| Literature DB >> 25186181 |
Andrew Kennedy1, Lourens Bester, Riad Salem, Ricky A Sharma, Rowan W Parks, Philippe Ruszniewski.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Liver metastasis from a neuroendocrine tumour (NET) represents a significant clinical entity. A multidisciplinary group of experts was convened to develop state-of-the-art recommendations for its management.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2014 PMID: 25186181 PMCID: PMC4266438 DOI: 10.1111/hpb.12326
Source DB: PubMed Journal: HPB (Oxford) ISSN: 1365-182X Impact factor: 3.647
Figure 1Study search strategy and numbers of articles identified
Conversions of the National Cancer Institute (NCI) and GRADE (grading of recommendations assessment, development and evaluation) scoring systems4,5 used by the present working group
| NCI levels of evidence | GRADE | GRADE | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Quality score | Strength score | ||
| (i) Population-based, consecutive series | |||
| (ii) Consecutive cases (not population-based) | |||
| (i) Population-based, consecutive series | |||
| (ii) Consecutive cases, (not population-based) | |||
| (iii) Non-consecutive cases | |||
| (i) Event-free survival | |||
| (ii) Disease-free survival | |||
| (iii) Progression-free survival | |||
| (iv) Tumour response rate |
Outcomes of studies of radioembolization in patients with liver metastases from neuroendocrine tumours
| Study | Patients, | Device used | Toxicity | Radiological response (RECIST 1.0) | Survival times and rates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rhee | 42 | Yttrium-90 (glass) | Grade III/IV (14%) | 54% | Median: 22 months |
| Yttrium-90 (resin) | 50% | Median: 28 months | |||
| Kennedy | 148 | Yttrium-90 (resin) | 33% (grade III), fatigue (6.5%) | 63% | Median: 70 months |
| King | 58 | Yttrium-90 (resin) plus 5-FU | Radiation gastritis (2 patients), duodenal ulcer (1 patient) | 39% | Median: 36 months 1-, 2- and 3-year survival: 86%, 58% and 47%, respectively |
| Saxena | 48 | Yttrium-90 (resin) | 0.5% (grade III) 1 patient (biliary obstruction) | 54% | Median: 35 months 1-, 2- and 3-year survival: 87%, 62% and 42%, respectively |
| Cao | 58 | Yttrium-90 (resin) plus 5-FU | Not reported | 39.2% | Median: 36 months |
| Paprottka | 42 | Yttrium-90 (resin) | 0% grade III | 22.5% | Median: 95% at 16.2 months |
| Memon | 40 | Yttrium-90 (glass) | Fatigue (63%, all grades), nausea/vomiting (40%, all grades), grade III, IV (bilirubin, 8%; albumin, 2%; lymphocyte, 38%) | WHO: 64.0%; EASL: 71.4% | Median: 34.4 months 1-, 2- and 3-year survival: 72.5%, 62.5%, 45.0%, respectively |
5-FU, 5-fluorouracil; EASL, European Association for the Study of the Liver; WHO, World Health Organization.
Outcomes of studies of transarterial embolization (TAE) and transarterial chemoembolization (TACE) in patients with liver metastases from neuroendocrine tumours (NETs)
| Study | Patients, | Device used | Toxicity | Radiological response (RECIST 1.0) | Survival times and rates |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Dong & Carr | 123 | TACE | Abdominal pain (44%), diarrhoea (30%), weight loss (22%) | 62% | Mean: 3.3 years 3-, 5- and 10-year survival: 59%, 36% and 20%, respectively |
| de Baere | 20 | TACE with doxorubicin eluting beads | Nausea (61%), fever (36%) | 80% | Not reported |
| Vogl | 48 | TACE with mitomycin C | Nausea and vomiting (27.8%), abdominal pain (11.1%) | 11.1% | Median: 38.7 months 5 years: 11.11% |
| TACE with mitomycin C + gemcitabine | Nausea and vomiting (16.7%), abdominal pain (10%) | 23.3% | Median: 57.1 months 5 years: 46.67% | ||
| Loewe | 23 | Bland embolization | Not reported | 73% | Median: 69 months 1- and 5-year survival: 95.7% and 65.4%, respectively |
| Eriksson | 41 | Bland embolization | Post-embolization syndrome (all), nausea (33%), fever ( | 50% | Median: 80 months 5 years: 60% |
| Pitt | 100 | Bland ( | Bland: 7/51, (3 liver abscesses, 1 groin hematoma, 2 ileus, 1 hypotension) TACE: none | N/A | Median from diagnosis: TACE, 50.1 months; bland, 39.1 months 1-, 2- and 5-year survival: TACE, 69%, 52%, 19%, respectively; bland, 19%, 70%, 13%, respectively |
| Ruutiainen | 67 | Bland ( | Grade 3 or worse toxicity in 25% of TACE and 22% of bland patients TACE (≥Grade 3): pain (3); nausea (1); GET/ALP (4); AST (1), and infection (1) Bland (≥Grade 3): GET/ALP (3); AST (1), and cardiac (1) | TACE: 22% Bland: 38% | 1-, 3- and 5-year survival: TACE, 86%, 67%, 50%, respectively; bland, 68%, 46%, 33%, respectively |
| Gupta | 49 | TACE ( | Serious adverse events in 19 patients (8.5%), hepatorenal syndrome (7), sepsis (6), transient myelosuppression (1), anasarca (1), cortical blindness (1), necrotizing cholecystitis (1), hepatic abscess (2) Overall complications: TACE, 20%; bland, 12% | TACE: 50%Bland: 25% | Median survival for carcinoid tumours: TACE, 33.8 months; bland, 33.2 months; islet tumours: TACE, 31.5 months; bland, 18.2 months |
| Maire | 26 | TACE ( | TACE: post-embolization syndrome (10), carcinoid crisis (2), acute liver failure (1), neutropoenia (2) Bland: post-embolization syndrome (10), carcinoid crisis (0), acute liver failure (2), neutropoenia (0) | TACE: 100% Bland: 92% | 2-year survival: TACE, 80%; bland, 100% Median PFS: TACE, 19.2 months; bland, 23.6 months |
| Guiu | 120 NET 88 HCC | DEB-TACE in HCC (with cirrhosis) and NETs (without cirrhosis) | Liver biliary injury occurred in 64/208 patients. Occurrence associated with DEB-TACE, | N/A | N/A |
| Ruzniewski | 23 | TACE | Bleeding peptic ulcer (1), oligoanuric renal failure (1), abdominal pain (50%), fever (6), nausea and vomiting (5) | PR, SD, PD, TTP 61, 22, 17, 14 | 8/23 died at a median of 12.5 months after final TACE |
ALT, alanine aminotransferase; AST, aspartate aminotransferase; DEB, drug-eluting beads; GGT, γ-glutamyl transferase; HCC, hepatocellular carcinoma; PD, progressive disease; PFS, progression-free survival; PR, partial response; SD, stable disease; TTP, time to progression.
Summary of statements of GRADE quality and strength
| Statement summary | Quality | Strength | Overall grade |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 No type of embolotherapy is most effective | Moderate | Strong | B1 |
| 2 Embolotherapy indicated for small and large tumour burdens and hormonal symptoms | Low | Weak | C2 |
| 3 Embolotherapy has the highest radiographic response rate | Low | Strong | C1 |
| 4 RE is superior to TAE/TACE in QoL and side-effects profile | Low | Weak | C2 |
| 5 By ENETS guidelines, RE is equivalent to TAE/TACE | Moderate | Strong | B1 |
ENETS, European Neuroendocrine Tumor Society; QoL, quality of life; RE, radioembolization; TAE, transarterial embolization; TACE, transarterial chemoembolization.
Figure 2Proposed treatment approach in liver-only metastases from neuroendocrine tumours. LITT, laser-induced thermotherapy; LMs, liver metastases; RE, radioembolization; RFA, radiofrequency ablation; TAE, transarterial embolization; TACE, transarterial chemoembolization; 90Y, yttrium-90