Poor infant and young child feeding practices and sources of caregivers' feeding knowledge in rural Hebei Province, China: findings from a cross-sectional survey.

OBJECTIVES: To obtain a general overview of infant and young child feeding practices in one rural county in China and identify current delivery channels and challenges.
DESIGN: A cross-sectional study.
SETTING: A rural county, Zhao County, in Hebei Province, China. PARTICIPANTS: 10 clusters were first selected within each township (16 townships in total) with proportional to population size sampling. In each cluster, a name list was used to select 13 children aged 0-23 months. We interviewed caregivers of all the selected children. PRIMARY AND SECONDARY OUTCOMES MEASURES: Coverage of infant feeding practices, reasons for low coverage of infant feeding practices and current delivery channels of infant feeding practices.
RESULTS: Findings from our survey indicated that infant feeding practices were poor. Early initiation of breastfeeding was only 22.4%, exclusive breastfeeding for 6 months was less than 10% and continued breastfeeding up to the age of two was just 38.2%. Only 32.5% of children were given iron-rich or iron-fortified foods. The leading sources of infant feeding information were family members, neighbours, friends and popular media. Only around 20% of the information came from health facilities and nearly none came from communities. Household property data showed that 99.9% of households owned televisions and 99.4% owned mobile phones. In addition, 61.2% of the households owned computers, with 54.8% having access to the internet.
CONCLUSIONS: Few caregivers of children in Zhao County received feeding information during pregnancy and after delivery. Moreover, their feeding knowledge and practices were poor. Multi-channel approaches, delivered through health facilities, community resources, popular media, the internet and mobile phones, hold potential to improve infant feeding practices and should be explored in future studies. STRENGTHS AND LIMITATIONS: Although this study took place only within one county, a full range of globally standard feeding indicators was used to assess the feeding practices of caregivers in our study. The name lists of children in some villages may not be complete, and therefore selection bias may have occurred. Some indicators may have recall bias due to long recall time. TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER: ChiCTR-PRC-11001446. Published by the BMJ Publishing Group Limited. For permission to use (where not already granted under a licence) please go to http://group.bmj.com/group/rights-licensing/permissions.

The strength of our study is that we collected a full range of globally standard infant feeding indicators as well as information on delivery channels and reasons for coverage failure, which could provide a basis for development of effective IYCF strategies.

Our study has several limitations. Firstly, the sampling of children was based on the name lists of children in each village. In Zhao County, all live births are reported to the Maternal and Child Health Hospital from all qualified delivery institutions each month. Therefore we obtained the name list from the hospital. Then we sent the name lists to village doctors and asked them to remove children who had died or moved outside the village and add children who were living in the village but who were not on the list. Although all these efforts were made, we are not sure of the completeness of the name lists and selection bias may have occurred. Secondly, some indicators such as initiation of breastfeeding after birth were based on the mothers’ recall, with a longest recall time of 2 years, which may have introduced recall bias.

Background

Nutritional status is an important determinant of maternal and child health.1 2 Maternal and child undernutrition is still highly prevalent in low-income and middle-income countries and results in significantly increased mortality and morbidity in mothers and children. Suboptimal breastfeeding is a key factor for undernutrition in infants and was estimated to be responsible for 804 000 child deaths worldwide in 2011.3 Studies have consistently shown that the peak for growth faltering, micronutrient deficiencies and common childhood illnesses occurs from birth up to 2 years of age.3–5

Appropriate infant and young child feeding (IYCF) is the basis for child survival, growth and development.3 4 6 7 The benefits of breastfeeding for both infants and mothers have been well documented in studies, including reducing the risk of morbidity and mortality, especially from infectious diseases such as diarrhoea and pneumonia.8 9 Introducing safe and adequate complementary foods to children aged 6 months helps to fill dietary gaps that cannot be met by breast milk alone. Continued breastfeeding for 2 years or beyond is an essential component of appropriate complementary feeding.10

To emphasise the importance of child feeding, the WHO and United Nations Children's Fund (UNICEF) jointly developed the Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding (IYCF) in 2002.11 The recommendations in this strategy state that children should be exclusively breastfed for 6 months after birth, and provided with safe and appropriate complementary foods with continued breastfeeding up to 2 years or beyond.11

During the past decade, the Ministry of Health of China (MoHCh) adopted the WHO's IYCF recommendations and implemented programmes to improve nutrition practices.12 13 However, suboptimal infant feeding is still very common in China. National Chinese data from 2008 showed that only 27.6% of Chinese children were exclusively breastfed up to 6 months, only 43.3% of children aged 6–9 months were introduced to solid or semi-solid foods, and only 37.0% of children aged 12–15 months received continued breastfeeding.14 In addition, introduction of complementary food too early or too late and a restriction in food selection, especially for animal-source food, were widespread in China.15–19 In poor rural areas, the rates of exclusive breastfeeding, continued breastfeeding for 1 year and continued breastfeeding for 2 years were 28.7%, 55.5% and 9.4%, respectively.20 At the same time, the rates of occurrence of underweight, stunting and anaemia among children under 5years  were 8.0%, 20.3% and 14.2%, respectively. It is noticeable that almost one-third (31.9%) of children aged 6–11 months were anaemic, which was the highest among children under-five years.21 These percentages can be translated into large absolute numbers of children in China. While the stunting rate was reduced by two-thirds between 1990 and 2010,21 it was estimated that 8.82 million children in China were still stunted in 2010.21

The poor IYCF practices and nutritional status of children indicated that the recommendations from WHO and UNICEF have not been put into practice. Therefore, the challenge is how to effectively translate the IYCF recommendations into caregivers’ feeding behaviours in China, thereby enhancing children's dietary intake and growth. However, the delivery channels for IYCF recommendations were not fully assessed for their usage and potential in previous studies in China. Thus, our study used a full range of globally standard breastfeeding and complementary feeding indicators to assess the feeding practices of caregivers in one rural county in China. In addition, information on delivery channels was collected with the aim of filling this gap and providing a basis for development of effective IYCF strategies.

Materials and methods

Survey setting

We conducted a cross-sectional household survey in Zhao County in Hebei Province in 2011. Hebei province is located in the northern part of the North China Plain, with an annual per capita net income of rural residents of ¥5958 (US$946) in 2010,22 which was nearly the same as the national average (¥5919).23 Zhao County is located in the middle-south part of Hebei Province. It has a total population of 571 000 (with under-five population of 38 019), and the annual per capita net income of rural residents was ¥6464 (US$1026) in 2010 (data from Zhao county statistics bureau, unpublished). There are four county-level hospitals, 16 township hospitals and 281 village clinics in Zhao County.

Survey instrument

The maternal, newborn and child health (MNCH) household survey (unpublished, 2009) was used as the survey instrument. It was developed by the WHO and has previously been used in Cambodia, Papua New Guinea and Vietnam.24 We translated the standard WHO household survey from English into Chinese, and adapted the survey following a consultation with Chinese experts and three pilot studies. The instrument collects data on the coverage of key child health interventions, delivery channels, reasons for coverage failure and health expenditure. The survey used in this study included modules on antenatal care, delivery and neonatal care, breastfeeding and nutrition, immunisation, cough and fever, diarrhoea and vitamin A. The breastfeeding and nutrition module aims to collect feeding information on children aged 0–23 months, including caregivers’ feeding knowledge and practices, delivery channels and reasons for low coverage.

In 2009, WHO and UNICEF jointly published the document Indicators for Assessing Infant and Young Child Feeding Practices, and set up 15 international standard IYCF coverage indicators (eight core indicators and seven supplementary indicators), which encourages researchers in all countries to use these indicators and makes the data comparable between countries.25 To date, very few studies in China have applied these standard indicators to assess infant feeding practices. Studies were either focused on breastfeeding practices20 or confined to earthquake areas.26 The breastfeeding and nutrition module in the MNCH household survey has standard questions for delivery channels and reasons for coverage failure, but only three core IYCF coverage indicators. Therefore, we inserted questions on the remaining core coverage indicators from the IYCF instrument to complete our survey instrument.

Participants

Caregivers in Zhao County were eligible to participate in the survey if they had a child aged 0–23 months. Mothers were the primary target group for the breastfeeding and nutrition module. If mothers were not at home or did not live with the child for any reason, other caregivers were interviewed to collect other information, such as basic household characteristics, cough and fever, diarrhoea and immunisation.

Sample size and sampling

The sample size for the survey was based on a planned cluster randomised control trial in Zhao County. The trial aims to develop and test the (cost-) effectiveness of scaled-up integrated child health interventions. The MNCH household survey was used as the baseline assessment for the trial. The sample size calculation and sampling method were based on the requirement of the trial, with townships as the randomisation unit (8 townships per group).

We expected that the anaemia prevalence would decrease from 30% to 20%, with a power of 80% and a design effect of 2 and 5% as the significance level. We calculated that a sample size of 800 children under 2 years for each group would be sufficient. For feeding knowledge indicators, we expected that the proportion of knowing duration of exclusive breastfeeding, knowing duration of breastfeeding and knowing time of first introducing complementary foods would increase from 41% to 80%, 6% to 80% and 59% to 80%, respectively. We calculated that samples of 241, 206 and 342 would be enough for each proportion. Therefore, we used the size 800 for each group as our final sample size. Meanwhile, we over-sampled 30% of children to compensate for possible refusal and loss to follow-up. We used a two-stage sampling procedure to select children for this survey. In the first stage, clusters were selected using proportional to population size sampling, with 10 clusters chosen from each township. In the second stage, the name list of all eligible children under 2 years in each village was obtained and 13 children per cluster were randomly selected using Microsoft Excel (V.2007) software. We interviewed 10 caregivers out of 13 sampled children in each cluster based on the order in which they came to the village clinic. If less than 10 sampled children were available, we asked village doctors to help us to find other children from the name list who lived nearest to the village clinics and were in the same age groups. We used those children as substitutes for the unavailable children.

Training of interviewers

We recruited 30 students from Hebei United University School of Public Health as interviewers. We trained them for 3 days, of which half a day was for field practice. The training included communication skills, explanation of questionnaires, demonstration, role plays, field practice and group discussions. The survey supervisors were all from the Capital Institute of Pediatrics, Beijing.

Data collection

We used smartphones to record data instead of traditional pen-and-paper data collection, with the standardised MNCH household survey questionnaire set-up in special developed software. We tested and used smartphones for the MNCH survey several times in the field.27

We carried out the survey from 15 to 24 August 2011 (10 days). Three teams of interviewers carried out the survey, with 10 interviewers and 2 supervisors in each team. Interviewers first introduced mothers or other caregivers to the aim of the survey and obtained written informed consent. Then the interviewers questioned the mothers or other caregivers following the instructions on the smartphone. Once an interviewer completed a questionnaire, the data were wirelessly uploaded into an Excel database via the internet server. Then the data were saved in the memory card of the smartphone as a text file to have a backup. We gave each mother a towel (worth ¥5, equal to US$0.79) to show our appreciation for their participation.

Data analysis

Data uploaded onto an internet server were automatically transformed into a Microsoft Excel sheet. After the data cleaning, we converted the database into data base file (dbf) for the final analysis. We carried out statistical analysis with SAS V.9.1 for Windows. We presented the descriptive results of our findings; data are reported with percentages, except for age of parents, which is reported as a median and range.

Results

A total of 1601 caregivers of children under 2 years were interviewed. Among them, 90.1% (1443) were mothers, 8.6% (138) were grandparents, 1.1% (17) were fathers and 0.2% (9) were others (such as uncles and aunts). Table 1 presents the characteristics of children and their parents. Among 1601 children surveyed, 57.7% were aged 0–11 months and 43.3% were aged 12–23 months. The gender ratio (boys to girls) of children surveyed was 138:100. The median age of mothers was 27 years (ranging from 20 to 43 years) and the median age of father was 28 years (ranging from 22 to 49 years). Overall, the education of fathers and mothers was good; more than 80% of them had completed at least 9 years of education.

Table 1

Characteristics of surveyed children and their parents

Category	Subcategory	Results (%)
Children*
Age group (months)	0–11	923 (57.7)
	12–23	678 (42.3)
Gender	Boys	916 (57.2)
	Girls	685 (43.8)
Mothers†
Education	Completed junior high school (9 years)	1117 (70.6)
	Completed senior high school (12 years)	158 (10.0)
Fathers†
Education	Completed junior high school (9 years)	1149 (72.7)
	Completed senior high school (12 years)	158 (10.0)

*The total number of children was 1601.

†The total number of mothers and fathers was 1583 and 1580, respectively, because some of the other caregivers of children did not know the education of the parents of the children.

Knowledge and practices of IYCF

As shown in table 2, the knowledge of caregivers about feeding recommendations and feeding practices were generally suboptimal. Around one-third of mothers knew to initiate breastfeeding within 1 h of birth, while only about one-fifth of mothers followed the recommendation. Moreover, the practice of exclusive breastfeeding for 6 months was even worse. Although only less than 10% of mothers knew to continue breastfeeding up to the age of two and to give children meat at the age of 6–8 months, only 38.2% and 32.5% of children were breastfed for 2 years and were given iron-rich or iron-fortified foods, respectively.

Table 2

Knowledge and practices of caregivers on key IYCF indicators

	Number of mothers who responded positive on the particular knowledge/practices	Total number of mothers eligible for the question	Percentage (%) (95% CI)
Mothers knowing to initiate breastfeeding within 1 h of birth	469	1443	32.5 (30.1 to 34.9)
Children who were initiated breastfeeding within 1 h of birth	317	1417*	22.4 (20.2 to 24.6)
Mothers knowing the duration of exclusive breastfeeding	539	1443	37.3 (34.8 to 39.8)
Children under 6 months exclusively breastfed	40	414†	9.7 (6.8 to 12.6)
Mothers knowing continued breastfeeding until 2 years	84	1443	5.8 (4.6 to 7.0)
Children breastfed until 2 years	104	272‡	38.2 (32.4 to 44.0)
Caregivers knowing introduction of complementary foods at 6–8 months	759	1187	63.9 (61.2 to 66.6)
Children given complementary foods at 6–8 months	196	233§	84.1 (79.4 to 88.8)
Caregivers knowing the minimum meal frequency	933	1182¶	60.0 (57.2 to 62.8)
Children given minimum meal frequency	827	1187**	69.7 (67.1 to 72.3)
Caregivers knowing feeding children with meat at 6–8 months	113	1182¶	9.6 (7.9 to 11.3)
Children given iron-rich or iron-fortified foods††	386	1187**	32.5 (29.8 to 35.2)

*Only children ever breastfed were used to calculate this indicator (from MNCH household survey guideline).

†Only children aged 0–5 months were used to calculate this indicator (from IYCF guideline).

‡Only children aged 20–23 months were used to calculate this indicator (from IYCF guideline).

§Only children aged 6–8 months were used to calculate this indicator (from IYCF guideline).

¶Data of five children on these two question were missing.

**Only children aged 6–23 months were used to calculate this indicator (from IYCF guideline).

††Suitable iron-rich or iron-fortified foods include meat, fish, poultry and liver/organ meat, commercially fortified foods specially designed for infants and young children which contain iron or foods fortified in the home with a micronutrient powder containing iron or a lipid-based nutrient supplement containing iron.

IYCF, infant and young child feeding.

The main reasons for not initiating breastfeeding early were caesarean section, seeing the baby later than 1 h after delivery, not knowing about early initiation of breastfeeding and having no breast milk (figure 1). Twenty-two per cent of the mothers received advice on non-exclusive breastfeeding from relatives and 7% of them from health workers (figure 2).

Figure 1

Distribution of reported reasons for late initiation of breastfeeding.

Figure 2

Distribution of reasons for non-exclusive breastfeeding.

Utilisation of healthcare services

Table 3 indicates that the maternal and child healthcare services were generally available and utilised by pregnant women, mothers and children, except for postnatal care. Only 11.4% of mothers received a home visit after delivery and 23.7% attended postnatal care at 42 days after delivery.

Table 3

Utilisation of healthcare services by pregnant women, mothers and children

	Number of mothers who responded positive on the particular knowledge/practice	Total number of mothers eligible for the question	Percentage (%) (95% CI)
Pregnant women receiving antenatal care at least once	1350	1443	93.6 (92.3 to 94.9)
Pregnant women receiving antenatal care four times or above	1014	1443	70.3 (67.9 to 72.7)
Children delivered at hospital	1436	1443	99.5 (99.1 to 99.9)
Mothers and children receiving home visit after delivery (within 7 days after discharge)	165	1442*	11.4 (9.8 to 13.0)
Mothers receiving postnatal care at 42 days after delivery	340	1413†	24.1 (21.9 to 26.3)
Children ever immunised	1598	1601	99.8 (99.6 to 100.0)

*Data of one child were missing.

†Only children older than 42 days were used to calculate this indicator.

Sources of infant feeding information

Table 4 shows that only around one-fourth of mothers ever received feeding information during pregnancy and after delivery. Table 5 describes the sources of feeding information through which mothers received information. The leading sources were family members, neighbours, friends and popular media; these accounted for around 80% of the total information. Only around 20% of the information came from health facilities and nearly none came from the community.

Table 4

Mothers ever receiving feeding information

	Number of mothers who responded positive on the particular knowledge/practices	Total number of mothers eligible for the question	Percentage (%) (95% CI)
Receiving breastfeeding information during pregnancy	379	1443	26.3 (24.0 to 28.6)
Receiving breastfeeding information after delivery	415	1443	28.8 (26.5 to 31.1)
Receiving complementary feeding information during pregnancy	341	1440*	23.7 (21.5 to 25.9)
Receiving complementary feeding information after delivery	385	1440*	26.7 (24.4 to 29.0)

*Data of three children were missing.

Table 5

Sources of feeding information for mothers during pregnancy and after delivery

	Breastfeeding		Complementary feeding		Formula feeding
	n	%(N=749*)	n	%(N=664*)	n	%(N=244*)
Family members/neighbours/friends	276	36.8	316	47.6	144	59.0
Popular media	312	41.7	228	34.3	5	2.0
Health facility	160	21.4	120	18.1	65	26.6
Community	1	0.1	0	0.0	1	0.4
Formula company	–	–	–	–	29	11.9
Total	749	100.0	664	100.0	244	100.0

*These are the multi-choice questions which mean all sources of information mentioned by interviewees are recorded as ‘yes’. To calculate the proportions, all ‘yes’ answers in different categories are summed up as denominators, and all ‘yes’ answers in each category are summed up as numerators.

Household property

Table 6 indicates that nearly all households owned a television and a mobile phone. More than 60% of the households owned computers, with 54.8% having access to internet.

Table 6

Households owning a radio, television, mobile phone, computer and accessing to the internet

	Number of mothers who responded positive on the particular knowledge/practices	Total number of mothers eligible for the question	Percentage (%) (95% CI)
Households owning a radio	377	1601	23.6 (21.5 to 25.7)
Households owning a television	1600	1601	99.9 (99.7 to 100)
Households owning a mobile phone	1591	1601	99.4 (99.0 to 99.8)
Households owning a computer	979	1601	61.2 (58.8 to 63.6)
Households with access to the internet at home	876	1600	54.8 (52.4 to 57.2)

Discussion

We found in our survey that caregivers’ feeding practices were poor, which was consistent with the national data as indicated in the Introduction of this paper. In addition, we found that the healthcare services were generally available and utilised by pregnant women and mothers, with notable exception of home visits, and visits to the health facility at 42 days after delivery. National data also showed that the proportions of women who ever received antenatal care and postnatal care were 93.7% and 91.0%, respectively. In addition, the hospital delivery rate was 98.7%.28 However, high utilisation of health services was not translated into high coverage of interventions.

Mothers need support not only from the healthcare system but also from the family, community and workplace to initiate and sustain optimal breastfeeding and complementary feeding practices.10 Mothers also need consistent IYCF messages that are reinforced through multiple channels.29 Therefore, healthcare providers’ engagement, community involvement and media support are all needed to maximise the effectiveness of IYCF programs. Three recommendations emerged from our study findings:

Strengthening the quality of care at health facilities to improve feeding counselling: China initiated the national Basic Public Health Service program30 to provide universal basic public health services for all residents. Maternal and child healthcare workers are required by the programme to provide face-to-face counselling to pregnant women during antenatal care visits and hospital delivery, and to mothers of young children during newborn home visits, postnatal care visits and child healthcare visits.31 However, rural health workers in China generally have poor education and lack expertise in, and motivation for, their work, which generally results in low-quality healthcare services provided by rural health facilities.32–34 Our study also indicated that few mothers reported that they ever received feeding counselling from health workers, which suggested that many health workers did not provide feeding counselling. Feeding counselling was the component of antenatal care in the late phase of antenatal care, which involves the village doctor, township hospital doctor and county-level hospital doctor. In addition, we found that the knowledge and practice of early initiation of breastfeeding were 32.5% and 22.4%, respectively. Hospital delivery is a requirement in China. Therefore, it is the duty of the hospitals to ensure that deliveries take place in hospital. However, we found that more than 50% of reasons for late initiation of breastfeeding were attributed to the health facility environment, such as high caesarean section, separation of babies from mothers and doctors’ advice. Also, 7% of mothers reported that they received advice on non-exclusive breastfeeding from health workers. It was reported that the current national rate of caesarean section in China was about 40%, which is the highest worldwide.35 36 Therefore, there is a need to strengthen the quality of healthcare services provided by rural health facilities as well as to increase service coverage.

Mobilise community resources to deliver IYCF recommendations: Community-based breastfeeding promotion and support were proven to be effective. Therefore, the Global Strategy for Infant and Young Child Feeding recognises this as one of the key components of a comprehensive programme to improve breastfeeding practices.11 Large-scale community-based programmes have demonstrated that the community offers indispensable resources for breastfeeding promotion and support.37 In the Regional Framework for Community IMCI of WHO Western Pacific Region, breastfeeding and complementary feeding are among the 12 key family practices that can be improved through community-based programmes.38 In addition, a study in China indicated that community-based behavioural change approaches that use trained village nutrition educators to provide feeding counselling to pregnant women and mothers are effective in improving breastfeeding and complementary feeding practices.39 Therefore, communities hold potential to effectively deliver IYCF recommendations in rural China.

The rates of knowledge and practice of 6-month exclusive breastfeeding were 37.3% and 9.7% respectively. Thus, there is a gap in breastfeeding and exclusive breastfeeding practices. In our study site, most village doctors were men. Other resources from the community have the potential to provide the support for exclusive breastfeeding. Our data showed less than one in a hundred mothers received feeding information from their communities. Studies have shown that peer counselling and lay counselling are effective in promoting breastfeeding.40–43 In rural China, existing community resources could be mobilised, such as the village women cadres, family planning workers, primary school teachers and volunteers, to provide feeding counselling to pregnant women and mothers.

Utilise popular media as well as internet and mobile phones to expand IYCF coverage: According to our results, the leading sources of feeding information were family members, neighbours, or friends and popular media (newspaper, magazine, book, radio and television: around 80% of information on breastfeeding and complementary feeding came from these two sources, whereas only 20% came from health facilities).

As those two main sources are both important, they should be fully used to disseminate accurate infant feeding information. However, we noted that some information from these two sources was invalid. As indicated in the results, around 60% of inaccurate advice to use formula feeding and more than 20% of inaccurate information on non-exclusive breastfeeding originated from family members, neighbours and friends. Therefore, much more effort must be made to strengthen these channels in terms of ensuring provision of correct information and broadening its scope to provide more mothers with accurate feeding advice.

Since two-thirds of mothers received no advice on feeding, new channels, such as internet and mobile phones, could be explored. Evidence indicates that computer-tailored nutrition education is an innovative and promising tool to motivate people to make healthy dietary changes.44 Also, a recent study showed that internet nutrition education can be a viable alternative to traditional nutrition education for increasing the fruit and vegetable consumption of women, infants and children.45

With the rapid socio-economic development and technical progress, many Chinese people have access to new information and communication technologies. Data showed that, by the end of 2013, there were 1229 million mobile phone users and 618 million internet users in China.46 Our survey showed that in Zhao County, nearly all households owned mobile phones, and more than 60% of households owned computers, with more than half of them having access to internet. In addition, the young generation of parents is well educated; around 95% of fathers and mothers attended junior high school (9 years of education). This implies a potential to deliver feeding recommendations through mobile phones or the internet. Future studies are needed to test the feasibility and effectiveness of these potential delivery channels in the context of rural China.

Conclusions

The findings of our study indicate that few caregivers of children in rural China received feeding information during pregnancy and after delivery. Moreover, their feeding knowledge and practices are poor, though the maternal and child healthcare services were generally available and utilised by mothers. Health facilities need to be strengthened and fully utilised to provide high-quality feeding counselling. Other channels, such as community resources, popular media, internet and mobile phones, hold great potential and could also be explored in future studies to maximise the effectiveness of IYCF programs.