Literature DB >> 25099239

Socrates was not a pimp: changing the paradigm of questioning in medical education.

Amanda Kost1, Frederick M Chen.   

Abstract

The slang term "pimping" is widely recognized by learners and educators in the clinical learning environment as the act of more senior members of the medical team publicly asking questions of more junior members. Although questioning as a pedagogical practice has many benefits, pimping, as described in the literature, evokes negative emotions in learners and leads to an environment that is not conducive to adult learning. Medical educators may employ pimping as a pedagogic technique because of beliefs that it is a Socratic teaching method. Although problems with pimping have previously been identified, no alternative techniques for questioning in the clinical environment were suggested. The authors posit that using the term "pimping" to describe questioning in medical education is harmful and unprofessional, and they propose clearly defining pimping as "questioning with the intent to shame or humiliate the learner to maintain the power hierarchy in medical education." Explicitly separating pimping from the larger practice of questioning allows the authors to make three recommendations for improving questioning practices. First, educators should examine the purpose of each question they pose to learners. Second, they should apply historic and modern interpretations of Socratic teaching methods that promote critical thinking skills. Finally, they should consider adult learning theories to make concrete changes to their questioning practices. These changes can result in questioning that is more learner centered, aids in the acquisition of knowledge and skills, performs helpful formative and summative assessments of the learner, and improves community in the clinical learning environment.

Mesh:

Year:  2015        PMID: 25099239     DOI: 10.1097/ACM.0000000000000446

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Acad Med        ISSN: 1040-2446            Impact factor:   6.893


  23 in total

1.  Critical Thinking in Critical Care: Five Strategies to Improve Teaching and Learning in the Intensive Care Unit.

Authors:  Margaret M Hayes; Souvik Chatterjee; Richard M Schwartzstein
Journal:  Ann Am Thorac Soc       Date:  2017-04

2.  Strategic Questioning in Emergency Medicine Training.

Authors:  Jordan Tozer; Timothy Layng; Margaret Wolff; Sally A Santen
Journal:  AEM Educ Train       Date:  2018-10-03

3.  Would Socrates Have Actually Used the "Socratic Method" for Clinical Teaching?

Authors:  Hugh A Stoddard; David V O'Dell
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2016-04-29       Impact factor: 5.128

4.  From Socrates to Virtual Reality: A Historical Review of Learning Theories and Their Influence on the Training of Anesthesiologists.

Authors:  Thomas J Caruso; Jimmy Qian; Kiley Lawrence; Emma Armstrong-Carter; Benjamin W Domingue
Journal:  J Educ Perioper Med       Date:  2020-04-01

5.  Teaching when Time Is Limited: a Resident and Fellow as Educator Video Module.

Authors:  Brittany Bettendorf; Kathleen Quinn-Leering; Heather Toth; Matthew Tews
Journal:  Med Sci Educ       Date:  2019-05-10

6.  Effective Strategies for Planning and Facilitating Morning Report.

Authors:  Sadie Elisseou; Stephen R Holt
Journal:  J Grad Med Educ       Date:  2022-06-13

7.  Growth, Engagement, and Belonging in the Clinical Learning Environment: the Role of Psychological Safety and the Work Ahead.

Authors:  Adelaide H McClintock; Tyra Fainstad
Journal:  J Gen Intern Med       Date:  2022-06-16       Impact factor: 6.473

8.  Applying Educational Theory and Best Practices to Solve Common Challenges of Simulation-based Procedural Training in Emergency Medicine.

Authors:  Michael Cassara; Kimberly Schertzer; Michael J Falk; Ambrose H Wong; Sara M Hock; Suzanne Bentley; Glenn Paetow; Lauren W Conlon; Patrick G Hughes; Ryan T McKenna; Michael Hrdy; Charles Lei; Miriam Kulkarni; Colleen M Smith; Amanda Young; Ernesto Romo; Michael D Smith; Jessica Hernandez; Christopher G Strother; Alise Frallicciardi; Nur-Ain Nadir
Journal:  AEM Educ Train       Date:  2019-12-27

9.  Observations of the hidden curriculum on a paediatrics tertiary care clinical teaching unit.

Authors:  Asif Doja; M Dylan Bould; Chantalle Clarkin; Marc Zucker; Hilary Writer
Journal:  Paediatr Child Health       Date:  2018-02-17       Impact factor: 2.253

10.  Case-Based Curriculum for Pediatric Residents in Diabetes Fundamentals.

Authors:  Iman Al-Gadi; Stephanie Sisley
Journal:  MedEdPORTAL       Date:  2021-05-27
View more

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.