal, 5–15 × 2.5–3.5 μm, proliferating with periclinal thickening (characteristic of this species). Conidia subcylindrical, smooth, granular, hyaline, (17–)18–20(–22) × 3.5(–4) μm, with a flared, funnel-shaped apical mucoid appendage.

Culture characteristics: Colonies flat, spreading, with sparse aerial mycelium and feathery margins. On PDA and OA surface and reverse olivaceous grey.

Specimens examined: Italy: Sardinia: Tacco di Sta Barbara, fallen leaf of Arbutus unedo, 10 May 1971, W. Gams & J.A. Stalpers (CBS 287.72). – Spain: Ibiza: Cala Llonga, fallen leaves of Pistacia terebinthus, 17 Apr. 1981, H.A. van der Aa (CBS H-10269, culture CBS 372.81).

Notes: Ceuthospora calderae was originally described from leaves of Pistacia lentiscus, collected from the Canary Islands. Culture CBS 372.81 closely matches the morphology of this species; CBS 287.72 was now sterile.

Phacidium fennicum Butin, Sydowia 37: 21 (1984).

Description and illustration: Butin (1984).

Specimen examined: Finland: Lempäälä Kulju, on needles of Pinus sylvestris, 18 Apr. 1982, U. Söderholm (CBS 457.83 – ex-type culture).

Phacidium lacerum Fr., Observ. mycol. 2: 312 (1818) : Fr., Syst. mycol. 2: 575 (1823).

(Figs 6–7)

Fig. 6.

Phacidium lacerum (CBS 761.73). A, B. Conidiomata on autoclaved barley leaves. C–E. Conidiogenous cells. F. Conidia. Bars: A, B = 300 μm, all others = 10 μm

Fig. 7.

Phacidium lacerum (K(M) 189269). A, B. Ascomata on needles. C–E. Vertical section through ascomata. F, G. Asci and ascospores. H, I. Conidia. Bars: A, B = 1000 μm, all others = 10 μm

Synonyms: Dothidea pinastri Fr., Elench. fung. 2: 123 (1828).

Ceuthospora pinastri (Fr.) Höhn., Mitt. bot. Inst. tech. Hochsch. Wien 2(4): 104 (1925).

Additional synonyms are included in Nag Raj (1993).

Description: Foliicolous or on cone scales. Ascomata amphigenous, circular, 300–2000 μm diam, aggregated to solitary, initially immersed, subepidermal, becoming erumpent, opening by 3–5 teeth of brown textura globulosa, to expose hymenium; inner layer of periphysoids, covered in mucilage. Asci clavate, 8-spored, with amyloid (straining blue in Melzer’s reagent) discharge mechanism, 70–110 × 7–10 μm. Ascospores aseptate, hyaline, smooth, guttulate, biseriate, 9.5–12.5 × 3–3.5 μm. Paraphyses simple, septate, hyaline, smooth, anastomosing, invested in mucilage. Conidiomata pycnidial, flask-shaped to irregularly subglobose, amphigenous, scattered, gregarious, to aggregated, subepidermal, splitting the epidermis, multilocular, 500–1500 μm diam, brown from surface view, with individual locules up to 170 μm diam, with individual ostioles up to 25 μm diam. Condiophores simple or branched, septate, often reduced to phialidic conidiogenous cells, lining the inner layer of conidioma, hyaline, smooth-walled, (5–)7–15 × 2–3(–4) μm, invested in mucilage; proliferating percurrently, or with visible periclinal thickening. Conidia aseptate, subcylindrical, base bluntly rounded with central, flattened scar, apex with funnel-shaped mucilaginous appendage, (10–)13–15(–18) × (2.5–) 3(–4) μm.

Culture characteristics: Colonies spreading with sparse to moderate aerial mycelium. On OA surface pale olivaceous grey. On PDA surface olivaceous grey, reverse iron-grey.

Specimens examined: France: Mt. Ventoux, living needle of Juniperus communis, May 1981, O. Petrini (CBS 400.81); Hagenau, Bas Rhin, on needles of Pinus sylvestris, 26 Aug. 1968, M. Morelet (CBS H-10302 – neotype for Phacidium lacerum designated here, MBT178726; CBS 761.73 – ex-neotype culture). – Germany: Baden, Bastadt, on pine needles, Apr. 1877, Schroeter [ex herbs Thuemen & Grove] (K(M) 189268); Königstein, on needles of P. sylvestris, 30 Apr. 1887, W. Krieger [Fungi Saxonici exs. 290] (K(M) 189269). – The Netherlands: on needle of Pinus sylvestris, Feb. 1930, J.Y. van Vliet (CBS 130.30); Baarn, Cantonspark, on leaves of Sciadopitys verticillata, 27 Apr. 1970, H.A. van der Aa (CBS 557.70); Baarn, Maarschalksbos, on leaves of Ilex aquifolium, July 1969, H.A. van der Aa (CBS H-10292, culture CBS 338.70); Hulshorsterzand, on needles of Pinus sylvestris, 12 Apr. 1970, H.A. van der Aa (CBS 540.70). – Sweden: on needles of Pinus sylvestris, ex-herb Fries (UPS).

Notes: Phacidium lacerum was originally described from European collections on needles from Pinus sylvestris, and is widely distributed throughout Europe, where it occurs commonly on this host. The material in UPS referred to as the “original collection” by (DiCosmo ) in UPS was stated to be depauperate. In the sanctioning work, Fries (1823) refers to “(Exs. ined.)” and later “S.S.” (Fries 1849) implying that he had intended to distribute material in his exsiccate Scleromycetes Suecici. This was not, however, done and the name is listed as “material unknown” by Holm & Nannfeldt (1962: 38). The UPS specimen is unlocalised and has no date, and appears to have been collected after Fries came to Uppsala in 1835 according to Stefan Ekman (pers. comm.) (Fig. 8). That specimen is not, therefore, the “original collection” Fries had before him in 1818 or 1823 and so a neotype is designated for Fries’ name here.

Fig. 8.

Phacidium lacerum (UPS – Fries’ specimen). Photo: Stefan Ekman

Phacidium lauri (Sow.) Crous & D. Hawksw., comb. nov.

MycoBank MB810293

Basionym: Sphaeria lauri Sow., Col. Fig. Br. Fungi 3: sine pagin. [53] (1803).

Synonyms: Cryptosphaeria lauri (Sow.) Grev., Fl. Edin.: 361 (1824).

Ceuthospora lauri (Sow.) Grev., Scott. Crypt. Fl. 5: 254 (1826) : Fr., Syst. mycol., Index: 167 (1832).

Xyloma multivalve DC., Fl. franç., 3rd edn 2: 303 (1805).

Phacidium multivalve (DC.) J.C. Schmidt, Mykol. Heft. 1: 42 (1817) : Fr., Syst. mycol. 2: 576 (1823).

Ceuthospora phacidioides Grev., Scott. Crypt. Fl. 5: 253 (1826); nom. illegit. (Art. 52,1).

Additional synonyms are listed in Nag Raj (1993).

Descriptions and illustrations: Sutton (1972, a sexual morph), DiCosmo et al. (1984; sexual and asexual morph) and Nag Raj (1993; asexual morph only).

Specimens examined: The Netherlands: Baarn, Drakenburgerweg, on Ilex aquifolium, 8 Oct. 1967, H.A. van der Aa (CBS 589.67, as C. phacidioides); Baarn, Cantonspark, on leaves of Prunus laurocerasus, 2 Mar. 1968, H.A. van der Aa (CBS H-10276 – epitype of , MBT178727; CBS 308.68 – culture ex-epitype); Wageningen, on leaves of Ilex aquifolium, May 1969, L. Marvanová (CBS 443.71, as C. phacidioides); Baarn, Eemnesserweg 90, on leaves of Vinca minor, 3 Mar. 1968, H.A. van der Aa (CBS H-10271, culture CBS 198.68, as C. feurichii). – UK: sine loc., on dead leaves of Prunus laurocerasus, G.B.W. Kirby (K – holotype of Sphaeria lauri [not traced]; K (M) IMI 153020 – slides ex holotype).

Notes: Conidia of the present strains (12–)13–15(–16) × 3(–3.5) μm fall into the variation of C. lauri (7–17 × 2–3 μm, Nag Raj 1993), which has several synonyms, including C. phacidioides (Nag Raj 1993). Furthermore, DiCosmo link C. phacidioides (conidia 10–17 × 2.5–3 μm) to Phacidium multivalve as sexual morph. Ceuthospora lauri, which is the type species of the genus Ceuthospora (on Prunus laurocerasus, Europe), and C. phacidioides (Ilex aquifolium, Europe), have been commonly confused in the past, but appear to be synonymous based on the cultures we investigated in this study. Di Cosmo et al. (1984) designated a lectotype for Xyloma multivalve in G but did not provide more details. However, we have been unable to locate the original material of all these synonyms (also see Sutton 1980, Nag Raj 1993), and suspect that they have been lost. The names Ceuthospora lauri and Phacidium multivalve were both sanctioned by Fries, and as the earliest species epithet which is legitimate under the ICN is Sphaeria lauri, that name has priority. Ceuthospora lauri also appears more commonly used in literature than Phacidium multivalve. Note that the name Ceuthospora phacidioides is illegitimate as Xyloma multivalve was listed as a synonym when it was introduced; it is therefore a superfluous name.

The choice of the epithet “lauri” by Sowerby is explained by Grove (1935: 291–292): “Owing to the custom, in Britain, of speaking of Prunus Laurocerasus as ‘the Laurel’, great confusion has arisen. It has frequently been erroneously regarded as the true Bay Laurel (Laurus nobilis), and its leaves are still sometimes used by our cooks as such.” He also confirmed that Greville’s specimens were on the Prunus and not Laurus, contrary to his publications, which led to that error being perpetuated although the misidentification was soon recognized, for example, by Berkeley (1836: 283) who gave it the English name “Cherry-laurel Ceuthospora” and stated “On dead leaves of Prunus Lauro-cerasus (not Laurus nobilis as is stated by Dr. Greville)”.

Sowerby (1803) referred to a single unlocalized, but presumably English (as his work was devoted to fungi from that country) collection made by the Rev. William Kirby (1759–1850) when introducing the name Sphaeria lauri (Fig. 9); Kirby was born in and died in Suffolk, England. The original material was located in K by Sutton (1972) who prepared sections (now preserved as K(M) IMI 153020; Fig 10) and published drawings made from Kirby’s specimen (Sutton 1972: 323 fig. 1). That specimen could not now be re-located in K, despite extensive searches by Begoña Aguirre-Hudson, Heidi Döring, and D.L.H. Sutton did, however, include a sketch of the material he saw which evidently comprised two specimens, the right-hand one of which had Kirby’s name below it and is therefore the holotype of Sowerby’s name.

Fig. 9.

Sowerby’s original diagnosis (A) and illustrations (B) of Sphaeria lauri. From Sowerby (1803)

Fig. 10.

Sphaeria lauri packet with slides made Brian Sutton from Sowerby’s holotype (K(M) IMI 153020)

Sutton (1972, 1980) attributed the epithet “lauri” to Greville and not Sowerby, in accordance with the Code then in operation which ruled that names of “Fungi caeteri” published before 1 January 1821 were not validly published; that situation changed with the deletion of the later starting point dates for fungi at the Sydney IBC in 1981. In using the term “lectotype”, Sutton meant as the type of Ceuthospora lauri “Grev.”, and that is clear from his annotation on the packet with the slides (Fig. 10) and not Sowerby’s original binomial. The use of that term was correct for Greville’s name, under the pre-1981 Code, as Greville had studied collections other than Sowerby’s.

Phacidium mollerianum (Thüm.) Crous, comb. nov.

MycoBank MB809680

(Fig. 11)

Fig. 11.

Phacidium molleriana (CBS 574.66). A. Conidiomata on autoclaved barley leaves. B–E. Conidiogenous cells. F, G. Conidia. Bars: A = 300 μm, all others = 10 μm

Basionym: Sphaeropsis molleriana Thüm., Inst. Coimbra 27: 40 (1879).

Synonyms: Phoma molleriana (Thüm.) Sacc., Syll. fung. 3: 110 (1884).

Macrophoma molleriana (Thüm.) Berl. & Voglino, Syll. fung., Addit. I: 314 (1886).

Ceuthospora molleriana (Thüm.) Petr., Annls mycol. 23: 29 (1925).

Description: Conidiomata uni- to multilocular, up to 400 μm diam. Conidiophores branched, up to 45 μm long, 2–3 μm diam. Conidiogenous cells terminal and lateral, 5–10 × 2–3 μm, with prominent periclinal thickening, rarely proliferating percurrently. Conidia hyaline, smooth, granular, subcylindrical, (9–)10–12(–13) × (2–)2.5 μm; apical mucoid appendage only visible when mounted in water.

Culture characteristics: Colonies spreading with sparse aerial mycelium and feathery margins. On PDA and OA surface and reverse olivaceous grey.

Cultures examined: Italy: Sardinia: Su Cologone, on leaves of Eucalyptus, 6 May 1971, W. Gams (CBS H-10285, 10286; CBS 365.72 – culture). – The Netherlands: Baarn, leaf spot on Polygonatum odoratum, 8 Aug. 1966, H.A. van der Aa (CBS 574.66).

Notes: Ceuthospora molleriana was originally described from Eucalyptus leaves collected in Portugal (conidia 10–13 × 2–2.5 μm, Petrak 1925), and closely fits the morphology observed in the present collections. Although originally described from Eucalyptus, this taxon appears to have a wider host range.

Phacidium pseudophacidioides Crous, sp. nov.

MycoBank MB809681

(Fig. 12)

Fig. 12.

Phacidium pseudophacidioides (CBS 590.69). A, B. Conidiomata on autoclaved barley leaves. C–E. Conidiophores, conidiogenous cells and conidia. F. Conidia. Bars: A = 300 μm, B = 400 μm, all others = 10 μm

Etymology: Named after its morphological similarity to the asexual morph, Ceuthospora phacidioides.

Diagnosis: Conidiogenous cells discrete or integrated, subcylindrical with perominent periclinal thickening or percurrent proliferation, 7–19 × 2–2.5 μm. Conidia hyaline, smooth, granular, subcylindrical, tapering at ends, bearing a funnel-shaped mucoid apical appendage, (11–)11.5–12.5(–13) × (2–)2.5 μm.

Type: The Netherlands: Baarn, Eenmnesserweg 92, on Ilex aquifolium, 8 Aug. 1968, H.A. van der Aa (CBS H-10289 – holotype; CBS 590.69 – ex-type culture).

Description: Conidiomata stromatic, pycnidioid, scattered, black, subepidermal, multiloculate, up to 600 μm diam, with papillate ostioles. Conidiophores arising from inner layers of cavity, subcylindrical, hyaline, smooth, extensively branched, up to 120 μm long, 2.5–3 μm diam, invested in mucus. Conidiogenous cells discrete or integrated, subcylindrical with perominent periclinal thickening or percurrent proliferation, hyaline, smooth, 7–19 × 2–2.5 μm. Conidia hyaline, smooth, granular, subcylindrical, tapering at ends, apex subobtuse, base with truncate hilum, 1 μm diam, bearing a funnel-shaped mucoid apical appendage, (11–)11.5–12.5(–13) × (2–)2.5 μm.

Other specimen examined: Switzerland: Zürich: Weiacherberg, on dead leaf of Chamaespartium sagittale, 3 May 1952, E. Müller (CBS 497.72).

Notes: The two isolates of C. pseudophacidioides were originally identified as C. phacidioides (i.e. P. lauri). However, P. lauri has larger conidia, and the conidiophores are much more extensively branched than in P. pseudophacidioides.

Phacidium trichophori Crous & Quaedvlieg, sp. nov.

MycoBank MB809682

(Fig. 13)

Fig. 13.

Phacidium trichophori (CPC 22952). A, B. Conidiomata in culture. C–E. Conidiophores, conidiogenous cells and conidia. F, G. Conidia. Bars: A, B = 300 μm, all others = 10 μm

Etymology: Named after the host genus on which it was collected, Trichophorum.

Diagnosis: Conidiogenous cells discrete or integrated, subcylindrical with prominent periclinal thickening, 5–12 × 2–3 μm. Conidia hyaline, smooth, granular, subcylindrical, tapering towards a truncate basal scar, 0.5–1 μm diam, bearing a funnel-shaped mucoid apical appendage, 3–5 μm long, 2–4 μm diam at apex, (9–)10–11(–13) × (2–)2.5(–3) μm.

Type: The Netherlands: Korenburgerveen, Winterswijk, on Trichophorum cespitosum subsp. germanicum, 29 Apr. 2013, W. Quaedvlieg (CBS H-21816 – holotype; CBS 138246 = CPC 22952 – ex-type culture).

Description: Foliicolous. Conidiomata pseudostromatic, pycnidioid, scattered to gregarious, black, subepidermal, uniloculate, up to 300 μm diam; walls of the pseudostroma 40–90 μm thick. Conidiophores arising from inner layers of cavity, subcylindrical, hyaline, smooth, thin-walled, branched, to 30 μm long, invested in mucus. Conidiogenous cells discrete or integrated, subcylindrical with prominent periclinal thickening, hyaline, smooth, 5–12 × 2–3 μm. Conidia hyaline, smooth, granular, subcylindrical, tapering towards a truncate basal scar, 0.5–1 μm diam, apex subobtuse, bearing a funnel-shaped mucoid apical appendage, 3–5 μm long, 2–4 μm diam at apex, (9–)10–11(–13) × (2–)2.5(–3) μm.

Notes: Phacidium trichophori resembles P. lauri (conidia (12–)13–15(–16) × 3(–3.5) μm), but is morphologically distinct in having smaller conidia. Ceuthospora gaeumannii (conidia 8–11 × 2–2.5 μm, av. 9 × 2.2 μm; Nag Raj 1993) has slightly smaller conidia, much larger conidiomata (500–1500 μm diam).

Phacidium vaccinii Fr., Syst. Mycol. 2(2): 575 (1823).

Synonyms are listed in DiCosmo .

Culture examined: The Netherlands, Loenen, on leaves of Vaccinium vitis-idaea, May 1969, L. Marvanová (CBS 444.71).

Note: Unfortunately this culture proved to be sterile, and thus its morphology could not be confirmed.

Pseudophacidium P. Karst., Acta Soc. Fauna Fl.fenn. 2: 157 (1885) [“1881–1885”].

Synonym: Myxofusicoccum Died., Annls mycol. 19: 68 (1912).

Caulicolous. Ascomata scattered to gregarious, immersed, raising the host epidermis, causing it to rupture; ascomata oblong, hemispherical to irregularly pulvinate, black, carbonaceous; wall of brown textura globulosa, becoming pale brown towards interior; inner layers of subglobose, hyaline cells, invested in mucilage; subhymenium of hyaline textura intricata; basal stroma of pale brown pseudoparenchymatal cells. Asci club-shaped, 8-spored flattened at apex which does not strain in Melzer’s reagent. Ascospores irregularly biseriate, oblong-ellipsoidal, straight to curved, hyaline, smooth-walled. Conidiomata brown, pycnidioid, stromatic, gregarious to crowded, immersed, discoid to orbicular, opening by means of irregular ruptures, multilocular; wall of brown textura globulosa; basal stroma of pale brown textura epidermoidea. Conidiogenous cells phialidic, lining inner cavity, lageniform to ampulliform, hyaline, smooth-walled; proliferating percurrently at apex. Conidia ellipsoid to oblong or subreniform, apex rounded, base with truncate scar, guttulate, hyaline, smooth-walled.

Type species: Pseudophacidium ledi (Alb. & Schwein.) P. Karst. 1885.

Pseudophacidium ledi (Alb. & Schwein.) P. Karst., Acta Soc. Fauna Flora fenn. 2: 157 (1885) [“1881–1885”].

(Fig. 14)

Fig. 14.

Pseudophacidium ledi (CBS 377.59). A. Conidiomata forming on PNA. B–E. Conidiogenous cells giving rise to conidia. F. Conidia. Bars: A = 500 μm, all others = 10 μm

Basionym: Xyloma ledi Alb. & Schwein., Consp. fung.: 60 (1805)l

Description: Sporulating on PNA. Conidiomata stromatic, scattered, erumpent, irregular to pulvinate, brown, opening by irregular rupture, multilocular, up to 500 μm diam. Conidiophores arising from inner cavity, hyaline, subcylindrical, branched or not, 1–3-septate, to 30 μm long, 3–4μm diam, or reduced to condiogenous cells. Conidiogenous cells subcylindrical or ampulliform, phialidic, hyaline, smooth, 5–10 × 3–4 μm, proliferating 1–2 times percurrently near apex. Conidia solitary, ellipsoid to oblong, hyaline, guttulate, thin-walled, mostly widest in upper third, apex subobuse, base truncate, 1 μm diam, (8–)9–11(–12) × (4–)5(–6) μm.

Specimen examined: Switzerland, Graubünden, Bergün, on Picea abies, Apr. 1959, J. Gremmen (CBS 377.59).

Notes: Species of Pseudophacidium are immersed discomycetes that occur on bark of hard- or softwood. Ascomata open by means of an irregular rupture of the covering layer, exposing cream to greyish or brownish discs. The genus contains saprobic, and plant pathogenic species (Smerlis 1969).

Potebniamyces Smerlis, Canad. J. Bot. 40: 352 (1962).

Caulicolous and corticolous. Ascomata scattered to gregarious, initially immersed, becoming erumpent, irregular in outline, opening by irregular rupture to expose hymenium; apical roof of brown textura globulosa, becoming paler towards inner region, which consists of subcylindrical, branched, septate, hyaline periphysoids, invested in mucilage; hymenium red-brown in water, turning blue-green in 2 % KOH. Paraphyses numerous, subcylindrical, branched or septate, hyaline, smooth-walled. Asci club-shaped, 8-spored, with apex not staining in Meltzer’s reagent. Ascospores uni- to biseriate, subglobose to ellipsoid, aseptate, guttulate, hyaline to pale yellow, smooth-walled. Conidiomata scattered to aggregated, immersed, subepidermal, depressed globose, papillate, non-ostiolate, multilocular, brown, opening by irregular rupture; wall of brown textura globulosa to textura epidermoidea above, pale brown below, with wall of yellow-brown textura prismatica. Conidiogenous cells phialidic, lining the inner cavity, subcylindrical, lageniform to ampulliform, straight to curved, hyaline, smooth-walled. Conidia subglobose to obovoid, guttulate, aseptate, base truncate, hyaline to pale yellow, smooth-walled (adapted from Sutton 1980, and DiCosmo ).

Type species: Potebniamyces pyri (Berk. & Broome) Dennis 1978.

Potebniamyces pyri (Berk. & Broome) Dennis, Brit. Ascom., 2nd edn: 231 (1978).

Basionym: Stictis lecanora var. pyri Berk. & Broome, Ann. Mag. nat. Hist., ser. 4 17: 144 (1876).

Specimen examined: The Netherlands: Wilhelminadorp, bark of Pyrus communis, Mar. 1963, G.S. Roosje,(CBS 322.63); Wageningen, on peduncle of P. communis, Mar. 1955, Zweede (CBS 282.55).

Notes: Although we assume that Phacidiopycnis is the asexual morph of Potebniamyces, the type species of Phacidiopycnis, P. malorum, still needs to be recollected to confirm this assumption. For this reason the synonymy between these two generic names remains unconfirmed. If shown to be synonymous, the older name, Phacidiopycnis, will have preference for the holomorph (Johnston ).

1The text to illustrate the plates in this work are not numbered, and the diagnosis for this fungus appears on the 53rd; the illustration is on pl. 371 fig. 4 (Fig. 9), which has no diagnosis or name, and is dated “1802”, but it seems unlikely that the text was issued before the whole volume was completed in 1803.

DISCUSSION

The primary aim of this study was to obtain molecular support for the assumption that Ceuthospora and Phacidium are congeneric, and at the same time elucidate the position of Phacidiaceae within Leotiomycetes, as the latter family and order were not represented in the phylogenetic study of Wang .

The order Helotiales contains members that represent a broad range of ecologies, including species that are plant pathogenic, saprobic, endophytic, mycorrhizal or ectomycorrhizal parasites, aquatic saprobes, or wood rotting fungi (Wang ). Although lacking many genera of Helotiales in their phylogenetic analysis, Wang concluded that the concept of Helotiales adopted by Eriksson (2005) included many non-monophyletic taxa. They placed 13 families in the order. In spite of earlier work on the class (Gernandt , Lutzoni , Wang ), no members of Phacidium were present in the phylogeny of Wang . By adding Phacidiaceae to Helotiales data present in GenBank, Phacidiales clearly separated from Helotiales, which still appear heterogeneous (Fig. 1). The separation of Phacidiales from Helotiales is also supported by the phylogeny of Wang , as Bulgaria inquinans and Phacidiophicnes pyri cluster outside of the Helotiales clade in their study.

A surprising result of our study concerns the phylogenetic position of Bulgariaceae. The genus Bulgaria, based on B. inquinans, effectively clusters in Phacidiaceae (based on P. lacerum). A second species has been reported, B. nana (Döring & Triebel 1998, Wang 2006b), but that is considered a species of Austrocenangium (see Gamundi 1997). Bulgaria inquinans is characterised by large (up to 4 cm), dark brown to black turbinate, gelatinous apothecia with brown ascospores. It occurs on bark of fallen trunks and branches, but has also been observed on living trees. The species is considered saprobic, and possibly facultatively plant pathogenic. The relationship of Bulgaria has been debatable. It has been placed close to other species producing gelatinous apothecia in Leotiaceae/Helotiaceae, e.g. Leotia, Neobulgaria, Ombrophila (in Leotieae, Korf 1973; in Ombrophiloideae, Dennis 1978), or considered to be rather distinct, and placed as the sole genus in Bulgariaceae (Helotiales) (e.g. Eriksson 2006). Although some molecular phylogenetic studies have not been able to place Bulgaria in a larger group with support, and instead suggest species such as Leotia, Neobulgaria and Ombrophila (Helotiaceae) are not closely related (Wang 2006a, b), Lantz placed Bulgaria in a strongly supported clade with Phacidium and Potebniamyces. The relationship between Bulgaria and Phacidium was also confirmed by Hustad & Miller (2011). The ultrastructure of the ascus apical apparatus of Bulgaria, however, is unique compared to other members of Helotiales (Verkley 1992, 1994). For the present, we treat Bulgariaceae as a synonym of Phacidiaceae, but it could be that the family is still heterogeneous, and as more members of Phacidiaceae and Helotiaceae get added in future molecular studies, the Phacidiaceae may yet prove to be paraphyletic.

In our results, the genus Allantophomopsis (based on A. cytisporea), clusters sister to the canker pathogen Potebniamyces pyri (asexual morph: Phacidiopycnis pyri). Potebniamyces produces black, gelatinous discs, erumpent from submerged stromata in tree bark. Although DiCosmo considered this genus a possible member of Phacidiaceae, Rhytismataceae or Dermateaceae, it appears to be a member of an independent family. As the majority of the families in Helotiales still lack molecular data, we consider it premature to introduce any new family name here to accommodate Potebniamyces. DiCosmo discussed the morphological differences between Potebniamyces and Phacidium, and Wang suggested a possible sister relationship between the two genera.

In the present study we introduce the generic name Allantophomopsiella to accommodate A. pseudotsugae, a pathogen of conifers (Roll Hansen 1992). The genus Gremmenia is resurrected to accommodate the snow-blight pathogens of conifers, namely G. abietis (on Abies spp. and Pseudotsuga menziesii), G. infestans (on Abies balsamea), and G. pini-cembrae (on Pinus cembra).

Finally, the position of the Phacidiaceae is clarified within the resurrected Phacidiales, with respectively a neotype and an epitype designated to fix the phylogenetic application of the names Phacidium lacerum (type of Phacidium) and Sphaeria lauri (type of Ceuthospora) (i.e. Phacidium lauri). Phacidium (1815) is accepted as the correct name for this genus over Ceuthospora (1827), based on nomenclatural priority, as both names are conserved; it also has a greater number of species.