Treatment of filamentous fungal infections relies on a limited repertoire of antifungal agents. Compounds possessing novel modes of action are urgently required. N-myristoylation is a ubiquitous modification of eukaryotic proteins. The enzyme N-myristoyltransferase (NMT) has been considered a potential therapeutic target in protozoa and yeasts. Here, we show that the filamentous fungal pathogen Aspergillus fumigatus possesses an active NMT enzyme that is essential for survival. Surprisingly, partial repression of the gene revealed downstream effects of N-myristoylation on cell wall morphology. Screening a library of inhibitors led to the discovery of a pyrazole sulphonamide compound that inhibits the enzyme and is fungicidal under partially repressive nmt conditions. Together with a crystallographic complex showing the inhibitor binding in the peptide substrate pocket, we provide evidence of NMT being a potential drug target in A. fumigatus.
Treatment of filamentous fungal infections relies on a limited repertoire of antifungal agents. Compounds possessing novel modes of action are urgently required. N-myristoylation is a ubiquitous modification of eukaryotic proteins. The enzyme N-myristoyltransferase (NMT) has been considered a potential therapeutic target in protozoa and yeasts. Here, we show that the filamentous fungal pathogen Aspergillus fumigatus possesses an active NMT enzyme that is essential for survival. Surprisingly, partial repression of the gene revealed downstream effects of N-myristoylation on cell wall morphology. Screening a library of inhibitors led to the discovery of a pyrazole sulphonamide compound that inhibits the enzyme and is fungicidal under partially repressive nmt conditions. Together with a crystallographic complex showing the inhibitor binding in the peptide substrate pocket, we provide evidence of NMT being a potential drug target in A. fumigatus.
Aspergillus spp.
are ubiquitous filamentous fungi and together with three other genera
(Candida, Cryptococcus, and Pneumocystis) account for more than 90% of invasive fungal
infections worldwide.[1] While invasive aspergillosis
due to A. fumigatus is estimated to affect over 200 000
people globally each year, a further 3 million are affected by chronic
pulmonary aspergillosis.[1] At present, treatment
is limited to three antifungal classes: polyenes, azoles, and echinocandins.
Voriconazole, introduced in the 1990s, is a third generation azole
and current “gold standard” for invasive disease and
has increased response and survival rates by 15–20%.[2] Overall mortality for invasive disease, however,
remains unacceptable at around 50%.[1] Moreover,
there are inherent problems with drug interactions, toxicities, and
increasingly reported resistant strains[3,4] necessitating
the urgent identification and characterization of novel targets against A. fumigatus.The myristoyl coenzyme A (MCoA)/protein N-myristoyltransferase (NMT, EC: 2.3.1.97) catalyzes an
irreversible co- and post-translational covalent attachment of the
saturated 14-carbon fatty acid, myristate, from MCoA to the N-terminal glycine residue of many eukaryotic and viral
proteins.[5]N-myristoylation
is abundant
in eukaryotic organisms including protozoa, fungi, and mammals. Membrane
targeting and the function of many proteins in a variety of signal
transduction cascades and other critical cellular functions is NMT
dependent.[5−7] Structural studies advocate an ordered Bi–Bi
reaction mechanism[8] whereby binding of
MCoA to NMT opens a “lid”
permitting access to the peptide-binding site. While the MCoA binding
site is highly conserved, NMTs are striking in their remarkable diversity
of peptide substrates.[9] Diversity in the
peptide-binding groove has been suggested to offer the potential of
developing species-specific inhibitors.[9] As a result, NMT has been considered as a potential anticancer,[10] antiviral,[11] and
antiparasitic[12−14] therapeutic target. A substantial pool of new chemical
starting points for inhibitors of NMTs from parasites has recently
been described.[15−21] So far, NMT in filamentous fungi such as A. fumigatus remains uncharacterized although orthologues in other fungal pathogens
such as Candida albicans(22) and Cryptococcus neoformans(23) are essential for viability. An NMT knockout in C. albicans resulted in avirulence in a murine model,[22] and several prototype inhibitors have been reported.[24−26] Attempts to develop broad-spectrum antifungal NMT inhibitors were
unsuccessful and are now potentially redundant given impending improved
diagnostics and a developing preference for targeted narrow spectrum
therapy.At present, there is a dearth of new antifungals in
the drug discovery pipeline. Conclusive validation of novel antifungal
targets from both a chemical and genetic perspective provides a critical
first step in reversing this trend. Here, we show that NMT is a potential
drug target in A. fumigatus.
Results and Discussion
A. fumigatus Possesses an Active NMT Enzyme
In
previous reports, BLAST searches using the Arabidopsis thaliana NMT1[27] or Aspergillus nidulans NMT[28] sequences predicted the presence
of an nmt gene (AFUA_4G08070) in the A. fumigatus genome. The gene is 1630 bp in length and contains two introns and
three exons. The 1479 bp mRNA encodes a protein of 492 amino acids
(UniProt: Q9UVX3) sharing 50%, 52%, 38%, and 44% sequence identity
with the NMTs of C. albicans, S. cerevisiae, Leishmania major, and Homo sapiens (Supporting Information Figure 1), respectively.Alignment of A. fumigatus NMT (AfNMT) with NMT structures deposited in the Protein Data Bank (PDB)
from C. albicans (1IYL[29]) suggested
truncation of the N-terminal end, leaving the core
catalytic domain intact. Therefore, to increase the chance of crystallization,
the first 85 amino acids were removed and a truncated AfNMT construct (Δ1–85) generated covering residues 86–492. AfNMT Δ1–85 was overexpressed as a GST fusion
protein in Escherichia coli, purified to homogeneity
by glutathione sepharose affinity chromatography followed by proteolysis
of the fusion protein and size-exclusion chromatography, yielding
2 mg of pure AfNMT per liter of bacterial culture.AfNMT steady-state kinetics were assessed by a
scintillation proximity assay [SPA[30,31]] using biotin-tagged
cytoskeleton-associated protein 5.5 (CAP5.5) as the peptide acceptor
substrate. The K of
myristoyl-CoA (MCoA) for AfNMT was 0.8 ± 0.1
μM (Supporting Information Figure 2A) and comparable to the K of MCoA previously reported for S. cerevisiae [1.4 μM[32]], L. major [1.4 ± 0.3 μM[30]], and Trypanosoma brucei [1.8 ± 0.4 μM[30]]. Likewise, the K of peptide CAP5.5 for AfNMT was 22 ±
2 μM (Supporting Information Figure 2B), similar for T. brucei [11 ±
1 μM[30]].
nmt Is
Essential for Viability of A. fumigatus
Attempts to construct a deletion mutant by replacing the A. fumigatus nmt gene with a pyrG selection
marker[33] and phenotypic rescue by supplementing
the culture medium with myristic acid failed. Although myristic acid
has fully or partially restored the phenotype in other species where nmt is essential,[22,23,28] all our transformants failed initial screening with this approach.
Instead, a conditional inactivation mutant was constructed by replacing
the native promoter of the nmt gene with the A. nidulans alcohol dehydrogenase promoter (PalcA) that is inducible by ethanol, glycerol, or threonine
but repressed by glucose.[34] A plasmid containing
a 3′ truncation of nmt fused to PalcA was transformed into A. fumigatus KU80ΔpyrG– to generate a conditional mutant
(from hereon referred to as the NMT strain) by homologous recombination
(Supporting Information Figure 3A). PCR
and Southern blotting (Supporting Information
Figure 3B–D) verified that in the NMT strain, the inducible PalcA promoter replaced the native promoter of
the nmt gene.Growth of the NMT strain was
comparable to the WT when grown under conditions of nmt induction on a solid minimal medium (MM) containing 0.1 M glycerol,
0.1 M ethanol, or 0.1 M threonine (MMT). However, growth of the NMT
strain was completely inhibited under conditions of nmt repression on YEPD or MM containing 55.5–166.5 mM glucose
after 48 h at 37 °C (Figure 1A). Thus, nmt expression is required for viability and is an essential
gene in A. fumigatus.
Figure 1
Growth phenotype of the
NMT strain under varying repressive conditions. (A) Growth of A. fumigatus strains on solid MM supplemented with 0.1 M
glycerol, 0.1 M ethanol, 0.1 M threonine or 55.5 mM, 111 mM, 166.5
mM glucose or YEPD. (B) Growth on solid MM supplemented with 0.1 M
threonine and 0.56 mM, 1.67 mM 3.33 mM, or 5.55 mM glucose. (C) Real
time PCR to amplify the tbp and nmt gene from MMT and MMTG conditions. (D) Growth curve of the WT and
NMT strain on MMTG plates.
Growth phenotype of the
NMT strain under varying repressive conditions. (A) Growth of A. fumigatus strains on solid MM supplemented with 0.1 M
glycerol, 0.1 M ethanol, 0.1 M threonine or 55.5 mM, 111 mM, 166.5
mM glucose or YEPD. (B) Growth on solid MM supplemented with 0.1 M
threonine and 0.56 mM, 1.67 mM 3.33 mM, or 5.55 mM glucose. (C) Real
time PCR to amplify the tbp and nmt gene from MMT and MMTG conditions. (D) Growth curve of the WT and
NMT strain on MMTG plates.
nmt Expression Affects A. fumigatus Cell Wall
In order to investigate the function of the essential nmt gene in A. fumigatus, various concentrations
of threonine (inducer) and glucose (repressor) were assessed to identify
a minimal level of nmt expression still producing
sufficient mycelia for analysis (Figure 1B).
MM with 0.1 M threonine and 0.56 mM glucose (MMTG) was selected for
all subsequent phenotypic analysis. Under this condition, the transcription
of nmt in the NMT strain was reduced to 39% of the
WT (Figure 1C). Growth of the NMT strain was
retarded compared to the WT (Figure 1D).Surprisingly, increased sensitivity to agents compromising the cell
wall (Congo red and Calcofluor white) or membrane (Sodium dodecyl
sulfate)
were observed under partial expression of the nmt gene indicative of cell wall defects and loss of membrane integrity
(Figure 2A). Furthermore, examination of the
cell wall ultrastructure
by electron microscopy showed that the conidia of both NMT and WT
strains were indistinguishable (Figure 2B,
I and II), but the hyphal cell wall of the NMT strain was thinner
than the WT (Figure 2B, III and IV).
Figure 2
NMT strain
sensitivity to chemical reagents and reduction in cell wall thickness.
(A) Serial dilutions of conidia from 105 to 102 were spotted on solid MMTG containing 50 μg mL–1 Calcofluor white, Congo red, or SDS. (B) Cell wall architecture
under repressive conditions (MMTG). I and II are conidia; III and
IV are mycelium. Scale bar is 100 nm.
NMT strain
sensitivity to chemical reagents and reduction in cell wall thickness.
(A) Serial dilutions of conidia from 105 to 102 were spotted on solid MMTG containing 50 μg mL–1 Calcofluor white, Congo red, or SDS. (B) Cell wall architecture
under repressive conditions (MMTG). I and II are conidia; III and
IV are mycelium. Scale bar is 100 nm.
nmt Is Required for Cell Wall Morphogenesis
Unlike other fungi such as A. nidulans(28) where NMT mutants grew only at 37 °C, growth
of the NMT strain was unaffected by temperature (37–50 °C)
on MMTG plates (Figure 3A). This suggests that
the target proteins of AfNMT appear to be neither
temperature sensitive nor involved in temperature adaptation mechanisms.
Figure 3
NMT strain
temperature insensitivity and delayed germination. (A) Serial dilutions
of 105 to 102 conidia were spotted on MMTG plates
and incubated at 37 °C for 36 or 42 h and 50 °C for 60 h
before imaging. (B) Comparison of germination times of the WT and
NMT strains in MMTG, YEPD, or YEPD supplemented with myristic acid
(YEPDM). Scale bar is 10 μm.
NMT strain
temperature insensitivity and delayed germination. (A) Serial dilutions
of 105 to 102 conidia were spotted on MMTG plates
and incubated at 37 °C for 36 or 42 h and 50 °C for 60 h
before imaging. (B) Comparison of germination times of the WT and
NMT strains in MMTG, YEPD, or YEPD supplemented with myristic acid
(YEPDM). Scale bar is 10 μm.Polarized hyphal growth is essential in filamentous fungi
and thought to be important for pathogenesis. Our NMT strain showed
a marked polar growth defect under conditions of nmt repression including delayed germination, abnormal development,
and retention of polarity (Figure 3B). When nmt was completely repressed in a YEPD medium, the conidia
remained swollen or displayed very short germ tubes (Figure 3B), indicating NMT is required for germination and
hyphal growth.Distinct to A. fumigatus was
the inability of myristic acid supplementation to fully restore the
NMT strain to the WT phenotype as has been demonstrated for C. albicans, S. cerevisiae, and C. neoformans.[22,23,35] Only short germ tubes with a ballooned tip or abnormal polarity
were evident after 19 h incubation in supplementation medium (Figure 3B).
AfNMT Crystal Structure
Reveals a Molecular Handle on Selectivity
As a first step
toward
the design of selective inhibitors, we determined the crystal structure
of AfNMT and compared it to the human enzyme. The
purified AfNMT was cocrystallized with MCoA and the
benzofuran compound Ro-09-4879 that is known to compete for peptide
binding in other NMTs.[29] The structure
of the inhibitor complex was solved by molecular replacement using C. albicans NMT (PDB: 1IYK(29)) as a search
model and refined against 1.9 Å synchrotron diffraction data
(Supporting Information Table 1). No interpretable
electron density was visible for the first 15 residues of the polypeptide
chain.The overall crystal structure of AfNMT
consisted of a monomer of 391 residues (101–492) forming two
GCN5 folds with MCoA bound to AfNMT in a horseshoe
conformation (Figure 4A). To date, crystal
structures of NMT from C. albicans, S. cerevisiae, H. sapiens, L. major, L. donovani, and P. vivax have been elucidated
showing extensive conservation of the core fold and active site residues
(Figure 4B). The structure of AfNMT reflects
the high level of conservation between species at a primary, secondary,
and tertiary sequence level, showing the highest level of conservation
with C. albicans (Cα RMSD = 1.301 Å with
346 atoms matched) and S. cerevisiae NMT (Cα
RMSD = 0.840 Å with 350 atoms matched). Although similar to NMT:MCoA
structures previously determined, the CoA phosphate group was not
coordinated by the polypeptide due to the truncated construct lacking
the YKFW motif. Electron density for the benzofuran ligand Ro-09-4879
was observed in the peptide-binding groove of AfNMT
where it competes with acceptor substrate binding (Figure 4A). Here, it adopts a similar conformation to a CaNMT:benzofuran complex [PDB 1IYL(29)]. The peptide
binding site of NMT is highly conserved with minimal sequence differences
between species. However, comparison of the known NMT crystal structures
reveals three nonconserved residues; Ser378 and Ala391 are conserved
apart from C. albicans and S. cerevisiae species where the corresponding residues are Phe and Ile. The residue
Val389 is unique to AfNMT, and it forms part of a
hydrophobic pocket with Phe155, Leu273, Phe278, Ser378, and Val432
that accepts the Ro-09-4879 ligand. In other species, notably human,
this residue is a larger leucine (Leu416; Figure 4C,D). Such a difference may be exploitable in the design of
inhibitors to selectively target AfNMT.
Figure 4
Crystal structure
of AfNMT complexes with inhibitors. (A) Overall fold
of AfNMT (residues 86–492) in complex with
MCoA (stick representation, Cα cyan) and RO-09-4879
(stick representation, Cα green). (B) Representative
crystal structures of NMTs. AfNMT shown in gray cartoon
superimposed upon ScNMT (PDB 1IIC, green), LmNMT (PDB 3H5Z, magenta), HsNMT1 (PDB 3IU1, cyan), and PvNMT (PDB 4B10, orange). (C) Conservation
of NMT active site residues. AfNMT backbone shown
in gray cartoon with active site side chains shown in stick representation
(C atoms gray). Strictly conserved residues between species are shown
for AfNMT only. Where residues are not conserved,
they are shown for all species in stick representation, ScNMT (green), LmNMT (magenta), HsNMT1 (cyan), and PvNMT (orange). (D) Close-up view
of the AfNMT active site, showing the MCoA (Cα cyan) and RO-09-4879 (Cα green). A
molecular surface is shown, colored by sequence conservation with HsNMT1 (gray, identical side chains; purple, nonidentical
side chains). (E) Stereoscopic view of the active site of the AfNMT in complex with DDD85646 and DDD86481. Active site
side chains are shown as sticks with gray Cα, whereas
the compound is shown as sticks with gold Cα. The
unbiased |Fo| – |Fc| map (2.5 σ) is shown as a green mesh.
Crystal structure
of AfNMT complexes with inhibitors. (A) Overall fold
of AfNMT (residues 86–492) in complex with
MCoA (stick representation, Cα cyan) and RO-09-4879
(stick representation, Cα green). (B) Representative
crystal structures of NMTs. AfNMT shown in gray cartoon
superimposed upon ScNMT (PDB 1IIC, green), LmNMT (PDB 3H5Z, magenta), HsNMT1 (PDB 3IU1, cyan), and PvNMT (PDB 4B10, orange). (C) Conservation
of NMT active site residues. AfNMT backbone shown
in gray cartoon with active site side chains shown in stick representation
(C atoms gray). Strictly conserved residues between species are shown
for AfNMT only. Where residues are not conserved,
they are shown for all species in stick representation, ScNMT (green), LmNMT (magenta), HsNMT1 (cyan), and PvNMT (orange). (D) Close-up view
of the AfNMT active site, showing the MCoA (Cα cyan) and RO-09-4879 (Cα green). A
molecular surface is shown, colored by sequence conservation with HsNMT1 (gray, identical side chains; purple, nonidentical
side chains). (E) Stereoscopic view of the active site of the AfNMT in complex with DDD85646 and DDD86481. Active site
side chains are shown as sticks with gray Cα, whereas
the compound is shown as sticks with gold Cα. The
unbiased |Fo| – |Fc| map (2.5 σ) is shown as a green mesh.
Screening-Based Discovery of a Low Nanomolar
AfNMT Inhibitor
Pyrazole sulphonamide ligands act as highly
potent inhibitors against T. brucei NMT (TbNMT).[12] A panel
of antitrypanosome NMT inhibitors was screened against recombinant AfNMT (Supporting Information Table
2), and the fungicidal effect on A. fumigatus was determined. As shown in Figure 5, two
potent nanomolar pyrazole sulphonamide inhibitors were identified
using the SPA assay with IC50 values of 23 nM (DDD85646)
and 12 nM (DDD86481).
Figure 5
Inhibition of AfNMT. (A) Chemical structures
of compounds DDD85646 and DDD86481. (B) Dose response IC50 curves of DDD85646 and DDD86481 against AfNMT using
an SPA assay.
Inhibition of AfNMT. (A) Chemical structures
of compounds DDD85646 and DDD86481. (B) Dose response IC50 curves of DDD85646 and DDD86481 against AfNMT using
an SPA assay.To investigate the binding
mode of these compounds, further crystal structures of AfNMT:MCoA in complex with the pyrazole sulphonamide inhibitors were
solved (Supporting Information Table 1),
demonstrating that they also occupied the peptide binding site. DDD85646
adopted a similar conformation to that previously observed in a L. major NMT complex (PDB 2WSA) used as a model for T. brucei.[12] Specifically, the piperazine group
interacts with the C-terminal carboxylate group via two bridging water
molecules. The first water molecule is tightly coordinated by the
C-terminal carboxylate and the phenolic hydroxyl groups of Tyr147
and Tyr159 while a second water molecule bridges the piperazine group
and the carboxylate (Figure 4E). The biaryl
system makes no specific interactions with the protein and sits on
a hydrophobic surface formed by the side chains of Tyr263 and Leu457.
A significant bend in the molecule introduced by the sulphonamide
allows the pyrazole moiety to penetrate a hydrophobic pocket. Oxygen
atoms of the sulphonamide interact with the protein through water-bridged
interactions with the side chains of Asn434, His265, and the backbone
amides of Asp454 and Gly455. The trimethyl pyrazole group sits in
the same hydrophobic pocket occupied by the trifluoro-phenyl group
of Ro-09-4897; however the pyrazole forms a hydrogen bond with the
side chain of Ser378 in addition to strong hydrophobic packing interactions
(Figure 4E).The isobutyl pyrazole derivative
DDD86481
has a very similar binding mode to DDD85646 (Figure 4E). The sulphonamide, however, sits lower in the active site
losing interaction with Asn434, and the pyrazole group rotates slightly
to accommodate the larger moiety at the 3- position (Figure 4E). As the isobutyl group packs against the side
chains of Phe155, Phe278, Val389, Ala391, and Val432, this explains
the increased potency over DDD85646 by increasing the hydrophobic
complementarity in this pocket.
DDD86481 Is Fungicidal
under Repressed nmt Expression
Initially,
all compounds from Supporting Information Table
2 were taken for MIC determination in RPMI medium containing
0.1 M threonine and 0.56 mM glucose. Only three compounds (DDD86481,
DDD90086, and Ro-09-4879) showed potent inhibition for the NMT mutant.
The fungicidal activity of DDD85646 was >2.5 mM irrespective of
the A. fumigatus strain tested (WT or NMT). Although
the MIC of DDD86481 was 925 μM against the WT (at 0.625 mM,
WT showed a mutant morphogenesis phenotype), it decreased to 116 μM
for the NMT strain (Table 1). As this molecule
is more lipophilic than DDD85646, this might account for marginally
increased cell penetration and a lower MIC. In order to demonstrate
target engagement inside the cell, the chemical labeling technology
employing click chemistry with a myristate alkyne derivative[13,16,36] was explored. However, this approach
did not work in A. fumigatus cells, probably because
the myristate derivative could not penetrate the fungal cell wall.
Table 1
MIC of Inhibitor Compounds against A. fumigatusa
strains
WT
NMT
growth conditions
BMT +
0.56 mM Glc
0.56
mM Glc
3.33 mM Glc
55.5 mM Glc
111 mM Glc
level of NMT repression
nmt transcription
(%)
100 ± 4
81 ± 10
78 ± 15
29 ± 7
24 ± 1
MIC
(mM)
DDD86481
0.925
0.116
0.058
0.014
0.007
DDD85646
>2.5
>2.5
ND
>2.5
>2.5
DDD90086
>2.5
1.25
ND
0.625
0.625
Ro-09-4609
>2.5
>2.5
ND
>2.5
>2.5
Ro-09-4879
0.625
0.625
ND
0.625
0.625
other compounds*
>2.5
>2.5
ND
ND
ND
amphotericin B
0.0017
0.0017
0.0017
0.0017
0.0017
The CLSI broth
microdilution method was used to determine the MIC (lowest concentration
that completely inhibited growth) after 48 h of incubation at 37 °C.
BMT, basic medium plus 0.1 M threonine; Glc, glucose; ND, not determined;
*All other compounds listed in the Supporting
Information, Table 2.
The CLSI broth
microdilution method was used to determine the MIC (lowest concentration
that completely inhibited growth) after 48 h of incubation at 37 °C.
BMT, basic medium plus 0.1 M threonine; Glc, glucose; ND, not determined;
*All other compounds listed in the Supporting
Information, Table 2.To investigate whether DDD86481 was acting through inhibition of AfNMT in the NMT strain, MIC values were determined under
different repressive conditions and nmt transcript
levels assessed by quantitative real time PCR. In 0.56 mM glucose
medium, nmt transcription was 81% of the WT. As nmt transcription reduced, DDD86481 efficacy increased with
correlating reductions in MIC (Table 1) to
7 μM with 24% nmt expression. As a control,
the MICs of amphotericin B, DDD85646, Ro-09-4609, and Ro-09-4879 were
unaffected by nmt transcript levels (Table 1), although the MIC of DDD90086 was decreased slightly.
Nevertheless, there is still a significant drop in activity of DDD86481
on going from enzyme to cell. When NMT is normally expressed, there
is an 80 000-fold drop in activity; when NMT is expressed at
24%, there is a 600-fold drop in activity. This could be due to poor
penetration of DDD86481 through the fungal cell wall but alternatively
could be due to the catalytic role of NMT not being essential or off-target
effects of DDD86481.
Concluding Remarks
Early stage drug
discovery suffers high attrition rates, and there are limited immediate
offerings in the antifungal pipeline besides modifications of existing
classes.[37] Increased recognition of the
clinical burden posed by chronic pulmonary aspergillosis threatens
to place huge selective pressures on oral azoles (e.g., itraconazole)
as they have been shown to partially alleviate symptoms.[38] Consequently, there is profound medical need
for alternative classes ideally with oral formulations. As a step
toward this, we presented evidence that validates AfNMT as a potential drug target in A. fumigatus showing
that protein N-myristoylation affects cell morphology
and integrity of the cell wall, a structure essential to all pathogenic
fungi and absent from the human cell.A conditional NMT mutant
strain showed that this gene was essential and also provided insights
into the downstream effects of NMT inhibition on the cell wall of A. fumigatus. Reduced expression affected cell morphogenesis
and cell wall integrity—effects that have not previously been
observed in NMT genetic disruption studies in other organisms. The
fungal cell wall is a dynamic three-dimensional structure composed
predominantly of polysaccharides. The cell wall involves numerous
biosynthetic pathways and hundreds of proteins for its synthesis and
remodeling. A significant fraction (typically 0.5%) of eukaryotic
proteins are thought to be myristoylated,[27] assisting switching between cytoplasmic and membrane bound states.
In fact, using the MYR Predictor (http://mendel.imp.ac.at/myristate/SUPLpredictor.htm), 29 proteins from the A. fumigatus proteome are
predicted to be myristoylated (Supporting Information
Table 3). While most proteins are of unknown function, two
classes, namely the G-protein alpha subunits and the ADP-ribosylation
factors, are known myristoylation substrates.[39,40] Myristoylation of G protein alpha subunits is required for localization
to the plasma membrane and also facilitating formation of a heterotrimer
for G protein signaling.[41] As signal transducers,
G proteins influence numerous signaling cascades especially activate
the cyclic-AMP-dependent PKA pathway[42] that
regulates growth, development, stress response, morphogenesis, and
virulence in A. fumigatus.[43−45] There is also
direct evidence that G proteins regulate cell wall carbohydrate composition
in both plants and other fungi.[46−49] One of the ADP-ribosylation factors in A.
nidulans, ArfB, is involved in polarity establishment during
isotropic growth and polarity maintenance during hyphal extension.[50] Three ArfB orthologues (Afu3g12080, Afu1g11730,
and Afu2g10980) in A. fumigatus are predicted to
be myristoylated proteins (Supporting Information
Table 3). Our NMT strain displayed the same polarized growth
defect as the ArfB mutant. In summary, we propose that the G alpha
subunits and these ArfB orthologues account for the changes in cell
wall and defect in morphogenesis in the NMT strain.Screening
a library of compounds identified a 12 nM AfNMT inhibitor
(DDD86481) that targeted the peptide binding site and interacted with
an amino acid side chain that is different between the fungal and
human enzyme. However, this failed to directly correlate with fungicidal
activity against A. fumigatus (MIC 925 μM).
Reducing nmt expression sensitized the organism to
the inhibitor, reducing the MIC to 7 μM, yet retaining a 600-fold
difference between activity on the target in vitro and the fungal cell, suggesting the need for more potent and cell-penetrant
compounds to pursue full chemical validation.Essential gene
targets like NMT produce a lethal phenotype but a significant challenge
will be discovering inhibitors that are highly selective for A. fumigatus. The peptide-binding sites of the human and A. fumigatus NMTs are exquisitely similar to only a single
amino acid difference (Val389 in AfNMT and Leu416
in HsNMT1). However, there is evidence from TbNMT inhibitors that a substantial window of selectivity
can be derived between HsNMT1 and TbNMT despite highly similar active site structures.[12] Recently, further optimized TbNMT inhibitors
not only possessed improved CNS penetrance but also improved selectivity
that could be used to treat stage 2 human African trypanosomiasis.[21] Highly potent Leishmania-selective NMT inhibitors
have been identified either from compound screening[15] or with a structure-based approach.[20] More encouragingly, although structure–activity
relationships (SARs) between Plasmodium NMT and HsNMT1 overlap,[15] potent and
selective Plasmodium NMT inhibitors have been discovered[15] and optimized,[18] demonstrating
that even the small conformational differences of single equivalent
tyrosine could be exploited to engineer selectivity over the human
enzyme.[17] Therefore, it may be possible
to discover selective A. fumigatus inhibitors based
on the structure differences between AfNMT and HsNMT1 described here.In summary, we have provided
the first comprehensive characterization of NMT in a filamentous fungal
pathogen and combined genetic, structural, and chemical approaches
to validate AfNMT as a target illustrating NMT dependent
inhibition of A. fumigatus growth. While the genetic
work confirmed NMT is essential for viability in A. fumigatus, the mutant NMT strain allows controlled gene expression and provides
a research tool for further probing the effects of (i) N-myristoylation and (ii) host-fungal interactions.
Methods
Construction of the Conditional Inactivation
Mutant
Plasmid pAL3 containing the A. nidulans alcA promoter (PalcA) and the Neurospora crassa pyr-4 gene as a fungal selectable marker[51] was
used to construct a vector replacing the native nmt promoter with PalcA. An 1120 bp fragment from −50
to +1070 of the nmt genomic DNA sequence was amplified
with primers P3 and P4 (see Supporting Information
Table 4 for all primer sequences) containing a KpnI and XbaI restriction site, respectively. The PCR-amplified
fragment was cloned into expression vector pAL3 to yield pALnmtN and
confirmed by sequencing. The pALnmtN was transformed into A. fumigatus strain KU80ΔpyrG– by
PEG-mediated fusion of protoplasts[52] and
screened for colonies with uridine/uracil autotrophy. The transformants
were confirmed by PCR and Southern blot analysis.For PCR analysis,
three sets of primers were designed: primers P5 and P6 for the 1.6
kb nmt gene, P7 and P8 for the 1.2 kb pyr-4 marker, and P9 and P10 for a 2.5 kb fragment from PalcA to a downstream region of the nmt gene. For Southern
blotting, genomic DNA was digested with BamHI, separated
by electrophoresis and transferred to a nylon membrane (Zeta-probe+,
Bio-Rad). The 1120 bp fragment of the nmt genomic
sequence and a 1.2 kb HindIII fragment of the N. crassa pyr-4 gene from pAL3 were used as probes. Labeling
and visualization were performed using the DIG DNA labeling and detection
kit (Roche) according to the manufacturer’s instructions.
Crystallization, Data Collection, and Structure Determination
AfNMT Δ1–85 (20 mg mL–1) was crystallized using the sitting drop method. Prior to crystallization, AfNMT was incubated with 10 mM myristoylCoA (MCoA). To obtain
ligand complexes, AfNMT was incubated with 10 mM
of compound. Crystals grew after 2 days in a mother liquor of 0.2
M NaCl and 25% (v/v) PEG3350 and were cryoprotected for flash freezing
in liquid nitrogen. Diffraction data were collected at the European
Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF, Grenoble, France) and all data
processed and scaled with HKL software.[53]The AfNMT-MCoA-RO-09-4879 complex structure
was solved by molecular replacement using MOLREP[54] from the CCP4 suite programs[55] with the C. albicans NMT structure
(PDB: 1IYK(29)) as a search model giving a solution with one
molecule in the asymmetric unit. The resulting electron density map
was of good quality, allowing WarpNtrace[56] to build virtually all residues except for a few disordered regions.
REFMAC5[57] was used for further refinement,
iterated with model building using COOT,[58] producing a final model with the statistics shown in Supporting Information Table 1. Other compound
complexes were solved by molecular replacement using the AfNMT-MCoA-RO-09-4879 structure as a search model. The model for ligands
was not included until their conformations were fully defined by unbiased
|Fo| – |Fc|
ϕcalc electron density maps. Ligand structures and
topologies were generated by PRODRG.[59] PyMol
was used to generate figures.[60]
Minimal
Inhibitory Concentration (MIC) Assay
Selected compounds were
tested against A. fumigatus (WT [KU80] and NMT strains)
according to the Clinical and Laboratory Standards Institute (CLSI)
M38-A broth microdilution methodology.[61] All compounds were dissolved in DMSO, and the final DMSO concentration
was 2.5% (v/v) in all wells. The MIC end point was defined as the
lowest concentration producing complete inhibition of growth (MIC100) for all compounds studied. The MIC values for each compound
were determined in triplicate. Amphotericin B (Sigma) and A. fumigatus ATCC 204305 served as a positive control and
the MIC within the recommended limits of CLSI M38-A.
Authors: M Masubuchi; K Kawasaki; H Ebiike; Y Ikeda; S Tsujii; S Sogabe; T Fujii; K Sakata; Y Shiratori; Y Aoki; T Ohtsuka; N Shimma Journal: Bioorg Med Chem Lett Date: 2001-07-23 Impact factor: 2.823
Authors: Andrew S Bell; Zhiyong Yu; Jennie A Hutton; Megan H Wright; James A Brannigan; Daniel Paape; Shirley M Roberts; Charlotte L Sutherell; Markus Ritzefeld; Anthony J Wilkinson; Deborah F Smith; Robin J Leatherbarrow; Edward W Tate Journal: J Med Chem Date: 2020-07-14 Impact factor: 7.446
Authors: Tracy Bayliss; David A Robinson; Victoria C Smith; Stephen Brand; Stuart P McElroy; Leah S Torrie; Chido Mpamhanga; Suzanne Norval; Laste Stojanovski; Ruth Brenk; Julie A Frearson; Kevin D Read; Ian H Gilbert; Paul G Wyatt Journal: J Med Chem Date: 2017-11-22 Impact factor: 7.446
Authors: Anja C Schlott; Stephen Mayclin; Alexandra R Reers; Olivia Coburn-Flynn; Andrew S Bell; Judith Green; Ellen Knuepfer; David Charter; Roger Bonnert; Brice Campo; Jeremy Burrows; Sally Lyons-Abbott; Bart L Staker; Chun-Wa Chung; Peter J Myler; David A Fidock; Edward W Tate; Anthony A Holder Journal: Cell Chem Biol Date: 2019-05-09 Impact factor: 8.116